CANON 5D CLASSIC VS CANON 6D MARK 1 REVIEW

BHG Photo Video (Zoom Plus!)
31 followers
In this video, I'm going to tell you about the differences between the Canon 60 Mark I and the 5D Classic.
Shooting on different cameras is a bit like shooting on different types of film.
The different types of film would give you a different look.
So with everything else being the same, let's say you have the same scene, the same lighting and the same lens.
When you use a different camera body, you get like a really different output from each one.
When we look at the different cameras that are available to us,
it's kind of important and interesting to understand what the differences are between them.
What looks are going to give you and what sort of functionality you're going to get from it.
Now in this video, I'm going to go into depth about the 60 Mark I
and I'm going to be very specifically comparing it to the 5D Mark I.
What the 5D Classic gave people was really good colour rendition, really pleasing files.
The way the images render just look very, very nice.
I've made videos on that before.
It's going to be a camera that you have to work on and really get to know
and really get to grips with to get the best out of it.
But there are also plenty of times where you just think,
I would like something that's as close as possible to the 5D Classic, but with modern benefits.
And the two cameras that come out of that question are the 5D Mark II and the 6D Mark I.
To me, the 6D Mark I is the closest successor to the 5D Classic
in terms of what you're actually getting out of the camera.
You'd think that the 5D Mark II would look the same as the 5D Mark I
and it would just improve on ISO, improve on all the other features that you have in camera.
But that's not the case at all.
When Canon made the 5D Mark II,
it had a completely different direction with the colour range and tonality that came out of the camera,
which I also think looks really nice in its own way.
It's just really different from the 5D Mark I.
The Mark II is much more brown and earthy toned
and the 5D Mark II doesn't have that creamy rendering that the Mark I has.
The 6D Mark I, when you're looking at modern cameras, reminds me most of the 5D Classic.
However, it's not the same.
It is different.
It's just closest.
How does it look different?
The 6D Mark I introduces a slight yellow cast to the pictures.
And I don't mind it.
And I'll tell you why.
Because the 6D has that creamy look that the Mark I has.
And I think that that creamy look, it's like the highlights are creamy on the Classic.
The 6D has that too.
I think it very much has that.
And I find it very pleasing.
It's very easy in post-production to have a blue-yellow colour tone in your images
or just get this kind of very nice, natural, pleasing look from them.
It's very, very simple to do.
The images that come out of it are very sharp.
Now, Canon did something.
And I know they're doing this without being aware of what they're doing when they're doing it.
Because they're trying to limit the camera somehow.
They reduced the megapixels on the 6D compared to the 5D Mark III.
And in doing so, they gave you better dynamic range.
They gave you higher ISO performance.
And the effect, which we need a name for, which I've read so many of your comments,
and you're all seeing the same thing.
When you take a full-frame sensor and you drop the megapixel count down,
the pixel density is really low.
So the pixels themselves are large, right?
So if you have a 12-megapixel full-frame sensor,
that's not many megapixels for the size of the sensor.
Somehow, and I don't know this math to do it and do not care, it looks better.
You get like a kind of a micro contrast and pop and subject separation that is there.
It's not massive, but it's noticeable.
And it does help with the look that you get.
And people were seeing the same thing on the A7.
Sorry, the A7S.
You know, the low megapixel one, the 12-megapixel one.
They were seeing the same thing on the D3 and the D700.
And some other of Canon's full-frame sensors like the...
I can't remember the name of the one.
Sorry, it's gone from my head.
That has six megapixels.
People are seeing that same thing.
So when Canon reduced the megapixel count for the 6D,
where they were trying to give you less,
what they ended up doing was giving you more.
And the 5D Mark II, if you notice, also has around 20 megapixels.
That's closest to the sweet spot that is around 12, 13 megapixels on full-frame sensors.
So actually, in the 6D Mark I,
the kind of bad shadow recovery ability
and the dynamic range from the 5D Mark III was gone.
You got much nicer kind of dynamic range.
So you got better sort of highlight roll-off and shadow gradations look better,
which I think helped to the overall look.
Which is really weird when you think about it,
because the 5D Mark I only shoots 12-bit RAW files.
I don't even know if you know that, but it does.
It only shoots 12-bit RAW files and it doesn't matter.
These things aren't important.
What matters is what it actually puts out.
This is kind of coming back to the spec sheet wars
versus what the camera can actually do.
Because in theory, the 6D on paper doesn't look that great.
But the results of what you get are always should be what informs you.
Now, I find the files from the 6D Mark I look very sharp,
but they've got nice creamy rendering.
At the same time, they've got a lot of pops.
So your subject, which is in focus will look very sharp and very good.
You can crop the files really nicely because of that.
But the overall gradations and tones of the images are really lovely.
I think they're very, very good.
Only for my opinion, beaten by the 5D Classic.
And you could argue the 5D II, it's just a very different look.
That's all.
You wouldn't go wrong with any of these cameras.
Now, where the 6D really improves over the 5D Classic
is in all of the functionality areas.
The 6D though has the same focus array that's in the 5D Classic.
It has the same focus point layout.
It's just been beefed up.
It's like the next generation up in performance.
Yeah, it's like the next generation up in performance,
but it's not going to give you...
You've still got the same focus point array, the same layout.
If you're used to mirrorless and you're seeing these cameras,
you need to understand that these cameras are designed for the center focus point
and the outer focus points are like an afterthought.
They're there, you can use them, and they're not very accurate.
The one thing that it did get right is they made them really small.
One thing that always annoyed me on my Nikon D3S was the focus points were so big
that if you were doing a portrait with a wide aperture prime,
you couldn't select the eyeball.
You would literally have to just get the face.
If you're shooting an 85mm at 1.4,
you're going to get the eyebrows in focus and not the eyes.
Bizarrely, the 5D Classic with its tiny focus points,
you can select the eyeball with that.
When I say select the eyeball, I mean you can put the focus point over the eyeball.
It has no eye tracking or detection.
The 6D has the same thing, so that's good in that sense.
You're going to have to take several shots
because several of them are going to be out of focus.
The accuracy is not so high.
Now on the 6D, the center focus point works down to minus 3 EV.
What that essentially means is it's very good in low light.
So let's say that you want to shoot an event
or you want to do portraits where you're okay with some focus and recompose.
That center focus point is very, very good.
It will smoke the 5D Mark III for that.
This is the thing.
This is supposed to be the lower down model,
but if you take the dual card slot issue out of the equation,
the 5D Mark III, yes, has better handling
because it's a bigger camera body and the control layout is superior,
but pretty much everything else is better on the 6D.
So the 6D has the best screen on the back.
It's actually got a pretty decent screen.
It's very vibrant, very easy to see.
It's colorful.
It's nice to use and it uses the newer...
When I say newer, gosh, this is going back a bit.
They're all old in comparison,
but it uses the newer battery.
It uses the current Canon batteries.
5D Classic uses the old type of batteries
and the battery life on them is not that great.
The Canon 6D's battery life goes on forever.
It really goes on forever.
And the ISO performance on the camera is really good.
You can shoot ISO 10,000 and you're good to go.
It's going to give you all of those modern features.
It shoots with SD cards.
I like that.
SD cards are good.
So you can stick in a nice big SD card and get on with it and shoot.
If you're trying to decide one or the other,
the 6D or the 5D Classic,
get the 6D and if you can afford to.
If you haven't got the money and you're thinking,
is the 5D Classic a good camera for me?
The 5D Classic is a brilliant camera to learn on.
And it's also a brilliant camera for people
that have newer and more advanced camera systems
that want to get back to basics a bit sometimes as well.
The difficulty about using these cameras on actual jobs,
if you want to do that,
or work that really matters to you,
is that with the 5D Classic,
you'll always have that feeling like,
is it going to get me the shot?
Am I going to do it?
The answer is yes, it will.
But the worry from having that feeling,
it's better to just go for the 6D and not have that fear.
Does that make sense?
Not have that fear there,
even though it's not the 5D,
it's just in your head.
The 6D, you'll know I've got the shot.
I can see that it was in focus.
You can kind of,
you know that you've got your exposures right and so on.
That's much harder to tell on the 5D Classic,
so it's not going to give you that feeling of like,
right, I know I've got the shot now.
And unless you get really very experienced with it,
and then I think it's okay again.
But I've shot weddings on the 5D Classic,
not many.
And I have no problem shooting them.
It's just that you always have that thing
in the back of your mind.
I hope that was in focus.
I hope I got this and I hope I got that.
Whereas when I only shot a couple of weddings on the 6D,
and it's just, you just know you've got everything.
And that's worth something in itself.
That's really, that's kind of worth paying for in its own right.
So to sum up, I would say for me,
the 6D Mark I is the natural replacement for the 5D Classic.
If you own a 5D Classic and you're looking for something
with more modern features,
my opinion is the 6D Mark I is your answer, okay?
And the 6D is just a very nice camera to have.
It's a very nice camera to own.
If you find these videos useful,
please give me a like.
It helps the channel a lot.
And consider subscribing if you're new here.
Drop me a comment.
Let me know what you think,
what cameras you're using,
and I'll try and get back to you.
If you want to help support the channel also,
you can buy me a coffee in the link
in the description below as well.
That would be much appreciated
as it would help me make more of these videos.
If you want to see my overall roundup
with a few other cameras thrown in as well,
then check out this video over here.
