In this awe-inspiring episode, we explore the mysteries of deep space — a place where time bends, galaxies collide, and stars are born from cosmic dust. Discover how the universe creates miracles in the most extreme conditions, and what lies beyond the limits of our imagination. Whether you're a space enthusiast or simply curious about the cosmos, this video will leave you in wonder at the beauty and power of the universe. (At the Edge of the Universe – Where Miracles Are Born)
philosophy does make progress The
achievement of philosophers of space and
time over the last 30 years has been
extremely important and
far-reaching The dramatic claims made by
Einstein and many other physicists about
the death of Newton's absolute space
have been rebutted The nature of
spacetime has been substantially
clarified in ways that would have
astonished the pioneers This success is
all the more significant because it has
taken place in the face of hostility
from many physicists Even today many or
most physicists cling to some of the
naive early claims made about relativity
theory which survive as a kind of
folklore in the physics community There
are exceptional physicists who
contributed to recent developments But
philosophers deserve recognition for
penetrating through the fog that
surrounded the foundations of space-time
theories and for moving the debate ahead
Ancient and medieval philosophers
debated the existence of universals Was
there they asked a single universal form
of red present in each red thing and
somehow making it red realists argued
that such universals were needed to
explain the similarities between colors
and all the properties we see around us
Tough-minded nominalists insisted that
universals were merely common names and
resisted entities that were not solid
respectable
individuals The controversies below
provide a modern parallel to these
debates One side accepts invisible
spatial structures to make sense of what
we see The other derides this as an
extravagant metaphysics and adheres
closely to concrete observables Unlike
the ancient debates which linger still
there is a strong if not unanimous sense
that decisive progress has been made
here The debate below is of sweeping
importance not only for physics and
philosophy but for intellectual culture
as a whole The existence of space as an
entity in its own right seems to be an
issue for
metaphysicians But the interpretation of
relativity theory is at once the
interpretation of our deepest scientific
theory and the science itself It cuts
quickly to the questions of where we and
the universe came from and whether
reason can discern what lies behind
appearances The future is fighting its
way out of this debate Recall from above
that Libnes attacked absolute space He
asserted that since all motion was
relative absolute place or absolute
velocity could never be observed Libnes
had however no answer to the bucket
argument In a flash of genius Newton
noticed that the sloshing water in the
rotating bucket was independent of
surrounding bodies He argued that his
acceleration was strong evidence for
absolute space Many philosophers and
physicists found Newton's vast invisible
unobservable absolute space irritating
and wished to banish it from physics But
the bucket argument proved a thorn in
their side They tended simply to ignore
or overlook Newton's insight They
certainly never had a plausible answer
to it 300 years after Newton this
changed with Ernst Mach an Austrian
physicist now remembered whenever we say
that a jet plane has flown at Mach 2
Unusually Mach was also a path-breaking
historian of physics and fully realized
the importance of Newton's bucket Like
Libnes he detested absolute space Unlike
Libnes he took up the challenge of the
bucket argument His reply inspired the
young Einstein and opened the way for
Einstein's heretical rejection of
absolute space Thus Mach is now
recognized as the originator of attempts
in the 20th century to rid physics of
Newton's absolutes We will see below how
far they succeeded Mach's famous reply
to Newton's bucket argument is driven by
a strict epistemological assumption Mach
was a prominent advocate of positivism
an important philosophy in the late 19th
century and early 20th century which
insisted that all knowledge was based on
experience It was an extreme form of
empiricism Positivists denigrated any
knowledge not based on experience as
mere metaphysics and this term became a
label for old-fashioned philosophy For
positivists these were merely old
superstitions and like belief in witches
had to be left behind by the march of
progress Physics in particular had to
expel everything not founded firmly on
observation and measurement As we have
seen Newton had argued that the
concavity could not be caused by
relative motion The spinning water was
at rest relative to the bucket and
surely the concavity could not be caused
by rotation relative to the distant
surroundings that is to the tree stars
and so on With his missionary zeal for
positivism Mach is certain that causes
must be observable This leads him to
conclude that the concavity must be
caused by relative motion since only
relative motions are observable Thus it
must be the tree or stars that cause
concavity For him there is no
alternative no option of invoking
unobservable absolute space For Mach the
spinning water slides up against the
sides of the bucket because the water is
rotating relatively to the distant stars
Somehow their distant masses grab the
water in the bucket Mach's general
philosophy of positivism had led him to
a specific view of space and time that
philosophers call
relationalism In this ontology the only
things that exist are bodies and the
relations between them Here bodies may
mean things with matter or energy and
includes fields of energy like those of
electricity or magnetism The key point
is that there is no counterpace
independent of bodies no spatial or
temporal structures over and above
bodies and their relations Thus there
are no places that have an existence
distinct from bodies Things are not in
places The motivation for this
relationalism is the rejection of
unobservable Bodies and relations are
observable while spatial containers are
not The opposite of this view is
substantivivalism which asserts that
there is some container some spatial and
temporal structure over and above and
containing ordinary bodies Newton was a
substantivist The terminology can be
confusing In ancient philosophy space
and substance were rival solutions to
the problem of change The atomists
solved the problem by supposing that a
vast invisible space existed Aristotle's
common sense insisted that only ordinary
bodies existed and that these substances
touched each other without gaps in a
plenum However over time the word
substance began to mean anything solid
and substantial anything existing on its
own and independently of other things
Philosophers began to call Newton's
space a substance when they wanted to
emphasize that it existed independently
of the bodies it contained John man
usefully notes that relationalism
insists that relations between bodies
are direct while substantivalism argues
for indirect relations According to the
latter the sun is 150 km from earth
because the sun is in one place earth in
another and the places are connected by
a stretch of space Thus the relation
between bodies goes through nonbodies
that is spatial structures Such
relations are indirect Relationalism
denies that the distance between the sun
and earth is constituted by a spatial
structure For example fields of gravity
and electricity stretch between them and
relationalism may say that these somehow
just are or constitute the separation
between the sun and earth Thus
relationalism and substantivalism
disagree about whether space and time
exist over and above ordinary bodies and
their relations More briefly they
disagree about whether space exists For
a generation now this question has been
at the core of contemporary philosophy
of space and time Newton's prestige was
so great that Mach's radical
relationalism was very liberating for
the young Einstein It gave him the
courage to consider whether absolute
space and time were really needed in
physics and probably directly
contributed to his great breakthroughs
As we have seen the spatial theory of
relativity of 1905 launched a direct
attack on invariant distances and
durations and therefore seemed to
dispose of both absolute space and
absolute time But Einstein knew that his
revolution was incomplete The theory
applied only to measurements made by
devices moving inertially and not those
undergoing acceleration The distinction
between inertial movement and
accelerated movement seems to depend on
the existence of space If there is a
physical difference between them there
must be some standard that determines
which is accelerated and which is not
But this standard must be space It was
for this reason that Mach was determined
to show that acceleration was merely an
ordinary kind of relative motion not
relative to absolute space but relative
to other ordinary bodies Thus for Mach
the coffee in an accelerating cup
sloshes because the cup is accelerating
relative to the distant stars Einstein
was determined to vindicate this insight
of Mox His work on the general theory of
relativity was guided by this belief
that he had to eliminate any fundamental
distinction between inertial and
accelerated motions Both should be kinds
of motion relative to other bodies and
should not be evidence for unseen
spatial structures In 1916 Einstein
completed his general theory and
announced in Newton's mechanics and no
less in the spatial theory of relativity
there is an inherent epistemological
defect which was perhaps for the first
time pointed out by Ernst Mock In an
epistemologically satisfactory law of
causality the reason given for any
effect must be an observable fact of
experience Ultimately only observable
facts may appear as causes and effects
Newtonian mechanics does not give a
satisfactory answer to this question of
why the spinning water in the bucket is
concave since it makes the unobservable
cause of absolute space responsible for
observable effects The general theory of
relativity takes away from space and
time the last remnant of physical
objectivity In this theory both a body
moving with uniform motion in a straight
line and an accelerating body may with
equal right be looked upon as stationary
The triumphant claim by Einstein that
had stripped space of its last remnant
of physical objectivity has been
extremely influential especially in the
middle of the last century and still to
a large degree today Einstein's
pronouncement was regarded as gospel
Philosophers have fought back against
mock in Einstein and largely vindicated
substantivalism and forms of absolute
space Although the battle still rages
and many points remain contentious there
is clearly a growing consensus against
Einstein and his fellow relationalists
The next three sections briefly
introduce this historic rehabilitation
of absolute space Here we discuss the
question of whether absolutes can be
justified within classical Newtonian
physics and then we return to relativity
theory Newton's absolute space
scandalized good empiricists and
positivists His ghostly invisible space
and unmeasurable absolute velocities
were outrageous lapses for those
crusading to rid physics of
old-fashioned metaphysics The core of
the relationalism attack on absolute
space was the inference Even before
Einstein's relativity we knew that
absolute velocity is unmeasurable and
absolute place is
undetectable This implies that there is
no scientific justification for
substantivalism There is no spatial
container over and above bodies and
their relations
This assertion that absolute space was
merely superfluous structure without
empirical justification was often used
to browbeat backsliding defenders of
Newton A milestone in philosophy of
space and time was passed when a strong
consensus emerged that the above
inference was a mistake Thus robbing
relationalists of a central weapon One
major reason is that philosophers now
agree that substantivalism can be
slimmed down and stripped of its
superfluous structure This lean and mean
substantivism can withstand empiricist
arguments from the nature of motion Thus
within classical physics the arguments
do not justify abandoning all structures
over and above bodies in their relations
This puts pressure on relationalism If
the absolutes are to be abandoned
altogether it must be because of
something new about relativity theory
Empiricism alone is not sufficient to
banish absolutes The strategy for
salvaging substantivism involves three
elements First concede to mock that
absolute velocities and absolute places
are unobservable and should be expuned
from physics Secondly shift from
considering three-dimensional spaces to
four-dimensional
space-times Thirdly strip down the
structure of the four-dimensional
spaceime so that it has just the
properties and relations justified by
observation and no more The result is a
theory or model of space and time known
as neonian spacetime It is
substantivalism and therefore Newtonian
But unlike Newton's space it is
four-dimensional and therefore a
space-time relative velocities and
absolute accelerations are observable
Before neonnewian spacetime was invented
no one knew how there could be absolute
accelerations without absolute
velocities and absolute space
Acceleration is after all just a change
in velocity The key feature of this
theory is that it predicts just the
needed combination absolute
accelerations but merely relative
velocities The quickest way to
understand the structure of this new
space-time theory is to compare it to
four-dimensional representation of
Newton's original absolute space Newton
believed that the universe was only
three-dimensional But a four-dimensional
model of Newton's theory can be built as
follows Imagine there is a
four-dimensional block universe that is
neatly sliced and that each slice is a
three-dimensional world at an instant
Newton believed that the same place
existed at different times in a
four-dimensional model This would mean
that places on different slices are the
same in some sense They are not one and
the same because they are on different
slices but have some relation that
indicates that they share something in
common This relation can be symbolized
by
rxy that is any two places say a and b
which are the same place at different
times have the relation r a and b If
these relations exist in our
fourdimensional model then it makes
sense to say that places persist through
time And this is what Newton meant by
absolute space These cross-linking
relations stretching from slice to slice
thus provide a fourdimensional model of
Newton's picture of space
Using these relations to keep track of
which places are which as time passes we
can define absolute velocities and
absolute
accelerations Thus this four-dimensional
model has the features that Newton
wanted But does it have too much can we
modify the model in a way that abandons
absolute place persisting through time
but keeps absolute acceleration in other
words can we drop absolute place from
our model but still pick out which
movements are along straight lines at
uniform speeds that is which movements
are inertial and
unacelerated Suppose now that the
relations are x and y do not exist in
our fourdimensional block universe and
thus places on different slices are just
different and unrelated
There is no sameness of place across
time and therefore no eternal absolute
space Instead suppose there are three
place relations I X Y and Z that stretch
across the different slices Three places
say A B and C have the relation I A B
and C Just when a body moving inertially
would pass through A on one slice B on a
later slice and C on an even later slice
If a body follows a path through
spaceime such that any three places
along its path are related by the new
relations then the body is moving
inertially along the entire path Anybody
deviating from an inertial path is
accelerating absolutely
This is the trick Instead of defining
persistent places we explicitly define
which movements are inertial That is
instead of keeping track of places
through different slices and using this
structure to decide which bodies are
moving inertially we simply keep track
of which trajectories are inertial If
the real spacetime of our physical
universe had the structure of this
neoonian spacetime then we expect to see
absolute accelerations which make the
water in the bucket and coffee cups
slush but only relative velocities Since
this is what we do see we have an
argument that this model correctly
describes the real structure of our
universe at least in domains where only
low velocities and thus no relativistic
effects are involved If this is so
however then classical substantivalism
is rescued We have a theory that posits
a container over and above bodies and
their relations but has no undetectable
superfluous structure We have put
Newton's absolutes on a diet and saved
them from Mox's empiricist
scoldings Neonian spacetime does not
represent a complete victory for
substantivalism Other attacks can be
made For example some of Libnes'
symmetry arguments apply equally to
Newton's absolute space and neonian
spacetime It is also true that the
plausibility of this model rests on
resolving questions about the status of
the future and past in a
four-dimensional block universe
Nonetheless a prominent and seemingly
persuasive attack has been rebutted by
shifting from Newton's three-dimensional
absolutes to a fourdimensional spaceime
Those who argue that space does exist in
its own right have won an important
battle As we have seen Newton believed
that the effects of acceleration like
the sloshing of liquids provided
evidence for absolute space Spatial
relativity retained a peculiar role for
acceleration by limiting its predictions
to nonacelerating inertially moving
rulers and clocks And this seemed to
endorse Newton's insight After 10 years
of labor Einstein was understandably
proud when he claimed to eliminate the
last remnant of objectivity from spatial
structure in his general theory Many in
the physics community still believe that
Einstein was correct A number of
physicists and most philosophers of
science now believe that Einstein was
wrong Although his theory has made many
correct predictions and remains the
foundational theory for astronomy and
cosmology Einstein misinterpreted what
his new mathematics implied It is not
true that general relativity eliminates
absolutes This reinterpretation of
general relativity represents an
important achievement of post-war
philosophy of space and time There are
two main lines of objections to
Einstein's claims about a general
relativity which can only be sketched
here The first concerns boundary
conditions and the second non-standard
models Recall that according to the
rubber sheet analogy we may imagine that
spacetime is stretched and distorted by
the presence of mass and energy Large
masses create curvature Regions that are
mostly vacuum are typically flatter At
first it was thought that this made
spacetime a kind of property of the
distribution of mass and energy That is
the mass and energy and their relations
fully determined all aspects of spaceime
To see that this is not the case
consider an ordinary drum The sound made
when a drum is stuck depends on three
things the location and intensity of
percussive whack the elasticity and
tautness of the material stretched
across the drum and the size and shape
of the drum A small child's drum and a
large drum like those used in orchestras
might be covered by the same taught
material and struck in the same way but
they will produce quite different tones
Thus the sound that emerges is an
important combination of local and
global factors The reason is that the
vibrations that produce the sound waves
are extended across the whole drum and
will therefore depend on the global
shape of the whole drum The bang
produced by the drumstick is a local
occurrence but the response is global In
general relativity mass produces
curvature the way that the drumstick
depresses the drum head The resulting
curvature of spaceime however depends on
the shape of the whole universe Just as
the drums tones depend on the shape of
the whole drum physicists say that the
curvature of spacetime depends on the
boundary conditions just as the
vibrations on the drum head depend on
the shape of the drum head and the way
it is tacked down at the edges This is
important because it means that the
distribution of mass and energy does not
determine all of the properties of space
and time The overall curvature of the
universe depends on mass and energy and
the boundary conditions Since these are
independent factors some aspects of
space and time are independent of mass
and energy Mox hopes that all of the
physics would depend only on the
relations between observable mass and
energy are thus dashed As Newton
proposed spacetime seems to have some
autonomous aspects and exists over and
above the bodies within it General
relativity is a local theory It tells
how each little patch of spaceime is
attached to its neighbors This sort of
theory leaves a great deal of global
freedom By analogy and a chain of iron
links we know how each oval link is
attached to its neighbors But the
overall shape of the chain is still very
free It may be stretched out in a
straight line or be left in a pile on
the floor This global freedom is
important It means that general
relativity can make very precise
predictions about what happens in small
regions of space say the size of a star
or a black hole but leave great doubt
about the shape of the universe as a
whole Unfortunately for relationalists
this freedom has also given scope for
the construction of non-standard models
These are models of the universe that
agree at each point with general
relativity's local predictions but have
bizarre global features Some of these
models prove that general relativity
retains a role for absolutes
In particular absolute acceleration
seems to have reared its head again and
confirmed Newton's original claim that
accelerations are evidence for spatial
and temporal structures independent of
their contents These models are
complicated but when examined in detail
show Einstein's claims to have
eliminated the last remnants of
objectivity from space-time were
premature
Philosophical victories are rarely
clear-cut No referee blows a whistle to
stop play and declares a winner
Inventive minds will always push and
probe more deeply Nevertheless the bulk
of the arguments now favor sophisticated
substantivalism over relationalism
The philosophers who led this revolt
Adolf Grunbalm John Earman and Michael
Freriedman fought against considerable
resistance from physicists and indeed
against all those who too quickly
exceeded to Einstein's authority We
admire the genius of Einstein's
mathematics and the success of its many
predictions But we also see that as a
pioneer Einstein misread the trail of
ideas that led him to his discoveries We
now understand the nature of Einstein's
relativity revolution better than he did
himself NASA will soon launch a
satellite built by a team based at
Stanford University to conduct Newton's
bucket experiment in outer space The
motivation for this experiment can be
understood by returning to the rubber
sheet analogy Remember that the heavy
weight in the central well is grasped
firmly depressed downwards to grip the
sheet and twisted The turning weight
will form a whirlpool of spiral wrinkles
radiating across the sheet and out to
the edge This effect can however be
produced in the opposite way Imagine
that the weight is left alone in the
center of the sheet and instead the
entire outer edge of the sheet is given
a sharp twist Since the heavy weight
will not immediately keep up with the
rotating sheet a similar whirlpool of
wrinkles this time converging on the
center will form Soon the weight will
feel the twist and begin rotating itself
The twisting rubber sheet gives us a
picture of Mach and Einstein's view of
Newton's bucket They claim that
acceleration relative to absolute space
does not produce the concavity on the
water's surface Instead they say it is
the rotation relative to the
surroundings that causes the concavity
In fact they add there is no way to
distinguish whether the water is
rotating or whether its surroundings are
Just as the rubber sheet suggests if the
universe was rotating around the bucket
the same concavity would arise Thus the
effect is due to the relation between
the bucket and its surroundings That is
the relative motion It does not depend
on whether the bucket has some fictional
absolute motion There is they say no
fact of the matter about which is
rotating the bucket or the starry
heavens Very soon after Einstein
published his general theory of
relativity it was shown that the theory
did predict that a rotating universe
would cause the concavity in the bucket
More precisely it was shown that mass
rotating around a central body would
grab the body and produce a rotation
This effect is known as frame dragging
The lines followed by bodies moving
inertially are known as their reference
frame and these are dragged around and
twisted like the rubber sheet above
Relationalists view these calculations
as a vindication of their interpretation
of the bucket Newton's argument has
always been a thorn in their side and
this they say is the nail in the coffin
of arguments for absolute space
Regardless of these debates the
experimental confirmation of frame
dragging would be an extraordinarily
important test of general
relativity Most tests to date rely on
astronomical observations and therefore
on distant objects we cannot manipulate
directly Physicists have proposed that a
spherical weight sent into orbit would
be influenced by the Earth's rotation on
the Earth's surface The effect would be
swamped by vibrations suspended in outer
space Delicate measurements could
distinguish the direct gravitational
forces from the subtler influences
produced by frame dragging Accomplishing
this however has required some of the
most advanced physics and engineering
ever poured into an experiment The
special weight in the satellite is said
to be the most perfectly spherical
object ever manufactured It will be
cooled to temperatures near absolute
zero to eliminate the tiny vibrations of
heat energy Substantivists can hope for
the success of this experiment without
conceding that it counts against the
existence of space in its own right As
Earman and others have argued
relationalists need to show not that the
rotating stars would influence the water
in the bucket but that rotation would
account for all of the observed
concavity This has not been done before
Even in general relativity rotation is
absolute Newton's deep insight into the
puzzle of rotational acceleration has
survived into the space age The concept
of space was born in paradox and seemed
to have the flimsiest claim to existence
Although nothing but mere empty
extendedness it helped make motion and
change understandable Aristotle's rugged
common sense rejected space out of hand
and made do with the plenum of concrete
objects We now have seen that this
ancient debate was preparation for the
grander controversies over Newton and
Einstein's concepts of space Like the
ancient atomists Newton embraced space
to make sense of motion His law of
inertia demanded a world of geometric
lines and the sloshing water in his
bucket seemed to make absolute space
almost visible Like Aristotle the
tough-minded empiricists made war on
this metaphysical extravagance Mach
Einstein and contemporary relationalists
all fought back against a space existing
over and above its contents Against
Newton and Lawrence they dispensed with
superfluous structure and pushed physics
back down towards concrete objects and
their concrete relations But now the
folklore that surrounds Einstein's
relativity theory has been dispersed
Amid Einstein's many triumphs he did
transform and deepen the concept of
space He did not however reduce space to
its contents This flimsy nothing has
proved resilient in special relativity
We saw that the defense of absolute
space in Lawrence's minority
interpretation was not ruled out by
experiment Furthermore it provided
attractive explanations where the
mainstream provided none A philosopher
would say that the case for eliminating
absolute space there rested on a strict
empiricist ideology and was not
compulsory In general relativity the
case for some features of curved space
remaining independent of matter was
significantly strengthened boundary
conditions and non-standard models
proved that the
anti-substantivivalists had not clinched
their case The theme connecting the
chapters in part two has been centrality
of real
relations over and above the individuals
in the universe There must be some web
of relations stretching between and
uniting them The philosophy of space and
time turns crucially upon the nature of
these relations The ancient paradoxes
exposed the knot of conflicting tensions
underlying relations and led to
Aristotle's rejection of real relations
In Libes we have the last great
metaphysician who saw the depth and
intractability of these problems and
likewise banished relations from his
system In part one we saw that the
mainstream interpretation of special
relativity turned the basic properties
of distance and duration into
relations Here in part two the
succeeding chapters have made a strong
case for the robust reality of spatial
relations from K's in congruid
counterparts to the three place
relations of neon-Newtonian spacetime
and then to the role of absolutes in
general relativity Relations between
concrete individuals were constituted by
something
non-concrete In short spatial relations
are as real as the things they relate
The victory of substantivalism of real
spatial relations is still in doubt
Physicists remain enthralled to
Einstein's premature claims to have
eliminated the objectivity of space
Among philosophers the autonomy of space
is still contested But from a long-term
perspective real spatial relations have
been gaining credibility for some 400
years Once mathematics have been
rephrased in the language of equations
and once physics have adopted this new
language the ancient resistance to
relations was rendered implausible
Modern critics of spatial relations
retreated to the claim that there were
somehow only concrete relations But even
this halfway house has failed to make
sense of the physics of motion and
change Opinion is moving toward
substantivism
If spatial relations are accepted as
real however future generations will
have to contend with the paradoxes they
conceal One philosophical question is so
exquisitly compact so breathtakingly
deep that it can only be regarded as a
miniature masterpiece It seems that
Libnes was the first to express it in
the haunting words why is there
something rather than nothing
it is clear that not even God could be
the answer here For even if God created
all things and even the universe itself
we could still ask why God existed If
the divine existence is pronounced
necessary we could ask in turn why this
necessity Some philosophers find
Libnes's question so frustrating and
unanswerable that they declare it to be
absurd a grammatical confusion of some
sort Others however have felt its sharp
bite its evocation of the miracle of
existence Modern scientists tend to shun
this sort of question altogether They
concentrate instead on how questions
They trace how one event caused another
or how one body emerged from more
primitive ingredients Teology the study
of purpose of ultimate origins and fate
has been expelled from science
Nonetheless every human society has
struggled to answer questions about the
origins of our world and have believed
in what anthropologists call creation
myths From the Judeaic story of Adam and
Eve in the book of Genesis and the Bible
and the Greek myths of Kronos and Zeus
to the Japanese tales collected in the
Nihonji each explains the emergence of
our world from a primordial chaos Modern
society prides itself on explaining the
world's formation in a scientific way
And the cornerstone of that explanation
is the big
bang The first indication that the
universe had erupted out of some large
explosion was a discovery made in 1929
by the astronomer Edwin Hubble Using the
largest telescope then available he made
the surprising announcement that distant
stars and galaxies are moving rapidly
away from us The universe is expanding
In fact the farther away objects are the
faster they are receding The most remote
objects are moving at large fractions of
the speed of light Through the Second
World War and the 1950s several
explanations of these facts were debated
But the controversy was finally settled
by surprising new observations In 1965
two young radio astronomers from Bell
Laboratories in New Jersey were
constructing early satellite dishes and
struggling to eliminate some hissing
static in the receiver They were
mystified by its source It seemed to be
coming from all directions in the sky
with the same intensity And this led the
engineers to conclude that the source
must be within their own equipment Since
no transmitter could produce a pattern
like that they checked all their
connections and even cleaned the white
dialectic material pigeons had left on
their antenna but made no progress at
all As luck would have it one of the
astronomers heard through friends that
physicists from nearby Princeton
University where Einstein had died 10
years earlier had just finished some new
very speculative calculations The
physicists argued that if Hubble's
observations could be explained by a
giant primordial explosion there should
still today be a faint afterglow of
radio waves filling the entire universe
They were able to calculate the main
frequency and intensity of this
radiation The two teams quickly realized
that the static in the satellite dish
approximately matched the
characteristics of the afterglow
calculated from theory Unknowingly the
astronomers had detected the remnants of
the big bang The astronomers and the
physicists later received the Nobel
Prize for their historic discovery of
this cosmic microwave background
radiation All this jumpstarted study of
the universe's origins Speculations
about the beginning had been regarded by
mainstream physicists as mere science
fiction But this new hard experimental
data moved the subject to the front
lines of scientific research Since the
1960s several lines of observational
evidence have all converged to make a
strong case for a big bang about 15
billion years ago Most scientists now
regard this theory as very well
confirmed For one reason detailed models
of the early fireball can be used to
calculate the kinds of debris it spewed
out and precisely predict the
proportions of hydrogen and helium that
would remain in the stars and galaxies
around us Astronomers have found that
the amounts of these elements observed
through the universe closely correspond
to the predictions This in turn suggests
that we have a good understanding of
what happened during the early big bang
There is an astounding match between
theory and experiment If this theory is
correct the original explosion was so
hot that only stray particles and the
simplest atoms could survive Any larger
atoms formed by random mixing would have
been ripped apart in collisions or
bombarded by intense radiation and
broken down again into simpler fragments
Thus only the lightest elements such as
hydrogen and helium emerged unscathed
from the big bang This raises an
intimate question Our bodies are mostly
composed of much heavier elements like
carbon Likewise Earth contains silicon
and other relatively large atoms Where
did these come from the generally
accepted view is that these were formed
much later than the Big Bang As the
universe cooled scattered atoms were
pulled together by gravitational force
congregated and formed stars After some
billions of years these stars would age
and some would collapse and explode
Such a supernova would be violent enough
to ram together simpler atoms into
larger clumps and would fling minute
portions of these heavy elements out
into empty space before they were broken
down again After generations of stars
were born and died significant amounts
of heavy elements would remain floating
through space If these dust clouds again
formed new stars their outer fringes
might congeal into planets Eventually
the heavy elements might form complex
structures like our bodies Thus
astronomers believe Earth and our bodies
are ancient ash from stars exploding
like fireworks Libnes would insist on
asking what came before the Big Bang But
this question makes physicists nervous
They tend to insist in turn that their
science merely traces causes It can only
investigate empirical questions Since
the Big Bang was so hot and so turbulent
probably no casual process can be traced
back through its origin Although a few
are brave enough to speculate most would
say that whatever came before the Big
Bang can be no part of science
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]