Arsenal fans, stay calm... I re-watched Newcastle 1-0 Arsenal so you didn't have to | Analysis

Harvey Gration
11 followers
12 Video Views·Nov 4, 2024
In a season blighted so far by injuries, harsh calls and probably excessive graft, already
slimming the margins more than they were, it makes missing the mark further down the
line often brutally punished, disproportionately so.
This was the case in Arsenal's 1-0 defeat on Sunday against Newcastle United, every
slight imperfection or inefficiency magnified to the extreme.
But today's video is not meant to be a positive video, that's never what my content
tries to be.
But it is a video that is going to attempt to measure the extremities of online discourse
and take you through a slightly different type of analysis to my normal post-match reaction,
a more play-by-play analysis of the Newcastle game, a match where Arsenal were by no means
bad, whatever bad means.
But, did we miss the mark in terms of balance, both forced and unforced?
Did we not focus on what was giving us real joy at times?
I think those are fairer critiques.
How did the approach shift after the substitutions of Wanyeri, Jorginho, Zinchenko, White etc?
This is a video that tries to let you guys into my head when I'm watching games back,
and I say watching games back with emphasis because I am a fan watching these matches,
I vent frustration, I am so desperate for Arsenal to win like we all are.
But I've channelled all of this into watching the game back, racking my brains.
So stick with me today guys, I think this is an important video to watch.
The result may be damaging, but Arsenal are by no means a catastrophe, there is a lot
to get behind.
I'm going to start with Arsenal's intentions in the game, because they were clear right
from the off.
This was our nominal shape that we tried to form, Partey inverting alongside Declan Rice,
Mourinho floating higher up to compete for second balls, Havertz who is off screen, drifting
wider to connect play with Saka on the right hand side, Trossard floating in the central
pockets and the wingers high and wide.
This is another view of the same shape, slightly later in the game.
Rice splitting the centre backs, Havertz has become that right link forming a kind of box
shape with Mourinho, but that's not important because back to the opening 25 seconds, that
shot I showed at the start of the game.
This is what I'm talking about when I say we created some really good situations at
times, but often the balance of the side got in the way of forming these more often.
This is what I mean, here Havertz leaves his role of Saka support and it looks like he
and Trossard at the start of the game are going to return to a much more balanced, fluid
relationship.
Things are dynamic, deeper too, Partey becomes the deepest midfielder, Mourinho is still
higher and Havertz actually floats into this midfield three with Trossard pulling to the
right and being that combination or link man with Saka.
This allows Kai Havertz to be a runner through the middle.
He goes then for a one-two with Bakayo Saka as our attack speeds up, it doesn't quite
come off and that's a theme, but we have one, two, three, four runners stampeding on
this Newcastle goal.
A fluid build-up and the fluid build-up that we've come to know with this Arsenal side
in recent weeks creates more of these dynamic situations higher up, but one of the big things
we missed in our fluid 4-2-4 or 4-triple-2, whatever you want to call that foundation,
is that thrust from our full-backs with the right-footed Timber at left-back on the day,
Calafiori out of course, and Partey at right-back instead of Timber or Ben White.
Those pushing forces from full-back that when we are talking about how Kai Havertz has seemingly
increasingly drifted wider and wider and closer and closer to Saka in recent weeks, Timber
or White would provide that pushing force to allow Havertz at times to be more central
and not having the problems that we showed on Sunday against Newcastle with Trossard
seemingly at times being our only central connector in a more of a false nine between
the lines and we weren't making as a result the most of these types of spaces we could
manipulate against Newcastle.
As always, there is a middle ground. Personnel can dictate approach to an extent, but I think
with this type of shape that I'm showing on screen, we were a bit too rigid with the player
roles within this. I hope that sort of makes sense, this middle ground. Havertz of course
is needed closer to the centre, but the debate is more nuanced and without these pushing
forces from the flanks, without a Odegaard or a Wanieri as we'll get on to in that sort
of more support staff right and side channel role, Havertz is having to play this more
functional role at the moment, but maybe, as I hope I've shown, maybe still one he's
playing and he's doing more than he should, because we create moments like this with Timba
driving into the pocket that Mourinho creates and just imagine here Havertz ghosting off
the shoulder in behind, stretching, creating room to isolate Saka for a potential 1v1,
Trossard moving off of him deeper into the pockets, that pendulum pivoting, hinging motion
that we've spoken about a lot on the channel and with Calafiori or White or Timba on the
right hand side, it just means Havertz wouldn't always have to be this essential right back
option at times in possession. We often stack our pivots like this, trying to stretch an
opposition press wide to create these dynamic situations out wide with those full backs
that I've just mentioned. That's the benefit of having these pushes from the flanks, this
fluid build up that creates dynamic situations further up the pitch and I think, again, maybe
a fairer critique of the Newcastle games were there still were times that we created situations
similar to this. This is the benefit, here we see a very Calafiori-esque left and side
look, stacking our pivots, Timba high and wide at left back, Martinelli actually pushed
inside and we now form what is a flat back four with Partey and Rice dropping together,
Partey then hurrying it through the lines to Mourinho who has the space in the pocket
now to show that intuitive economical play of his, with Timba as an outside threat and
Martinelli instantly dashing in behind. This is an example of balanced movements and to be
probably hypercritical of Martinelli, he could probably carry it further and make more of an
opportunity of this. These types of in and out movements really help exploit the central spaces
Newcastle can leave because they have centre backs uncomfortable in following these false
90 type movements deeper and here we have Trossard, we give Trossard space and he doesn't
in this scenario look lost in these central pockets having to connect everything and do it
all as he had to at times on Sunday. Here he actually has three or four runners beyond him
but this became a theme of the day and it was mishit passes, mistimed passes, often not making
most of the situations we did manage to fashion. Maybe this is another one, for example, I like
the throwback here to the left back runs we saw last season, Mourinho coming low, Trossard drawing
the centre backs higher, Timba darting in behind, making that Newcastle line play at different
heights, giving Saka an opportunity. Or here when we're talking about maybe the all-too-rigid roles
that players play, this was a rare occasion where Kai Havertz allowed himself to stray more central.
Here he connects play from deep and then makes that ghosting run from deep in behind. This is
an example of Martinelli as well, showing how he has improved on how he can open up angles from the
touchline that we've spoken about post Southampton and Spurs matches. Here he finds Kai Havertz who
stands up across to Saka, it's another moment, it's another situation created. But to do a brief aside
on Gabriel Martinelli, I thought he had a really good game yesterday despite the discussion online.
I don't think it's the right game to criticise Martinelli for, especially considering that
without Calafiore and Timba, who we all know, his tendencies make him do the best work and
makes Timba the best player when he's on the inside, in the inside pockets. Martinelli as a
result had a much more touchline, huggy role than he stylistically suits. What I would say though
is that I wonder if Martinelli could be, even from wide, a bit more like Martinelli. What I mean by
this is making those darts off the shoulder more constantly to provide that stretching force to
unsettle the Newcastle backline in these types of situations here, even if it's just a decoy.
Because it was ultimately a game of moments and that's often what you expect at St James' Park,
it's what happened to Manchester City for example on their trip to Tyneside, and Newcastle are a
side in games like this that hurt you in one way, that's playing fast and through you. They didn't
create too much as well against us, but if they were going to hurt you, they do so like this. Let
me explain. Here there are lots of rotations and fluidity on that Newcastle left-hand side with
Bruno Guimaraes dropping deep. Normally he would be shadowed in our pressing structure by Declan
Rice, but here Rice is forced to stay lower on Joe Willock, who has rotated inside from the
touchline. Joel Linton is pinning Thomas Party out wide, who can't step through. Long staff then adds
to the overload by drifting left, and it's, let's be honest, it's brilliant vertical combination play.
That's Newcastle, it does happen sometimes. Good teams with good qualities are allowed to cause
you harm. This was their way, their only way of hurting us in the first half. Often happy to create
these chaotic second ball situations in and around our own box, in which they actually often outdueled
us. But that also got me thinking about our own moments of winning our own knockdowns and those
pinball-y situations in their half, and how, again, a more central Havertz, and we've spoken again about
the nuances to this debate, would secure a lot more of these wins. Someone who is so smart in moving
about like a false nine, but the body of a real true centre forward, in and out of pockets as well
as stretching a back line. Some of our best moments in the game, our best moments, came in winning
very similar moments like this, but not being as decisive. So it's something for you guys and all
of us to think about. Let's move on to the second half though. Trossard and Havertz were sharing the
load much more now of playing that more functional right-hand-sided role, and combine this though with
a team chasing the game, pinning Newcastle deeper. I think it's fair to say we're losing steam somewhat
in terms of an attacking threat. It was a matter of time before we shifted from the foundation I've
been previously talking about, to a more final third heavy setup. Not so much bent on creating
dynamic attacks, but sitting and breaking. And this meant that it was only a matter of time before
Ethan Wanyeri came on. And he came on alongside Zinchenko around the hour mark, and we formed this
more staggered midfield setup, very similar to the dynamics we saw against Wolves on the opening day
of the season. With Zinchenko positioning himself outside the block, dominating our touches,
Partey almost positioned as an interior to accelerate play, and Wanyeri higher in the right
pocket, but able to be that connecting presence, displacing Havertz's first half job, who had moved
central. And Wanyeri's first involvement was dropping lower and drawing a foul. It was a sign of the
personality and the confidence Ethan always shows on the ball. We had probably 20 to 25 minutes of
trying to break this super compact Newcastle defence, but we created spaces. And I go back to
what I've said as a bit of a theme in this video, we just didn't exploit them I think. We missed the
mark in terms of exploiting them to the best of our ability. Wanyeri here demonstrated that
that constant shifting between spaces, the same constant shifting and movements that make
Odegaard so good in and out of the pockets. And if you remember my scouting report on Wanyeri,
the thing that sets him apart as a talent more broadly is his range of motion, his motor. Partey
here finds that between the lines pass once again, Wanyeri takes it and drives. And here comes a very
niche memory, but I know you'll allow it, it reminded me of as Wanyeri here drifts and overloads the
left-hand side, it reminds me of the assist he had for Gabriel Jesus in pre-season against Manchester
United. Unfortunately, Zinchenko doesn't see that slipped ball in behind and there were lots of just
these nearly moments for us in the second half. Saka standing up across just over Kai Havertz's
head, or Wanyeri here staying higher to provide that space deeper for Jorginho, who is normally
so accurate in picking passes from these zones, but here as White adds that velocity and run from
deep in a right-hand side that started to look very much like our away performance against Aston
Villa in terms of the dynamics, Jorginho overhits the pass, uncharacteristically so. And of course
there was that rice header that just went wide from that Saka wonder cross. It was a day where we
just missed the mark. It's a bitter pill to swallow and one that we have to swallow. Nothing more,
nothing less. And of course there is a middle ground to this as we've discussed, but it was
not an atrocious performance. I think it's another difficult context and situation that you had
against going down to 10 men against Manchester City, against a Brighton team, against a Bournemouth
team, that as an 11 men Manchester City side found out this weekend are notorious banana skin
situations. These are the fixtures that the robots or the computer does not always win and it's a
where especially when we're talking about team balance in particular, fixing roles for players
that they do not quite fit into whether that was forced or in some cases unforced. These are the
slight inefficiencies and ever so slight inefficiencies that are laid bare when you're
already in a position that we find ourselves in now, five points off Manchester City and a couple
more off Liverpool. Missing the mark is punished often disproportionately so. I'll end in a similar
vein to last video though. This Arsenal team has so much potential this season and if you've watched
us closely enough or hopefully if you trust my words somewhat, you will trust yourself not to
fall into real extreme discourses and discussions. And you'll also know, especially if you've watched
any of Manchester City this season, that we find ourselves in a harsh, I don't want to say unfair
because it's not going to change the fact that we are where we are, but we are in a position that
we are in a position in the table that could very easily be a much different landscape in another
realistic world. And as I said last video, it's about staying with the pace until Christmas time,
until the new year. That is the key. If we can stay probably within five points of City, I give us a
real, real chance. And like I said, there is still so much this season to be so excited for.
There is nothing fundamentally wrong with how we are playing. There is nothing faulty with our
machine. We haven't chugged to a halt. We need a healthy squad back, yes. We also need to react as
quick as possible to maintain though that thick skin and also to show our teeth a bit more now.
There is work to do. I'm not going to pretend there is not, but let's not ignore that this
season has so much in store for us. I'll speak to you guys again very, very shortly,
but until next time, I'll catch you in a bit. See you later.
