Behind the Scenes: An Affair to Remember (McCarey, 1957) with Cary Grant and Deborah Kerr

Fantastic behind the scenes
10 followers
10 Video Views·Nov 8, 2026
This audio-visual film commentary has been extensively edited, dubbed and transformed by Serious Feather in an original and thoughtful manner for historical, cultural and educational purposes.
AI Generated·May contain errors
The camera goes right through the skin.
The camera brings out what you are.
And in her case, there was always a kind of a humanity
that she had in all of the things she played.
The Affair to Remember was one of her most successful roles.
She knew it was a movie that everybody saw
every six months and had a good cry.
Why didn't you tell me?
If it had to happen to one of us,
why did it have to be you?
Cary Grant is a wonderful actor.
I'd known him for years and years. We both worked at RKO together.
He had a great friendship with Deborah.
There was a chemistry between them that came across.
Must you be so darn delightful? You make it easy to be true.
Ha, ha, ha.
Oh, why can't we go on doing this forever?
It's a very sentimental, sad love story, but very touching.
I started as a junior writer for David Selznick.
I was all of 19 years old.
In 1958, Anatole Litvak was a movie director I had worked
for on several occasions,
was making a film with Deborah Carr,
and then he asked me would I come in.
And brighten up a few lines.
So I went to Vienna at the start of shooting the movie.
Litvak gave a dinner at the hotel where we were staying, the Imperial.
And I was lucky enough to be seated next to Deborah.
And the rest was pretty simple.
We both liked each other immediately.
Every other man in the world had fallen in love with Deborah.
Why shouldn't I? And indeed I did.
We had a very stormy beginning because she was married.
She was not the kind of Hollywood actress
who would shed a husband that easily.
So it was torture for her.
Very, very difficult for him, too.
Her husband arrived and there were fairly unpleasant moments.
Her marriage had not been all that successful.
And Tony Barclay, her husband,
made her children wards of court in England.
So the whole thing became rather serious quite quickly.
It's an unpleasant thing to have to go through.
At the same time, it was necessary
if I could ever be with her and her children,
if we could all live together.
And finally, we managed.
It took a considerable amount of time.
It had to be years' wait before she could remarry,
which we did.
The things that stood in our way
seemed almost too big to conquer.
However, we were lucky enough
We both hung on, and then really had, oh,
three or four pretty happy decades after that.
My first wife, from whom I was divorced, died very early on.
And Deborah really took over as a mother of my daughter.
And she was as good a mother to my daughter as she was to her own.
Which again, is very much in character.
Always there were problems,
but if she was a model wife and I was anything but a model husband,
it survived, the marriage survived.
The sad thing is that somebody
who has almost as unblemished a character as Deborah,
She's gotten this disease.
The medicine one takes against Parkinson's
is a medicine that slows up your reactions even more.
She has become chair-bound.
The amazing thing about Deborah, and rather typical thing,
despite this really severe illness, she never complains.
She never was really conscious of the fact that she was world famous.
She was an actress and she loved to act
and in acting she assumed somebody else's personality.
I think she made movies that have never worn off their splendor.
This is frightfully intimate.
I know just enough French to be embarrassed.
Could you um refine it a little and tell me in effect what it says?
Deborah is a saint and whatever foibles and insufficiencies
and mistakes I've made in my life she could forgive them quite easily.
And as she never made any, it was quite easy for me to go on.
In Hollywood films of different periods,
there's different styles of looks that come into play.
And An Affair to Remember is a classic example
of the look of the 1950s Hollywood feature film.
The amazing thing to me,
the thing that makes it very interesting for me, is that Leo McCarey...
works within the format of Hollywood filmmaking in the 1950s
and uses color, uses the frame,
uses his staging to tell a very particular story. One of the reasons
I think this film has lasted as a classic
is because the look of the film
It's so carefully crafted.
It has a kind of fox look of the 50s.
That's because of the cinemascope and color.
Otto Preminger said that the only thing a cinemascope would be good for
would be snakes making love.
McCarey's motto was always do it visually.
And so I think he does a wonderful job with cinemascope
in terms of filling the frame with information
and his placement of characters and how he utilized them,
especially some of the shipboard scenes.
McCarey had really come into prominence.
Doing films for Laurel and Hardy.
And he understood that comedy and drama were about the characters.
They weren't about the architecture.
And so that's how he chooses to draw you in to these people.
He lets the actors have a tremendous
amount of freedom within the frame.
There are parts of this film
that were improvised between Cary Grant and Deborah Kerr.
He allows you to do that because he's got everything set up
that you're only focusing on now.
Even though Leo McCarey
He really used sort of a tableau set up to do most of his scenes there,
very flat set up,
put his players generally on the same plane of movement in the frame.
He knew how to use his location,
he knew how to use his sets in creative ways to help tell the story.
When you see Terry and Nicky first meet,
well they meet on board a ship.
But Nikki is inside a hallway, a passageway, and there are windows
that he and Terry interact through when she has his cigarette case.
And there's a wall between them, a physical wall,
a barrier between them actually being able to come together.
One of the things that's fascinating to me about this film is that...
Cary Grant really wanted to shoot this on a real ship at sea.
He wanted everything to be on location.
Leo McCarey did not want to do this.
Leo McCarey wanted to make a studio film.
Because they didn't try to go and shoot this on a ship,
it has a very different look.
It's a dream film. It's a memory film.
And so the fact that it's done in that kind of bright Technicolor,
done in widescreen and done in studio with artificial backdrops,
is not a problem for most people.
There's no way you could have shot.
This movie and gotten the type of emotional response from an audience
by shooting it on location in a real ship because you wouldn't have had
the layer of unreality that surrounds this movie.
All of the exteriors.
...of Cary Grant and Deborah Kerr on the ship are shot on a soundstage.
And it's very evident when you're looking
at the film that it's shot on a soundstage.
This layer of unreality is very subtle. Most viewers won't notice it.
Deborah Kerr's head shadow in one shot
is very clearly on Cary Grant's shoulder.
And then when you reverse the shot,
they've moved the light so that her face is fully lit,
so her shadow falls behind her.
And this layer of unreality actually adds to that emotional intimacy.
That you see in a romance like this.
Well, that sort of brings us up to date.
Now my life is an open book.
Now that's only one page.
Leo McCarey was making sure that you were focused on the faces.
It's one of the reasons he doesn't use the architecture of the ship,
that he uses very subtle pastel colors in the background,
so that you're looking at his two stars.
You are falling in love with Deborah Kerr.
You are falling in love with Cary Grant.
And to do that, he focuses very much on their faces.
You see the layer of unreality tremendously
when they go and visit Cary Grant's grandmother.
You see a location shot, and you look
at the hard shadows that they cast on the sidewalk.
And then when Cary Grant and Deborah Kerr arrive at his grandmother's,
if you look, they're casting six, eight shadows at a time.
Well, they're on a soundstage.
All the lights are set up in different directions
to make sure their faces are beautifully lit.
What you get is you get a scene
that is still very intimate about the characters.
Now, once they arrive back into New York,
once they come back into the real world,
You start having reality intrude.
You have this one icon of reality,
and that's the Empire State Building.
The way Leo McCarey uses the Empire State Building
and the way it had to be shot,
I mean, you could have gotten a filmmaker
who would have created a model of the Empire State Building.
You could have done things
where you did elaborate moves around it
to sort of romanticize the Empire State Building.
Leo McCarey doesn't do that.
The Empire State Building is not an icon of something good.
It is this.
A large gray monolith that stands up
and it keeps reappearing in this film and it's almost
like a tombstone in the way that it's used.
And of course the classic shot
is when Deborah Carr pushes the glass door open and as it
swings out you see the Empire State Building perfectly reflected in it.
Well, this was a shot that was done on a studio soundstage.
Leo McCarey is careful that they make it look realistic,
that it is not something that is
done with a cheap special effect or anything like that.
He wants that to be an icon of reality.
He wants that to intrude on the bubble of the romance.
This is a film that takes you into the unreality of falling in love,
where the rest of the
world disappears and the reality of the rest of the world disappears,
and reality intrudes
harshly.
for these characters,
and then they have to find each other again outside of that bubble,
that blush of the initial romance.
And that's what this movie's about. And visually,
Leo McCarey is able to use the tools
at his command to create an unreal world
for them to fall in love with, to let reality intrude visually.
And to bring them together in a smaller, more human way.
And this is done not just with the script,
not just with the performances,
but how Leo McCarey sets up his frame,
the canvas on which he chooses to paint.
And it goes from the grand to the simple.
And that's one of the things that makes this film resonate with people.
To come from the background that he came from,
with very, very little education,
to become such an extraordinary intelligent man.
To become such a loving man.
He was truly one of the most extraordinary people that I've ever met.
Just an awful lot of good things about Cary.
Really an awful lot of good things.
He was just an extraordinary man.
The first ten and a half years of my life
was in East Africa in what was then Tanganyika.
It's now called Tanzania.
When I was about ten and a half I went to boarding school in England
and after I'd finished schooling I went up to London.
I was doing public relations at the Royal Lancaster Hotel.
Margot Hemingway was the Fabergé girl
and I had the press all waiting for her.
And the plane had been a little bit late,
and so they were beginning to get a tiny bit antsy.
So I was much more concerned with her than meeting Carrie.
Finally, someone came over and said,
now you must come over and meet Cary Grant.
And I said, no, no, no, just let me get this finished,
and then I'll come and see him.
And they said, no, he's around the corner, you'll come now.
So I went, I said hello,
and I said goodbye within seconds and disappeared.
Sorted out the situation with Margot Hemingway.
And then came back about two hours later, walked through
the lobby area just before the dining room at the Royal Lancaster
and there was Roddy Mann and Cary seated and calling me over.
And Roddy said to me, I believe you're taking us to lunch.
And I thought that was a little bit fresh, so I said,
no, I'm not, but I'll make a reservation for you.
And disappeared again when they said no, it wasn't necessary.
About two hours later, I came back, and they were still seated there.
So I went up to them, and I said,
I'm sorry you couldn't find anyone to take you to lunch.
I'll take you.
And so that's how we met.
I really didn't know very much about Cary Grant.
We were not a family that went to see many films.
When we came back to England,
we'd see a little bit of television and not that much.
Obviously, I was aware of his name.
I had seen a couple of his films, but that was about it.
My first impression of him was just as an extremely nice gentleman.
I just enjoyed him.
I loved talking to him.
I loved his inquisitive mind.
And we just seemed to have fun together.
I had actually been a little concerned
at maybe having to spend too much time with someone
who thought too much of themselves, which was not the case with him.
He very seldom talked of himself.
It was always about other things and other interests.
The friendship really evolved for various reasons.
One of them was he had relatives in Bristol.
My parents were in the southwest of England, so I would take him
to Bristol, drop him off there, and then continue on in my little Mini.
Paul Carey had his knees virtually up
his nose whenever we drove down there.
So we would have hours of conversation during the drive.
And it just,
Every time that he was coming to England, he would call,
and sometimes he would call when he was just in America.
We would just have wonderful conversations,
always long conversations and always with a lot of laughter.
One time he came over, and there was a charity affair,
and Carrie asked if I wanted to go.
He, I believe, was sitting with Mountbatten,
so I was just in the audience.
And I remember when I was listening to the songs, thinking,
now I should be thinking of the person that I'm going out with,
I should not be thinking of Carrie.
And that was the first time that something began to creep in there.
And then I suppose the major decision was made
when Cary was over for Princess Caroline's wedding.
And everyone was there, that the Pecks were there,
Sinatras, everyone of course.
And one night they went to a restaurant up
in the hills behind Nice called Le Chaumier.
And they were all having such a wonderful time,
and everyone said, you know, why don't you have someone with you?
And Carrie said, well, there's someone that I'm interested in,
but she's not interested in me.
And they said, oh, don't be silly, you know,
just put your charm on, call her, and get her to come over here.
And he actually called that night,
and we had a long, long conversation.
And probably for about the fourth or fifth time,
he asked me if I would join him somewhere, and I just thought, why not?
Both of us had a relationship at that stage.
I mean, Carrie would ask me, whenever we were on the phone,
he would always ask me what was going on with my relationship,
which always amused me.
But, as I said, there were never any thoughts in my mind,
I have no idea what was in Carrie's mind,
there were never any thoughts in my mind
that we would have a relationship.
It purely was friendship.
But, in retrospect, it's interesting.
We were both in relationships, and we both, I think, did some...
Soul-searching towards the end of those relationships
and realize that there was something that we had in our relationship
that could lead to something else.
Finally did, obviously, but that was only right at the end of the time
before it changed from a friendship to a love affair.
I think we were very in sync, and I think that's why I didn't have
so much trouble finally making a decision to change my life completely,
because the relationship that we had was a very precious one.
The age...
The difference really wasn't that important,
and after a while I really wasn't so aware of it.
I was, for example, if I sat down
in the place that said Mrs. Cary Grant,
and someone would say to me, no, no, no,
you shouldn't be sitting there, that's for Mrs. Cary Grant,
it would always amuse me, because they obviously
were expecting to find someone a little older than me.
And I used to tease them a tiny bit and say, no, no, it was me,
and unfortunately watch them get a little bit red,
so that was rather unkind of me.
But it really didn't...
It didn't become of any importance
to me after a certain amount of time.
The only thing was that of course there's
a little shadow hanging over you because you
sometimes wonder, well how long will this be?
But the important thing of having
that age difference was also that you didn't waste
time.
We had arguments because I'm a little strong-willed sometimes,
and so was he, but they didn't
last for very long
because we both realized that we didn't have the time to be so stupid.
So we would say what we had to say,
and it would always be over and done with before
the night was out.
The most surprising thing about Cary
was always the fact that he was so down to earth
having had the career that he had, and I admired that so much in him.
He never desired to speak about himself.
I mean, I had to pull things out of him.
He would never talk about his films.
He would never do anything of that sort
because he was much more interested
in what was happening in the present
and was going to happen in the future
as opposed to constantly referring to the past.
Harry's charm was greater offscreen than it was onscreen,
but it was not a charm that was...
Sometimes charm can be beguiling in a bad way.
It can be in order to get what you want.
And I suppose we all use charm
for that at certain times in our life. But his was
It was just a part of Cary.
It wasn't the Cary Grant on screen
that just had to portray this figure,
this being so sophisticated and being so charming.
He was charming.
I mean, that was Cary.
I think he maybe taught me how a relationship should be
and that one shouldn't have fear in a relationship.
If you're constantly fearful that you're going to get hurt,
then you're never going to experience a very deep relationship
because you always will have.
Some boundaries around you that people can't penetrate.
So don't go into a relationship
if you want something deep with those boundaries.
I think that I learned.
I learned to be more accepting of people
and their different thoughts and their different ideas
because Cary was very open to a mass of things
that maybe I was a little bit more closed to.
And basically his thought was that everyone has
the right to say what they want,
to think what they want, and if you
are having a disagreement with someone,
you need to give that person the space and the right.
To voice their opinions without thinking,
no, no, no, they're 100% wrong
because they don't think as I think
because we all have different thoughts
and those need to be acknowledged.
So that I learned from him
and that was a very good lesson
because I think things were much more black and white for me.
You're either right or you're wrong,
but that's not life.
You know, everything's in tones.
Carrie and I did speak about the fact that this was an amazing romance,
but he spoke about it very generously because he would sit me down,
much to my objection, and he would say, now we're going
to talk about something that you don't like, and that is,
when I'm no longer here, what I want you to do with your life.
He said, the worst thing you can possibly do is just sit
and be sad that we had the
relationship that we had.
He said, I want you to absolutely have joy in it
and to go out and find someone else
that will make you tremendously happy
and never for one second feel any guilt.
Now that, I think, is probably the most generous thing
that anyone can do, because always in
the back of most people's minds are, my goodness,
I hope they never meet anyone who they loved
as much as us.
And he was saying, please go out
and try and find someone that you love.
He gave me the freedom to do that,
which was again a wonderful gift, because I never felt
any guilt afterwards for having other relationships.
Because it was as though I would have
still done it because life goes on,
but he had given me a blessing,
which was a very generous one, which made it easier.
