Bethune, Praised by the Leader of China’s Communist Party

Decipher China
6 followers
15 Video Views·Oct 14, 2022
Bethune was an ordinary Canadian doctor. However, he was highly praised by the Leader of China’s Communist Party. Do you know why? And do you know what the real Bethune is like? Let's find out in our video.
People living outside China may not have heard of the name Norman Bethune.
But in China, almost everyone knows of him.
Do you know why?
This is our story.
For many Chinese, the name Norman Bethune is very well known.
This is because during the Cultural Revolution,
everyone in China had to recite by heart three articles written by Mao Zedong.
One of them is named in memory of Bethune.
According to Mao, Bethune was a noble, pure and moral person who benefited the people.
However, was Bethune really such a person?
Bethune was born in 1890 in Gravenhurst, Ontario, Canada.
Both his great-grandfather and father were Christian Presbyterian ministers,
and even Bethune's former home was built by the local Christian church for ministers.
His mother was also a devout Presbyterian missionary,
distributing Christian pamphlets in her native city London at the age of 10,
and left England at the age of 21 to serve as a missionary in Hawaii,
where she met Bethune's father.
The family of two devout Christians brought untold love to Bethune.
They had an extraordinary influence on him.
My mum gave me an evangelist character, said Bethune,
and my dad gave me a fervent drive to act.
In other words, Bethune grew up in an environment
surrounded by God and traditional Western culture.
As a graduate from the University of Toronto Faculty of Medicine,
Bethune went on to become a clinical postgraduate and doctor at the Royal Victoria Hospital.
During his time at medical school,
Bethune invented the artificial pneumothorax therapy,
which he experimented on himself with success.
In addition, he invented 22 surgical instruments,
including the Bethune rib shears, which were at the forefront at the time.
It can be said, at the time, Bethune was a competent and dedicated doctor.
Phoenix, The Life of Norman Bethune,
a book written by a Canadian expert on Bethune,
historian Roderick Stewart, together with his wife Sharon Stewart,
provides a vivid account of the other side of this protagonist.
In addition to being an excellent doctor,
he was, however, also a womaniser and a violent man.
In their book, there was such a story.
In 1923, Bethune became a clinical postgraduate at the Royal Victoria Hospital.
By then, he had met Frances Campbell Penny,
a Scottish girl who was 11 years younger than him.
Despite their drastically different personalities,
under Bethune's stubborn and crazy pursuit,
on the 13th of August of the same year,
Frances decided to disregard her family's objections
and marry Bethune in London, England.
In 1926, Bethune was ill with tuberculosis.
Convinced that he was about to die,
Bethune forced his wife to divorce him.
I will never go to a sanatorium for treatment unless you agree to divorce me,
said Bethune.
It's difficult for us to find out why Bethune forced Frances to divorce him,
but according to a short film provided by Bethune's former residence,
Bethune was living a rather debauched life at that time,
drinking heavily, smoking and attending various parties at night
and living a rather unrestrained life.
In the autumn of 1929, after recovering from his illness,
Bethune begged his ex-wife in Scotland to come back to him.
Later, they remarried in Montreal.
However, soon after, their marriage once again had reached a dead end.
There is such a description in the book.
One morning before going to work,
Frances asked her husband to buy some meat and vegetables
so she could cook a few nice dishes for him later.
In the afternoon, Frances returned home with great interest.
When she entered their home,
she saw her husband sitting on the floor intently studying a skeleton.
She asked,
Have you bought the meat and vegetables?
Without thinking, her husband said,
It's in the fridge.
She opened the fridge and saw only a section of intestine.
She frowned and cupped the intestine and said,
You just bought this crap?
Her husband jumped and shouted,
Don't move! That's human intestine!
Frances cried out in horror and threw it away.
How can you put a dead man's intestine with our food?
But Bethune said without looking up,
What's the big deal?
Aren't all the beef, mutton and pork you eat the organs of dead animals?
Encounters like this one happened several times
until Frances couldn't stand it anymore.
In March 1931, Frances filed for divorce once again
after two years of remarriage.
In 1935, the trajectory of Bethune's life changed.
He attended the International Congress of Physiology in Moscow, USSR,
and having learned about the medical and health benefits system
introduced by the Soviet Communist Party,
which seemed to agree with what he had in mind,
he returned home and immediately joined the Communist Party of Canada,
where he vigorously promoted for national health care.
However, ironically, during his visit to the Soviet Union,
he was unaware that Stalin was conducting a purge,
slaughtering large numbers of civilians and communists,
including most of the Soviet Communist Party Central Committee members
and senior generals in the Soviet Army.
When the civil war broke out in Spain in September 1936
between the German-Italian-Nazi-backed Francisco Franco
and the Soviet-backed left-wing government,
Bethune organized a medical team to go to Madrid
as a member of the Canadian Communist Party to support the left-wing regime.
There he set up the first mobile blood transfusion station in history.
However, owing to his own doings, such as indulging in sexual behavior,
alcoholism, bad temper and inability to work with others,
he was later expelled back to Canada in May 1937.
After the Marco Polo Bridge incident on July 7th, 1937,
a full-scale resistance against the Japanese invasion broke out in China.
Bethune raised another US$5,000 from the Communist Party of the United States,
bought a batch of medical instruments
and was sent to China by the joint American and Canadian Communist Party
and arrived in January 1938.
His life journey began to take a turn from then on.
At the time, the Nationalist government of China were on the front lines
fighting against the Japanese invasion,
committing almost the entire regular army to the war.
Many medical volunteers from all over the world came to help the Nationalist army,
but Bethune, unlike the other volunteers,
was determined to help the Chinese Communist Party,
who were nowhere near the front lines,
and hid in Yan'an to gather its strength.
A few months later, arranged by several Chinese Communist Party members
such as Tao Xingqi, Song Qingling, Liao Chengzhi and Zhou Enlai,
a medical team of Canadian and American doctors led by Bethune arrived in Yan'an.
They were personally welcomed by Mao Zedong,
who appointed Bethune as a health advisor to the Jin Cha Ji military region
of the Eighth Route Army.
For the Communist Party of China, who was still weak at that time,
it was a great joy to have a highly skilled doctor like Bethune.
In one and a half years, from March 1938 to November 1939,
Bethune made a great contribution to the Chinese Communist Party.
Not only did Bethune perform a large number of surgical operations
to save numerous wounded, but he also founded a medical school,
trained a large number of medical personnel
and wrote a variety of war medical teaching materials.
Out of the lascivious nature of the Chinese Communist Party,
as a reward for foreign support,
the CCP arranged temporary wives and sexual partners
for foreigners working in Yan'an.
The only exception to this was Bethune,
who refused to have an arranged temporary wife
and preferred to drink and visit rural brothels.
On one occasion, while waiting for a boat ride to cross the Yellow River,
people couldn't find Bethune anymore.
They were all anxious about his disappearance.
Later, with the help of a Canadian priest, Luo Mingyuan,
who practiced medicine in the local area,
the drunken Bethune was found in a rural brothel and was brought back.
In late October 1939, while taking care of a wounded man,
Bethune's left middle finger was cut by a scalpel and got infected.
Later it led to sepsis,
and Bethune died in November at the age of 49 after ineffective treatment.
Of course, Bethune's death was an important loss to the Chinese Communist Party,
which was the main reason why Mao praised him so highly.
Looking back, we can clearly see the turning point in his life.
Whoever aligned with the evil Chinese Communist Party
was doomed from the start, often ending in tragedies.
Little is known about the many Canadian Christian missionaries
who served in medical and educational work in China
during the time of national crisis for the Chinese people,
most of whom served under the national government
and in the areas of the Japanese occupation.
Of course, after the Communist Party took power,
it tried to erase the good deeds done during the rule of the nationalist government
So naturally, the touching stories of international missionaries
working under the nationalist governments
had not been told to the Chinese people
in the same way as the publicity given to Bethune.
Their great contribution to saving the lives of Chinese people
should be justly commemorated from the standpoint of love,
justice and humanity,
and not just Dr. Bethune alone out of political needs.
Dr. Isabel McTavish, born in 1881 in Manitoba,
was one of the Canadian missionaries.
At the age of 24,
she was sent to China by the Presbyterian Church of Canada.
This young doctor worked for more than 30 years
in Weihui and Anyang in Henan province
and remained unmarried for the rest of her life.
Her service to the Chinese people was 20 times longer than that of Bethune.
During the war, Dr. McTavish was detained
and brutally treated by the Japanese
and was only released to Canada after the war was over.
Dr. Victoria Cheung, also known as Cheung Sha Bai,
was the first female doctor of Asian descent in Canada.
She was sent by the Presbyterian Women's Missionary Society of Canada
to work at the Barclay Maternity and Children's Hospital in Jiangmen, Guangdong,
also known as the Renji Hospital,
the predecessor of the present Jiangmen Central Hospital.
She is fondly remembered by several generations of the Jiangmen people.
Fortunately, Dr. Cheung passed away on the eve
before the 10-year catastrophe of the Cultural Revolution
and did not have to experience the horrors of the revolution.
On the day of her funeral,
people from all villages in Jiangmen rushed to pay their respects to Dr. Cheung
and the procession stretched for kilometres.
By comparison, Bethune was not in any way a noble man,
a pure man, a moral man, a man free of low taste, as Mao says.
Nor was he a man of benefit to the people,
but rather a man of benefit to the Chinese Communist Party.
While the Chinese people were fighting a bloody war
under the leadership of the Nationalist government,
the Chinese Communist Party was cowering in Yan'an
far from the front lines of the war,
taking the opportunity to strengthen itself,
raise its international image
and prepare for the eventual seizure of power.
It is no wonder why the Canadian communist Norman Bethune
became a heroic and exemplary figure of the Chinese Communist Party.
We'll continue our story in the next episode.
Please like and subscribe to our channel and see you next time.
