👉 Discover the art of breaking poetic conventions with Stephen Dickey's thought-provoking works and Nicholas Korn's innovative "Wild Sonnets." Dive into a world where creativity knows no bounds! 🌟📖
📗📗 𝐈 𝐇𝐎𝐏𝐄 𝐘𝐎𝐔 𝐆𝐔𝐘𝐒 𝐄𝐍𝐉𝐎𝐘 𝐓𝐇𝐈𝐒! ▶ If you enjoy this video, please like it and share it. ▶ Don't forget to subscribe to this channel for more updates. ▶ Subscribe now : @classicalpoetslive
⚠ 𝐃𝐈𝐒𝐂𝐋𝐀𝐈𝐌𝐄𝐑: We do not accept any liability for any loss or damage incurred from you acting or not acting as a result of watching any of my publications. You acknowledge that you use the information I provide at your own risk. do your own research.
✖ 𝐂𝐎𝐏𝐘𝐑𝐈𝐆𝐇𝐓 𝐍𝐎𝐓𝐈𝐂𝐄: This video and my YouTube channel contain dialog, music, and image that are property of "Classical Poets Live" 🌟 Like, comment, and subscribe to join us on this poetic journey and discover more about classical poetry and literary careers! ✨ 👋 Thanks for visiting my Channel! 🌟
I want to talk about an idea I've been mulling over in my head.
I've been having some back and forth conversations with my friend,
the poet, translator, and linguist, Steven Dickey.
And we were talking about this trend that you see in poetry today where
most of what you see is either freeform to the point of being weird and bizarre,
and just very virtue signaling in its iconoclasm,
or it's rigid and rule-bound to the point where it just repeats what's been done in the past
without really doing anything new.
And I should say that between these two groups,
which more or less neatly fall into the liberal and conservative camps,
the avant-garde iconoclastic camp is by far the larger and more influential side today.
And in thinking about the other camp, Steven raised the question,
is it possible to have conservative avant-garde art?
Or merely just avant-garde art that doesn't overturn everything,
throwing all the old values of the past in your face?
And Steven realized that in thinking about this question,
both of these are loaded terms.
Conservative art is a loaded term because it usually designates poetry
that sounds like a Hallmark card,
or the kind of unsubtly sentimental paintings you see by John McNaughton.
And as for the term avant-garde,
that tends to designate a certain type of modernism
that I'm not really talking about in this sense.
But setting those terms aside, one can ask the question,
if you accept that tradition is not just a stale set of rules to follow,
but a set of living principles that must continue to transform
so as not to become ossified,
exactly how can one work within the boundaries of tradition and be fresh?
Don't you have to break the rules of classicism in order to do this?
Another way of putting this is,
is it possible to introduce unusual experimental ideas into art
in a way that isn't totally iconoclastic or bizarre,
but still remains at least traditional-ish?
Can art be perennially avant-garde,
something that isn't just a passing fad,
but that still seems fresh after a hundred years?
I'm reminded of what the poet Don Patterson said
about the ancient Greek philosopher Heraclitus,
that reading Heraclitus' aphorisms is like
unearthing a hundred daggers from the ground that are still sharp.
And so I think the answer to this question is obviously yes.
And my friend Stephen Dickey came up with a term for this.
He called it creative unorthodoxy.
Emily Dickinson would be a good example of a poet who represents this sort of aesthetic.
Her poetry is not quite like anything else that's ever been written.
It's unique and meaningful without being totally bizarre and alienating,
which isn't to say that it isn't sometimes strange in a good way.
Much of Stephen's own poetry as well represents this kind of aesthetic.
His work is somewhat reminiscent of Dickinson,
though not intentionally.
I think it's more that because he cut his teeth on German language poetry,
his verse has a Rilkean quality to it.
The most recent poet I interviewed, Nicholas Korn,
also writes sonnets that I think could be called creatively unorthodox.
He is a classical poet who breaks some of the rules of classicism,
but not all of them.
And he has invented a sonnet form that is remarkably fresh.
But skirting this boundary of creative unorthodoxy is very difficult.
There seems to be a lot of pressure to either follow the rules all the time
or to never follow any of them at all.
To either be all order or all chaos.
But while I have tried to make a case that it can be a good thing
to introduce some chaos into your order,
if you're going to do that, you have to know what you're doing.
You need to know how to create the order, to develop discipline,
so that you can then introduce a little chaos into your work.
Now, beyond just talking about rules of formalism, or lack thereof,
there's the deeper question of how you think as a poet.
It's a question of vision.
Are you just staying within the realm of comfortable feelings,
relying on cliches to express your thoughts like an insta-poet would?
Or the opposite, just being outraged and writing angry stuff all the time,
making every topic about some identity subgroup.
Without deliberately trying to shock people,
you shouldn't be afraid to come to a conclusion
that might offend the puritanical dogmas of some social groups,
whoever those are.
And I'm not just talking about how
everything leftist poets write is offensive to the right,
and everything right-wing poets do is offensive to the left.
Creative unorthodoxy involves a deeper commitment of
not substituting aesthetic principles of taste for ideological allegiances.
The scholar Spencer Clavin wrote an excellent essay earlier this year about how
as art gets politicized,
like it has in our own age where everything has just become about red team versus blue team,
there is a tendency to exchange aesthetic commitments for political loyalties,
and praise someone's work because you agree with them on social issues,
rather than because their work is actually good.
If you want to produce work that actually stands a chance of being remembered in the future,
being creatively unorthodox involves a commitment to art above all other things.
Which isn't to say that you won't also have political opinions,
or shouldn't express political views through art,
because this is always going to be inevitable to a degree.
I'm not saying disconnect morality from art like Oscar Wilde advocated,
but don't let the politics overwhelm the art.
Express the moral views in an artful way.
And I would also say as a corollary of that,
just because you disagree with the politics behind someone's art,
don't necessarily dismiss the art itself.
It might still be good.
That's like refusing to watch the plays of George Bernard Shaw
just because he was a Fabian socialist.
That's stupid.
A true artist is able to inhabit multiple perspectives.
I've reflected on the question of why almost nobody writes good narrative poetry,
and while there are a lot of complex reasons for this,
I think one reason might be that
Very few artists today seem capable of creating characters
that convincingly hold perspectives the authors don't believe.
Conservative writers often refuse to engage with the problem of evil
in a convincing, non-satirical way, because it offends them.
While leftist writers will put viewpoints they don't believe into characters,
but then immediately denounce those viewpoints
through the mouthpiece of other characters.
Both sides are excessively moralizing,
and it gets in the way of telling a great story.
The opposite of creative unorthodoxy is, of course,
uncreative orthodoxy,
or cliché.
I spent a little bit of time last week making an Instagram account called
Sexy AI Poet,
in which I created posts of insta-poems written by ChatGPT,
coupled with AI images of sexy people.
With my whopping six posts and two followers,
it has yet to take off,
but who knows.
The point is that insta-poetry of the kind Rupi Kaur and others like her write,
can be written by ChatGPT now.
And what ChatGPT spits out is just as good as what Rupi Kaur can write.
And honestly, I think it can actually write much better than Rupi Kaur can write,
and I know this because I have seen it.
I would also say the same thing is true on the opposite side of the spectrum
regarding populist poetry of the kind a lot of conservative people like.
ChatGPT can write a poem in the style of Edgar Guest,
and you won't be able to tell the difference.
That is because both of these types of poetry rely on cliché
and don't really use any virtuosic imagery that make them unique.
Now, I know a lot of people like this stuff,
and I'm not saying don't write it.
When a poem is written by a person,
there is a meaningful quality behind it
that is obviously lacking in something written by a sophisticated algorithm.
But the point remains.
Nobody can tell the difference between a human and a robot when it comes to this verse.
If you like to write this kind of stuff and it keeps you sane,
and it has therapeutic value,
then all well and good.
I'm sure you won't stop on my account.
But don't have any illusions about what you're doing.
You, my friend, are obsolete.
Unless you're a beautiful woman like Rupi Kaur.
There's obviously a highly photogenic dimension to Rupi Kaur's success,
but if you're not photogenic enough to make sexy live appearances
that prove you're not a cloned AI avatar of yourself,
then you're obsolete.
So I would advise you, the aspiring poetic genius,
to shy away from writing the type of verse that can be written by a robot.
Creative unorthodoxy is about uniqueness.
The best poetry still cannot be written by AI,
so we're safe at least for the next few years.
But who knows, by 2030, we may all be obsolete.
Now, being a great artist is ultimately about having sound taste and judgment
in aesthetic matters.
And taste is simply not something that can be taught.
Either you have it or you don't.
If you have bad taste, that is,
if you like Rupi Kaur more than Shakespeare,
or if you have a compulsion to fill your house with
live, laugh, love wall art and binge the Hallmark channel,
then there's simply no helping you.
Puritans make horrible artists.
But where I can help you become a better poet
is by focusing on method.
And if you're writing poetry in English,
the most important aspect of developing discipline
is knowing how to write in iambic pentameter.
So, join me next time for a discussion of that.
Thank you.