Bernard Arnault, l'art de payer moins d'impôts

Bernard Arnault
8 abonnés
22 Vues de vidéo·9 juil. 2025
A la tête de LVMH, Bernard Arnault, première fortune de France et quatrième fortune mondiale, a le sens des affaires… et un exceptionnel talent pour l’optimisation fiscale. Selon une ONG, en 2014, le groupe LVMH comptait 202 filiales dans des paradis fiscaux, tandis qu’une bonne partie du patrimoine de la famille Arnault est placée dans une fondation en Belgique, un paradis fiscal qui ne dit pas son nom. Montages financiers opaques, succession organisée hors de France, mécénat… l’enquête lève le voile sur les pratiques des plus fortunés qui, comme Bernard Arnault, tentent de payer le moins d’impôts possible, voire d’y échapper.
Last spring, the prestigious Philharmonic Orchestra of Moscow
gave an exceptional concert.
At the piano, a guest of honor, Bernard Arnaud.
Next to him, his wife, Hélène Mercier, a renowned pianist,
and their son, Frédéric.
A brilliant and virtuoso businessman.
Bernard Arnaud leads a group that weighs nearly 120 billion euros, LVMH.
With his family, he owns nearly 47%.
His fortune is estimated at 58 billion euros.
According to the Forbes magazine, he is the richest man in France,
the 4th richest man in the world.
In Paris, his enseignments occupy the most beautiful avenue in the world,
Louis Vuitton, Guerlain on the Champs-Élysées,
Christian Dior Avenue Montaigne, the flagship brands of his empire.
In the Arnaud galaxy, luxury also has more popular names,
like Sephora or Carrefour.
In all, nearly 70 brands.
Further away, in the woods of Boulogne, the last nugget of the billionaire,
the Louis Vuitton Foundation, dedicated to contemporary art.
LVMH has subsidiaries all over the world.
And if Bernard Arnaud likes to display the success of his group,
there is a subject that makes him very irritable, his tax sheet.
You can ask the French tax office, call Bercy,
I have always paid 100% of my taxes in France.
It is impossible to know how much Arnaud's taxpayer pays in taxes.
The LVMH group pays more than 2 billion euros per year to the French tax office.
But in 2014, an NGO specializing in tax evasion
revealed that the LVMH group is a champion of tax havens,
alongside the BNP.
The number one in luxury would have 202 offshore subsidiaries.
We went to the billionaire's seat,
where taxation is more advantageous than in France.
In Malta, we found the lawyer who took care of the symphony,
Bernard Arnaud's yacht.
What's the name again?
Bernard Arnaud.
In Belgium, we wanted to know what is hidden today
behind the billionaire's companies.
Is there a lot of people who work here?
Yes.
In France, we explored the background of the Louis Vuitton Foundation.
Making Parisians believe that their taxes are a gift,
when they give it to Bernard Arnaud, you have to do it.
He is really the master of illusion.
With his tax montages,
has Bernard Arnaud been reformed by the French tax office?
The former Secretary of State for Budget, Christian Ecker,
made a revelation to us.
Your question was precise.
My answer is yes.
Investigation on a love story,
Bernard Arnaud and tax havens.
Bernard Arnaud's yacht is called the Symphonie.
The billionaire is discreet.
The visit of his yacht gives a small idea of his way of life.
In 2015, when the Symphonie leaves its site in the Netherlands,
it is one of the largest in the world.
101 meters long,
a heliport,
a pool with a transparent bottom,
a golf course,
eight rooms,
not to mention a piano in the reception room.
The ship can accommodate 20 guests.
Its price is estimated at 130 million euros.
For its first crossing,
the ship set sail on the island of Malta, in the Mediterranean.
Why this destination?
Malta is one of the 28 member states of the European Union.
400,000 inhabitants and 4,500 yachts.
We have an appointment with a woman
who knows a lot about these luxurious boats,
Caroline Navarro.
She is the manager of the largest marina on the island.
Are there many yachts more than 100 meters long here?
There are not many, but there are more and more.
How do you explain it?
I guess you always want to have a bigger one than your neighbor.
Caroline Navarro remembers the party she had organized
for the arrival of the Symphonie on the island.
The Symphonie's maiden voyage to Malta was a great excitement
because it was a brand new yacht, more than 100 meters long.
So we organized a great party.
It was epic for the boat and for the marina.
It was fantastic.
Was the owner there?
No.
To be honest, we have very little contact with the owners.
Often, it is management companies that take care of the boats
and the owner only comes here for an hour or two.
They are very busy people and their time is very limited.
If the yacht made its inaugural voyage on the island,
it is not only to enjoy the landscape.
Indeed, it is a very attractive place.
Apparently, the larger the boat, the less tax you pay.
Taxes and very low taxes are one of the tax advantages
unique in Europe that Malta offers to yacht owners.
The island has other charms.
You can own an incognito yacht there.
All you have to do is create a management company on site.
This Maltese journalist was part of the Malta Files team in May 2017.
This is what was revealed in the press
about the secrets of tax evasion on the island.
In the case of those companies,
where the ultimate beneficiary, the person who owns the yacht,
is hidden behind a company which could be an accountant,
an auditor, a consultant or a lawyer,
then that may be difficult to actually find out.
Ultimately, it is said that Malta is part of the system of global bankruptcy.
Malta helps the rich, the global elite, to make savings on their taxes.
And it is part of the game to hide behind a lawyer.
It is also part of that game to keep things secret.
For the symphony, we found the trace of this company
in the records of the yacht manufacturer.
It is called Sonata Yachting Ltd.
It is based in Malta.
We also found the name of the lawyer who created this company.
After a month of discussion, he agreed to meet us.
Yes, we have a company named Sonata.
But I can't tell you more.
You have to ask the client himself.
When we asked him if the client could be Bernard Arnault,
his memory failed him.
I can't even tell you if he is one of our clients.
And if I had to remember Sonata,
and the name of the person you mentioned,
I can't even repeat it.
What is his name again?
Bernard Arnault.
Typically French.
Typically, yes.
Listen, we open a lot of companies,
and I can't tell you if a client did this or that.
I would have liked to have information in the official documents,
but all the documents are not public.
Malta is not so transparent.
We have our limits, it's true.
But it's not fair to say that Mr. Arnault benefited more from taxes,
just because he opened a company here.
If it's him.
You say that's what the French newspapers say.
I don't know.
In the French press,
the Sinfonie has always been presented as Bernard Arnault's yacht.
And he never defended it.
Looking in the annual report of LVMH in 2015,
we find the trace of Sonata Yachting Limited.
It is a subsidiary of the LVMH group.
Let's recapitulate.
The yacht is managed by Sonata Yachting Limited,
which belongs to LVMH,
controlled by Bernard Arnault.
Thus, the billionaire never appears as the owner of the yacht.
He therefore does not have to declare it in his tax on the fortune.
Christian Ecker is the former Secretary of State of the budget.
He is wary of this practice among the leaders of large companies.
For the first time,
he agrees to express himself about Bernard Arnault.
I don't think it's Bernard Arnault's yacht
that allows him to do business.
It's not really a work tool,
or else it seems rather curious.
But we can see the mix of genres
that is made in terms of the use of a company's assets
and the use, for private purposes, of the company's heritage.
We asked Bernard Arnault.
He answered us via his communication service.
He tells us...
The main reason for the immatriculation in Malta
is confidentiality.
He adds...
Mr. Arnault occasionally gives the symphony
to the Sonata company, which owns it.
The boat is mainly rented to external customers.
To each of his cruises, the yacht fascinates.
On the Instagram image sharing app,
he even has his fans.
Photos and videos are shown.
In Portofino, in the port of Monaco,
in Capri, in the Antilles, in Saint-Tropez.
Renting this boat is possible.
Still, you have to have the means.
We call the company that manages the boat's rental.
It is also a subsidiary of the LVMH group.
Yes, the symphony is for charter.
Do we have to book it in advance?
Yes, it's a very popular boat because it's very big.
It can accommodate more guests than a regular yacht.
The owner also uses it.
I wouldn't say he makes a lot of use of it,
but he uses her as well.
The boat's rental cost is 1,500,000 euros per week.
It's not because you're a billionaire
that you don't need to make your yacht profitable.
It helps to charter a boat because there are so many costs.
It helps to reduce the costs considerably.
Gasoline, insurance, crew, repairs.
The symphony's maintenance costs
are around 16 million euros per year.
For Bernard Arnault, there are no small savings.
One detail intrigued us.
The symphony is well managed by a Maltese company,
but it sails under another pavilion
of another tax haven, the Cayman Islands.
On the other side of the Atlantic, in the Caribbean,
on this former British colony,
there's an Eldorado for the owners of ships.
Under this pavilion, they can hire crews at the lowest cost.
Frank Dolfus, a lawyer specializing in maritime law,
explains how it works.
It's a very simple contract.
The parties to the contract, the role of the sailor on board,
the determination of the salary.
For each 24-hour period, you work a minimum of 10 hours.
With a minimum of 77 hours for each 7-day period.
It's not bad.
What about social charges?
There are none.
Can we consider that when we have a yacht
and we put it in Malta, in the Cayman Islands,
which is part of the list of official tax havens in Europe,
can we consider it a form of optimization or tax evasion?
In any case, it's legal.
You just have to comply with the law of the country
in which you want your ship registered.
In the wonderful world of mega-yachts,
you'd have to be crazy to spend more.
Only 45 luxury ships are registered in France.
A few days before the broadcast of our investigation,
the management of LVMH sent us this email.
The company Sonata, which was a subsidiary of LVMH,
has been ceded to the Arnaud family group.
The transaction, for a sum of 54 million euros,
took place very recently, in February 2017.
The yacht is now owned by the billionaire and his relatives.
To pay less taxes,
Bernard Arnaud has other strings attached to his bow.
To the north of France, on the other side of the border,
there is a small, less sunny paradise,
but just as welcoming.
Belgium and its tax system, very advantageous.
Planted on the most prestigious avenue in Brussels,
here is the Blue Tower.
This is where Bernard Arnaud has 14 of his companies.
They occupy barely two floors,
but total, according to their accounts,
more than 20 billion euros in assets.
Haute Couture, Parfumerie, Maroquinerie
are the headquarters of Bernard Arnaud's group in Belgium.
In the reception hall, very little information.
Of the 14 subsidiaries here,
only three appear at the entrance of the Blue Tower.
LVMH Finance Belgique,
Le Peignet,
and LVMH Publica.
We go up to the 15th floor.
This is LVMH Finance Belgique.
There is a nice welcome with a Louis Vuitton jacket,
for Louis Vuitton's hands,
a nice red sofa,
a little press,
but there is no one.
I don't know, it looks like there's no one.
Hello sir.
Hello.
We ask to meet a manager of these companies.
Can I ask you to wait there?
Yes, can't we wait here?
No.
Okay, thank you.
Why?
Because I can't.
Can I ask you something?
Yes, of course.
Thank you.
Is there a lot of people working here?
Thank you.
To make sure we leave the place,
in the elevator,
another employee comes to accompany us.
But are there a lot of people working here?
Because we heard there was almost no one here at LVMH Finance Belgique.
Yes, yes.
Are there people working?
Yes, yes, there are people working.
Okay, very good.
So, let's go.
I think it's clear.
Okay, thank you very much.
To know how many people work here,
we use another method.
We look at the accounts of 2015,
published by the companies at the strike of the Court of Commerce.
For this one, for example,
in front of the line of workers, there are no figures.
Same for the personnel costs,
the column on the right is empty.
Common point of all these companies,
they hardly count employees,
but they show huge profits.
Pile Invest.
Profits, more than 114 million.
Employees, zero.
Jim Invest.
Profits, more than 31 million.
Employees, zero.
At LVMH Finance Belgique,
and its 86 million profits,
there are six employees.
And Le Peignet,
183 million profits,
has four employees.
There are therefore only 14 employees
of the Arnaud empire in this tower.
And they are super productive.
They make a profit of more than 411 million euros.
That is, more than 29 million profits per employee.
These companies have a legal existence,
but they display an intriguing profile.
We go to the parliament in Brussels,
to meet the man who was the first
to get involved in the affairs of Bernard Arnaud in Belgium.
Former tax inspector,
Marco Vaness is now a deputy.
In 2012, he sought out
the real intentions of the French boss.
I discovered that there is really
a decision to make of Brussels,
the financial center of the group.
Which has nothing to do with real activities.
We are really only in pure finance.
And it shows in any case
that there is a real intention
of Bernard Arnaud's group
to implement these different companies in Belgium
for tax reasons,
to take advantage of Belgian tax niches,
starting with national interests.
National interests.
A gift from Belgium to attract companies.
Here, the more capital a company has,
the less taxes it pays.
A bonus for large multinationals.
There are many companies that pay 0 euro tax
thanks to national interests.
And informed by the media campaigns
of the Belgian government
for this tax advantage,
there are new multinationals
that have been attracted by Belgium.
And Bernard Arnaud's financial companies
are the example.
These companies, in any case,
have settled in Belgium.
These are Belgian companies,
specifically to be able to benefit from this system.
Marco Vaness had fun
listing all the tax deductions
that the Belgian subsidiaries
of Bernard Arnaud benefited from
between 2008 and 2011.
We have completed his table until 2016.
In all, for a cumulative benefit
of 2.7 billion euros,
these subsidiaries paid in Belgium
taxes worth 83 million euros.
In France, this tax could have been
ten times higher.
The economy realized would be
more than 800 million euros.
Isn't there a counterpart to that?
When the subsidiaries of LVMH
come to Belgium,
don't they create jobs?
Don't they run the economy?
No, it's one of the problems
of national interests.
It's unconditional.
There are no conditions
in terms of investment
or employment.
There are companies
with zero employees
who benefit from it.
In Belgium,
what is good for LVMH
can also be good for Bernard Arnaud.
To the point that in 2011,
the billionaire decides
to become a resident.
Would he have had a crush on Belgium,
his beer, his chocolate, his waffles?
Or would he have wanted to benefit
from the country's tax advantages
For the rich,
Belgium is very attractive
in terms of heritage.
On one condition,
to live in the country.
Hucles, the chic suburb of Brussels.
Here, 10% of the residents
are French.
Bernard Arnaud became a resident
in 2011,
in the most discreet way.
We walk in front of his building
in the company of David Leloup,
a Belgian investigative journalist
who investigates the billionaire.
It's the first time
he comes to the place.
Four seats.
Yes, it's here.
In front of the apartment
in which he was supposed to settle
to become a Belgian resident.
On site,
a resident of the building
agrees to let us in
as long as we are not filmed.
240 square meters,
with an American kitchen,
a large living room,
three bedrooms and two bathrooms,
all with a view of a wood.
Bernard Arnaud rents
the same apartment
on the opposite level.
The building is chic,
but according to the journalist,
it would not correspond
to the standing of the French billionaire.
I'm a little disappointed.
It's true?
Look, there's water on the façade,
the cleanest stone,
there's green foam.
It's not great.
Indeed, this apartment
is standing,
it's pretty,
but it does not correspond
to Bernard Arnaud's standing.
I have the impression
that it is part of a strategy
and that this apartment
is part of the physical
dressing of this strategy.
Did Bernard Arnaud
really live in this building?
We meet a neighbor
who doesn't believe it.
We rented an apartment.
In fact, it was a mailbox.
There was someone,
very well dressed,
very chic,
who came to get the mail.
Okay.
He never lived here?
Never spent a night.
Okay.
And no one lived in this apartment?
No.
There was a gentleman
who had rented it to Arnaud
at a very good price.
It must have been a little expensive.
Yes, but you know,
to avoid taxes,
it's worth it.
Would Bernard Arnaud have claimed
that he was a Belgian resident
to transfer his fortune
to his children without paying taxes?
At the Free University of Belgium,
we meet a professor
specializing in succession.
He explains to us
the advantages of the Belgian law
in this regard.
We are also known
as a tax haven
for succession rights.
Why?
Because it is very easy
to escape from succession rights.
How do we do it?
We simply build a foundation,
then we bring the assets
into this foundation.
And during his life,
he has the opportunity
to give to his children.
And like that,
everyone escapes from succession rights.
In 2012, 60% of Bernard Arnaud's
shares in his group
are gathered in a family holding,
PIL Invest,
based in Belgium.
The billionaire
houses this family holding
in a foundation,
Protect Invest.
Is it to pay less taxes
on his succession?
His goal is written in full
in the foundation's statutes.
The foundation aims
to protect the financial
and heritage interests
of the Belgian host family.
Like the University professor
Bernard Arnaud can make
a donation to his children
without paying taxes
as long as he lives in Belgium.
In 2012,
the actions of the billionaire
in Belgium began to show.
The French discover that
the big boss even asked
for Belgian citizenship.
The journal Libération publishes this famous one.
We have found a key figure in the case, John Krombeze.
He was at the time Secretary of State in charge of the fight against tax fraud
within the Belgian government.
He immediately had doubts about the sudden interest of Bernard Arnault for Belgium.
In 2012 Bernard Arnault swore to us that he loves Belgium.
Yes, I understand that.
It's one of the expressions of Mr. Arnault that I understood.
Mr. Depardieu too.
And then he loved Russia too, Mr. Depardieu, yes.
But it's good, I understood that.
I understand why he loves Belgium.
And I think when he really loves it so much as he says
that he would be more often in Belgium.
You haven't seen him so much in Belgium?
No.
Belgian justice wonders.
Did Bernard Arnault fraud on his homestead?
To check if the billionaire lives well in Hucle,
she discreetly launches an investigation.
The investigations remain confidential
until a statement is published in 2017 by the king's prosecutor.
The Belgian justice abandons the prosecution for fraud at home
against Bernard Arnault in exchange for a cash transfer.
The Public Prosecutor's Office proposed to Mr. Arnault
to put an end to public action by the conclusion of such a transaction.
How much did the billionaire pay?
The amount is confidential.
David Leloup investigated.
Bernard Arnault would have paid 2.5 million euros.
If it wasn't a fictitious home, if he really lived here,
I don't see why he agreed to pay 2.5 million
because it's all over the press
and there's always this suspicion that he'll never be released.
Was the prosecution founded or not?
Do you know a lot of people who say
I didn't do anything, but I'm going to pay a few million euros?
Come on!
And then there are press releases where they say
I didn't do it, but I'm going to pay.
It's a bit ridiculous.
It's really class justice.
We say that in French.
It's class justice because we see that
with very difficult amounts of money,
they close criminal investigations.
With this transfer, Bernard Arnault avoids
that the details of his Belgian history are revealed to the public.
The advantage of a transaction is obvious
for someone who is well-known,
who is important, who has important companies.
Obviously, we avoid a trial and the mediation of a trial.
A trial is a public matter.
Bernard Arnault probably thinks he has calmed the Belgian authorities.
Not quite.
The case hasn't stopped there.
John Krombeze has made the tax file of the Arnault contributor
available to Bercy.
He's cheating the French Republic.
We ask Christian Hecker.
He was Secretary of State at the time.
He confirms the information to us.
And he goes even further.
Bernard Arnault must have made a lot of accounts in Bercy.
Nevertheless, since I am a well-known person
and have a significant financial volume,
I had knowledge of this case.
Could the tax have used the information provided to him?
My answer is yes.
Tax affairs have led to regularization
and penalties, as it should be in the matter.
According to our information,
it would have been the subject of a redress
that would have been raised to nearly 1 billion euros.
All suggests that Bernard Arnault
could not make donations in Belgium to his heirs.
But despite these conflicts with the tax,
we discover that he continues to organize his succession
via his Belgian foundation.
We have obtained these public documents.
In 2016, the company Pilinvest,
which owns the shares of Bernard Arnault
in the foundation, split in two.
Pilinvest Participation
and Pilinvest Investment
We submit these documents to an economist,
Benoît Boussmar.
He is a specialist in French large fortunes
and the LVMH group.
Here is his interpretation.
In 2016, not only is he still in Belgium,
but he divides the company Pilinvest in two
and above all, he separates the ownership of Usufruit.
The ownership is simply the part
that gives the right to his children
to manage and start the distribution of the succession.
On the other hand, he keeps Usufruit.
And Usufruit is what gives the voting rights.
So it is always him who is in charge,
even if formally there is already a part
that has gone to the children in terms of succession rights.
You are categorical.
The split of Pilinvest in two companies,
that means that ...
At the death of Bernard Arnault,
if he is still a French resident,
his heirs should pay succession rights in France.
Concerning the foundation,
Bernard Arnault confirms to us
He adds
According to several specialists we consulted,
the heirs should not pay taxes on the succession in Belgium
as long as their share remains in the foundation.
This is the gift that Bernard Arnault gave to the French.
Finally, this is the story we were told.
The Louis Vuitton Foundation of Contemporary Art.
An architectural prowess signed by Frank Gehry,
the world star of architecture,
destined to host exhibitions of contemporary art.
President François Hollande is invited to his inauguration.
He is dithyrambic.
What is happening here is more than a fantastic museum.
It is a piece of humanity
that shows everyone
that the dream can,
by the power of genius and will,
become reality.
It is you, yes, it is you who offer us this cathedral.
Two years later,
the first event organized by the foundation is a success.
The Stukin exhibition gathers paintings never seen in France.
What we know less is that to create this foundation,
Bernard Arnault had to weigh all his influence
and change the laws.
With the arrival of a formidable tax economy
for the LVMH group.
At first, the story had started badly.
In October 2006,
Bernard Arnault announces that he wants to build
a foundation of contemporary art in the Bois de Boulogne, in Paris.
The building must be ceded to the city of Paris
after 55 years.
On his website,
LVMH talks about a major philanthropic act.
But in the city hall of Paris,
local councillors are opposed to the project.
At their head, a green elephant,
Yves Contasso.
The construction in the woods posed a series of problems.
First, the respect of the Charter of the Woods,
signed in April 2006,
which says that the woods must remain places of relaxation,
of promenade,
and therefore not at all to build large equipment there.
And so it poses a fundamental problem.
The second problem is the local plan of urbanism,
which says that in the woods,
we cannot build on more than one level,
beyond the ground floor.
And so, obviously, a foundation 48 meters high,
there was, as he would say, a small problem,
because a floor of 48 meters,
no one really believes in it.
The rules of urbanism in the capital
do not allow the building to be built.
At the Council of Paris,
the mayor, Bertrand Delannoye,
organizes a vote
that authorizes the construction of the foundation.
In March 2008,
the work can begin.
But the drivers seize the administrative tribunal.
In January 2011,
they obtain the shutdown of the site.
To save his foundation,
Bernard Arnault will have to find
new political support,
this time at the National Assembly.
The session is open.
On February 15, 2011,
the deputies vote a law
on the digital book in the evening.
Before the session,
the Minister of Culture, Frédéric Mitterrand,
asked them to introduce
an amendment that has nothing to do
with the law discussed.
It is called a legislative cavalier.
In reality,
it is a tailor-made amendment
for the Louis Vuitton Foundation,
which modifies the rules of urbanism.
I submit to the wisdom of the deputies.
Two deputies have agreed
to defend this amendment.
Hervé Guémard, from the UMP,
and Marcel Rogemont, from the PS.
The amendment would legalize
the permit to build the foundation,
once and for all,
and discreetly.
In the hemicycle,
only one deputy opposes it.
We're going to end up in a fanfare.
This amendment, I must say,
surprises me a lot.
First of all,
it has nothing to do with this text,
as Jean Dionis said,
we are in the cavalier in its purest form.
This decision of the legislative power
explicitly intended to favor
a private project,
bothers me a lot.
The amendment is extremely precise.
At the limit,
it could have been shorter
by giving us the number
of the permit to build
and asking us to validate it.
Well, I vote in favor of this amendment,
which, by the wisdom of the government,
is for...
which is against...
it is adopted.
To find out what happened behind the scenes,
we asked the two deputies
who defended, in the hemicycle,
the project of the foundation.
Only Marcel Rogemont
agreed to talk to us.
It was the cabinet of the minister
of culture at the time
who asked me
but because they knew
that I was available.
I considered that there was
public interest
in bringing this amendment.
That's why I did it,
but really,
without any particular questioning.
From the outside,
it gives the impression
that Bernard Arnault
has the power
to vote for laws
that suit him,
that go in the direction
of his business.
Well, let's agree on one thing,
I don't put that in business.
I didn't have the feeling
that I was at Mr. Arnault's feet
stripping his shoes.
That's not it.
I didn't ask for any...
I was going to say
no remuneration
because this word
can be taken
in a very broad sense.
I'm not talking about money.
I'm talking more about this and that.
As for the other deputy
who supported the amendment,
Hervé Guémard,
we asked for it.
No answer.
How far is Bernard Arnault's influence
on the elected representatives?
We asked the sociologist
Monique Pinçon-Charlot.
She has been dissecting
the practices of the most fortunate
Bernard Arnault
is obliged to use
political representatives,
deputies,
through lobbying actions,
through the integration
of left and right-wing people
important here,
important there,
for this transformation
of these particular interests
into general interests.
We have the impression
that today,
the real power
is first in the hands
of the billionaires
who can buy
such a part of the territory,
whether it is Parisian or not,
by saying
I want to settle there
and so I'm going to negotiate
with the local leaders
and possibly
the President of the Republic.
And like all this
there is a small group of people
who appreciate each other
and who discuss among themselves
and agree independently
on local or democratic
wills.
In the winter of 2011,
Bernard Arnault
has his hands free.
The work resumes.
During the entire construction period,
the amount of work
remained secret
until the inauguration.
A figure is then
released in the press.
100 million euros.
Is this really
the cost of the building?
Bernard Arnault,
accompanied by
the architect Frank Gehry,
swallows the question
of an elegant pirouette.
We are not dreaming.
Thank you very much.
Three years later,
we started working
on the accounts
of the year 2014
of the Louis Vuitton Foundation.
It is a public document.
It emanates from the Foundation
and was validated
by an account officer.
According to this document,
we are very far
from the 100 million announced.
The construction
cost 771 million euros.
If we add
the various technical expenses,
the cost exceeds
800 million euros.
A problem
for Bernard Arnault?
Not really.
LVMH will recover
a large part of this amount
thanks to a law
on the patron,
the Ayago law.
It allows a company
a deduction of 60%
of the amount
invested in a foundation.
If the operation
cost 800 million euros,
it allowed LVMH
to save 480 million euros
in taxes.
A loss to be made
of several hundred million euros
for the public treasury.
When you vote for the amendment,
do you know how much
this foundation will cost?
No.
Do you know
Oscar Wilde said
we need to have
big enough dreams
so we don't lose sight of them
when we pursue them?
No.
We just discovered
that it's 800 million.
And so it means that
tax-wise...
800 million...
800 million euros.
The...
The construction cost...
The Louis Vuitton foundation.
No, wait.
The construction cost
of the building?
770 million.
It seems a lot to me.
We show him the accounts.
That's it.
You inform me
that it's 800 million.
That...
No, but I...
Wait.
That there was
a tax cut
of 60%.
OK.
Well...
That's it.
I...
You tell me now...
OK.
You want me to tell you...
If you knew...
Would you have done that?
No.
I wouldn't have.
If that's the question.
I wouldn't have.
That's it.
That's all.
In March 2017,
again alongside Bernard Arnault,
President Hollande
celebrates the success
of the foundation
and even congratulates
the billionaire
for this beautiful operation.
It's also a success
in terms of attendance.
Without...
making you pay more taxes,
which is still appreciable
in the period we are in.
Bernard Arnault
appreciates this joke,
but she doesn't make everyone laugh.
Tax niches
are disguised subsidies,
but here it's a scandalous tax niche.
I think that if there should be
a major modification
in terms of foundation,
it's the ceiling
of defiscalization.
By saying,
I don't know,
50, 100 million,
it can be discussed,
but it should be ceilinged.
There is no reason
to go so far,
close to 500 million
of defiscalization,
when we are told
that we are looking
for a few million
here and there.
It's unthinkable.
We wanted to ask the minister
who offered this advantage
to the patron,
the author of the law,
Jean-Jacques Ayagon,
Surprisingly,
the former Minister of Culture
ignores the cost
of the Louis Vuitton Foundation.
I discovered,
and I'm going to show it to you,
because in general,
you don't believe me.
No, you are very kind.
The Louis Vuitton Foundation
cost nearly 800 million euros.
It's a lot of money,
but it's an extremely sophisticated building,
built by a great architect.
I don't know,
you can take the price
of this site,
it's undeniably
a lot of money,
but I think that the size,
the size,
probably justifies
this significant investment.
For the former minister,
it wouldn't be the tax savings
that would have motivated Bernard Arnault.
No, I don't think
there is a tax optimization strategy.
I think there is probably
an intelligence,
but with Bernard Arnault,
like here,
like everywhere,
there are excellent specialists
on tax issues.
There is awareness,
indeed,
that part of the committed sums
can lead to tax cuts,
but I find it hard to believe
that these projects
are deliberately committed
just to obtain
tax cuts.
Another former minister of culture
also seems to have
ignored the numbers
in this case.
He is, however,
in the front row.
Renaud Deneudieu de Vabre
is one of the five administrators
of the Louis Vuitton Foundation.
He will learn more from us
than from a board of directors.
I don't have the number in mind,
but in any case,
these are numbers that are
totally public
and totally accessible.
Completely.
In fact,
we have the number
at almost 800 million euros.
What do you think about it?
I don't know what you mean.
I don't think this number corresponds...
The construction of the building.
Just taking the construction
of the building,
in fact,
we have almost 800 million.
I don't have the number in mind.
I don't think it's that number.
Once again,
we show the documents.
800 million,
that's the number
that appears
in the accounts of the foundation.
That means that 60%
of the 800 million
are defiscalized,
so about 480 million
do not go into
the state's revenues.
Isn't that money
that the state could have used
in culture, precisely?
I think that,
if you will,
there you have to be
very realistic.
If this project
had not taken place,
in any case,
the state would not have
given more budget
to the creation
or to the support
of a certain number of projects.
So there, if you will,
there was a great initiative,
there was a private funding,
tax deductions,
it made this project possible.
In his email,
Bernard Arnault writes to us...
And he adds...
Some elected representatives
of the nation
do not agree with this.
Tax deductions
related to the patronage
of companies,
such as those
that LVMH benefited from,
have increased
significantly in recent years.
In the Senate,
the Finance Committee
has recently been alarmed
by this in a report.
The report is critical.
Among the former
Ministers of Culture,
Aurélie Filippetti
is the only one
to break the consensus
around Bernard Arnault
and his foundation.
What I find
rather shocking
in the way
in which all this is presented,
is that ultimately,
public opinion
has the impression
that it is a gift
that Bernard Arnault
made to France,
to Paris,
that this foundation.
However, if there is a gift,
it is rather a gift
from the State.
It is quite funny
how generosity
with the money of others
is easy to implement.
It is really
the master of illusion.
It costs him
quite a bit of money
in relation
to the benefits
he draws from it,
both in terms of images,
in terms of radiation.
Jean-Michel Taubelhem
is a specialist
in patronage.
According to him,
the richest man in France
is not as philanthropic
as he claims.
If I make a gift to someone,
I will not ask
this person to contribute
financially to the gift
I make to them.
I will assume it entirely.
After all,
a group as rich
as LVMH,
and we can be happy about it,
does not need
to ask for the benefit
of tax deduction.
It can assume it
completely.
As for Mr. Arnault,
on a personal level,
his fortune of more than
40 billion euros
of personal fortune
would allow him,
as an individual,
to offer several foundations
of this kind
to Parisians
or French people,
if they wanted.
We asked for an interview
filmed by the billionaire.
He made us answer
that he did not have the time.
In the press,
he prefers to highlight
the jobs created by his group.
Example,
in this interview
published in Paris Match
in October 2017.
In France,
we hire 3,000 people per year.
Hire or create jobs.
Benoît Boussmar
listed the employees
of each of the branches
of the LVMH group
until 2016.
What is certain,
according to him,
is that the group
does not create
3,000 new jobs per year.
When he tells me
that he has created 3,000 jobs,
we can see that between
2008 and 2016,
we have a maximum
of 1,000 jobs per year.
And in these 1,000 jobs,
three quarters of the time,
these are companies
that have been bought.
For example,
in terms of purchases,
I look at new companies
in 2016.
What is it?
It's the Parisien,
it's Tim Diffusion,
it's Proximity.
We can't say
that he creates jobs
in this area.
The creation of jobs
by Bernard Arnault,
for me, is zero.
At the end of our investigation,
we are far from having
unraveled all the fiscal threads
used by the billionaire.
One thing is certain,
it is one of the keys
to his immense success.
