Batman v Superman: The Fundamental Flaw

Nerdwriter1
2 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 21, 2024
GET MY BOOK: https://amzn.to/3ymfQPV
I'm putting together a team of people with special abilities.
You see, I believe enemies are coming.
Stop right there. I'm in.
You are?
Now that the Justice League trailer is out and it has jokes,
there's a lot of talk about DC's course correction,
as if the overly grim tone of Batman v Superman was the key to why it wasn't that good of a movie.
But from my point of view, Zack Snyder could make Justice League an out-and-out comedy,
and it still wouldn't fix what I see as a more fundamental problem in his filmmaking,
something that's really apparent in Batman v Superman.
His preoccupation, his obsession with moments at the expense of scenes.
What do I mean by this?
Well, let me start by saying this.
Movie moments are awesome.
A really great moment can be transcendent.
It can leave deep, lifelong visual impressions on a filmgoer.
They can come to represent a whole new category of feeling.
That's why film geeks like me reference them so much in conversation with friends.
When you're a film student, at least when I was a film student,
that's what makes things exciting.
Most of the student films I directed revolved around a few moments
that I thought were gonna blow people away.
If I could just navigate the story there, that would be enough.
The moment would do all the work.
Then I'd just navigate to the next one.
For this reason, my student films weren't that good.
Batman v Superman, Dawn of Justice.
I think suffers from a similar problem.
Zack Snyder is obviously obsessed with moments.
The movie is chock full of them.
Moments when time is slowed down and the composition is just right.
Moments when the score swells and the film tries to broadcast a single message.
Be on.
A lot of people talk about Snyder as a great visual stylist.
Well, of course he is.
That's where all the focus goes, toward crafting moments.
They say his characters lack motivation.
Well, of course they do, because all character motivations
are subservient to the film's own motivation to reach the next moment.
It makes sense then that Snyder puts extraordinary care into montages.
Twice in this film, the opening credits featuring Batman's origin story
and at the 44 minute mark, spotlighting Superman's more impressive heroics,
we have slow motion moment montages.
There are something like 40 shots in these montages together
and they all aim to be iconic.
I think if Snyder could make a whole movie like this, he would.
Oh, wait, he already did.
This is Sparta!
It's also why he favors dream sequences and flashbacks.
More excuses to show more moments.
What Batman v Superman really lacks is scenes.
Actual scenes, not just filler between moments.
Scenes are hard to define, since they're so malleable.
It's hard to say what one is.
But what a good scene does is dissolve the actors and the soundstage
and the costumes and makeup and camera angle
into a living and breathing reality.
There should be a strong sense of place, a feeling of possibility
that the characters who inhabit the space could go anywhere within it,
even if they don't, even if you know that the technicalities
of lighting and blocking wouldn't let them.
In other words, the discrete elements that make up a good scene
should not feel like they're in service to something else,
even though they are.
Too often in Batman v Superman,
the characters feel awkwardly placed in their scenes.
I mean, does anyone get the sense that Clark Kent, Lois Lane or Perry White
actually spend time as the Daily Planet?
We visit the Daily Planet eight times in the movie,
but the longest scene there is only a minute and 11 seconds.
The rest are under a minute and half are under 30 seconds.
This doesn't feel like a place.
It feels like a fraction of a location where people say things like this.
When the planet was founded, it stood for something, Perry.
The Batcave, Lois and Clark's apartment, Lex Luthor's office, the Kryptonian ship
all have the same issue, and that's just about the extent of the settings
that we visit more than once in the film.
What's more, these scenes are filmed largely in medium shots,
close-ups or extreme close-ups,
which makes it even harder to ground the scenes
or for the audience to ground itself within them.
And in all these places, we spend an awful lot of time looking at screens.
There's also very little distinction between Metropolis and Gotham,
the two cities that sculpted their respective heroes.
If you're looking for a metaphor for the whole film,
note the fact that one of the longest scenes takes place
on an abandoned island between the two cities
that the heroes completely destroy.
Building a good scene isn't only about location.
It's about fitting the dialogue, the tone and the characters
into that location and endowing it with a sense of duration.
Avengers Age of Ultron from last year, it isn't a perfect movie,
but there's a great story about how Joss Whedon
fought to keep the Hawkeye farmhouse scene in the film.
That slow-paced, confident scene runs for a full 16 minutes,
right in the middle of the action.
And when you're there, you're not waiting to go somewhere else.
You're there, learning about the characters.
And when those characters have their moments later in the film,
they land with poignancy.
Of course, almost all films, especially superhero blockbusters,
are gonna have expositional scenes and scenes that set up future action.
And in great movies, all the scenes often work together
to participate in an overarching tone or a complex message.
But great scenes function as their own little universes within a film.
And good movies should have plenty of them.
Batman v Superman runs for two and a half hours
with a heaping helping of big moments,
and yet I don't quite feel like I've been anywhere.
The scene is where awe is loaded into the chamber.
Firing the gun without loading can only result in empty noise,
a bang, but no impact.
I'm always hopeful about new Superman movies
because Superman is so important to me,
but I won't let some Batman jokes and upbeat rock music fool me.
Lightheartedness isn't the basic problem that needs to be fixed here.
The overused and unearned moment is DC's greatest foe.
Hey guys, you know I couldn't resist doing a video on Superman.
I just can't resist.
There's a new Nerdwriter video every Wednesday,
so if you go right there and click that and subscribe to this channel,
you'll get all of them.
That really helps me out.
I gotta thank Squarespace for helping to sponsor this video.
They helped to fund this channel without interfering in the content,
which is just so awesome.
They make sleek, intuitive websites.
You don't have to know coding.
If you sign up for a year, you can get a free domain name,
and if you use the offer code NERDWRITER at squarespace.com,
you can get 10% off your first purchase,
which is cool if you want to make a website.
Thank you guys so much.
I'll see you next Wednesday.
