Biden rewrote Title IX — the law designed to protect women in sports — to include gender identity. Schools were forced to prove why biological men shouldn’t compete with women. 20 states sued. They won. The Department of Education ignored the injunction anyway.
The UN’s own 2024 report found nearly 890 medals were lost by female athletes to transgender-identifying male competitors across 29 sports. Not just medals — scholarships and careers.
National Review’s @lockedinwithcarolinedowney breaks down what Title IX was, what Biden did to it, and what Trump has done to restore it. Plus: why the WNBA is killing the golden goose that is Caitlin Clark.
Excerpt from The Brief with Shabbos Kestenbaum — watch the full episode at the following link: https://l.prageru.com/4zZ6QLa
In 2021, President Biden signs an executive order
that bans discrimination on the basis
of what he calls gender identity and sexual orientation.
And this is across the entire
federal government.
20 states immediately sue him, and they actually win a court injunction
in 2022 that blocks the Department of Education
from enforcing its mandates. But it seems like,
based on recent whistleblower testimony
and an in-depth investigation from the New York Post,
that the Department of Investigation essentially ignored
the court injunction anyway. So what can
Tell us about what Title IX was like under
the Biden administration and what Title IX
enforcement is like now under the Trump administration.
Yeah, well, let's rewind, take a step back here.
So Title IX.
was obviously the statute that enshrined
the separate spaces for the sexes when it came to
educational institutions that applies to sports competition.
The Biden administration bastardized
Title IX to include gender identity as a protected category
when obviously previously it was sex. So
there's female and there's male.
But by including that under the umbrella, gender, preferred gender,
or what you identify as.
That meant that.
Transgender identifying men could be theoretically protected under
that. And from my understanding of the litigation that went on during
that time is that the onus was placed on the educational institutions,
the schools themselves,
to prove why they should not have such a policy on the books,
to prove why men should not be allowed to compete in the same category.
As women, which of course is just warping reality grossly
because any, we didn't have
to explain this previously.
It was, this was just a common understanding among humans for.
The vast majority of our history,
that men and women are biologically different down to their
DNA, and men have natural physical advantages
that cause them to dominate women in the athletic
arena when they are put together.
And so that was obviously, that was known to everyone. But
with the gender ideology craze under Biden, that was really like the
This modus operandi of the Biden administration,
if there's one legacy that I just will always associate with him,
of course, there were many dangerous and noxious ones,
but it was enshrining gender identity.
As this protected category across the government and that included,
you know, Title IX.
So I'm going to ask you something that might
be a little unfair, which is responding to
critics.
How would you respond to the critics against you,
against Riley Gaines, Isabel Brown, who
say, look, when you guys talk about.
Transgender participation in women's sports.
You're talking about like four people.
This is not a major impact on women's sports.
This is not a major issue.
We're talking about a very, very small amount of people.
How would you respond to those arguments?
Yeah, they want to dismiss this issue as being a nothing burger
because this is supposedly
happening to a minority of young women predominantly, right?
I mean, the reverse is also true that there are young,
there are male athletes where there
are transgender identifying women in there.
Category, but obviously it's not the same ball game
we're talking about, but the UN published a report.
A few years ago that found that I believe it
was over 900 medals had been stolen from
female athletes in their respective sports
by transgender identifying men, you know,
titles, trophies, but also scholarships.
Not a lot of people talk about
the financial opportunities that these young women have
lost out on.
So, yeah, it's a pretty significant number.
And I would argue that, you know,
their reaction to say to just dismiss the concerns of these
It's like, it may not have happened in your town,
but we have so many documented cases. And also,
the sports issue is a microcosm of how gender ideology has penetrated
and infiltrated many other institutions.
My beat for a long time in National Review was the prison issue,
which that's a population
that the public doesn't have like immediate compassion for, obviously,
by and large, because they're not innocent, like they committed crimes.
The number of cases I found of transgender identifying male felons,
some of them with horrific rap sheets,
I'm talking like double murderers killed both their parents,
you know, in the dead of night, they were found
to be sexually abusing female inmates in Seattle, Washington alone.
I mean, I covered that beat for a few years and several, several cases.
I was in correspondence with the female inmates,
many of them very battered, very vulnerable.
And they said, yeah, I mean, they're coming in here
and they're terrorizing the place.
And so, you know, we can have this conversation all day long,
but it's but even if they say
it's just a small percentage that's affected,
I would argue that if one is too many.
So you're essentially arguing that the prioritization
of transgenderism can very often put women's
rights at risk, which I think is an important distinction to make here.
Hey, if you enjoyed that clip,
make sure you click the link below to watch the full episode
of this week's The Brief.