Can DIY Fiberglass outperform UHMWPE - Today's body armor of choice

Ancient Shield Chronicles
3 followers
May 19, 2025
Taking a closer look at homemade body armor to stop pistol threats (level 3A). I make a Fiberglass homemade body armor plate and put it to the test against a purchased 3A plate in todays material of choice, UHMWPE.
Welcome back.
So in this video we are going to go ahead and do something that has been brought to
my attention by a third party source.
What he was asking us to do is to go ahead and make a fiberglass plate, one of these
that we have made in the past, and take a polyethylene plate and do a comparison.
Basically see if a homemade 3A plate can withstand more, can be a little bit more durable than
the polyethylene plate.
Now one of the claims to fame of polyethylene is how many shots it can take.
It can take multiple hits and, you know, keep on stopping the projectiles.
So what we have done in the past is we have shot these plenty of times and you can see
what starts to happen with polyethylene is it loses its rigidity and after two or three
substantial energy shots out of a 44, even some 9mm, it really starts to have some back
face deformation.
It really starts to pull the polyethylene apart.
This has been shot 12 times.
Now two of them were with rifles just to prove a point that it will go through.
But as you can see, not only does it continue to keep its shape, it's still completely rigid
and could probably take, you know, another 10 shots.
So we're going to go ahead and take these out to the range.
We're going to shoot them with the same rounds, same distance, and see how they perform.
Now what I want to go over is some of the specifics.
Now I have been told you can get polyethylene for the same cost as what you do for this.
That just, it's not true.
Some of the benefits of this is it's extremely lightweight.
This weighs just over one pound, 1.3 ounces is what this is.
This definitely weighs more.
This is two pounds, eight ounces, two and a half pounds, I believe.
And so it definitely has an advantage in that it's lighter, it's slightly thinner, but as
you can see, it is, they're very, very similar.
Now it does have added weight, but it is, I would say two and a half times less the
cost.
This is a very inexpensive plate.
This is from online.
This is the cheapest thing I could find that was pure polyethylene in a hard plate.
This to my door was around $48, $50, I believe.
Total costs that I have in this, this is with resin, with the fiberglass, even just some
tape that I put outside of this, we are at just under $15, $14, $14.50, $14.80, something
like that.
So $15, $50, $48.
So that is one of the big advantages to this.
So weight goes here, cost goes here.
Now it's kind of an even playing field.
So let's go ahead and take these to the range.
We're going to shoot them, see the durability, see how they stack up against each other,
and we'll go from there.
Okay, out at the range on a windy and cold, snow is now here, day, and this is what we're
going to be shooting the two level 3A plates with.
So we're going to hit it four times with the 44 mag, 240 grain, jacketed soft point.
And it should be going about 1,300 feet per second.
We've got the chronograph, we'll see it, what we get.
And then we're also going to be shooting it with some 9mm, I believe these are 124 grain
full metal jackets.
Those are probably going around 1,100 feet per second.
And we will also get some chronograph reading on that.
We got the slow motion camera.
And we are going to just kind of hit them in order.
I will stitch this all together because it is cold and I don't want to talk too much.
So we'll go from there.
Okay, so first up we're going to try the polyethylene plate.
We're going to hit it with four times the 44 mag.
Please forgive me, I forgot the clay backing, which is only for representation anyway.
We went ahead and did ranch style.
We did some clay dirt instead.
We'll see if that holds past one or two rounds.
But let's go ahead and hit this with the 44 mag.
And we will go from there.
That was definitely high.
So at this point we decided to hit it with 9mm, 10 shots of 9mm to be exact.
We wanted to concentrate a good majority of those to the center of the plate and then
have a few edge shots if I could actually get them in the edge.
So from this point forward I lost the audio, I will have to voice over this and let you
know what we did.
So here on the plate you'll notice we hit the 44 very edge, you'll see in slow motion.
We were having some problems with the barrel.
So we decided to only do one shot of 44 on each plate.
We did get some edge shots of 9mm, but the majority of them were in the center.
And here you can see the amount of deformation.
This was a single curved plate.
Now we have quite a bit of movement and deformation in the back of this plate.
So let's move on to the fiberglass and see how that one does.
So now we'll hit it with the 9mm.
I attempted to get one edge shot and then try to concentrate most of the rounds towards
the center.
As you see the plate fell over, I had to reset it and then I shot it a few more times.
And as you see us come up to the plate here, we have no pass throughs.
Very little deformation.
I was able to hit it one more time close to the edge right there.
And I have 5, 6 shots, that's the 44.
Those are the last two right there that I went ahead and did.
But all told, we had 10 shots of 9mm, one shot of 44 mag, and you can see there is very
little back face deformation.
No delamination, no separation.
Very solid plate, especially one for homemade.
So let's go ahead and do a little breakdown.
Again, this is just my personal opinion from using both these plates, but I'm going to
give you what I believe is the good and the bad, and overall my opinion for what I would
use for a level 3A.
So starting with the good, you know, the polyethylene, it's lightweight, multi-hit capable, we saw
that very very good.
However, the fiberglass is less expensive to make and it is also multi-hit capable.
And lastly, both of these composites have been proven in body armor.
And now the bad.
The polyethylene, it is definitely more expensive and is susceptible to back face deformation.
However, the fiberglass has to be made to get that less expensive product.
And with that comes some inconsistencies and added weight.
And those are the drawbacks to the fiberglass.
So in conclusion, I really believe that you either get a high quality polyethylene plate,
which is going to cost upwards of $100 or more, or you really learn how to build a fiberglass
plate.
Can't go wrong with it.
I have tested it numerous times and for a level 3A plate, still one of my go-to's.
Alright well thank you all for watching.
Like, share, subscribe, got more of these on the way.
And until the next one.
