Autopsie d'un tableau : Bonaparte visitant les pestiférés de Jaffa d'Antoine-Jean Gros.

Antoine-Jean Gros
1 follower
1 Video View·Dec 1, 2025
Cette vidéo se propose d'analyser sur le plan artistique, historique et surtout médical le tableau d'Antoine-Jean Gros, Bonaparte visitant les pestiférés de Jaffa, de 1804, qui se trouve au musée du Louvre. Elle revient sur le rôle de la peste dans la défaite de Bonaparte en Syrie, sur les événements qui ont entourés cette épidémie et surtout sur les buts de la commande de ce tableau par le futur Napoléon.
Hello. Welcome to Histomène,
the history of medicine in question channel,
which offers you in this playlist of medicine, art and society
an up-to-date subject, since we are going to perform
the autopsy of the painting entitled
Bonaparte visiting Jaffa's pestiferous
by the painter Antoine-Jean Gros.
This large oil painting on canvas,
more than 5m by 7m,
executed in 1804,
is exhibited at the Louvre Museum
in the Molien Hall,
between the horse-riding officer
of the Imperial Guard, Chargent,
of Théodore Géricault,
and the portrait of Joachim Murat de Gros.
We also find in this hall
the raft of the jellyfish of Théodore Géricault,
which will be the subject of a later autopsy.
The detailed analysis of the painting
Bonaparte visiting Jaffa's pestiferous
first imposes a little historical reminder.
This episode is set during the campaign of Egypt,
which was a military expedition,
but dubbed a scientific expedition,
led by General Bonaparte and his successors,
the generals Cleber and Bon,
from 1798 to 1801.
Outside of the battles,
such as the Battle of the Pyramids,
which takes place under our eyes,
thanks to the painter Lejeune,
many morbid infections decimate the military,
like the civilians.
Ophthalmia, variole, dysentery,
tetanus, leprosy, paludism,
but the most deadly of all
was certainly the plague.
The plague had disappeared from France
since the terrible epidemic of Marseille in 1720,
depicted on this painting,
but the expedition's doctors
knew they would come across it on their way,
starting with Degenet,
the chief doctor of this expedition.
He wrote in his Medical History of the Eastern Army,
that the plague was endemic in Lower Egypt
and along the coasts of Syria,
as it had been there for centuries.
He could have written for millennia,
since the tenth plague of Egypt was the plague.
The troops and the doctors
were going to discover this disease
as soon as they landed in Alexandria.
They ignored everything,
apart from the evocative clinic
with the famous bubons,
including the cause
and, of course, the treatment.
I remind you that it was the Swiss Alexandre Yersin
who discovered in Annam
the plague pathogen agent in 1894
and the French military doctor
Paul-Louis Simon
the role of the pus as agent
for the transmission of the rat to man in 1897.
However, it was especially during the expedition to Syria
that this dreadful disease,
with nearly a third of the deaths,
caused the most victims,
participating in the defeat
against Saint-Jean-d'Acre.
On March 9, 1799,
the day after the capture of Jaffa,
the wounded were evacuated
by mobile ambulances
to the sedentary hospitals
where the surgeon-in-chief
of the expedition,
who recounted the events in a book, was.
We found, the citizen Saint-Ours,
major surgeon of the 32nd half-brigade,
and me,
some bruised tumors
on the corpses of these individuals
and, a few of them,
gangrene petechiae,
which made us believe
in the existence of a pestilential fever.
The first case,
patient 0, as we now say,
seems to have been Grenadier Roubion,
for whom, two days before the assault,
the surgeon Saint-Ours had noted
that the top and upper extremities
were covered with livid spots.
He had a soft tumor
under the right armpit.
It was covered with petechiae
half an hour before his death.
The disease spread to the troops,
filling the hospitals,
and accompanied Bonaparte
on his march to Saint-Jean-d'Acre.
Aware of the fear
that this invisible enemy
was causing to his men,
Napoleon wrote in
Campagne d'Egypte et de Syrie,
The fear was in the army.
It is in these particular circumstances
that it is most dangerous
for the people who fear it.
Those who let themselves be controlled
by fear are almost all dead.
This remark is astonishing,
but we know well today
the impact of morality
on the immune system.
Strong with this remark,
the day before leaving the camp
and in order to contest
the contagiousness of the disease
and to boost the morale of his troops,
Bonaparte then decided
to visit the hospitals of Jaffa.
If some placed this visit
at the return of Syrie,
Desgenettes,
drawn here by living names
that one cannot tax as idolatry
of Bonapartist,
made a precise account
of it and places it well
on March 11th.
On March 21st, he writes,
General Anchef went through
the two hospitals,
spoke to almost all the soldiers
and took more than an hour and a half
of all the details of the organization.
Being in a narrow
and very cramped room,
he helped to lift
the wrinkled corpse of a soldier
whose clothes were soiled
by the opening of an obsessed bottle.
Chateaubriand,
of whom we know
the painful relationships
with Napoleon,
of course contested
the veracity of this visit,
quoting Bourienne,
Bonaparte's secretary,
but whose memories had been written
in the ink of resentment.
This visit of General Anchef was
however reported by several witnesses
of good faith,
such as the battalion commander
of the three,
the treasurer Perus,
General Damas,
or the gold collector.
Other chroniclers reported
what they had heard
and sometimes distorted the truth.
This is how history is written
and painted,
since a letter from Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire,
a member of this expedition
of Egypt as a scientist,
which we see around General Anchef
on this canvas of cognac,
yet absent from Jaffa at the time of the events,
seems to have been the origin
of the big picture that interests us.
The naturalist indeed wrote
to his father a letter from Cairo
on June 23.
The health officers,
to whom an intrepid action
of General Anchef communicated
a real enthusiasm,
treated the plague-stricken
with devotion.
This visit to the hospital
bore its fruits,
if we believe Napoleon.
The result of all these means
was that the army remained
convinced that it was not the plague.
It was only a few months later
that the army had to agree
that once the army was in motion,
the disease would cease.
The painting of Gros dates back
to a very real visit of General Anchef
to the hospital in Jaffa,
but it is his treatment
that we are going to detail
that raises questions.
Let us begin with the genesis
of this work,
whose commission almost escaped
to Gros, yet a few years earlier
from a good apartment
at the Pont d'Arcole,
which had been very much appreciated
by those interested.
A living name who had participated
in the campaign of Egypt,
but not that of Syria,
member of the art commission
and in the meantime
became the director of the Louvre,
had reserved it to Pierre Narcisse Guérin,
a neoclassical painter,
member of the institute
and director of the Villa Medicis in Rome.
Above all, the author,
to stay in our campaign of Egypt,
of this good apartment,
thanks to the Revolte du Caire,
painted in 1808.
The painting of the Pestiferi
was finally ordered to Gros,
whose portrait is here
at the Château de Versailles,
by Bonaparte in person,
probably thanks to the commission
of Josephine,
who appreciated the painter
since Italy,
where he had been appointed
to the head of the commission
who was in charge of selecting
the stolen works of art
intended to enrich the collections
of the Louvre.
This agro-commission of Bonaparte
visiting the Pestiferi of Jaffa,
which will be followed in 1806
by that of the Battle of Aboukir,
which is at the Château de Versailles,
and in 1808 by that of Napoleon
on the field of the Battle of Elos,
preserved at the Louvre,
was therefore in honor
of the withdrawal of the order
from the battle of Nazareth,
another episode of the campaign of Egypt,
but where General Junot,
judged less opportune,
and whose sketch is seen here.
This battle took place
on April 8, 1799.
Junot, led by 300 men,
met in Lubia an army ten times
superior in number,
and defeated it,
as shown by this canvas of Tonnet.
Bonaparte immediately offered
a price of 500 louis
for a painting depicting this battle,
which was called
the Battle of Nazareth,
more media-like.
Gros won the jury's vote
and began sketching.
He was going to execute
when the first consul
reduced the size of the painting
to 8 meters for the final work,
wanting to avoid too much publicity
to Junot,
whose republican sentiments
were known at least
before he became duke of Abrantes.
It is on the unused canvas,
but on which we find
the preparatory drawings of Fusain,
that Gros then punished
our Bonaparte visiting
the pestilence of Jaffa.
At the request of Denon,
who consulted Dejeunette
for the occasion,
Gros then sketched a first drawing,
currently at the Louvre's
Isaac Delgado Museum
in New Orleans,
where we see Bonaparte
being raised by a sick man.
This scene is therefore
more realistic
than Dejeunette's.
After significant changes,
probably suggested by Denon,
the artist made another sketch
at the Musée Condé de Chantilly,
far from the effect
but very close to the final work,
entitled
Bonaparte General-in-Chief
of the Army of the East
Touching a Pestilence Tumour
while Visiting the Pestilence
in the Jaffa Hospital.
The final painting,
painted in Versailles,
was finished in six months
for the exhibition opening
on September 18, 1804,
a few weeks before Napoleon's sacrament.
We will see the importance
of this chronology.
Before that, Gros showed it
to a certain Allard,
a surgeon at the Hospice Cochin,
and to his master David,
the author of the sacrament.
Contrary to the sketches
at the Museum of New Orleans,
where the scene took place
in a closed room,
everything now takes place
in a mosque with a courtyard
and a minaret.
The stories of the protagonists
of this expedition
indicate that the Jaffa hospitals
had been created in two convents,
the largest of which,
reserved for the wounded,
was the Convent of the Fathers
of the Holy Land,
perhaps a building
like the Monastery of St. Nicholas
in Jaffa,
south of Tel Aviv.
In addition, in the background
of Gros's painting,
there are murals of the city,
of which a tower
has a gap,
a sign of the recent battles,
while a French flag
floats over the smoke of a fire.
We are therefore outside the city,
which was rarely the case
of the mosques.
The officer of Génie Manus,
who fell ill from the plague in Jaffa
and remained there,
confirms in his story
that the Hospice of the Pestilentiary
had been set up in a Greek monastery,
which should have resembled
the Copte Monastery of Saint-Maquaire
in the Ceté Desert.
Let's go back
to our final painting,
which follows the same principle
as the Sermon on the Horses
of 1784 by Jacques-Louis David,
also preserved in the Louvre.
We notice on Gros's painting
the same three arcades
as on the Sermon on the Horses.
It is the same for the three groups
of characters.
On the left, the sons pledge their oath,
in the middle, the father,
raising the swords,
and on the right, the sad women.
We find these three groups of characters
on Gros's painting.
Let's start with the one on the right.
The first character is a soldier
from Ofthalmy.
He was already present
on the sketch of the New Orleans.
Ofthalmy is a generic term
to designate many eye affections,
from trachoma to conjunctivitis,
and especially in Egypt,
linked to the sun and the Kamsin,
the nitrous wind of the desert.
This Ofthalmy,
who was the object of a memory of the Array,
affected up to two-thirds of the army
and was the cause of many suicides.
The second character,
apparently ill,
with a disturbing look,
depicts a medical officer
on the knees of a soldier.
Gros would have given this doctor
the features of Pierre Masclay,
a first-class surgeon,
a young man of rare merit
who died of the plague
as a victim of his wing,
a friend of the painter,
and who would have wanted
to honour the memory.
But Masclay had already died
of the plague in Alexandria
at the time of the capture of Jaffa.
It could also be Jean-François Saint-Ours,
who died at the Jaffa hospital
as a first-class surgeon
of the 32nd half-brigade,
that of soldier Roubion,
the famous Patient Zero,
and also that of the soldier
depicted on Gros' painting
with this hat,
embellished with the number 32,
which has nothing regulatory.
It could also be one of the 44
other medical officers
carried by the disease
during this expedition,
whose names are on a plaque
placed in the cloister of the Val-de-Grâce.
Finally, this group includes a soldier,
almost entirely naked,
supported by a young Arab
who was being incised
by a doctor dressed as an oriental.
While waiting for the antibiotics,
the treatment offered
had not changed much
since the Middle Ages.
Imitating the angel treating Saint-Roch,
as on this German wood engraving
from the 15th century,
the incision was the only treatment
offered by the doctors of the time,
without efficiency,
if only to soothe the pain.
It was, however,
the only way to avoid
bad moods,
according to Hippocrates' theory.
As on this image
depicting a doctor
from the Lazaret of Marseille
in 1819,
the surgeons protected themselves
from a mask of cloth
soaked in vinegar on the face
and a tunic of waxed cloth
or rubber taffeta
soaked in vinegar water.
They also wore sandals
or varnished shoes
with terrabentine essence
or a varnish in the spirit of wine.
As in the Middle Ages,
they used cataplasms
by rubbing a piece of quince
or cinnamon
and then opening them
with dexterity and speed
with a red iron or scalpel
before covering them
with antiseptic ointments
made of copper or mercury.
During this time,
they made the patient sweat
by wrapping him in blankets
and giving him stimulants
made of spices or cinnamon.
Today, we understand better
the high mortality rate
of this disease at the time.
But let's go back to our painting
and try to ask ourselves
which oriental doctor
Gros tried to depict on this cloth.
It is unlikely that it was
Dr. Mustafa Haji,
a Turkish doctor from Constantinople
whom he met in Jaffa
and who considered himself
a worthy heir to Abul Qasis
but whose genetics,
which he shared with his aunt,
did not seem to be of high esteem.
His instruments,
which he was very satisfied with,
were to be classified
in the history of art
at the end of the 16th century.
On the other hand,
it could be a Christian doctor
who, this time,
evoked with benevolence
by his own genetics,
as a man of the country
who gives us a lot of service.
He is the only one
who does not fear the disease.
He is a very exercised Christian
in this genre
and who is as fatalistic
as Muslims.
He does the necessary operations
and bandages.
It is worth noting
that after opening
the bottles or removing the charcoals,
he slightly wiped his bisturi
and placed them between his forehead,
often covered with sweat,
and his turban,
without any inconvenience.
Let's leave this group on the right
for the one on the left
of the composition.
There is a man who looks dark,
obviously ill,
perhaps not from the plague
but rather from leprosy
because his legs are swollen
and seem to carry the stigmata.
This disease,
always impressive,
affected some soldiers
of the expeditionary corps.
This man is not without recalling
one of the damned
of Michel-Ange's last judgment.
Next to him is another sick man,
who also looks agar,
and a corpse,
a symbol of the ravages of the plague.
The two men are represented
in the form of academic nudes,
idealized beauty,
where the moustaches are clearly visible,
like antique sculptures,
which was not necessarily
the case for all the plague patients,
as the victims of the epidemic
of Marseille remind us.
Behind our possible leper
stands a man dressed
quite luxuriously,
in the oriental way,
distributing bread,
helped by a servant
who carries a basket.
This character may allude
to the reinforcements of the Druze,
who provided the supplies
of the French troops
against Caesar,
their common enemy.
But the most important part
of the work is the one
in the middle of the painting.
Bonaparte occupies
the space of composition
at the intersection
of the dominant lines.
The serene and benevolent air
of the future emperor,
wearing an oriental belt,
touches with a disheveled hand
this detail of his importance,
the armpit of a soldier
half-dressed,
who raises his arm
to show his bow tie.
The red pants made some historians
think that it was a sailor,
but this is unlikely
during the campaign of Syria,
at least on the way.
Bonaparte, on this painting,
is surrounded
by several characters.
If the doctor in charge
is easily recognizable,
the others are less likely
to be identified.
The officer with the flak
that protects his mouth
with his handkerchief
would be Bessières,
who Gros would have painted
in this fearful position
to take revenge
on a military insolence.
The second, in the background,
would be Berthier,
then Chief of Staff
of the Commander-in-Chief.
While he looks at the lesion
as a clinician
on the edges
of the museum in Chantilly,
it is noticeable
on the definitive canvas
that Dégénète acts
as an epidemiologist
and seems to try to
move Bonaparte's hand
away from him
to avoid contagion.
But the mechanisms
of this bubonic plague
were unknown to him.
But for those of us
who know the role of rats
and especially fleas,
we know that touching a bubon
was not particularly risky
and that the other actors
of the scene
were as at risk as Bonaparte.
Dégénète gives us
the explanation of this gesture.
After trying, without affection,
to bring the Commander-in-Chief
back to the door,
I made him understand
that a longer stay
became much more than useless.
This attitude of the Commander-in-Chief
seems in contradiction
with his own feelings
about the contagiousness
of the plague
that the doctors of the time
thought were coming from the flesh.
Moreover, shortly after
visiting Jaffa Hospital,
Bonaparte had asked Dégénète
to find another way
to improve the morale
of his troops
vis-à-vis this disease.
This was the episode
of the inoculation of the plague
on April 4, 1799
by the Commander-in-Chief
which we see here
represented by Wafflard.
Dégénète also gives us
the explanation.
It was to reassure the imagination
and courage of the army
that in the middle of the hospital
I dipped a lancet
in the well of a bubble
belonging to a convalescent
of the disease at the first degree
and that I gave myself a slight
prick in the wool
and in the neighborhood
without taking other precautions
than washing myself
with the water and soap
offered to me.
I had for more than three weeks
two small points of inflammation
corresponding to the two pricks
and they were still very sensitive
when, on my way back from Acre,
I bathed in the presence
of a part of the army
in the Bay of Caesarea.
We notice here that Dégénète
does not speak of plague.
Like him, other doctors
of the expedition who wrote
about this disease
spoke of radiating diseases,
abominable diseases,
epidemic fever, malignant fever
or gland diseases.
The aim was not to frighten
the men.
We know more than Dégénète
was a partisan convinced
of the technique of variolyzation
which consisted in injecting
a form that was considered
an attenuated form of variolyzation
before the discovery of
the anti-variolytic vaccination
by Genère.
By the way, Dégénète does not
inoculate the pus
coming from a sick person
in a serious condition
but a convalescent
to the first degree
as was done for variolyzation.
This version of the inoculation
of the plague was contested
by many actors,
starting with Larrey,
always prone to oppose his
brother, but it was the subject
of many representations
like that of Waffler
or this one.
Or like this painting by Soro
which is not without recalling
our pestilential Jaffa
with his arcades,
his health officer in the shadow
and the light on the main character.
Or this fresco by Jean Coquet
in the hall of entrance
of the Dégénète hospital in Lyon
painted in 1946.
In the case where Dégénète
would have inoculated
the pus of a convalescent,
we can think that he realized
the first vaccination in history
by injecting a culture of
attenuated or killed bacillus
because he was not sick or very little.
With this unfinished experience,
the chief physician missed
a considerable discovery
that would have brought him
to the pantheon of medicine.
But Dégénète was not a hygienist
who discovered the vaccination,
nor a pastor,
and he will be content with a title.
The officer that we think
to be Bessière nevertheless
does not have a totally unfounded attitude
by protecting his mouth and nose
since 12% of cases
of bubonic plague can evolve
into pulmonary plague with this time
a very high risk of contagion
by aerosols emitted by the cough of the sick.
Our painting, therefore,
which suggests the Orientalism
of Delacroix, admirer of Gros,
certainly sought to highlight
the unquestionable courage of Bonaparte,
but we will see that
the motivations of the commander
of the work were much deeper.
This painting indeed sought
to refute some accusations
exploited by the English press
that he did not clean up
relative to his campaign in the East.
Not so much the massacre
of the population of Jaffa
after the capture of the city
or that of thousands of prisoners
that the general-in-chief
thought he could not keep
and feed,
that his desertion
and the abandonment of his army
to join France where his destiny
was waiting for him.
By the way, this escape
and the landing in Fréjus
without respecting the quarantine
when he came from a country
in the midst of a plague
was totally irresponsible
and should rather have led him
there than there.
But above all,
the touch of Bonaparte
on the painting of Gros
and on the imagery of Epinal
that inspired it
sought to show the compassion
of the general-in-chief
for his own men
after the suspicions
of poisoning
by a high dose of opium
against thirty
unbearable pesticides.
Geneticists,
to whom Bonaparte
had asked to supply this poison,
had refused to obey,
retorting this famous sentence
in particular to the doctors
opposed to euthanasia,
My duty to me
is to keep health.
While it is certain
that this first order
given to Acre
to the chief doctor
was not executed,
Bonaparte seems to have
renewed it
when he left Jaffa
to the pharmacist Royer
and that the opium
had been distributed
to some unfortunate patients
that the Turks of Al-Jazar,
said the butcher,
would not have missed the massacre.
Finally, as we have already mentioned,
this theme of the visit
of the Jaffa hospital
where his treatment
in the composition,
colors and light
was mainly used
at the end of 1804
to give credence
to the legitimacy
of Bonaparte's imperial aspirations.
The gesture of the general
touching the pustules
of a patient
refers to the ritual of the sacrament
when the king of France
exercised his thaumaturgic power
on the parvis of Notre-Dame-de-Reims
by touching the pustules.
Even stronger than the king,
Gros represented Bonaparte
in the position of the healing Christ.
Nothing less.
In addition, the posture of the general
can also recall
that of Apollo of Belvedere
that Bonaparte had brought
a few years before from Italy.
It is interesting to note
that Apollo is the god
who gives laws to men
as Bonaparte did,
but also the god
who provokes the plague
with his arrows
and who can also make it stop
as god of medicine
and father of esculapes.
The painting,
exhibited at the 1804
show, a few months
before the sacrament,
took another dimension,
that of a work of pure
Napoleonic propaganda
in the midst of many others,
contemporary or later,
from the coup d'état of the 18th Brumaire
to the exile of Saint-Henen,
from the sacrament of the emperor
in Paris to the staging
of his death for posterity,
to which Histomède,
the channel of the history
of medicine in question,
may devote a future video.
