Full: https://www.ganjingworld.com/s/Gwe2gmmE0k Ebook: http://e.pc.cd/O32y6alK ----- Preface Introduction Chapter One: The Specter’s Strategies for Destroying Humanity Chapter Two: Communism’s European Beginnings Chapter Three: Tyranny in the East Chapter Four: Exporting Revolution Chapter Five, Part I: Infiltrating the West Chapter Five, Part II: Infiltrating the West Chapter Six: The Revolt Against God Chapter Seven, Part I: The Destruction of the Family Chapter Seven, Part II: The Destruction of the Family Chapter Eight, Part I: How Communism Sows Chaos in Politics Chapter Eight, Part II: How Communism Sows Chaos in Politics Chapter Nine, Part I: The Communist Economic Trap Chapter Nine, Part II: The Communist Economic Trap Chapter Ten: Corrupting the Legal System Chapter Eleven: Desecrating the Arts Chapter Twelve, Part I: Sabotaging Education Chapter Twelve, Part II: Sabotaging Education Chapter Thirteen: The Media — The Specter’s Mouthpiece Chapter Fourteen: Popular Culture – A Decadent Indulgence Chapter Fifteen: The Communist Roots of Terrorism Chapter Sixteen, Part I: The Communism Behind Environmentalism Chapter Sixteen, Part II: The Communism Behind Environmentalism Chapter Seventeen: Globalization and Communism Chapter Eighteen, Part I: The Chinese Communist Party’s Global Ambitions Chapter Eighteen, Part II: The Chinese Communist Party’s Global Ambitions Conclusion: How the Specter of Communism Is Ruling Our World ----- ntd.com
You're listening to the audiobook of How the Specter of Communism
is Ruling Our World. Written by the editorial team of the Epoch Times groundbreaking series,
Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party.
Chapter 9 The Communist Economic Trap Part 1
Introduction
Over 150 years ago, Karl Marx published Das Kapital, advocating the abolition of private
property and its replacement by public ownership. A century later, communist public ownership was
being implemented across one-third of the world's nations. After the disintegration of the Soviet
Bloc in 1990, many Eastern European countries underwent shock therapy to return to market
economics. Other countries, not ruled by communist parties, but which had nevertheless
embraced socialist nationalization and endured the misery and poverty of public ownership,
ultimately had no choice but to introduce market reforms. To achieve global domination,
the specter of communism launched offensives worldwide. Looking at those countries that
abandoned communism or the socialist economic model, one would think that the specter had
failed in its goals. But the reality isn't so simple. The communist specter does not follow
a fixed set of principles. Instead, its methods and forms are constantly shifting to fit the
situation. It may abandon or criticize its previous actions for the sake of the greater
objective. Nowhere is this truer than in the economic sphere. Upon careful analysis of our
present economic system and the reality behind it, one cannot help but discover how the communist
specter has spread its tendrils to every corner. As wishful schemes and blind worship of government
abound, the economy of virtually every country on earth is moving away from the principles of the
free market. Nations are losing their moral foundations and gravitating toward communism.
It is time that we wake up to this reality and take measures against it.
1. Developed Western Countries, Practicing Communism by Another Name
In the Communist Manifesto, Marx wrote that communist theory can be summarized in one
sentence, abolish the system of private ownership. For individuals, this implies the
abolition of bourgeois individuality, bourgeois independence, and bourgeois freedom. For society,
it meant that, quote, the proletariat will use its political supremacy to seize, by degree,
all capital from the bourgeoisie to centralize all instruments of production in the hands of
the state, i.e., of the proletariat organized as the ruling class. To achieve this objective,
communists used violence and mass murder in communist countries. But as violent communism
lost its appeal, nonviolent forms were devised. These variant strains of socialism infiltrated
all of society to the extent that they are difficult to identify. Western countries are
using many economic policies that don't appear to bear any relation to socialism either in name or
form, yet they play the roles of restricting, weakening, or depriving people of the right
to private property. Others weaken the mechanics of free enterprise, expand government power,
and lead society further down the road toward socialism. Methods include high taxation,
generous social welfare, and aggressive state interventionism.
A. High Taxes and Generous Social Welfare
An important feature of communist or socialist economics in western countries is robust social
welfare. Current social welfare policies make people who came from communist countries feel
as though they have simply moved to another socialist state. Undercover socialism. The
government itself doesn't generate value. Rather, it's like shearing wool from a sheep.
All social benefits are ultimately paid for by the people, via taxes or national debt. A high
degree of welfare itself is a kind of communism, just without the violent revolution practiced by
communist parties. High taxation is the forcible nationalization of private assets for redistribution
on a large scale. At the same time, it is a hidden path to gradually phasing out the system
of private ownership. The end result of high taxation is the same as public ownership and
egalitarianism imposed by communist regimes, with the only difference being whether nationalization
comes into play before or after production. In communist planned economies, production materials
are directly controlled by the state. In the West, production is controlled privately,
but the revenue is converted into state assets via taxes and redistribution schemes. Either way,
it is equivalent to the robbery and plunder of others' wealth. In western countries,
rather than through killing and violence, this was achieved legally through democracy and
legislation. Some government aid is reasonable, such as social security for victims of disasters
or accidents, but the positive aspects of welfare make it a convenient instrument of deception,
and it becomes the excuse needed to increase taxes. In this regard, generous social welfare
has already achieved the same destructive consequences as communist economics for the
By nature, communist economics brings out the dark side of human nature.
This is the root cause of why the specter is pushing communist economic values around the
world, whether in free societies or in those directly controlled by communist regimes.
Social welfare developed in western countries consumes a large portion of fiscal revenue,
which comes from taxes transferred from private wealth. There is no other way
to maintain this bountiful level of government money. In the United States, more than half of
tax revenue is spent on social security and medical care. More than 80% of this money
comes from personal income taxes and social security taxes. 11% is from corporate tax.
Many western countries go even further than the United States, given their more comprehensive
welfare systems. According to 2016 data on 35 market economies published by the Organization
for Economic Cooperation and Development, OECD, 27 countries had an income tax rate of over 30%.
The countries with the two highest income taxes, at 54 and 49.4%, were both in Europe.
On top of this, eating or shopping in many parts of Europe comes with a value-added tax as high as
20% in some places. Corporate taxes and other taxes further add to the overall rate. Other data
showed that in 1900, only 7 of the 15 countries for that year imposed an income tax, with Italy
leading at a rate of 10%. Australia, Japan, and New Zealand had income tax rates of about 5%.
But by 1950, the average maximum tax rate across 20 countries was over 60%. Today,
it has slowly fallen to around 40%. High taxation burdens not only the wealthy. The poor are also
penalized in various ways. While the rich often have various legal means of shielding themselves
from taxes, welfare benefits afforded to the poor disappear as their income increases beyond a
certain threshold. In short, people are being penalized for working harder. High welfare.
In 1942, the British economist William Beveridge advocated the welfare state,
a plan, quote, all-embracing in scope of persons and of needs. In modern society,
the high welfare system has been expanded to cover unemployment, medical care, pensions,
occupational injury, housing, education, child care, and the like, far beyond traditional
concepts of charity for those in immediate need of aid. A report from the Heritage Foundation
showed that in 2013, more than 100 million people in the United States, or about a third of the
population, received welfare benefits, excluding Social Security and Medicare, worth an average of
$9,000 per person. According to statistics collected by the U.S. Census Bureau, about
12.7% of the population was living under the poverty line in 2016. Yet their living conditions
may come as a surprise to many. According to government surveys, 96% of parents in impoverished
households said that their children had never been hungry. Almost 50% of impoverished households
lived in detached houses, and 40% lived in townhouses. Just 9% lived in mobile homes.
80% had air conditioning, and two-fifths owned widescreen LCD TVs. Three-quarters of impoverished
households owned cars. The deliberate categorization of large numbers of people into the,
quote, impoverished demographic provides a sufficient excuse for the expansion of welfare.
Benefits provided by the U.S. government are below average compared with members of the
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. Most people living in Nordic
countries and other Western European nations enjoy far greater welfare than Americans.
In Denmark, for example, even the wealthiest citizens enjoy a cradle-to-grave social safety
net that includes free medical care, university education, and other generous benefits.
Prior to their country's economic collapse, Greeks enjoyed an annual 14-month salary,
retirement at the age of 61, and a pension equivalent to over 90% of their salary.
Swedes are entitled to 550 days of continuous sick leave and other benefits. The expansion
of welfare from its traditional role of emergency charity to constant benefits for the entire
population is, in fact, part of the specter's scheme to impose a communist economy. Social
benefits. Spreading corruption and intensifying contradictions between rich and poor. From an
economic point of view, the essence of welfare is to take money from some people and transfer
its value to others. However, it is the government that is responsible for distributing the wealth,
thus de-emphasizing the wisdom that one must work in order to gain.
The loss of this moral principle is particularly evident in Northern Europe.
Swedish scholar Nima Sanandaji demonstrated this point using data from the World Value Survey.
In the early 1980s, 82% of Swedes and 80% of Norwegians agreed with the statement that,
By the time of surveys respectively taken in Norway and Sweden in 2005 and 2008,
only 56% of Norwegians and 61% of Swedes agreed with this statement. Under a generous welfare
system, those who work hard receive fewer returns, and those who are less industrious
are rewarded with benefits. Over time, this subtly distorts moral traditions,
as those who grew up with high government welfare lose the industriousness, independence,
responsibility, and diligence of their forefathers. They take the system for granted,
and even consider welfare to be a human right. They have formed a habit of relying on the
government and even holding it hostage for continuous aid. Social values have changed
almost irreversibly, and like boiling frogs slowly, communism's use of high amounts of
welfare erodes moral wisdom. High government welfare also squeezes out the role of traditional
charities, depriving both the donors of the opportunity to do good works and the beneficiaries
of the chance to feel gratitude. In traditional society, charity was done by one's own choice,
either by directly aiding the less fortunate or by donating to charitable organizations
such as churches. There were definite donors and recipients, and being able to receive assistance
was a privilege, not a right. Recipients felt gratitude for the donor's kindness
and would be motivated to use the charity to supplement their own efforts to improve their lot.
Those who received charity and turned their lives around would be likely to return the
when others confronted the same challenges they once faced. French thinker Alex de Tocqueville
noted that charity combines the virtues of generosity and gratitude, which interact
mutually to improve society and exert a positive moral influence. Meanwhile, the relationship
between givers and receivers functioned to ease conflicts and antagonism between rich and poor
as charitable behavior on the part of individuals, connected members of different economic classes.
The bloated system of modern welfare alienates donors and recipients by bureaucratizing the
process of charity. The donors of today are taxpayers who are forced to give up their wealth
rather than sharing it voluntarily. Meanwhile, recipients of welfare have no connection to
their benefactors and feel no gratitude for their sacrifice. De Tocqueville believed that social
welfare worsened conflicts between the rich and the poor. Having part of their wealth forcibly
confiscated, the wealthy would come to resent the class of welfare recipients. De Tocqueville said
that the poor, too, would continue to feel discontent since they would take their economic
relief for granted. Quote, one class still views the world with fear and loathing while the other
regards its misfortune with despair and envy. Bloated welfare also becomes a point of jealousy
and political conflict that communism uses to destroy people's moral and social harmony.
This has been observed in the Greek economic crisis. Rather than a conflict between rich and
poor, the struggle is between the middle and upper classes. Among the latter, tax evasion has become
a national sport, according to Greek officials cited by The Economist. At the same time, so as
not to upset its constituents, the Greek government has relied on taking loans to offset diminishing
tax revenue and maintain the same level of welfare found in other European countries.
In the aftermath of the economic crisis, the Greek government attempted to cut back on social
welfare, only to meet with staunch resistance from the general population. The people set their
sights on the wealthy and demanded that they pay even higher taxes, creating a headache for the
government that has yet to be resolved. The welfare system erodes the traditional work ethic
and makes people feel entitled to that which they did not earn. As industriousness is punished,
the entire economy suffers. In 2010, a practical study by Martin Halle, Mario Lackner, and Friedrich
G. Schneider produced data showing that social welfare disincentivizes hard work in the long term,
and such a result will not be shown until a long period of time later.
The three economists concluded that the dynamics of the welfare state
are harmful to the health of a nation's economic base.
The Culture of Poverty
In 2012, The New York Times ran a feature article titled,
Profiting from a Child's Illiteracy, in which it described the impact of welfare policy on
low-income families living in the Appalachian Mountain region in the eastern United States.
The feature described how impoverished families gave up sending their children to school
in order to qualify for aid. Quote,
Moms and dads fear that if kids learn to read, they are less likely to qualify for a monthly check
for having an intellectual disability, the article states. Quote,
Many people in hillside mobile homes here are poor and desperate, and a $690 monthly check
per child from the Supplemental Security Income Program goes a long way, and those
checks continue until the child turns 18. This aid program was begun about 40 years ago
with the goal of helping families raising physically or mentally challenged children.
By the time The New York Times reported on the subject, over 55 percent of qualifying children
were categorized as mentally challenged, but did not have any defined condition.
Across the United States, there are now a total of around 1.2 million, quote,
mentally challenged children for whose care taxpayers provide $9 billion annually.
Here, welfare and the flaws of human nature feed each other in a vicious cycle. Despite
the good intentions of those who advocate and make welfare policy, it indirectly aided
the communist specter in its goal of bringing down and destroying humanity.
Over a century ago, de Tocqueville made the observation that welfare programs do not
discriminate among individuals, only poverty thresholds. This makes it hard to allocate aid
efficiently, since it is impossible to know whether the qualified individuals are actually
suffering from circumstances beyond their control or if their misfortune is of their own making.
Welfare abuse doesn't just tie down public finances. It also affects the futures of children
who grow up under its system. Research conducted in 2009 found that two-thirds of people who
received welfare as children continued to receive it into adulthood and possibly would
remain on welfare for the rest of their lives. As a matter of election strategy, the term
disability is being continually refined to include an ever-expanding part of the population
in the ranks of those eligible for welfare. The criteria determining who is entitled to
welfare creates an atmosphere of negative reinforcement that encourages the misuse of
these benefits. The loss of social morality and economic angst help the communist specter
achieve its aims. Welfare is an emergency measure to assist those in genuine need,
effective in circumstances such as those involving occupational accidents, epidemics,
natural disasters, and so on. It shouldn't become the default form of subsistence,
as it is incapable of resolving the dilemma of poverty. As of 2014, in the 50 years since
President Lyndon B. Johnson launched his war on poverty, American taxpayers spent 2.2 trillion
dollars to pay for welfare. Yet as statistics from the U.S. Census Bureau show, the poverty
rate has remained steady for the last 40 years. According to American economist William Arthur
Niskanen, the welfare system spawned a culture of poverty, which in turn feeds a vicious cycle
of dependence on government aid, extramarital children, violent crime, unemployment, and
abortion. His analysis of U.S.-wide data for the year 1992 produced estimates on the effects that
could be expected from increasing aid to families with dependent children, AFDC. Increasing AFDC
benefits by 1% of the average per capita income resulted in a 3% increase in AFDC recipients.
The number of people in poverty would increase by about 0.8%, births to single mothers would
increase by about 2.1%, and the number of unemployed adults would increase by about 0.5%.
Abortions and violent crime would become more common as well. Niskanen's findings suggest that
a robust welfare system fosters dependence on the system and discourages personal responsibility.
The disintegration of families is a chief ingredient in the culture of poverty. In a study
of historical and contemporary poverty among Blacks, economist Walter E. Williams found that 85%
of impoverished Black children lived with teenage single mothers. The welfare system promotes this
as it encourages single mothers to live without taking responsibility for their actions.
They can get a variety of subsidies like housing subsidies, food stamps, and the like from government
welfare. Welfare has been instrumental in pushing single parenthood, causing more poverty. Despite
the fact that welfare has been expanding in the last few decades, the gap between rich and poor
has been continuously increasing as well. The average wage adjusted for inflation increases
at a snail's pace, while wealth flows to the wealthiest. A class of working poor has emerged.
Armed with these societal issues, the left wing pushes for a bigger government, higher taxation,
and more welfare to combat poverty by exacerbating it further. The left's use of welfare policy to
Left-wing politicians often promote more welfare and higher taxes.
Using a variety of election slogans to convince voters of their noble intent,
they portray themselves as possessing the moral high ground, even though these politicians are
not the ones who will be providing the welfare. Their method is merely to seize the wealth of
the upper and middle classes and distribute it among the poor. Since the system conceals
the relationship between donor and recipient, the politicians nevertheless claim to have
played a crucial role in the process. They receive the recipient's gratitude in the form of votes.
b. Aggressive Economic Interventionism in Western Countries
State Intervention
At present, governments in the free world are already practicing heavy interventionism
in their national economic systems. One cause of this was the welfare politics,
developed under the socialist influence, which expanded the state's role in wealth distribution.
Another impulse for this trend was the Great Depression of the 1930s. Following the crisis,
Western society was deeply influenced by the theories of Keynesian economics,
which advocates active state intervention and regulation of the economy by using finance.
In a normal society, the government's role is limited. Only in exceptional situations should
the state interfere in the economy, such as during times of natural disaster or some other crisis.
But today, Keynesian theory has taken hold around the world. Governments of all countries are racing
to take greater control over their respective economies. When the government plays an active
role in the economy, each action has a massive ripple effect on the market. New policies and
laws can make or break entire industries, making many businesses and investors reliant on the
government's decisions. The state, which traditionally only passed and enforced laws,
has now become a leading participant in the economic arena. Like a referee joining a soccer
match, the state has become responsible for controlling and regulating capital and what
used to be the privately owned economy, replacing the invisible hand with its visible hand.
Active financial control, combined with high welfare policies, has caused many governments
to incur huge debts. According to data from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and
Development, OECD, more than half of its member states have government debts near or over 100%
of GDP. Some countries' debt exceeded 200% of their economic output. This presents a major
vulnerability for the social and economic future of many countries. Nobel Prize-winning economist
Ronald Coase wrote multiple research papers on the impact of government intervention.
In his work, Coase found that interventionist policy almost always produces negative results.
He believes that the crisis of intervention has reached the point of diminishing marginal returns.
Despite this, the governments of all countries have only become more active in their manipulation
of the economy, bringing it more and more under the control of the state. The consequences and
reality of interventionism. There are at least two major consequences of extensive state intervention.
First, the power of the state expands in terms of its role and scale. Government officials develop
increasing arrogance about their ability to interfere with the economy and have the state
play the role of a savior. After handling a crisis, the government is used to holding on to its
expanded powers and functions. Second, interventionism creates more reliance on the government.
When the people encounter challenges or when the free market cannot provide the benefits they
desire, they will lobby in favor of more state intervention to satisfy their demands. As the
power of the state increases, private enterprise weakens and the free market has less space in
which to function. People who have benefited from and grown dependent on politicians will
increasingly demand that the government take responsibility for allocating wealth and enact
laws to enforce this. In the West, there is a strong political current pushing society toward
the left. This includes followers of the original left wing, including socialists and communists,
as well as those not traditionally associated with the left wing, but who have been co-opted by them.
The convergence of these disparate forces encourages the government to take greater
measures to intervene in the economy and interfere with the functioning of private enterprises.
This erosion of normal economic activity appears to be caused by various social movements,
but in fact, it is the specter of communism that pulls the strings. It can be seen that
Western governments wield their public authority under the banner of equality and other political
excuses to increase intervention and are even enacting laws to make this the permanent state
of affairs. There is no doubt that this behavior deprives market economies of their main authority
figure, the free will of the people. The state is essentially expanding its authority over the free
market to turn it into a command economy. The long-term implications are that all aspects of
the economy and popular livelihood will come under public control. Economic means will be used to
consolidate political power, enslaving society and its citizens. Using policy that looks kind on the surface,
but progressively tilts the economic structure toward centralism, the specter is gradually
leading humanity into full communism. C. Socialist economics leads to communist totalitarianism.
High taxes, high welfare, and widespread state intervention are manifestations of socialism
within the Western capitalist system. Thus, socialism shares the same principled nature
of planned economics as both use the authority of the state to manipulate the economy. The underlying
article of faith here is in the omnipotence of the government, which is allowed to play god.
As things stand, the only difference between heavy state interventionism in the West and the
planned economies of communist countries is that in free countries, the law and some basic aspects
of the capitalist system protect human rights from total government control. Friedrich Hayek,
the prominent Austrian economist and philosopher, cautioned against state-controlled planning and
wealth redistribution, saying that it would inevitably tamper with the market and lead to
the rise of totalitarianism, regardless of whether the system was democratic or not.
Hayek believed that although the socialism practiced in Europe and North America was
different from public ownership and planned economics, it would nevertheless come to the
same result. People would lose their freedom and livelihood just in a slower and more indirect
fashion. As has been discussed earlier in this book, Marx, Engels, and Lenin all saw socialism
as a mandatory step on the path to communism. A train's movement towards its destination will not
be affected by it stopping at a station platform along the way. Likewise, the specter of communism
is the driving force behind a country that is moving towards socialism. Once humanity forsakes
tradition, whether in the economic sphere or in other areas, and accepts communist ideology,
the pace of development is irrelevant. Sooner or later, the destination will be reached.
The destination at the end of this path is not heaven on earth, but the destruction of humanity.
In fact, the devil is not concerned with whether heaven is realized or not, as it is merely a bait
to lure people to their doom. 2. The Dystopian Socialism of the Chinese Communist Party
After public ownership and the planned economy reduced China to poverty, the CCP was compelled
to embark on a process of, quote, reform and opening up, by which it introduced elements
of the free market into Chinese society. Many believe that the party has become capitalist,
but this is far from the truth. A. The Chinese Economy, No Relaxation of Communist Control
Based on its knowledge, the CCP liberalized some aspects of the Chinese economy,
such as allowing private business. But this does not mean that the communists have loosened their
grip. On the contrary, economic reform was the strategy they used to continue their power and
deceive the world. The Chinese communist model is a monstrous combination of socialism, controlling
social and economic affairs, and market economics. Although private enterprises exist, the CCP has
never promised the people any fundamental right to private property. All resources and land remain
ultimately at the party's disposal. At the same time, the CCP uses the state to impose strict
controls on economic matters. It still implements large-scale national planning in what should be
considered an economy of power. The market is only a means used by the state to stimulate
production. It is not truly independent, and neither are there institutions in place to support
a free market. The spirit of the law is absent, and there is no clear system of property rights.
The exchange rate is not allowed to adjust itself naturally. The flow of wealth in and
out of the country is restricted, and international firms are tightly controlled.
The CCP uses government subsidies and export tax rebates to boost exports with the aim of
defeating competitors with a price race. It has disrupted the normal order of world trade.
In China, all economic activity is geared toward the fulfillment of political needs. The economic
freedoms of enterprises and individuals are subordinate to the whims of the state and can be
revoked at any time. It is precisely for these reasons that the World Trade Organization has
long refused to acknowledge China as a market economy. Many in Western governments harbored
the naive hope that economic development would bring political liberalization and democracy to
China. Instead, China's public capitalism was used to nourish the socialist organism, reinvigorate
the party's leadership, and continue along an evil path. With greater financial means,
the CCP subjected the people to more brutal and sophisticated forms of repression.
In July 1999, the regime started the persecution of Falun Gong, targeting its 100 million
practitioners. This war against the universal principles of truthfulness, compassion, and
tolerance continues to this day. Since 2009, the CCP has spent over 500 billion yuan,
$75 billion, annually to cover the costs of, quote, maintaining stability,
that is, policing the Chinese population. B. The Truth Behind China's Economic Rise
Because of China's rapid GDP growth over the last 40 years, many have come to believe in
the superiority of socialist economics. It has made many Westerners, including elites in political
and academic circles, as well as think tanks, marvel at the efficiency of the totalitarian
system. In fact, the economic model the CCP has built cannot be duplicated. On the one hand,
the reasons for its economic rise demonstrate the internal instability of the socialist system.
On the other, the party's model foreshadows an abundance of vices created by its unprincipled
economy of power. China's economic growth in the past 40 years draws in large part
from the following factors. First, the relaxation of the state-owned economy
and the abandonment of central planning, as well as the revitalization of the private sector,
have given the Chinese economy a powerful productive drive. Chinese people are hard-working
and intelligent, but the party hindered their industrious potential for decades.
A desire to alleviate themselves of poverty has rekindled the motivation to do business
and unleashed the tremendous economic power of the Chinese. A second factor was the massive
influx of Western capital and technology into China during the reform era. Under the command
economy, China's vast expanses of underutilized land, labor, and markets were like gold for which
prices were not yet determined. The combination of capital investment and underdeveloped resources
ignited the blaze of China's economic growth. Had it not been for the party's totalitarian rule,
this fire could have started decades earlier and in a much more controllable and sustainable
fashion. The scale of Western investment in China is immense. According to published figures,
direct American investment in China reached nearly 800 billion dollars between 2000 and 2016.
The total value of foreign capital entering China from 1979 to 2015 amounted to about 1.64 trillion
dollars. Western countries even gave the Chinese regime preferential trade status along with broad
In May 2000, the U.S. government granted China Permanent Normal Trade Relations,
PNTR. On December 11, 2001, China formally entered the World Trade Organization, WTO,
and joined the international market. The CCP developed its economic power using unethical
models of development. Among these are the use of sweatshop labor, the extreme exploitation of
workers and peasants, the violent demolition of housing and relocation of the occupants,
and the like. For the sake of short-term growth, the CCP ignored environmental destruction and
other hazards in order to squeeze every last drop of profit from its land, people, and resources.
The Communist Party took advantage of Western capital, technology, markets, favorable trade
status, and cheap domestic production costs to make vast sums in foreign reserves. The trade
deficit between the United States and China rose from about 80 billion in 2000 to over 375 billion
in 2017. Finally, the CCP overturned the conventions of international trade and took
full advantage of the opportunities available to it regardless of their legitimacy. It adopted
the nationwide strategy of plagiarizing intellectual property in an attempt to overtake
other countries in terms of industry and technology. This constitutes the biggest case of theft in all
of history. The 2017 report by the Commission on the Theft of American Intellectual Property
stated that China's fake goods, pirated software, and stolen trade secrets caused the United States
a loss of between $225 billion and $600 billion every year, a figure that does not include losses
due to the theft of intellectual property. The report stated that over the past three years,
$1.2 trillion was lost due to intellectual theft, the majority of which was from China.
A report by the Director's Office of National Intelligence Service states that 90% of cyber
attacks on U.S. businesses come from the Chinese government and inflict an estimated $400 billion
in total economic damage every year. China's economic growth was fueled by the relaxation
of socialist ideology, investment from advanced Western countries, and the CCP's immoral business
conduct. In no way does this indicate the superiority of socialism, nor that the party
is developing along a normal capitalist path. Western observers sometimes describe Communist
China's unprincipled business model as, quote, state capitalism. This is giving the party undue
praise. Under the CCP's totalitarian rule, the economy is merely a political instrument. The
window dressing of market economics is a superficiality the CCP uses to deceive the world.
The CCP's economic model utilizes state authority to induce rapid economic development while
employing underhanded tricks to be competitive. It has encouraged other countries to adopt heavier
state intervention. These countries have made the grave mistake of idolizing the party's model
as a success while ignoring its human and moral tragedies.
c. Consequences of the Chinese Economic Model
The CCP's economic model has put society in moral freefall, exactly in line with the
Communist Specter's aim of destroying humankind. The party's economic power goes hand-in-hand
with the erosion of morality as it drags people into a bottomless sea of indulgence
and toward eventual annihilation. Today's China is inundated with fake goods, poisonous food,
pornography, drugs, gambling, and gangs. Corruption and prostitution have become
achievements to take pride in, while social trust is virtually non-existent. The widening
gap between rich and poor is accompanied by social strife and abuse of justice. Citizens
turn a blind eye to the suffering of their compatriots. In the economy of power,
party officials use their authority to amass wealth. The enormity of corruption increases
with rank. The misappropriation of billions is a normal occurrence. There is no government as
corrupt or morally degenerate as the Chinese Communist regime. In October 2011, the world
was shocked by the death of Yue Yue, a two-year-old girl in Guangdong province who was hit
by a truck. Instead of getting out to help, the driver put his truck in reverse to crush Yue Yue
again and ensure that she was dead. During the tragedy, 18 people walked by without stopping,
and Yue Yue later died in the hospital. International media wondered if China had
lost its soul. It might be understandable that people are reluctant to come to the
aid of others when there is danger involved, such as in an armed robbery. Yet Yue Yue did
not pose any conceivable threat to anyone as she lay dying beneath the heartless driver's tires.
Chinese society has hit rock bottom. Economic growth without morality is chaotic, brief,
and disastrous. Under the inhumane policies of the CCP, social conflict abounds, and the
environment is on the verge of collapse. The consequences of moral decay are fatal.
China calls itself a strong country, but its strength is an illusion. Its superficial prosperity,
built on the reckless pursuit of wealth, is doomed to collapse in the convergence of moral crisis
and social conflict. There is no good future in store for China if it cannot escape the devil's
snares. The specter of communism has no intention of implementing healthy and sustainable growth,
as its goal is to destroy China. 3. The Ravages of Socialism in the
Developing World. A. Socialism continues to haunt Eastern Europe.
In the world today, developed Western countries engage in hidden socialism,
and the Chinese Communist Party has imposed an authoritarian socialist monstrosity.
In Eastern Europe, communism continues to haunt the region, as there has not been a full reckoning
of the crimes committed by the former Soviet bloc regimes. The lingering presence of communism can
be seen in various facets of Eastern European politics and economics. For example, Russia and
Belarus retain powerful state-owned enterprises, high welfare, and aggressively interventionist
policies. During the transitional period from communism, Eastern European countries experienced
crises of slow economic growth and high unemployment. All this encouraged the relapse of
communism and socialism in new forms. The ghost of communism has not been banished. Left-wing
parties were animated with renewed vigor, feeding off a sense of nostalgia for the socialist past.
B. Socialist Economics Failed the Developing Nations. In the developing nations of Asia,
Africa, and Latin America, many newly independent countries had declared their allegiance to
socialism by the 1960s. The aftermath has been nothing short of a mess. More recent cases
include Venezuela and Zimbabwe. Venezuela was once the richest country in Latin America,
since socialism drove its economy to collapse. Venezuela has been rife with poverty, crime,
and starvation. Zimbabwe was once the richest country in Africa. Today, it has sunk into
complete catastrophe, as inflation has spiraled beyond imagination. Venezuela, How Socialism
Bankrupted a Prosperous Country. Venezuela is blessed with considerable oil reserves.
In the 1970s, it was the fastest-growing country in Latin America, enjoying the lowest level of
income inequality and the highest per capita GDP in the region. Venezuela's relatively free
economy attracted skilled immigrants from Italy, Portugal, and Spain. Together with the protection
of property rights, these factors enabled the nation's economy to grow rapidly from 1940 to
1970. After the new president came into office in 1999, he embarked on an ill-fated program of
nationalization that eventually threw the Venezuelan economy into chaos. The president
had publicly declared that he would engage in quote 21st century socialism. To build socialism,
the Venezuelan government requisitioned or nationalized many private companies
across industries including oil, agriculture, finance, heavy industry, steel, telecommunications,
energy, transportation, and tourist enterprises. This process was ramped up following the
president's 2007 re-election. His government expropriated 1,147 private companies between 2007
and 2012 with catastrophic effects. Companies in once-productive industries were shut down
and replaced by inefficient state-owned enterprises, scaring off investors. As production
sank, Venezuela turned to heavy reliance on imports. Coupled with a series of government
interventions involving foreign reserves and price controls, disaster inevitably struck when the price
of oil dropped. Some attributed this tragedy to the oil crisis, but the reasons for Venezuela's
dramatic failure are not to be found there. According to data provided by the World Bank,
seven countries that relied even more heavily on oil exports than Venezuela does
still experienced economic growth from 2013 to 2017. The root of the problem lies in the socialist
economic system. Venezuela's economic policy essentially marched to the tune of the 10
revolutionary demands Marx proposed in the Communist Manifesto. Venezuela met its economic fate
at the hands of the communist specter, Zimbabwe, from breadbasket of Africa to land of famine.
After Zimbabwe's declaration of independence in 1980, it endeavored to build a socialist state
according to Marxist-Leninist principles. Its first president had been a Marxist believer in
his youth. His guerrillas, guided by Mao Zedong thought, received unconditional assistance from
the Chinese Communist Party and maintained a relationship with China. Unlike other African
countries that implemented socialism, Zimbabwe did not immediately impose nationalization policies.
Zimbabwe's economic woes began in 2000 following the start of land reform.
Under the reform program, land belonging to white farmers was seized and redistributed.
The result was a sharp decline in agricultural productivity. In an attempt to evade the crisis,
Zimbabwe's central bank printed more money, leading to endless hyperinflation.
Figures from the Central Bank of Zimbabwe indicate that in June 2008, the country's
annual inflation reached 231 million percent. By mid-November 2008, inflation had peaked at
nearly 80 billion percent, after which the authorities gave up on publishing monthly
statistics. A year later, the exchange rate of the Zimbabwe dollar against the U.S. dollar
reached $35 trillion to one. Zimbabwe was eventually forced to abandon and reissue
its currency. In 2008, a great famine struck Zimbabwe. Of the country's 16 million people,
as many as 3.5 million went hungry. Today, malnutrition is chronic and widespread.
Communism plagues the world in ways that can be observed or foreseen across all countries.
Developed Western countries are beginning to experience crises. Meanwhile, the tragedy of
socialism is already a reality in the developing world. This is the principle. The specter uses
economics to promise momentary comfort and satisfaction, luring people to moral degradation
and pulling them into the abyss.