A 17th Century Lord's Pumpkin Pudding Pie

Healthy food
929 followers
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTAVA explores the creation of a complex, historical pumpkin pie based on 17th and 18th-century recipes. Unlike modern versions, this dish combines savory herbs, fried egg batters, and layered apples, resulting in a unique, multi-textured dessert that blends sweet and savory elements in a way that mirrors early colonial cooking styles.
Have you ever run into a recipe that seems
so strange and convoluted that there's no way you
can imagine exactly how it's going to turn out until you make it?
That's this recipe today.
It's for a pumpkin pie, and we've all made any number of pumpkin pies.
We've made pumpkin pies
here on this channel, but this one is nothing like
the pumpkin pie you think of. I've got Ryan here
with me today because I think it's going to take both
our minds to put this together and make it
Into something edible.
17th century to 18th century cooking
is so wildly different.
It's almost like they haven't moved out
of medieval times quite yet.
And so, like looking at this,
it doesn't read anything like an 18th century recipe at all.
And it's like, I think that we're making
some kind of like pancake pie with apple slices.
And it's a pumpkin pie, but there's
not a ton of pumpkin in it, I don't think.
But it does have the quintessential ingredients
that pumpkin pies have to have.
It has to have pumpkin pie spices.
Right, but it has, like, these fresh herbs and pepper.
Along with them.
And some scrambled eggs.
It's a weird pie.
This is from The Complete Cook or The Queen's Closet Opened.
To make a pumpkin pie, take half a pound of pumpkin and slice it.
A handful of thyme, a little rosemary, parsley,
sweet marjoram, slipped off the stalks, and
chopped them small, then take cinnamon,
nutmeg, pepper, six cloves, and beat them.
Take 10 eggs and beat them, and then mix them,
and beat them all together.
That means the spices and the eggs.
Then we put in as much sugar as you will think fit,
and then you fry them like a foie.
After it is fried, let it stand till it be cold, then fill your pie.
Take sliced apples, thin, round ways.
Lay in a row of the foies.
Lay in a layer of apples with currants betwixt the layers
while your pie is fitted and put in a
good deal of sweet butter before you close it.
When the pie is baked, take six yolks of eggs,
some white wine, and make a caudle of this.
Not too thick. Cut up the lid, put it in,
stir it well together whilst the eggs
and the pumpkins be not perceived, and so serve it up.
This pumpkin pie is very complex.
Luckily, there is another version.
That is about 20 years later,
and this one is from the queen's like closet.
Huh?
Right?
Like it's related to the other one?
It's much shorter.
It says take pumpkin, pare it, cut it into thin slices,
dip it in beaten eggs and herbs, small, fry it to be enough,
and then lay it into a pie with butter, raisins, currants,
sugar, and sack, and in the bottom some sharp apples.
When it is baked, butter it and serve.
it in so there is our our truncated recipe it's like
a recipe that they took the other one and
said well how can we make this super short
and so it actually kind of cuts out some of the confusion
which is helpful here but i don't know
that it actually makes it easier we might go into it
thinking that we know what we're doing
and it's going to change but that's funny because when
you initially sent me this recipe
I'm like check this recipe out this is one of the craziest pie recipes
You only sent half of it?
Yeah.
You only sent half of it? I read it, I was like,
that seems like a pretty straightforward recipe.
And then the second page is where it gets really funky.
Basically, all we're going to use the second recipe
for is to help us interpret the first recipe.
And to get started with any of this,
we need to address the herbs and the spices.
And so what's going on with this is you kind of have all
of your Thanksgiving spices in this one pumpkin pie.
So pumpkin pie spices with the clove and the cinnamon and the nutmeg,
all of that's really classic, right, for a pumpkin pie.
and then we have basically turkey stuffing herbs
that are going to go in this too and so
i think what we're going to get is this super spiced
but also very kind of floral
and like fresh smelling pie
so we need to address the herbs first after we get those
all chopped and we get the spices we're going
to mix those up with all those eggs
and it's going to essentially be a batter
that we're going to put our pumpkin pieces in
You've got this mixed up and it looks great,
actually it smells really good, but the next
step is the pumpkin and it calls for it to be in thin slices.
Actually, the first recipe just says
cut it into slices, the second one tells us thin slices,
so we probably want it a quarter
inch thick or so. And I think the second one says to pare it
and I think we need to listen to that
too. Yeah, definitely. Usually you would just kind
of half this and for a pumpkin pie you
You would have this roasted and then it would make everything soft but
We're not doing that.
So I think we need to get rid of the skin.
Once we have our pumpkin sliced up nice and thin,
we have to figure out how to cook it, fry it with these eggs.
We could either dip it or we can sort of have the egg
and we put in the slices of pumpkin all the way around it.
Something like that.
Let's try it both ways and see what works.
I don't know.
Because one way, I think if you make it kind of like an omelet.
Yeah.
That when you bring it out,
you're going to have to cut around the pieces of pumpkin and flip it.
And then...
It looks like they want chips, like the apple slices are in chips.
So I think that that's the goal,
and we're just going to see what is the best way to get there.
We tried dipping the chunks.
It just didn't look like it was going to work.
We wouldn't have been able to use up hardly any of the eggs.
I went ahead and put some butter in the pan,
and I just put in the pumpkin slices by themselves,
let them warm up just a touch.
I didn't want them to go in cold.
And then I basically just poured the whole egg mixture all around them
and made this omelet, which is kind of like what it's supposed to do.
And guess what?
It looks like a horrible mess, but it smells great.
It does, yeah.
I think it's close to what they want.
We're going to find out.
Yeah, this is going to go in the pie.
We've got our apple sliced up nice and thin.
You want to make sure to pare off all
of the skin and just slice them around.
The pie crust is ready, and it's just a typical pie crust
with almost equal measures of butter
and flour with a little bit of water here.
This one fought me a little bit, but I just patched it together.
Now it's time to put it together,
and the recipes are sort of opposite each other.
One puts the bottom layer of apples,
and the other one says put the pumpkin in the bottom.
We're going to put the pumpkin mixture.
into the bottom and then layer in as we go.
So how are we going to get a nice thin layer?
I think what we're going to try
to do is cut it into individual little pieces
and kind of layer that in like we're going to layer the apples in.
And we want to make sure, I know it seems kind
of weird with this egg mixture.
It's like there's pumpkin, then there's scrambled egg,
but the egg mixture is where all the spices is.
So it's like the carrying component for all of the flavors.
So you need to make sure to get that in there.
Let's layer this pie, put in the pumpkin.
Pieces in the bottom and you'll kind of have to move it around
and fit it into a nice flat layer.
Now, let's put in a few currants and then apple slices
and then we go with another layer of pumpkin.
These are very thin apple slices. We don't want them to fight
this whole pie and make it so it's hard to cut apart.
After we get all those multiple layers on that fills your pie pan,
we can put the lid on and then make sure to press all the air out.
Let's crimp it and then put in some vent marks
or vent holes in the top so it doesn't puff up.
Now you can bake this.
And we are going to bake this about 45 minutes at about 375.
Our pie is in the oven.
Right now it's time to work on the sauce.
They call it a coddle.
Thank you.
Thank you.
It almost reads like a pudding sauce to me,
we're taking egg yolks and we're taking wine
and we're just going to slowly heat that up
and thicken it until it's a nice custardy
type sauce that's going to go inside
the pie once the pie comes out of the oven.
For starters we're just going to kind of feel
this out a little bit but I know that it takes
six egg yolks. I've got about a jill
which is about four ounces of white wine that I'm going
to mix in with that and I'll probably just mix it
in slowly to see where the consistency is.
I don't know if I'll use the whole thing.
It's interesting putting the sauce onto the pie.
I was very confused by the directions but it says something about
do this or stir it in until the pumpkins are not perceived
which I think possibly means
Put this on over the top so you can't see the pumpkins.
Right?
And it's interesting how like it,
it didn't seem this thick when it went in
and then it just thickened up.
So it really does coat the whole top of it.
In fact, I, at first I was only using half
of that jill of wine and then it got thick.
All of a sudden I added the rest in
to try to loosen the sauce up a little bit.
Right.
We have no idea how this is going to taste,
but it really smells great.
Okay. So just right up front, this smells great,
I'm concerned, and you were concerned,
about the texture of the eggs and how that's going to work.
The eggs are the only thing I'm worried about.
It's like, why would they fry it? I don't know.
So let's try it out.
All right.
Hold on. I'm not sure.
I'm looking for...
Well, what I can tell you is, this is not your average pumpkin pie.
It's so complex. It's got so many different components,
so many different textures, and so many different...
I just got a big piece of pumpkin.
And so then it was like, oh, yeah, I'm eating a pumpkin pie.
But you really kind of have to look for it.
Find it, yeah.
None of the herbs come through for me.
No?
Not one.
I probably put more herbs than I did spices.
There's nothing bad about it.
But it has so much going on that you can't,
like, take any single bite and say,
oh, here's that particular ingredient.
Is it a mincemeat pie without meat?
Yeah.
Well, it's spiced like that, too.
With the raisins?
I don't really think the sauce gives us anything.
I think it's kind of like...
You just concentrate on that
because there's so much wine flavor in it.
Yeah, some things are just meant for looks
in this time period.
And that could be, they're like, this is ugly.
Let's cover it up.
I don't know.
The most worrisome part of it was the scrambled eggs
and that doesn't throw me at all.
This was an incredible cooking experiment.
You never know what you're going to get
when you dig into some of these recipes.
They look complicated and this one certainly is.
And I'm not sure exactly what this is.
I might have to eat the whole pie to find out.
But that's all right.
These experiments are worth doing.
I encourage you to get out there
and do some of these cooking experiments.
You will love it.
