Adam Chandler, "99% Perspiration - A New Working History of the American Way of Life"

C-SPAN
473 followers
2K Video Views·Jan 13, 2025
Hi, I'm Caitlin, a podcast producer here at C-SPAN. This week on C-SPAN's Afterwards podcast,
journalist Adam Chandler argues that hard work is not enough to obtain the American Dream. Author Alyssa Court interviews him.
Hi, Adam, how are you doing? I'm doing great, Alyssa. It's so great to finally meet you and talk to you.
Yeah, it's really great. I've always
seen your byline and been like, wow, we're so much in common. In fact, you know, I wrote a book called Bootstrapped.
It's the only time you'll see it on the show.
It's a book about the myth of pulling yourself up by your bootstraps and
the grindset narrative and how it harms people across this country, Americans for many years.
And I realized reading your book, 99% Perspiration, that we share so much.
And I felt like I was reading the words of a mental twin.
So what brought you to this topic about writing a book about fast food? This is your second book, I think.
Yes, this is my second book.
So my first book was about sort of the history of America told through fast food and the post-war economy and a
lot of a lot of the mythology. And
while I was reporting that book, I was traveling around the country and I would meet
franchise owners at fast food restaurants who had started on the fryers working for $1.25 an hour
back in the 1970s. And
they had these stories about how through sheer grit and hard work
they had ascended to become corporate executives or franchise owners and
become millionaires. And
there was this belief, it was kind of an article of faith in the fast food industry, that if you
if you succeed, you've done it through hard work and hard work alone. And
I found that contrast interesting because if you look at the modern fast food worker,
they by and large have no shot at that, right?
The average fast food worker is usually around 26 or 27 in debt, probably has
some dependents and also very limited in benefits. So the idea of
the myth of hard work being the salvation force in American life and the reality of it not being true for so many people
really explains this bitter moment that we're in. And I know I love bootstraps for that reason as it gets at the
realities of where we are. And you know, for 99% Perspiration, which I have to
have to showcase as well, that's a big theme for me too. And it's really great to talk to you about it.
Yeah, and I mean
you talk about work as a font of secular meaning. That's the phrase I think you used.
And
that it's not, we assume that this is just like, you know, Benjamin Franklin founding father kind of idea.
But the idea that work is this form of secular meaning is a relatively new concept you write. And what do you mean by that?
Yeah, it's a great question. So, you know, we go back to the Puritan work ethic.
We talk about the pilgrims a lot and the Protestant work ethic in general.
And it's fascinating to me because work then was a vocation.
It was a form of higher calling and you did it to earn
salvation in the afterlife. It was a one surefire way of proving your worthiness.
And we eventually got away from that idea where work was just kind of a means to an end, you know.
Industriousness is something we've always cherished in American life. Hard work is something we've always cherished in American life.
But in recent decades, work has come to signify
something else. It's a form of your identity. It's an expression of who you are in a way that I think
previous generations
didn't see it that way. And some of that's an extension of working so many hours or working too much.
And the precarity of
having
income inequality. You really want to be identified by your work because it grants you some significance, some social capital.
And in the last few years, it's become a problem because
identifying with your job is a dangerous proposition.
And I think that that's an important thing to consider when you wrap yourself up in work.
Yeah, and I mean, I just was looking, there's a Brookings study that just came out today about volatility in low-wage work.
And sometimes I think that one of the main elements now for across the income gradient
up until the top, you know, 5% of earners, let's say, is insecurity and volatility, you know.
And I wonder if that's part of the need to
find a kind of brand for yourself as a worker because otherwise, you know,
how else do you put together the story of yourself if you're working odd jobs? I mean, did you see that in your reporting?
Absolutely. I mean, another Brookings study looks at the fact that 44% of jobs in America qualifies low-wage. So
we're really moving against the tide here of bad jobs and limited opportunity. And that has this knock-on effect
socially and
civically, and how we can't focus our lives on community in the way that we once could, or family, civic organizations.
These are the things that, you know, Robert Putnam and Ray Oldenburg and Coining Third Space is talking about. Places where Americans congregate.
Things that are good for democracy of
people just meeting and having social lives and being parts of their community. That's really dissipated. And
overwork and
identification with your profession has kind of stepped in to fill that void in a way that probably isn't good.
It's fueling, in many instances, a loneliness epidemic when you talk about American workers.
Yeah, and I mean, your writers and creative professionals and journalists are not alone.
I mean, do you see that even now in your own work? The kind of over-identification with your labor and the kind of volatility as well?
It's hard to paint a picture of,
you know, of sadness for journalists who get to travel around the country occasionally and talk to a lot of interesting people.
But there is a lot of precarity in the work. And what's troubling about that is,
we're convinced from on high, from our jobs, from the way that we talk about our work, that what we're doing is
important and is prestigious. And this isn't just journalism or media or publishing, but when you have a dream job,
when you have something that is seen as
prestigious or meaningful somehow, you're willing to make sacrifices. You're asked to make sacrifices for those jobs.
Because it is seen as being almost as
important or more important than the basic mechanics of the job being well-paying enough or
stable enough. So people are really willing to grind out in jobs that don't support them
materially and in necessary ways because there is some prestige attached to it.
I think a lot of people fall into that trap. And it doesn't pay off in the short term and it doesn't pay off in the
long term, but we're seduced by it all the same. I know, I'm sure you have this experience with your work.
Oh, I absolutely do. And even more so, I run an organization called the Economic Hardship Reporting Project, which I started
sort of running 10-11 years ago with Barbara Ehrenreich, the late, great Barbara Ehrenreich.
And part of why we kind of built it up was we saw that
journalism was becoming a precarious profession and also, you know, there was layoffs, etc.
But, you know, one of the most striking things about many of our writers who are working class or working poor or financially
unstable is that they're
still eager to see themselves, like you're saying, as writers and
they're, you know, it's very rare to have people who have working experience, working class experience now in journalism.
A study found that 10% of reporters identify as working class and that was a long time ago.
So I think one of the things that I was impressed by in your book was
your level of empathy and connection to the workers that you're writing about and getting inside their lives,
which is kind of hard right now when you read journalism.
You sort of have the journalists just popping in and writing about people at a bar at Pittsburgh or whatever.
But one of the things that I also recognize is that I think you have more first-hand experience with those kind of jobs than a
lot of journalists do today. You bartended for many years,
so you were part of the grind set. Do you mind talking about that?
Absolutely. I think, you know, for me,
I found my way into writing and journalism through a lot of trial and error, which again,
I think used to be the way that a lot of people found their way into jobs where you had summer jobs before
you went off to college or when you were home from school or you just had summers off in high school.
And that's kind of been replaced by a long-term careers
mentality where you want to have prestigious internships
that are unpaid if you can afford that, if your parents can afford to support you during those periods of time,
where you don't do a lot of exploration, a lot of meaningful work that
teaches you about how everybody around you lives. And so for me, bartending was eye-opening.
I did it for six years after I graduated from college while I was finding my footing as a writer, but also,
you know, working in nonprofits and
doing a bunch of odd jobs to make my life work and
being in a position where you see what it's like to not have health insurance.
And I was lucky to be healthy, but I went years without health insurance. My co-workers around me at a bar,
several bars, you know, didn't have paid sick leave. So either the rent was due or they went to work sick.
That's not something that we want, especially in the restaurant industry.
But it's the way that it is.
Not having stable hours and stable income is a real problem that a lot of people deal with.
Millions of American workers deal with every single day. And so to experience that and to see it, and again,
I was very lucky in that I was never at risk of losing my apartment, but people around me,
I could see very clearly we're struggling with the system, and it's still true all these years later.
And as that relates to journalism, and by the way, the work that you do in your organization is so
impressive and important because it highlights these issues that I think
fall under the radar because we don't have a lot of economic diversity in our newsrooms anymore. This is crucial.
This is important to think about. We talk a lot about diversity as being a critical part of telling the stories of American life,
problems, and its realities, and it's
critical to have that. Diversity is important.
But economic diversity and geographic diversity are very important aspects of that, and that's been lost over the years, I want to say.
And I'm sure that you've seen that. I have seen that. I mean, the lack of economic diversity, I mean, it's interesting.
You're talking about your early experiences, and I think about my daughter.
I have a teenager, like what she'll be probably doing, internships and college summer programs, and what we did in my generation.
I mean, I sound like an old.
But you know, we tempt, we lived with roommates, we fact-checked, we worked in bookstores, and
you know, I just do wonder, especially say the last election season, how it would have been
treated by reporters if they were more like our writers, say, who had been Uber drivers, or
had been unhoused, or had worked at a grocery store, or had worked
at a shoe store. You know, like, these are the stories that you can read on our site, economichardship.org, and
I just wonder,
and I wonder what you think, like, how would people
have reported the election differently when they have noticed that some of the pocketbook issues were being given short shrift?
Right, I think that's critical, and you know, in the book, I travel around the country talking to
construction workers in Wisconsin. I talked to a high school teacher in Indiana.
I talked to a pastor in rural Alabama about opportunity, about the struggles that people face, and it's always shocking to me because the story of
people working hard in this country, not getting ahead, in the richest country in the world,
is shocking and staggering, but it also
doesn't necessarily register as a surprise, even as it's shocking, because
if you are plugged into
the basics of what people are going through, it's not ever completely,
you know,
a revelation. It's more of just,
you hear these stories and tropes over and over again, and they never exactly make sense,
but you see the movement of it shift over the years, and it just becomes more calcified as a fact in your mind, and
the realities of it, that it isn't changing, is something that I think
people discover again and again and again, but once again,
it's so strange to live that life as a reporter, and to see it firsthand,
because
the story feels new for a lot of people the first time they report it out, and that's a symptom of
the turnover in our industry, the turnover in media, the turnover in,
you know, culture, writing, and all of these different storytelling
that inform people, that give people
basic information about what's going on, and so the 2024 election is a key example of that.
I don't think a lot of people near me, and I live in a
somewhat conservative part of New York State,
I wasn't shocked by the result, but reading the news coverage of it, a lot of people were. They didn't see what was happening,
and they didn't know what was coming, and I know that for other people,
it was clear as day.
Yeah, and
I
mean, I really appreciate that you
followed the money in that way, and you, all these different people's lives,
but also I want to say that this story is not always the same, and one of the things I
appreciated also about your book was that you have a frame.
It's not just like the poor are always with us, like the frame is about a shift into overwork, a shift to
the grind set, a shift that I also wrote about in my previous book, Squeeze, the middle precariat,
where you have middle-class people whose lives mirror that of low-wage people in their
contingency and overwork, and so I think that
you're sounding an alarm about that, that a lot of people, not just the lower-wage people,
but middle-class people are also feeling. They're feeling squeezed. They're feeling the perspiration, and how it's not paying off. Yes.
Gallup does an economic opportunity poll every few years, and I'm sure you're familiar with it, but in the year 2002,
23% of Americans said that they were failing to get ahead despite working hard, and
20 years later, in 2023,
39% of Americans said that they were failing to get ahead despite working hard, so that's a huge jump, and that's emblematic of a broader shift
and a fear and a tension that exists in America about what hard work is actually
doing, what it is actually providing, what is the sweat
actually making possible or not making possible in American life, and if you look at what's happened over the last 40 years,
American workers have
grown 64% more productive, and their pay has only increased 17%. The American economy has doubled in size since
1979, and if you're a person of color or a person without a college degree,
you are making less in real wages than you did 40 years ago, and that is a huge problem,
and that is spurring what we're seeing in terms of distrust of institutions,
xenophobia, and extremism, and all of these different facets of American life that are so troubling and so unnerving and speak to this bitter moment.
I mean, those stats are remarkable.
Adam, I feel like we should have them written on the sides of buildings and sent to our politicians.
I've been shouting them out, you know, to random people on the street as I go. While, you know, while reporting this book,
you stumble over some statistics that will just blow your mind, and you see the realities of them,
but when you see it in print, and you think, oh, you know,
medical debt is
the biggest cause of bankruptcy in America. Baby formula is one of the most shoplifted items.
We're the richest country in the world. How is it possible? Why is it our reality? Yes, sorry, I totally interrupted you there.
Good work, I have to say. So,
my book Bootstrapped, which, again, is your mental twin, it came out two years ago,
but two years is now an eternity, right? What has happened the last two years? We've had
the end of the pandemic and its social supports, you know, the child tax credit, the
eviction moratoria. You have a Trump re-election, which I think we can, both you and I, probably agree is potentially quite dangerous.
What is the shift in the psyche of the country in the period between
when my book came out and probably when you were starting to write this book and
its publication?
The pandemic protection is gone. There's like a huge upswell of need, right? Do you mind telling us about it?
Absolutely, and you're so wise to point out the difference in these two years, these two
crucial years, because the pandemic protections were really revolutionary. If you think about the fact that we stopped
evicting people from their homes and we gave them rental assistance, owing to the fact that
there was a calamity, there was a pandemic happening that made it impossible for people to work.
But we were also keeping people who are on Medicaid from having to recertify over and over again so they could keep their health coverage.
We had an expanded child tax credit, which gave every family, including low-income families that have previously been
excluded from the child tax credit,
$250 or $300 a month
per child to
basically acknowledge that child care is work, that if you're staying home and raising a family or
watching kids, it benefits the economy and it is work. And if you're watching over
elderly or disabled people, you have
value and it's important. And again, you could list so many of these pandemic protections, but they all went away.
You know, they all, after the child tax credit cut
child poverty by over half in this country, it shot right back up because we failed to
renew it. We failed to make the case that this is transformative. And so, of course, people were furious.
Of course, people were angry
when they had the basic protections that
countries that we love to compare ourselves to have just in place
go away. And it's no surprise to me that we have this upswell of both need and anger as a result of that.
And it's so important to look at because we could have changed the nature of the relationship between
governance and citizenship. And we had it for a minute and it went away by the slimmest of margins because we're in a 50-50 country.
And the
mechanics of our politics make it impossible to actually make big change that we need to do.
Yeah, and I mean, I think
you know, we're three days out
today from the anniversary of January 6th and the second Trump inauguration brings to mind that link
between the
loss of opportunity and extremism.
Excuse me, you know, we're working harder for less job security and we have less societal security.
And one thing I was wondering, like, it's chicken or egg in some ways. Has the lack of security
led to an embrace of extremism like the extremism we saw on January 6th and
autocrats and or have autocrats and extremism led to greater insecurity for ordinary people?
And obviously the right answer is both, but like how would you explain in layman's terms how those two sides of it work?
C-SPAN's afterwards podcast continues in a moment.
Now back to C-SPAN's afterwards podcast.
You're very right in saying the right answer is both, but I would say that the lack of security
led to an embrace of
extremism in this country and a lot of that in my understanding of it and in conversations
I had and reporting that I've done
just kind of circles around the idea that if you were working hard and you've been told all your life that all you need to
do is work hard and you'll get to where you're going. That's an American principle. That's an American
article of faith.
For that to not be true
is
shocking and infuriating and of course you wouldn't believe in your institutions anymore.
Of course, you would listen to someone who says look you've been doing everything right. It's
undocumented immigrants coming in that are taking your jobs or ruining your communities. You will listen to anyone who's saying
listen, this is not your fault because you've been doing everything you've been told to do and you're not getting ahead.
So it opens the door for extremism and this isn't unique to our time.
This has happened throughout the history of the country. If you look to the Chinese Exclusion Act or if you look to
the Great Depression where we were
deporting not just people of Hispanic descent, but Mexican Americans who've been living here and were citizens because of economic precarity.
This is a through line throughout our history. However, in this moment
we're just seeing it again in another potent form and it's important to acknowledge that. It's harder to convince people
to buy into extremist ideology or to fall prey to these kinds of
opportunists and grifters when life is good, when we're making ends meet and where your hard work matches your reward, your stability.
When that isn't true, we leave ourselves vulnerable to all kinds of terrible forces.
Yeah, and I think I mean
you pointed out it's a 50-50 country, so there is a limit to what let's say the Democrats could have done with their election
year discourse.
But I did want to ask you about this because a lot of the discourse of the Kamala campaign was about freedom.
But the failure of the promise of hard work to pay off
to me, to my mind, was what influenced election results and
that's if it's about any kind of freedom, it's like
economic freedom. So what do you think was the problem with this election year language about preserving democracy
when it wasn't addressing economic freedom?
This is such an important question because as you're watching all of these politicians give speeches about preserving democracy,
it's important and it's critical and we're only going to learn how important it is in the coming weeks and months
However, if you are working hard and if you are doing everything right
and if you are plugging yourself in as much as you possibly can to
your job and your life and you're still not getting ahead, democracy already isn't working for you.
Democracy is not worth preserving when we have this level of
economic precarity where we have this gap between effort and
reward and stability and basic security. That's the truth and that's the reality and until we are able to
bring
the universe in balance and
have the world that we live in be a little bit fairer and a little bit more secure or a lot more secure,
I should say, we're going to be
susceptible to anyone who has an idea that
breaks out of the norms of the institutions that have failed us and it's important to talk about that because
democracy is very important, but people don't buy into it when we have such income inequality where we have so many opportunities
squandered, where we have all of this
devastation and it's not just the pandemic that means we need protections. We have
an economic environment that is a calamity in and of itself, that is
constantly generating
misery and poverty and
deaths of despair. Our life expectancy is lower than all the countries
we love to compare ourselves to and this is another huge problem that speaks to the hollowness of
what America actually is as a democracy when you want to talk about what's durable in American life.
Yeah, and also I have to say, you know, when you're talking about democracy,
it's an abstraction, but when all the things you're naming are bodily, they're utterly concrete, you know, they're people's
inability to be
physically durable and to, you know,
properly have fine dwellings in major cities. I mean, you know, that's not
democracy. Democracy feels a little vague, I think, when you're struggling like that. Absolutely.
Yeah, in your book, 99% Perspiration,
which is a great title, by the way, and I'll ask you later how you came up with that,
you write about workism and I was like, oh, I hadn't really heard that before and how all these
predictions in the 21st century
about workism have failed to come true. So what is workism?
Workism is a term coined by the journalist Derek Thompson, who is,
you know, a fantastic writer and thinker about these big topics. And the idea of workism is that work has come to replace
religion in some ways. It is a secular religion where we derive our identity from work,
where we forge our social ties from work, where our relationships and our
social lives revolve around the office or the places where we do jobs.
And it's a problem in a lot of ways because
it's something that has come to replace
friends and family and community in
really potent,
in really potent ways. If you look at, there was a Pew study not too long ago, in 2023, that asked
Americans what the most fulfilling parts of life would be. What are components that make for a fulfilling life?
And 71% of Americans said a meaningful career
is central to having a fulfilling life. And that's all well and good.
However, that ranked higher than getting married, having a family, and close friendships.
And so when a meaningful career outweighs all these other facets of life that are so important to us being
socially engaged and
plugged in and aware of each other and the struggles that other people are going through,
it blinds us in a way. And work is a key component in what puts on these blinders in
keeping us from understanding each other. We are
politically and economically segregated in ways that have only grown stronger the more that income inequality pushed us. If you look at
political clustering and
economic clustering,
it's very easy to go through your life without meeting someone or engaging someone in your general area who believes something different than you or
has a different income bracket than you or lives in a different income bracket than you. And
that really robs us of a basic
empathy and understanding of what people are going through. It makes everyone, like democracy as you were saying, into an abstraction.
And that's dangerous because
we have to fill in those gaps. We have to understand what everyone else is going through. And it's rural and poor.
It's urban and wealthy.
It's old and young. All of these different facets interact with each other and need to interact with each other for us
to really have a comprehensive understanding of what it means to be a citizen and not just an individual.
Yeah, I mean, I completely agree. I mean, one thought I'm having when you're talking about work is not to
derive people's workism, but to potentially call the formation of communities,
especially ones outside of your kind of
whatever ordinary trajectory, you know, like
desegregating your communities into work. Like I think maybe framing work is something more radical. Like the work of
community, collective happiness is a form of work. Like that could be a turn. Anyway.
Yeah, I know. I love that idea because when we talk about aspiration, we talk about what it means to actually
be someone who is a
go-getter or
ambitious.
That can mean in your community, that can mean in your family and in your life around you.
It doesn't all have to be at the office. It doesn't all have to be
the things that we are able to
achieve in a professional capacity. It is ambition to take more time off. It's ambition to
be there for your neighbors, to
plug into your community, understand its needs better so that you can
play a part and play a bigger role and be fulfilled by those things and have that come back to you and fulfill you.
So I really like that framing.
Yeah, and it's something that I think
Lynn Sachs and Barbara Ehrenreich, they both wrote about this collective joy piece
almost as an extension of their vision of hard work and labor, if that makes any sense.
So that, I'm just joining the dots, but maybe that's something to collaborate on the future.
Yeah, yeah, let's talk after the show.
You write in the book that 36% of workers are now classified as independent,
which means they're not employees, and that's up from
27% in only
2016. And I was, again, this was another one of your numbers where I was like, wow, that is a huge shift.
And I'd love you to explain to the audience, you know, why this growing number of independent workers
is part of the problem, why it's creating
this idea of perspiration and hustling and making it so difficult to escape.
Right, well, what I think really, this kind of statistic where we're working, big economy has taken off or where independent contractors have taken off
vis-a-vis
jobs that are more traditional and, you know, what used to be a nine-to-five, it is now, you know, a nine-to-eleven.
If you have email on your phone, you're just working on the whole day through until you go to bed.
Or you're responding to messages constantly, and we're all guilty of it to some extent, and it's impossible to ignore.
But the workism component, I think, connects to the fact that a lot of the traditional jobs are gone, and
that
really wreaks havoc on our stability, and that means that we're constantly hustling to stay up.
There is a precarity around it, and this is coming all the way up the economic ladder.
One study that recently,
again, while I was reporting this book, blew my mind.
Of the Fortune 500 companies that existed in the year 2003,
by the year 2023,
52% of them were gone. They had either merged, collapsed, or been acquired by someone else.
So if you had signed up for a Fortune 500 company job where, you know,
this is a stable, most successful company, and you're thinking this is 25 years in a gold watch or a pension,
obviously, those days are gone. But whatever modern version of that, by joining an enormous company,
even you in that position aren't safe from the way that our economy is playing out and
introducing constant precarity. And that is a reality that is,
again, going all the way up the income ladder, and people are now dealing more with
what it means to
be performative in your labor, to show that you're dedicated and devoted to the job at all hours.
Or if you don't have a full-time gig,
just running ragged, trying to keep the pieces of your life together through all of these different platforms that offer you no protection
and no certainty of work. It's the hustle mentality that has gone from being a niche concept to
all-encompassing. And our digital lives reinforce it, but the economy reinforces it, too.
I mean, the return to work also seems part of it, the return to the office,
which goes really far up the ladder, actually, and does seem quite performative to me.
You know, that this idea that you're gonna go into the office in another state, you know,
to show your fealty to your company, you know, after you were perfectly productive at home. So that's another piece of this.
So I call this the con of the side hustle and bootstrapped. Is the hustle a con? Is it always a con?
The hustle is largely a con, but it's a con of necessity, and it's a trap, I would say. In addition to being a con,
it's a trap. The idea that you were constantly focused on moving around and
finding your financial footing wherever you can by working constantly is
both a sign of status because you're so busy all the time.
It's meant to show that you're important, but underneath that is a great fear, anxiety, and precarity that guides those
motivations to be
someone who doesn't have hobbies that are things that happen offline and aren't productive and are just leisure.
Instead, these are things that you can show to the world.
I have these other skills, or I'm doing these other passion projects that I hope may lead to some other job or some other
opportunity. There's none of this kind of innocent hanging out in third spaces or
just
completely consequence-free leisure. There's always some kind of undercurrent of productivity and productivity culture
guiding us in what we do. And again, I'm speaking in broad generalizations,
but these are cultural norms that existed once that are being shredded. And as a result,
we're seeing people spending less time with their friends, spending less time with their family. And that has a knock-on effect in how
we
operate as a society that's meant to be durable and functional and dynamic and creative. Having time off from work
boosts loyalty. Having time off from work leads to healthier outcomes in life.
And that is the problem of our
work culture right now, is that our
quality of life is deteriorating because we're working harder and longer hours. And it also costs businesses a lot of money.
I think that's an important point.
Every year, American businesses lose over a trillion dollars to attrition, to people leaving their work because it's not sustainable enough for them.
Imagine if that trillion dollars, over a trillion dollars, were invested into making workers happy or
convincing them or urging them to take time off,
not having offices be understaffed.
That would pay off in dividends for business and for people. And for whatever reason, the disconnect just exists so strongly that
we can't make that connection
actually happen in a meaningful way.
I mean, there used to be a culture of
like a slacker, right? This is a Gen X conceit or that like there is a kind of
honor, honorability in like the Eidler. That was a publication I remember.
And I mean, do you think that there is a sort of, is there honorable
slacking anywhere? And is this generational? I mean, was this kind of one of these shifts?
Are you, are you millennial by the way?
I'm a geriatric millennial, which is a designation that I absolutely hate.
But I'm an older millennial. And so for me, I actually
sort of came of age in what was a time of great prosperity as a teenager in the 90s. And ultimately,
my cohort and I graduated more or less from college into the Great Recession.
And so we saw, you know, this hollowing out lead to this enormous
cleaning out of American families and American jobs and these industries that had been sort of stalwart parts of our economy.
Just kind of dissipate. And so for us, the car crash has been happening in slow motion.
And I've seen a lot of people that I know in my life kind of change from being
someone who was, you know, people who are interested in the humanities and literature in college,
take a sharp turn out of that, out of those creative professions or out of
those, I guess, more mission driven professions and going towards higher paying, more secure jobs,
even though they're not as secure as they once were, in order to avoid, you know,
bankruptcy, catastrophe, debt, and just have their lives work.
It's just getting harder and harder to have basic stability.
And it, it really costs us as a culture in terms of what, what innovation might happen if we had universal health care.
What, what we might actually achieve if we let people take risks.
That's the problem with hard work is not the problem if it pays off.
But we are not giving people the tools to be socially mobile anymore.
And if we are this country that cherishes bootstrapping as much as that is a myth, if we cherish social mobility,
if we need to give people the mechanisms, the tools to be able to do that, or else we're just
creating more dissonance between our words and our values and our, in our actual lives.
Yeah.
Love it.
So I'd like to turn to someone who is constantly in the news right now, Elon Musk.
Sure.
Like, I know it's a sharp turn away from, you know, anybody knowing anything about literature and, and humanity, but talk about hustles and cons.
He's the ultimate preacher for perspiration.
And he claims that working a hundred hour weeks is how you change the world.
But he has inherited wealth.
I think he's disputed the fact that his, about his family's emerald mines.
It's still right.
He benefited from tax breaks.
He benefited from grants for like R and D and, you know, from the state and I think national grants as well and public investment.
So Musk and his American oligarchs tend to attack the role of government, but they never seem to mention what the alternative to government is.
What do you think it is?
And why are they hell bent on this myth?
And how are they harming people?
Every time I see a Tesla and also those evil cyber trucks, you know, I'm thinking this is like the car of, you know, individualism run amok.
You know, like I identify it with that.
So it's on every street corner now.
C-SPAN's afterwards podcast continues in a moment.
Now back to C-SPAN's afterwards podcast.
Absolutely.
Uh, well, you know, in some ways you have to salute Elon Musk because his commitment to innovation has, has brought EVs and, you know, green cars more into the discourse in ways that one hopes will create a culture shift.
So there is innovation there, but we have to acknowledge that that innovation wasn't because of Elon Musk's, you know, fealty to the grind.
It's because he got billions of dollars in taxpayer subsidies.
All of these things inherited wealth, all of these, all of these boosts, all these legs up that we're talking about that you mentioned.
And so, um, you delineate it so clearly.
Elon Musk is an example of somebody who benefited because of the investments that we put into innovation in this country.
And when you deride government as he does, you are taking away a lot of what made Tesla, SpaceX, all of these projects possible.
You know, the, the immigration system that creates new jobs.
You know, an immigrant is 80% more likely to start a new business.
They pay a $1.38, they, they pay $1.38 in taxes for every dollar that they received.
These are real stats about what it means to, to, um, to be an American that's supported by a government and a system that inspires innovation.
And to deride that constantly is dangerous because it takes the focus off of the community and puts it on the individual.
And that's a big part of what, of what the book is about.
The idea of success in American life is based on individual, individuality, individual grit, someone like Elon Musk.
But what that does is it turns success or failure into a matter of character.
If you didn't make it in America, the land of opportunity, you didn't try hard enough.
That's what it says.
And that means that if you failed because you didn't work hard enough and therefore you're morally unworthy.
And that's very dangerous because millions of people are working so hard.
And I know your reporting is every single day is about this.
Um, millions of people are working hard and they're not getting ahead.
And that has nothing to do with their character or their grit.
It has to do with the obstacles that people face that make it harder and harder for people to achieve success.
The child, the cost of childcare, the cost of housing, the cost of education, all these things that have shot up in you are tattered social safety net, our health insurance system.
All of these things are obstacles to the success and the possibility of innovation that we say we aspire to.
And that's the incompatibility of, especially in this moment, the American myth and the American reality.
And, um, you know, it's, it's so fun to talk to you about this in part because you dig into these topics.
Every single day.
And it's really meaningful for people to understand how this interacts with our sense of self, our sense of worthiness in this country.
It's shameful for people to need help.
And this is why I think we're seeing a lot of deaths of despair.
I think this is why people are turning away from institutions and turning away from their communities.
Because if you need help, it's deemed to be shameful.
If you apply for welfare, um, or food stamps, there are all of these hoops that you have to jump through to prove you're deserving this.
And that's not something we ask of wealthier people who get all kinds of tax cuts, who gets up, who get all kinds of breaks, um, in ways that make everything else look kind of silly.
What we spend on, um, writing off, you know, your mortgage, your, your, your mortgage or property taxes every year far, far exceeds the amount that we give in housing.
You know, these are, these are just incompatibilities that really exist, um, that we don't really reckon with.
And there's been a lot of important scholarship on that.
And, you know, I'm lucky to be able to report a book on it because I can synthesize all of these things that are, you know, satellites orbiting around my head at times into a cohesive narrative.
About opportunity and, um, talking to you about it is so gratifying because I know, I know that, you know, and it's, uh, we want, we just want more people to know.
We want more people to know.
Um, and also one thing I'm just thinking of this is, uh, why are there so few people thinking about the psychological element of this?
Like, I, I mean, I, part of why I was so excited about your book and your work in general and a few other, I just saw a film death and taxes by Justin shine.
That was about, uh, what taxation did to his family, you know, how, uh, his father's tax avoidance affected their family.
I love that those moments, like, uh, those kind of, uh, works that are about where individual psychology or collective psychology hits the market and the economy.
Why do you think people don't think about that that much?
It's a great question.
And, um, I wish they would give us another hour cause I feel like we could, we could really, we could really unpack all the, all the particular, uh, sort of nuances of this specific issue.
Um, I, it's just so encoded in American life that you have to be productive and that you need to succeed in ways that I think other countries just bristle at.
In the book, I traveled to France and one example I'll just give, I mean, they're notorious for a 35 hour work week, which again, there are so many loopholes in this, that it's, it's not actually a 35 hour work week.
It's just hashing out reasonable policies between companies and workers.
There are ways that it works and doesn't work.
It's not perfect.
Um, but if you go to a museum in France, if you go to any of the major cultural institutions and you look at the admission board, when you're buying a ticket, there's a
special admission fee for people who are unemployed or seeking jobs that is less than the basic admission for entrance for anyone else.
Can you imagine in the, in the, in the U S going to a museum and saying, if you're not working, yeah, you can still enjoy art or mood or culture.
Um, you shouldn't also have a life outside of your, your job hunt, you know, it's so wrapped up in these concepts of identity and success and focus that.
Um, it's just jarring to me to think you're allowed and encouraged to have a life outside of your work.
And it's reinforced by cultural norms, whether it's four weeks off year, as is commonplace in Europe or a work week that ends, it's not seen as a sign of inefficiency.
Um, in America to work at your job until seven o'clock at night or 11 o'clock at night, it's seen as an act of loyalty.
But if you go to other countries, if you're still at the desk at 7 PM, it means that your company's understaffed or it means that your job is inefficient or something is institutionally wrong.
It's seen as, uh, as, as foolish or, or, you know, again, problematic, not a sign of devotion.
And all of these things just kind of create this mosaic of individual focus on success and achievement that takes all of the obstacles out of the equation.
And we're just trying our best to get through our days.
And I think that that blinds us to the realities that we really have a unique working culture that is very specific to our cultural identity and our history.
Going back to the pilgrims and the frontier and all of these landmark moments where we've defined work as being individual and success as being individually driven, as opposed to communally focused.
It's a very, it's a very long winded answer, but sorry, go ahead.
Yeah, yeah.
But one of the, you know, we are a culture that also is very psychological and to self-help and diagnostics and all this kind of stuff.
But somehow that doesn't, it's never the twain shall meet with our economic reality.
And that to me is like a very fascinating, um, if anything, the psychological piece is a way of like letting off the steam of hyper-capitalism, you know?
Ah, that's a great point.
I love that.
It's, you know, you hear, I talked to white collar workers about all the perks that they have at their offices and gyms and laundry and all of these things and breakfast, lunch and dinner at your office place.
And you're like, it's never the question of whether you should be at your office for breakfast, lunch and dinner.
They have, you know, focuses on, on, on self-care, but not work boundaries, the things that create, you know, safer and, um, healthier balances in your life.
It's, it's all about these quick fixes that are, again, it is, um, the quiet quitting as, as a, you know, as a, as a labor phenomenon of just doing your basic job and not going above and
beyond that scene is a phenomenon and not a basic expectation that of course, you're just going to do the basics of your job.
And if you, it's not bad if you want to work harder, but, uh, that shouldn't be the baseline expectation unless you're getting compensated.
So that's a really great point.
We, we, we, we can't quite make that connection, get it over the finish line.
It exists for moments in, in, in crisis and, and, and bubbles.
And I think the discourse around it is changing, but you know, all the, all the, all the experimentation we've been doing with remote work seems to be coming to an end, even though there are so many benefits to it.
And it's just another example of what's happened where you've had these clarion moments of possible change and they've kind of slipped through our grasp and we've been distracted.
You know, it's, we're not talking about work or the unsustainable nature of life because we're talking about renaming the Gulf of Mexico or potentially annexing Greenland, whatever it is right now.
But I think amongst like liberal Democrats also who are safe therapists, there's, there could be a frame where you start to think, look at like what it means to treat people as treating them around money and class.
Uh, I call it inequality therapy.
Tell me more.
I want to hear, I want to know.
Oh, that's just in bootstrapped.
I came up with that as a way of thinking about, um, trying to get, um, therapeutic access to people who might not have it normally.
experiences that are very defined by your economic reality.
If you're struggling to make a living, it's not really about therapy in some ways, you know, the therapy should be about that problem too, as not as a personal problem, but as a social problem.
And there's some people who are starting to do that.
So that's just a, I can, we can talk about that offline too.
One thing that I think that is interesting that's kind of changed in that is, um, this speaks a lot to a masculinity crisis that's going on as, as traditionally masculine coded jobs of, you know, working in manufacturing have, have gone away.
Um, there are more opportunities for people to become home health aides or to do work that in nursing that would be seen as feminine, but men are unable to make that transition because we have these.
Very psychological kind of, um, concepts of what certain jobs are for certain people and what is good work and what is bad work or what is different work from what you're expected.
And those can close a lot of gaps in our economy.
And I think the psych, the psychological component is, is really critical to it because asking for help is, as we kind of talked about before is seen as shameful here.
And as a result, people who feel alienated from the workforce are, you know, becoming susceptible to isolation and deaths of despair and all of these different, um, all of these different sort of challenges of life.
If you have a college degree and, uh, you used to live two years longer than someone who didn't have a college degree in the 1990s.
And more recently they found that that gap has expanded to eight and a half years, which is wild.
And a lot of that falls on middle-aged white men who, again, felt more control over their economy, um, their own personal economy in the years past and are now grappling with the fact that their perception of themselves.
And again, this is a lot of therapy speak has changed because of the, of, of the reality of today.
So we're closing in on our hour.
So I just wanted to ask two more questions.
The last, you know, we work in the inequality relief business, you and I.
Um, so what are some examples of like hope and sanity, uh, that we might one day see, uh, what would get us out of this grind set worldview?
Uh, and where do you, where do you see possibility?
There is a lot of possibility.
And I, you know, I, I, I try to emphasize that wherever we're going.
It's, it's interesting to me because traveling around the country while reporting this book, you meet people from all different parts of the country.
And I, you know, I, I traveled all over the country to, to report this.
And what's interesting to me about it is that the more people you meet, you find people in this country are very kind and very, even if our chosen policies in this country are not very kind and very caring.
And that gives me hope in ways that I think is meaningful cause or are meaningful because you see how that manifests in community efforts to take care of people in ways that we don't allow the government to do.
You know, civic groups and church church organizations.
When people are increasingly sleeping in their cars, governments on local levels have passed bills against sleeping in your car, even though more people are homeless and civic organizations have
stepped in to provide safe places for people to shower, to stay overnight, to, to be warm in cold, cold times.
And that is asking a lot of, of communities, but communities that can acknowledge and see the problems around them are plugged into the need.
And we shouldn't have to ask people to do that.
You know, I talked to a pastor in Alabama who sleeps with his phone ringer on because he's the pillar of the community and people trust him.
They can confide in him.
And when the worst happens, he needs to be there.
So his phone is on all the time waiting for the worst thing to happen.
And that's a lot to ask of a person when we could have better support around us to make that less necessary and less troublesome to everyone.
Um, so that's one, one part of that, one part of that story, I think that needs to be told.
And, um, yeah.
And in my last book, I call that the dystopian social safety net.
Yeah.
I love that concept.
Oh, but so one of the things, um, so is there bigger things that you write?
Yes, yes, absolutely.
Sorry.
I, I, I get caught up, I get caught up on the individual stories and again, this is part of being American, right?
Right.
Where we, we, we love a good story.
Um, and we, we have imagination and it's a beautiful part of it.
And again, there are beautiful parts of the story that I love in the American constitution.
The idea of, um, not banning titles of nobility, right.
That is, that is a really nice concept that I love.
Um, but talking about universal basic income or, um, talking about guaranteed income or even, even negative tax, um,
negative income tax, where if you are living below the poverty line, they give you money to be 150% above the poverty line and just eradicate poverty.
That is something that we could do that doesn't cost that much money.
And talking to experts in this, in the book, you realize that there are all these experiments going around and all these communities that could change the basic functions of life in America.
And we just don't do it.
And we have to, we need to.
And so writing about each of those small community experiments was really enlivening because you see how much need there is, but you also see how creative the solutions are that people are coming up with to help.
And I think that that's such an important part of the story is the vital work that people are doing to solve these problems.
Yeah.
Well, thank you so much, Adam.
This has been a real pleasure talking to you.
Thank you.
This is a dream for me.
I appreciate it.
Yeah.
So everyone should go and read 99% Perspiration and I'll see you soon.
Yeah, let's do it.
Thank you.
Thanks for listening to this week's afterwards podcast.
If you are interested in podcasts about nonfiction books, listen to C-SPAN's Book Notes Plus podcast for interviews with authors and historians hosted by Brian Lamb.
