Are you a taker, a giver, or a matcher_ (reciprocity styles)

Anne-Laure Le Cunff
54 followers
4 Video Views·Dec 17, 2022
Are you a taker, a giver, or a matcher_ (reciprocity styles)
Let's be honest, we all know some people who only help when it benefits themselves.
Some other people tend to have more transactional relationships like
I give you this, you give me that.
And yet other people are generous with their time and energy without ever asking anything in return.
What's super interesting is that takers, matchers and givers have very different outcomes
and you can see that in both their professional and personal relationships.
And the most surprising thing is that it's givers,
the most generous people who have the most radical results.
So are you a giver, a taker or a matcher?
In this video, we're going to explore how you can shift your relationship style
so you can have a better impact on your professional life,
your personal life and the world in general.
In his book Give and Take, Adam Grant who's a psychologist
and a top-rated professor from Wharton University
divides people into three different groups, takers, matchers and givers.
He explains that whereas takers strive to get as much as possible from others
and matchers aim to trade evenly,
givers are the rare breed of people who contribute to others without expecting anything in return.
Okay, so let's go through all of these one by one.
First, takers.
Takers are self-focused and only strategically help others
when the benefits for themselves outweigh the personal costs.
In the words of Adam Grant,
takers have a distinctive signature.
They like to get more than they give.
They tilt reciprocity in their own favor,
putting their own interests ahead of others' needs.
On the other hand,
givers will help others whenever the benefits to others outweigh the personal costs.
Again, Adam Grant explains,
in the workplace, givers are a relatively rare breed.
They tilt reciprocity in the other direction,
preferring to give more than they get.
Whereas takers tend to be self-focused,
evaluating what other people can offer them,
givers are other-focused,
paying more attention to what other people need from them.
And finally, you have matchers.
Matchers strive to keep an equal balance between getting and giving.
So again, let's have a look at what Adam Grant has to say about matchers.
Matchers operate on the principle of fairness.
When they help others,
they protect themselves by seeking reciprocity.
If you're a matcher,
you believe in tit for tat,
and your relationships are governed by even exchanges of favors.
Of course, most people are not locked into one specific reciprocity style.
For example, you may be a giver when mentoring a less experienced colleague,
act as a taker when negotiating your salary,
and be a matcher when you're exchanging productivity tips with a friend.
You may ask yourself,
okay, cool, but why does it matter anyway?
Shouldn't I focus on my own success
rather than being too generous and trying to help everyone at work?
Of course, I know we all have limited time and limited energy,
so I can see why it would make sense
to be protective of these limited resources.
But as often, the answer is not so simple.
A team of researchers at the University of Arizona
conducted a big meta-analysis.
Across 38 studies and covering more than 3,500 business units,
they found that companies with a culture of generosity and giving
were more likely to have higher productivity,
efficiency, customer satisfaction,
as well as reduced costs.
Not bad at all,
but you may be wondering about the individual impact of being a giver.
And again, the answer is not that simple.
Okay, listen to this.
Givers are most likely to occupy
either the lowest or the highest levels of an organization.
The worst performers and the best performers are givers,
but takers and matchers are more likely to land in the middle.
Basically, givers dominate both the bottom and the top of the success ladder.
And a little bit later,
Adam Grimm explains that across occupations,
if you examine the link between reciprocity styles and success,
the givers are more likely to become chumps, not only chumps.
Okay, so here's a graph to make it a little bit clearer.
As you can see, givers are more rare than takers and matchers
and have dramatically different performance results.
Basically, low performance givers say yes to everything,
which can have a negative impact on their own work.
However, smart givers ask themselves
what is best for the organization in general,
not only for the individual that is asking for their help.
This way, they're able to be helpful for the organization in general,
helpful to their colleague,
and helpful to their own career as well.
It's basically a win-win-win situation.
They succeed,
their colleagues are elevated,
and the company performs better.
Now, you may be wondering,
how do I become a smart giver,
the kind of giver that is going to succeed
both professionally and personally?
The first thing is to change your mindset.
Consider the lens through which you're considering your job
and your relationship with friends and family.
For your professional context,
ask yourself,
who exactly is being affected by my work?
How do your choices impact the experience
of your colleagues and of your customers?
How can you align your decisions
so when you win, everybody wins?
Instead of being self-focused like a taker
or transactional like a maker,
think of it as an expanding pie
when everyone can benefit from your own success.
The second one is to help wisely.
Low-performance givers have a lack of focus
on the way they help.
It doesn't mean that you have to become a taker
and only help when it benefits you,
nor that you need to become a matcher
and only help when you get something of equal value in return.
It means that when you help,
you need to make sure that you're helping
with something that's going to be beneficial to everyone
and not only to the person that you're helping.
Ask yourself,
is this good for the company,
for the customers,
for the team?
In a personal context,
ask yourself,
is this good for our family?
Is this good for a group of friends?
Or maybe is this good for a relationship in general?
If the answer is no,
that's okay.
You can just brainstorm other solutions
that are a win-win-win for everyone.
And finally,
track your impact.
From time to time,
try to block a little bit of time for yourself
or self-reflection
so you can look at the past times where you've helped
and what the outcome was.
In the end,
who benefited from your help?
Was it only one person who may have been a taker?
Or did your help have a wider positive impact
which may justify the time and energy that you spent
in order to provide support?
If you feel like your impact wasn't as positive
as what you expected,
that's completely fine.
Just try to think about the factors that were at play
and keep them in mind
so you can be a little bit wiser
the next time someone asks for your help.
This way,
your future involvement can be as beneficial as possible
to everyone,
including yourself.
Instead of an automated behavior,
deciding how we help our friends and family and colleagues
can be a conscious decision.
Let me finish with one last quote from Adam Grant,
which I really like.
Every time we interact with another person at work,
we have a choice to make.
Do we try to claim as much value as we can
or contribute value without worrying
about whatever we see in return?
I think these are wise words to live by.
And as we've seen,
research suggests that being generous
can actually be a smart thing.
Whether you're already a smart giver
or intent on becoming one,
I hope you found this video helpful.
If you did,
please make sure to like and subscribe
and I'll see you in the next one.
Squishy Squishy!
