Better than the Odyssey? Ramayana Review

Movie review
9 followers
I went with @joeljwhite and watched the Ramayana, an incredibly ambitious Indian epic. Let's talk about it.
BTW, I watched the Hindi version with English subtitles.
#ramayana #theramayana #fantasy #theodyssey #odyssey #christophernolan #nolan #movie #movies #mythology #bollywood
AI Generated·May contain errors
Okay, The Ramayana. To say that this is a big release
is kind of an understatement. It's one of
the most ambitious Indian cinema projects ever.
With an international release, huge budget, big
name actors, they really put everything they had into this movie.
So, does the movie live up to the
hype? Is it actually entertaining?
How does it compare to The Odyssey, another cultural epic
that released this year? Well,
I had the opportunity to watch the movie last night with a buddy.
Let's talk about it.
So on this channel, I've been following the Ramayana pretty closely.
I've reacted to several trailers.
I even made a video about the director, Nitesh Tiwari.
And I was very interested in this movie.
It's an ancient epic that's similar
to the Odyssey in terms of cultural importance.
In fact, the Ramayana is actually more important
to India than the Odyssey is to Greece
because a lot of people in India view the Ramayana as a historical book
and it's a religious text
and they believe it on the same level as a religious text.
What were my expectations going into this movie?
I knew the visuals would be really unique,
really interesting. I knew we would get a very epic spectacle.
And I was pretty familiar with
the story, to the point where I'm anticipating plot points.
I'm sitting in my theater seat,
and I'm thinking, okay, this is going to happen,
this is going to happen, this is going to happen.
I knew the story pretty well, actually.
So I knew we were going to get a visual spectacle.
I knew that a lot of people involved in the project seemed to
honor the source material. They really love
the project that they're working on.
I think the movie did live up to the expectations
in terms of visual spectacle. In fact, the opening
sequence of the movie, the first like 20
or 30 minutes where we're talking about Ravana,
was a really good introduction to the lore of the movie.
It goes into the backgrounds of the gods
and the goddesses and the creation of the universe.
It goes into the backstory of Ravana and
how he got to be basically invincible.
And the opening battle sequence is really cool. We have
and monsters and a lot of mythical creatures all
of that was really cool
and again the spectacle of the movie was great the weapons
and the armor and the
sets and the props all of that visually
was awesome by the way if you're
enjoying this video please like subscribe and this is actually what I
wanted out of the Odyssey
the Odyssey had bad costumes bad armor it did not
I do not respect the cultural origin of the story.
The Ramayana
did it seems like to me visually it looked like it
was very consistent with Indian culture
everything visually was very high quality
however there was a lot of CGI environments
that was kind of distracting very often
the characters are like walking through
an environment like a forest or some kind of landscape
or a palace and it looks very
obvious that they're on a CGI set
so that would be my main critique of the visuals is that
Very often I'm looking at the screen
and I'm like that's a CGI environment and it's kind of distracting.
The movie is very bright and very colorful and it is very different
from like the Odyssey where everything just is dark and
depressing and sad and just looks like sludge. So the Ramayana
embraces the color.
of its environment and the color of its culture.
And I'm going to keep comparing it with the Odyssey
because that's just the most similar
release so far in terms of its source material.
But the Ramayana was unapologetic in its source material.
The Odyssey was tripping over itself to apologize for its culture,
to apologize for its main
character.
The Ramayana made no apologies.
This is our main character.
This is Rama, this is the story, this is our culture.
Very unapologetic in its presentation.
And if you couldn't tell already,
I did not like the Odyssey.
In fact, I saw it twice,
and I liked it even worse the second time around.
The first time I watched it,
I did not like all of the external things,
the way that it did not respect Greek culture visually.
So it wasn't Greek externally,
and then it wasn't Greek internally.
The themes and messaging of the movie did not match the themes
and messaging of the book and
the story. It was constantly making apologies
and undermining its own source material. The Ramayana,
like I said, makes no apologies.
It respects and honors its source material. It's excited
about its source material.
And I went with a buddy and he used the word earnest.
I liked that word. Everyone wanted to put their best foot forward.
The actors, the cinematographers,
everybody. The action was the best part of the movie.
You have some really cool battle scenes
up front at the beginning, and then you have some
cool battle scenes between Rama and then fighting
the demons. The best part of the movie, to me,
is the fight between Ravana and this eagle thing. I
thought that was really cool.
For me, that was the best part of the movie, is watching Ravana
Fight the eagle up in the sky with that big floating vehicle thing.
I'd never seen that before.
You know, I'd seen battles between like superpowered individuals
and monsters and things,
but I'd never seen this near God figure fighting this kind of...
Almost humanoid vulture in the sky
with a flying like spinning ancient vehicle.
So for me the best part of the movie is just there
were a lot of visuals that I had never
seen before and the movie made no apologies for its source material.
It was very earnest about its source material.
It loved to present its source material
when it put its best foot forward.
The costumes, weapons, armor, sets, props...
All excellent, high quality.
The armor and the weapons and all of that was very ornate,
very detailed. It reminded me of Creation of the Gods.
That armor and weapons and sets and props,
everything was very ornate, very detailed.
Everything felt like it belonged visually
in an ancient mythological epic, which was great,
which was perfect. I loved how it just
went for the color, went for the overly ornate design.
That's what I wanted out of the Odyssey.
I wanted something that
The Odyssey leaned into its source material
that made me feel like I was experiencing
a mythological epic.
The Odyssey did not deliver that.
The Ramayana did.
So is the Ramayana better than the Odyssey?
Yes, it is better than the Odyssey, just in terms of its adaptation.
However, the Ramayana did have a number of problems.
I walked out of the theater feeling very, very mixed.
Like I said, I knew the story pretty well,
and I knew the plot points coming up.
And so for me, I was really surprised.
At two hours into the movie, Lord Ram had just been exiled.
That, to me, I was like, man,
I was expecting that to happen a lot earlier.
So the first two hours of the movie, to me, were very slow.
I actually was having kind of a hard time.
The plot was moving at a glacial pace.
But I thought the last hour and a half...
was much better. My overall impression of the movie
was simply that this movie was made primarily for
Hindus. It wasn't really made for anyone else.
It offered some explanation and things for
non-Hindu viewers, but it wasn't really made for anyone else.
This movie was made for Hindus.
Why do I say that? Well, because there
were a lot of moments in the movie
That it just demanded some kind of unearned emotion.
Like the movie seemed to rely pretty heavily
on some previous religious familiarity with the source material.
Really great example is the first time we see Lord Ram.
So we kind of hear about Lord Ram.
We hear that he's the incarnation of the god Vishnu.
And there's these kings and people talking in court.
And then Lord Ram finally enters.
And we get our first main introduction to Lord Ram.
And he says his first line.
When this happens.
The movie, like, stops, and the music swells.
There's, like, a full almost 20 seconds
of just him slow-motion walking.
And everyone's smiling and grinning at each other,
and they're looking really reverent at Lord Ram.
The problem is that the movie seemed to demand my admiration,
but so far Lord Ram had done absolutely nothing to earn my admiration.
He hadn't even fought a demon yet, everyone just kind of seemed
to love him, and I was so far not given a reason to love and admire
this character, but it still felt like it demanded my admiration.
And at that moment, I thought...
This movie was made for Hindus
because Lord Ram finally entering and finally like being
introduced. It doesn't really mean anything to me,
but it means a lot to Hindus. And so that's
part of why the characters don't really work for me in the Ramayana.
I think the characters are
not very interesting.
They're underdeveloped and they're kind of flat. Lord Ram
does not show any sign of struggle in overcoming obstacles.
He always says the right thing, always does the right thing,
he's very admired, well-loved,
he never really struggles in overcoming obstacles.
And so when a character is constantly winning,
there's not really a reason to celebrate it anymore.
But when you see a character struggle,
struggle, struggle, struggle, struggle,
And then finally win.
Then you feel like, oh, that character finally succeeded.
I'm happy for him.
A really great example would be,
I rewatched Into the Spider-Verse recently, and that movie
has really great dialogue, really great character development.
And the main character, Miles Morales,
for most of the movie, he's struggling.
He has these newfound Spider-Man powers,
and he does not know how to work the powers.
You see him bumbling around and sticking to things,
and he's having a hard time.
And it even gets to the point where his friends like
tie him up and leave him and say you're not gonna go fight
the bad guy with us you're just gonna get
in the way you need to stay here
and he is so embarrassed he feels like he's at a low point in
his life and he watches his friends go out to confront the villain
but he somehow escapes and
then he gets it all together and he does heroic things
and you want to cheer him on the problem
with the Ramayana is that you never get that kind
of character development with Lord Ram and the
And the reason is that he's a religious figure.
He's a god incarnate, and if that's who he is in the source material,
you know, fine, but he's not
relatable. He's not interesting.
He's not a very well-developed character. You know, Lord Rom's
character is.
Always says the right thing. Always does the right thing.
Always makes perfect shots with his bow.
Always defeats his enemy flawlessly.
Has no real struggle to overcome obstacles.
He endures obstacles, such as when he's exiled,
but he encounters that obstacle
very graciously and with perfect humility and perfect patience. And so,
for me, there's just nothing to root for,
because I never see him struggle.
I never see him exhibit any flaws.
I don't feel like I want to root for him
because I don't see him progressing or developing
as a person.
So for me, the movie was kind of a mixed bag.
I thought visually it looked really awesome.
I loved how it was unapologetic about its source material.
I loved that it embraced all of the ornate
Over-the-top kind of mythological design of things.
Very ornate armor, very ornate weapons, very ornate sets.
The movie totally leaned into its source material
and was unapologetic about it.
But for me, I did not feel very emotionally invested
because I thought the characters
were underdeveloped, very flat, not very interesting,
and I definitely thought there were some pacing issues.
So that is my overall impression of the Ramayana.
That's all I have for you today.
Hit the button, hit the bell.
Catch you later.
