Can open-source apps really replace professional creative software? I’m testing six free alternatives to Adobe apps, including tools for photo editing, video editing, graphic design, and more.
I’ll see how they compare with industry standards like Photoshop and Premiere Pro—and whether they’re worth trying if you want to cut your software costs.
**Chapters** 0:00 The True Cost of Creative Software Subscriptions 0:38 Testing PhotoCraft and FilmCraft 2:10 VectorCraft and LightCraft Performance 4:36 The Final Verdict on Adobe Alternatives
If you edit videos, design graphics, retouch photos, or produce audio,
you know how quickly the cost of creative software can add up.
Adobe Creative Cloud gives you powerful tools,
but a subscription can cost hundreds of dollars a year.
Most alternatives come with trade-offs.
They might be missing key features,
or they might ask you to pay another monthly subscription.
But I found ArtCraft, a desktop launcher
for a collection of free, open-source creative apps.
They claim to offer alternatives to Photoshop,
Premiere Pro, After Effects, and more.
I've installed the launcher,
and today I'm putting these apps to the test.
Can open source software really handle professional creative work?
For each app, I'll rate the user interface,
the range of tools, and stability out of 5.
Then I'll give my verdict on whether it's worth trying.
I'm testing 6 apps, starting with PhotoCraft.
Let's see how they compare.
Photocraft is the Photoshop style app.
I'm starting with a JPEG and putting its retouching tools to the test.
The spot healing brush works,
but it removes too much of the skin texture.
Create Texture gives me a slightly better result,
while Proximity Match leaves some repeating patterns behind.
The regular healing brush gives me more control
when I sample the texture myself.
The app feels fast, but the masking workflow is confusing.
I couldn't find the controls to refine a mask,
and pressing delete removed the photo instead of the
mask. I also tried opening raw files.
An older file opened, but the colors looked strange.
A newer CR3 file wouldn't open at all.
So Photocraft has some useful tools for basic edits,
but I ran into a few important limitations.
UI 3, Tool Depth 3, Stability 2.5.
Overall, three. Filmcraft is the Premiere-style video editor.
I'm more used to DaVinci Resolve,
so I'll keep this test simple.
I've opened a screen recording, and I'm going to try selecting
and removing a transition.
I'm already having trouble getting the timeline to respond,
I can't comfortably select the transition,
and the interface feels sluggish while I'm trying to make
the edit. I kept trying, but I couldn't get far enough
to properly test the rest of the editing
tools. I can't judge the whole app based on one task,
of course, but if even a basic timeline
edit is this difficult i wouldn't want to rely
on it for a project just yet scores ui one tool
depth one stability one overall one VectorCraft
is the Illustrator style app and it's one of the
smoothest apps i've tested so far i tried making
and combining shapes drawing with the pen tool
creating another artboard
and using shape builder those tools worked well for the basic designs i
tried i could also put text on a path
and use the width tool some of the selection behavior confused
me. At times I had to click directly on an object instead
of selecting it with a drag. Still, I was
able to get things done. VectorCraft feels like the most workable app
so far for everyday creative
tasks. Scores, UI 4, tool depth 4, stability 3.5.
Overall, 4. Lightcraft is the Lightroom style
photo editor. It includes profiles and presets,
exposure and shadow adjustments, white balance,
point color, masking, and edit versions.
Highlight recovery looks good and I like being able to
create versions and compare my changes.
Point color also makes it easy to select a color.
The masking and brush controls are harder to use.
I struggled to resize a mask and adjust the brush
and some of the white balance changes felt abrupt.
Lightcraft has a useful set of photo tools but the
workflow could be clearer and smoother. Scores.
UI three-fifths. Tool depth 3.5 over 5. Stability 2.5
over 5. Overall three-fifths.
EffectCraft is the After Effects style app. I tested a simple
animation using position and opacity keyframes.
Both worked, and pressing F9 made the movement
smoother. I also tried the curve controls, text animators, and masks.
The controls weren't always
intuitive. When I tried to remove a text animator,
it was easy to change the text itself by mistake.
I also couldn't open some of the footage I wanted to use.
EffectCraft can handle basic animation
experiments, but I'd want a more dependable
workflow before using it for a larger project.
Scores. UI 3, tool depth 3, stability 2.5. Overall, 3.
DesignCraft is the InDesign style layout app.
Setting up pages and columns was straightforward,
so I started making a simple booklet.
Then I tried to paste in some text. Copying and
pasting worked everywhere else,
but I couldn't get the text into DesignCraft. Since adding text
is such a big part of page layout,
that stopped me from properly testing the app. There may be
other useful tools here, but I ran
into a basic problem before I could explore them.
scores UI 2.5, tool depth 2, stability 2, overall 2 fifths.
So should you cancel your Adobe
subscription? Based on my tests, I wouldn't recommend it just yet.
These apps include some
impressive features and a few could be useful for basic tasks
or experimentation, but in my tests
they weren't reliable or polished enough to replace Photoshop,
Premiere Pro, After Effects, or the rest
of Adobe's tools for professional work.
That doesn't mean they aren't worth trying. If you're
curious about free open source creative software,
give them a look. I've put the links in the
description. Thanks for watching and I'll see you in the next video.