Anger at health insurance industry boiling over after CEO shooting
1 Video View·Jan 25, 2025
Anger at the health insurance industry boiling over.
High premiums, high deductibles, high frustration.
We'll look at what's fueling the vitriol
and lack of empathy for the murdered CEO
of UnitedHealthcare, Brian Thompson.
We have an epidemic of obesity,
an epidemic of diabetes.
Ultra-processed foods in the crosshairs.
Some U.S. Senators want the FDA to do more.
And the food industry is slapped
with a first-of-its-kind lawsuit.
He's having a brain bleed.
And actor Jamie Foxx shares his remarkable story
of recovery in a new special.
They said I was paralyzed.
Said I couldn't walk, but look at me now.
Welcome to Eye on Health, where we focus on stories
that affect your physical and mental well-being.
I'm Bradley Blackburn.
The murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO, Brian Thompson,
has revealed widespread and long-simmering rage
among Americans toward the health insurance industry.
CBS's Mark Strassman takes a closer look.
It's very hard for me to be empathetic.
Free-floating outrage fuels this American moment.
There are wolves who want to kill you for money.
A targeted killing in Midtown Manhattan,
a hooded gunman, and thousands of online posts
like, he's a hero, overwhelmingly side with a shooter.
This guy's bringing the country together.
In New York City, a hooded shooter lookalike contest
brought cheap laughs.
When shooting suspect, Luigi Mangione,
was arrested in Pennsylvania,
online hot takes doubled down.
Which one of you McDonald's employees ratted that guy out?
The web's new hot sellers, free Luigi shirts,
deny, defend, depose coffee mugs, delivery before Christmas.
Seemingly forgotten, Brian Thompson,
UnitedHealthcare's CEO, murdered in cold blood.
A 50-year-old husband and father of two sons
was buried on Monday.
But online voices see him only as the face
of a half-trillion-dollar health conglomerate.
In their eyes, the obstacle to affordable healthcare.
To many of these critics, it's a business model
built on refusing to pay for services.
In 2023, UnitedHealthcare denied roughly 33% of all claims,
the highest rate in the industry.
The overall industry rate, 19%.
I understand the kind of cultural wash,
the response that is kind of washed over
a large segment of the population.
Yolanda Wilson is a healthcare ethicist.
In January, she needed a hysterectomy.
This letter from UnitedHealthcare denied her claim
two days before her scheduled surgery.
I was surprised.
It just kind of sent me into turmoil.
Were you angry?
A little bit.
Maybe more than a little bit?
Probably more than a little bit.
Her surgeon fought for her.
The claim was approved.
But in a world that's often black and white,
her take on the murdered executive has lots of gray.
You don't agree with the shooting.
I don't agree with the shooting.
When it first happened, you weren't sad.
No.
Were you sad for his family?
Yes.
But you were also sad for all the people
his company had denied.
Yes.
The decisions are made by multiple people,
not just by one person.
We heard more nuance from customers
at Pickles Deli in downtown St. Louis.
Sure, lots of health insurance horror stories,
including Kim's Fahelics.
High premiums, high deductibles.
High frustration.
But everyone we talked to here,
like Gary Sims, repudiated the killing.
They can empathize with the frustration
that they may have with the insurance process
but that's no excuse whatsoever to gun that man down.
In our recent round of elections,
healthcare costs and companies got scant attention
from politicians in both parties.
Now, everyone's talking about it.
I don't feel bad for this guy.
In voices like that, any hint of compassion
for a murdered man and his family, denied.
Mark Strassman in St. Louis.
Several major food companies have been hit
with a new lawsuit accusing them of designing
and marketing ultra-processed foods
to make them addictive to children.
The plaintiff, a Pennsylvania resident,
says he was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes
and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease at age 16
as a result of eating foods from multiple companies,
including Kraft Heinz, Coca-Cola, and General Mills.
The first-of-its-kind lawsuit follows a hearing
by the U.S. Senate Health Committee
about rising rates of obesity and diabetes
and who's to blame.
CBS's Natalie Brand reports.
Senators grilled the outgoing leader of the FDA
on why more hasn't been done to address rising rates
of diabetes and obesity in the United States
and what research has shown
is the link to ultra-processed foods.
Much of what we try to do, frankly, gets blocked.
FDA Commissioner, Dr. Robert Califf,
suggested his agency needs more resources
and laws from Congress to combat legal challenges
brought by the food and beverage industry.
Senator Bernie Sanders has compared it
to the fight decades ago against big tobacco.
We have an epidemic of obesity, an epidemic of diabetes.
People are getting sick, people are dying.
Our lifespan is lower than other countries.
Sanders wants to see front-of-label packaging,
which would warn about products
with high sugar, fat, or sodium,
a change that's been under review since last year.
Lawmakers also asked about strengthening the review
of chemicals in popular foods.
Califf was talking, too, about research not being shared
between the food industry and the public.
Can Congress do something about that?
Yeah, we wanna know what the impact
of ultra-processed food, of high amounts of sugar,
are on human health.
For its part, the consumer packaged goods industry
said in a statement it's committed
to protecting access to nutritious,
affordable, convenient, and safe food.
If we take the issue seriously,
it means confronting the industry.
Senator Sanders says this should be a bipartisan issue
that he hopes gets increased attention
with the next administration.
Natalie Brand, CBS News, Washington.
Contaminated food hospitalizes
more than 50,000 people each year,
according to new estimates from the CDC,
and it kills nearly 1,000.
Health experts say seven common germs are to blame,
including listeria, norovirus, and salmonella.
The bird flu virus in raw milk is believed
to have sickened a California child.
It follows last week's order
by the U.S. Department of Agriculture
requiring all raw and unpasteurized milk nationwide
to be tested for avian influenza.
This year's outbreak has infected
more than 700 cattle herds around the country,
and about 60 people have contracted the virus too,
mostly dairy workers who were in close contact
with infected cows.
We know that this virus in a dairy cow
concentrates in the milk,
and so by testing the milk
before it even gets to pasteurization,
we'll provide another level of assurance
that the dairy products that we consume,
milk, cheese, yogurt, all those delicious things,
are absolutely safe to consume.
Federal officials continue to warn
against drinking raw milk,
which can contain a host of germs that make people sick.
Recently, California officials quarantined
a farm and halted distribution
after bird flu virus was detected.
Raw Farm issued a voluntary recall of raw milk and cream.
The Food and Drug Administration
is pushing for White House approval
to drastically lower the amount of nicotine in cigarettes.
The FDA first floated the idea two years ago
with the hope of making cigarettes
minimally or non-addictive.
If it gets the green light from President Biden,
it would have to be finalized
under the Trump administration.
The CDC is warning there's been a re-emergence of a drug
a hundred times more potent than fentanyl.
Carfentanil is a synthetic opioid
used by veterinarians to tranquilize large animals
like giraffes and elephants.
For humans, it's deadly.
It takes two milligrams of carfentanil
to tranquilize an elephant,
but that same two milligrams
can kill as many as 50 people.
DEA officials say it's being mixed with other drugs
to create a cheaper product.
An influential panel of health experts
says women should be able to take their own test samples
for cervical cancer screening.
The kits for at-home use contain a swab tube
and directions for collecting cervical cells.
Patients can provide the sample to their doctor
or in some cases mail them to a lab
that can check for signs of human papillomavirus or HPV.
This new effective option,
we hope and will help even more women
be screened for cervical cancer regularly.
The U.S. Preventative Task Force says women in their 20s
should still get a pap test every three years.
Women ages 30 to 65 can get an HPV test every five years.
Last year, some 800,000 Americans suffered a stroke.
Actor and comedian Jamie Foxx was one of them.
The Oscar winner is now telling his story
in a new Netflix comedy special.
CBS's Vladimir Dutier has more
on the 56-year-old's long recovery
that kept him out of the public eye for months.
Jamie Foxx is back in a new Netflix special.
You have no idea how good this feels.
He finally shares the details
of his near-death experience in 2023.
He's having a brain bleed that's led to a stroke.
Foxx says the last thing he remembers before a coma
was asking a friend for help with a headache.
Before I could get the aspirin, I went out.
They took me to the first doctor,
and that doctor just gave me a cortisone shot
and sent me home.
Last spring, Foxx was filming the upcoming Netflix movie
Back in Action with Cameron Diaz in Atlanta.
When Foxx fell ill, he was taken to the hospital.
I went to hail them back.
In the months that followed,
his family kept his condition private.
Nobody sees him.
They cut it all off.
Foxx said after waking up,
he was told a full recovery was possible,
but it would be the worst year of his life.
And when I woke up, I found myself in a wheelchair.
I couldn't walk.
Couldn't walk, bro.
The 56-year-old Foxx described relearning basic functions
and relying on his nurses.
Jay, you don't remember, do you?
What?
I've been bathing you for the past month and a half.
I said, mystery illness.
While singing, dancing, and playing the piano,
Foxx credited his healing to family and faith.
God gave me a second chance.
Body imagery tip, CBS News.
New York.
After the break, a note on music therapy.
And we'll take you inside a one-of-a-kind program
taking a holistic approach to support people
with autism and other disabilities.
About one in every 36 children
is now diagnosed with a form of autism.
Some children with autism and other complex medical issues
need round-the-clock help.
CBS News chief medical correspondent, Dr. John Lepook,
takes us inside a one-of-a-kind residential community
for teens and adults that has a unique approach.
Tommy Bove is a 20-year-old resident
at the Center for Discovery in Monticello, New York,
for people with autism and other complex conditions.
Like others at the Center, Tommy receives care and therapy
and works on the campus farm.
Tommy is autistic, nonverbal, and clearly thriving.
Scott and Kelly Bove are Tommy's parents.
Courtney is his 22-year-old sister.
Oh, this is like the best place for him.
This is the best thing that's ever happened to him.
Honestly.
Tommy has trouble sitting still,
and throughout the interview,
kept the family on their toes.
Come on, come here, buddy.
Yeah.
Tommy was a teenager when the pandemic hit.
COVID, the pandemic,
he was still living with us at the time.
He was heavy before then.
We were just giving in to everything at that point.
Just whatever he wanted in terms of whatever food.
Yeah.
He topped out at 360 pounds.
Get the tomatoes, bring them over there, put them in.
And after three years on a wait list,
Tommy finally got a spot at the Center for Discovery.
This has all been a lot for you and your family.
I mean, everyone has things, though.
There are things, and then there are things.
Yeah.
This is a thing.
It's a lifelong thing.
Dr. Teresa Hamlin is the CEO of the Center.
She has worked there for more than four decades.
When parents come here,
what's the description you give them of the program?
It's a program that's gonna look at your whole child,
that's going to appreciate them
from the inside out and outside in,
that we have a tremendous team here,
and they're part of that team.
Hamlin oversees 1,700 staff across multiple programs.
All in, the center services 1,200 people,
including 164 younger residents like Tommy,
nearly 200 day students,
181 adults who live on campus,
and hundreds of others who participate in programs.
Hamlin says their center is unique.
Do you know that there are not other programs
across the country where they're doing something similar?
There really aren't.
I think that so many people see autism
as a behavioral problem,
and so the treatment is behavioral therapy.
And we've missed the boat.
Keep pushing, keep pushing.
There's a lot more that we need to understand
and a lot more that we need to do here
in order to help these kids.
The backbone of the center includes healthy food,
sleep, activity, healthcare, and a soothing environment.
How are you guys doing?
How's the day going?
Jennifer Frank leads the Nourishing Arts Program.
It includes 35 chefs and their farm-to-table,
or as the center calls it, seed-to-belly program.
Residents eat whole foods,
much of it grown on the grounds.
Ultra-processed foods are banned.
Food has amazing power.
It has the power to completely support your health
or to totally undermine it.
What about outcomes?
We're seeing amazing results in the health of the kids.
Our obesity rate, you know,
we have about a 60% rate of ideal body weight.
Frank says adults at the Center for Discovery
also have much lower rates of high blood pressure
and diabetes than the general public.
Imagine if we can do this
for some of the most medically complex individuals there are.
Imagine what that means for you and I.
The Boves say Tommy's progress has been amazing.
So you're actually noticing
not only weight change and physical change,
but behavioral change.
Well, he's like dressing himself too,
which we always just did it, honestly.
The things that most people take for granted,
for you, him doing them.
Huge, it was huge.
Like we're in shock.
I don't want to imply that
the program here fixes everything, right?
These kids still do have a disorder.
Oh, absolutely.
That they will have forever, right?
Yeah, we don't cure the autism,
but we help kids function much better
so they can interact, so they can have friendships,
so that they can have a sense of normalcy,
whatever that is for themselves and for their family.
But yeah, we're not curing the disorder.
The State Disability Program covers room and board
for New York residents like Tommy.
But for those out of state,
the annual cost is more than $100,000.
Tommy will age out of the pediatric program
when he reaches 22.
What happens when he leaves here?
That's what causes stress.
Adult slots here open only rarely.
So in about 18 months,
Tommy will likely have to find
a different residential center
and adjust to new surroundings.
And of course, you're thinking about the future.
Yes.
What's that thinking like?
A few years ago, I ended up in a hospital in New South.
You know what happens if something happens to you?
Yeah.
You know, it was a relief when he came in here.
It was a relief to say, okay, you know,
the state's gonna take care of him now.
The school will take care of him.
It's like, oh, it's very hard.
Squeeze tight.
Squeeze her.
Give me another hug.
Give her a hug.
Tommy's sister, Courtney,
also feels the weight of responsibility.
I'm gonna be in charge of him one day.
So I always have to keep that in the back of my mind
for whatever happens.
Is there, in the future, some thought
that he might end up living physically with you?
I'd say so.
You shook your head no, right?
I don't expect her to.
No.
It's too much.
She's 27.
She's gonna have her own life.
She's gonna have her own life
and she doesn't have to take care of him.
Those worries and discussions
are echoed in families across the country.
As parents ask themselves,
what happens when we're not around?
Music therapy is known to offer health benefits
for people living with dementia and Alzheimer's disease.
CBS's Carter Evans introduces us
to a California college student
who has turned melodies into remedies.
For college sophomore Grace Sun,
playing the piano is therapeutic,
not just for her, but also her audience.
In her free time, she volunteers to play for seniors.
The concept of music therapy
is using music as a healing tool
to provide comfort and happiness
to those living with dementia and Alzheimer's disease.
She was inspired by her 79-year-old grandmother,
isolated at the height of the 2020 pandemic.
This is really detrimental
to the mental health of these seniors.
And I was thinking, what if I used my interests
and my passions so we could help out these people?
It sparked her idea for melodies for remedies.
The concerts were virtual at first,
playing for hospitals and senior centers.
But over the years, it's grown into a movement
with more than 100 musicians performing.
Aster Jin was Grace's high school classmate
at San Diego's Bishop School.
What drew you to it?
Like part of it was just like being a performer
and wanting to perform,
but it was also kind of a personal connection for me.
And my grandma also happens to have had Alzheimer's.
Studies show music therapy can boost cognitive function
in Alzheimer's patients by up to 50%.
And they start talking
and it's almost like they become a different person
like when they were younger
and they weren't suffering
from this neurodegenerative disorder.
Over the last four years,
melodies for remedies musicians have performed
for more than 40,000 seniors around the world.
Music from my experience is a universal language.
And I think it deserves to be shared around the world
and to whoever needs it.
Bringing back old memories
while creating priceless new ones.
I will come back.
Carter Evans, CBS News, San Diego.
Coming up, a tailor-made remedy.
We'll introduce you to a cancer nurse
keeping her patients stylish and comfortable.
And what pediatricians say is the optimal age
that parents should start reading to their children.
Many studies show the benefits of reading to children
go beyond literacy.
Now the American Academy of Pediatrics
is putting the spotlight on shared reading.
As CBS's Michael George explains,
it should start when children are just infants.
Ooh, yummy, yummy.
One-year-old Saori is trying to eat
the delicious fruit she sees in her favorite book.
Her mom, Julicia Costa, started reading to her
when she was just an infant.
She was licking the book.
She wanted that blueberry.
They still are able to understand the concepts
that you give them, no matter how small you think they are.
The American Academy of Pediatrics says
it's something all parents and caregivers should be doing,
reading aloud with newborns and young children
because the positive parenting practice
has benefits for a lifetime.
We've known for years that young children
who have parents who look at books with them
and talk to them, that their language development
has improved those positive experiences.
Also shaped the child's social and emotional development,
shaped the child's excitement later on
when it comes time to go to school.
Study author Dr. Perry Klass says
print books are best for young children.
Holding the book, turning the pages,
all of that helps young children understand
how the books work and how they can elicit
from their parents the kinds of reactions
and language that they want to hear.
The AAP says pediatricians should encourage
shared reading at least through kindergarten.
Lola's daddy reads a story.
The Acosta's pediatrician works with Reach Out and Read,
which provides books in low-income communities
in New York at child well visits.
I want my kids to know that no matter where they live,
wherever they come from, we can have a window
into another world through reading.
You love cheese.
I love it.
A world filled with discovery and adventures.
Michael George, CBS News.
Finally this half hour, a South Carolina nurse
is going above and beyond for her cancer patients.
Whitney Carpenter makes shirts for the people she treats
that allow easy access to the patient's chest
during chemotherapy.
This type of clothing called a port shirt
can retail for hundreds of dollars,
but Carpenter gives them to her patients for free.
Because you get to know these people
and you care for them
in the most difficult time of their life.
And it's such a rewarding and fulfilling job to have.
Just that little act, I hope, makes them smile.
Proof that care can come in so many designs.
That's this week's Eye on Health.
I'm Bradley Blackburn.
Thanks for joining us and be well.

