5 Kayaks Under 300 Reviewed Are They Worth It

Headwaters Kayak
7 followers
24 Video Views·Oct 29, 2022
What's up guys? Dan from the Headwaters Kayak Shop and I'm out in front of our
local Dick's Sporting Goods here in Redding, California.
So what I'm going to do today is bring you guys along. I'm going to buy five
kayaks under or in the $200 range and I'm
going to go to the lake and review them. We're going to talk about them.
I'm going to let you guys know what you're getting for your money. Is
something worth buying? Is something not worth buying?
And give you guys my honest review. So let's get into it. Alright we're rolling
in here and they've actually got a pretty decent selection compared to the
Dick's and Lodi. It's a hallway of kayaks right here. I'm
over here listening to the guy's sales pitch and I'm just like
pulling out my hair about the ignorance that these customers are getting spitted
right now. It's unreal. Let's sit on top here. This one's uh 40
pounds. It's called the Bandit 100. $199. So I
think I'm going to pick this one up. Let's see. It's got a little front
storage compartment. Seat. Zipper bag in the back. Rod holders.
That one's $279. A little bit above the budget where I
wanted to be but I think I'm going to pick that one up just because
it seems like it would be a popular one. The colors look like pink and then this
one's like a blue green. I'm gonna go with the pink though. I
don't know why. Alright we got the Pallet or Perception
Swifty 9.5. We've actually reviewed that one before.
I'm going to throw one in the video too though because it's under $300
and I think it's a really good boat for the price. So here you guys go. This is
going to be the Blade. Check this one out. $159.
It looks like it's roto molded. It's got a nice hull design. I think I'm
going to pick this one up too. That brings us up to four.
Mike's going to help me pick one more boat. And for my last one you guys I
decided to just get this one. The 189 Pelican because
I don't know. They're just so deep on them. I see a ton of these around. The
Trailblazer 100. I'm going to grab one of those. I think
we'll go for. Let's go with the lime green. I'm a lime
green guy. Alright you guys. Here's my five. Thank you so much. It was Mike right?
Yeah anytime man. Have fun. Yeah. We'll get in your
hand. Pack them out. Are you in the trailer? Yeah that's my
trailer right out there. There's a protection plan I can get on
any kind. There is a protection plan. Pricing right there. Okay so $29.99.
For any issues with your seats, your straps, your hatches, whatever. Any of the
stuff that you bolt on. Any of that stuff tears out.
It's covered. It doesn't cover normal wear and tear if you're banging it on the
rock. Right if you're dragging it. It's not going to cover that. Okay so I got to say
you guys. This shopping experience was way better than my last Dick's Sporting
Goods experience. The guy was super super nice. He didn't
have all the answers but he didn't pretend like he did either.
And you know I told him the whole story. I introduced myself and
you know he introduces a lot of people into paddle sports. So hopefully
we can educate them about our shop so when people want something a little
nicer or when they want to learn about community events and stuff like that
we can send them our way. I'm going to go. I'm going to first line them up and I'm
going to walk you guys through the different boats. Why I picked them
and then next I'll go hit the water and let you guys know how they paddle.
Oh there it is. So we're actually outside of Redding today. We took a drive about
45 minutes up the hill from Redding to the east
and we're just at the base of Mount Lassen at a little PG&E lake called Lake
Macumber. This is a great summer escape from
Redding heat because it does get hot in Redding you know.
105 degrees yesterday and it's probably 75 up here this morning and I feel like
it's a great place to test the boats because this is probably going to be the
kind of lake that most people are going to use these basic kayaks. You know when
they have the picture in their mind of what am I going to do with my kayak.
I want to do flat water lakes. I want to go you know camping and have a kayak
just to paddle around whatever campground I'm at.
So behind me I've got the five kayaks I picked up ranging from the least
expensive to the most expensive. The least expensive being the blade 10
foot at $159. The next up is the Pelican
Trailblazer 100. This one was $189 on sale. Then we have
the Pelican Bandit which is a 10 footer and it was the only sit on top they had
under $300. And next up is the Pelican Mustang. That
one came in at $279. It's got some upgrades like the bag in
the back, the knee pads, a little front hatch.
And then lastly is the Perceptions 59.5 and that one is a heavy duty
rotomolded construction. We've actually reviewed that one in the
past and thought it was a good value for the price.
Now that we've seen it come under 300 bucks at that I think it was a $289
price point. We had to put that one back in today's
review. So we're going to get these things on the water you guys. I'm going
to test them out for you. The first kayak I'm going to paddle
today is a Pelican Trailblazer. This is the one that I see everywhere
on top of every car in town. So I wanted to just give it a shot, paddle it around
and see how it felt. And I am using the molded foot pedals in
this boat, the ones that have notches. And I gotta say for me and my height it
fits me just perfect. I think if you were in between sizes you
might find your knees to be way up or your legs to be straight out.
But I'm able to get mine pretty solid. Now I will say that if you look at my
my knees in the cockpit there's no padding on the outside of my knees so
you're kind of just against the plastic. But it is rounded off so it's not
too bad. Feet are on the foot pedals. You want a
little bit of a bend in your knee. You don't want your legs straight out
because that's going to make you feel tippy. You also want your back rest if
you can see that. See how I'm sitting nice and upright and
I'm not kicked back? If you're kicked back you're going to be less stable. You
want to push your butt all the way back in that
seat so you have a nice upright position. Feet against the foot pedals. Now I'm
ready to go paddling. I love this little lake. Off to my east
is Mount Lassen. We're about eight miles from the park entrance
and so you're just paddling around next to these white cap peaks.
It's just beautiful. Now as I paddle around it's so beautiful and it's so
calm. You forget what kayak you're in. It
almost it doesn't matter. For this kind of water
where it's flat, you're at a small lake. This is probably
you know a couple hundred acre lake. Not a big lake.
It's almost always flat calm. This is a fine tool for the job.
I think a lot of kayak shops like mine, independent shops,
tend to want to look down and talk bad about these kayaks. Call them
you know coffins, you know Costco coffins or bathtub boats.
But I think if you're being realistic and what you're wanting to use the boat
for and not going to running white water or
not going you know on big lakes or open water,
I think you can be completely satisfied with a boat like this.
So if we're talking stability, I'm the boat rocks and rolls to its secondary
but I definitely wouldn't say it's unstable.
Now I have paddled the Aruba SS. I have one of those as well
and I purposely didn't put it in this review. I should maybe.
But Dick's doesn't sell them. Walmart sells them and those boats are tippy.
I highly recommend looking elsewhere. If you're looking at that Aruba
or that Walmart style boat, here's a boat that's basically the same price
you know under 200 bucks that is head and shoulders better paddling, more
stable, more forgiving, will fit a broader range of people.
Buy this one over the Sun Dolphin Aruba any day of the week.
So as I speed this boat up, you'll notice that just a big old bow wake starts
coming off the bow. It doesn't want to go fast. This boat's
for leisure paddling. If you start getting this thing going fast, the bow
wake piles up on the front and you're not going to go anywhere. Any
sort of efficiency. So if you're buying this boat, just think
of it as you are buying a toy yak. You know an easy to paddle at two miles
an hour close to shore. You're going to go for a couple
you know an hour, two hours, putz around on a lake like this and you're going to
have a great time. If you want more out of the sport, if
you want to go you know five, six miles and you want to paddle in some wind and
some chop or maybe you want to run a local class one river, look for
something that's a little bit more sophisticated. Something that has bulk
heads, safety features, maybe a little bit
more more length and keel that's going to help you going straighter
and expect to spend you know five, six hundred bucks on something that's
appropriate for that kind of water. Again, it's not that this is a bad boat
because it's definitely not. I feel comfortable and having a great time
but knowing your boat's limitations is the most important part.
So I'm a fan. I like this boat. I think it's totally fine. I think
you know the outfitting on it is a little bit disposable in the trail
blazer but for an entry-level kayak at 189
bucks if it gets you in the sport, you're not going to hate it. One thing
that does concern me is the really low back tank well.
The fact that if water comes over here it's going to go straight into my
cockpit and flood the kayak and the fact that this kayak has no
flotation means if water's inside this thing is sinking or at least sinking up
to the gunnels and you're having to swim home.
And the last thing that I hope it goes without saying when we're talking boats
like this, these boats are not safe if you flip
them over. These boats fill up with water so
always always always wear your life jacket. Again on a lake like today, worst
case, if I flip this thing over I would be
floating this high. I'd float back to shore or swim back to
shore. I could probably drag my kayak or worst
case I'm going to get back safe but if I don't have this little device on
I'm going to be in a world of trouble because I can't depend on this boat for
my flotation. You should always always wear a life
jacket no matter what water you're in, no matter what boat you're paddling but
especially if you're in one of these little sit-in sides.
All right so that's uh that's the trailblazer. Next I'm going to hop in
that little bandit sit on top. Try that one out.
All right so now I'm in the bandit sit on top and uh this one's not quite as
cozy as the uh trailblazer. The seat's a little, I
mean I guess it's the same height but it feels
a little bit more flimsy on this one. Maybe it's an adjustment thing or maybe
it's just how I sit with my legs a little bit more straight
out in front of me. Again with the molded foot pedals and
here's a good example of this one's too close. This one I feel a
little bit too far. I'd love to be right here
but again there's no foot pedal so you know sit in them in the store make sure
they work good for you. But the thing I do
like about the sit on top is again water can come up over the deck
it's going to drain right out here through the scupper holes. It's a lot
safer boat and if I was paddling with my family I
would probably be putting it in sit on top
just for that safety aspect of knowing hey if they flip over they can flip it
back up and climb back on. You know I was a kid not that long ago
and I remember being on Silver Lake and flipping over my kiwi kayak which was a
sit inside and that thing filled to the brim and I
remember having to swim that thing back and it was
I don't want to say it was traumatic but it was definitely a scary learning
experience. Whereas if I had to sit on top I would
just flipped it over and then back to paddling
no big deal. So as I paddle I don't know if you can hear
this one take requires more effort to push through the water
so when you sit on top you elevate your center gravity up a little bit so the
boats tend to have to be a little bit wider to compensate and it
definitely feels a little wider. So same length 10 foot
but another couple inches wider and it makes this boat a little bit
harder to handle. Man I just look out here and I'm just
seeing trout crush top water all over and I don't have my rod. Again I
should be out here fly fishing today but instead I'm doing this for you guys
and I'm happy to do it because hopefully this means you guys
are going to get out on the water and come experience some of this beauty
for yourself. I get plenty of room behind me if I
wanted to bring a kid or a small dog this would be a good one for that.
All right well I'm going to wrap it up in this one. I think from a safety aspect
I really like the idea of this boat for something under $200
that you can be safe with if you wanted to go float a river or something like
that this boat's going to serve you better
than the trailblazer. Next why don't we jump in why don't we
jump in that little 159 field and stream
blade kayak. It looks inexpensive on the outside but I know a hole design when I
see it and I really like the looks that hole design so let's try it out. I'm a
little bit concerned about how my 34 inch legs are going to fit into that
little tiny cockpit but we'll give it a shot here. This one's
got that those nice adjustable foot pedals in there so that shouldn't be a
problem with my leg length. Yeah that was my concern right there you
guys look at that. So if you're a taller person this isn't
the boat for you. I'm going to get in and paddle it but if
I'm being honest this would be so uncomfortable to paddle because look
at my knees are just right at the front of that cockpit there's no padding.
I already know I would pick the trailblazer over this one no matter how
good it paddles if you're a bigger guy. Now let's try it out and see how it does
and just talk about performance because if you're a smaller person you know
that's not going to be a problem you're going to be out of the way so
let's see how she goes here. So I've got some of my friends and colleagues that
think I'm nuts for doing these videos and you know selling dicks sporting
goods hundreds and hundreds of boats but you know what you guys are buying
boats anyway from somewhere and I always tell people an independent
shop like mine we're probably not going to be somebody's first kayak shop.
We're going to be their second kayak shop if somebody wants to get into the
sport and wants to just spend $200 $300 to see if they like it
they're going to be buying something like this. If they fall in love with the
sport which I think you will out here on a place like this then guess
what you're going to be back to see me and say hey I want a good kayak I want
something that I can you know do class two rivers in or I can go
longer I can go harder I can put my camping gear in
whatever niche you decide you want to pursue that's where I come in
with knowledge with expertise with selection
and I can help dial in the boats but if I'm inspiring you right now
or motivating you to get out on the water and try kayaking
then that's really my job that's what I'm more excited about
than selling a boat and long term if you're getting into the sport and
you're excited about it there's always going to be a need for a pro shop like
headwaters or whatever pro shop you have in your
local town. So again you guys I'm in the blade field and stream model this is
their little sit inside and I picked it up for 159 dollars
it's got a nice seat in it I would say out of the pelican versus this
the seat is a little bit higher a little more supportive I also really
like how in the back it's got a tank well
but it's also got this little hump that's going to keep the water out of my
cockpit so a little bit more versatile a little
bit more safe and it paddles really nice yeah a little
dragonfly landed on me there this boat has really nice glide I think
that whoever designed this boat had to be the same person that designed the
original wilderness systems pungo because it
looks eerily similar from the waist down
as a pungo just way more simplified but the whole DNA is really what matters I
mean what how a boat paddles glides turns how stable
it is all has to do with how someone designed
the boat and the fact that it's rotomolded means
you can get a lot more complex contours and design out of a boat as opposed to
the pelican sheet mold so
my only complaint is the legroom this thing has the adjustable foot pedal so
it's got better foot pedals better seat better hold performance a
little bit heavier but not bad the only downside for me is just those
those knees they're being so close to that cockpit so again if you're
six foot and under I don't think you'd have a problem with it but if you're a
bigger guy like me I'm 6'2 230 you're going to feel a little bit
crammed into the cockpit of this thing with that said now that I'm on the water
this is my favorite one out of the bunch so far this thing paddles really nice
I cannot believe that they can make a kayak
that is $159 that one that they can make a profit at it
but two that they can make something that paddles as nice as this thing does
the outfitting is where you get into your additional cost so if you can live
without some of the creature comforts you can still get into a boat that
paddles really nice at a basic price point
and you can get into this sport for 200 bucks for
for this boat this paddle I guess you need a life jacket so let's say
250 bucks and you're into the sport and you're out here you're doing this
um I don't know I don't think I don't see how that could be bad
I guess where it could be bad is if you if you're taking the boat into
inappropriate water if you're taking the boat into waters
that it shouldn't be in open water waves things like that this
boat doesn't belong there this is a flat water
close to shore recreational kayak and as long as you know that
man you're gonna have a good time the other thing that you should invest in if
you're thinking about a boat like this invest in some float bags they're
basically little triangle shaped bags that you jam up into the nose you jam
into the stern and blow them up and they basically fill
up the otherwise dead space that would fill with water and give you a lot of
buoyancy so if I were to flip over out here
now I have a nice buoyant boat that I could hold on to
that I can potentially empty the water out or use a bilge pump and bail the
water out and then get back in and paddle to shore
again without that I've got a cockpit full of water all the way to the brim
and I'm not getting this thing to shore
this thing is fun the other thing I gotta say about this boat
is man look at that I can just lean myself
way the heck over on this boat and it's stable
it is solid on a secondary edge again that classic pungo hole design that I
see on the bottom of this thing that's what made the pungo so popular
because it still paddled well but you could lean away the heck over
without tipping over so comparatively to that um that
pelican I mean I like that pelican it felt great
and at that price and that weight is good
but on the water this one is it's a touch better if that one was a
a three-star review this one would be a four-star review this is just a little
nicer foot pedals backrest uh whole
performance outfitting all better the only
complaint is just that small cockpit 159 bucks
next I'm going to take out the perception swifty all right again this
is my second time reviewing this kayak I reviewed it once before in the top
five under 500 that I did last year and I was impressed with it but I felt
like it was a little bit of a beam pushing through the water now my filter
is a little skewed because today these are 300 an undercut so my my level
of expectation goes way down with uh with
these style boats one thing I'll say right off the bat is
the foot pedals the backrest is super tall on this one
ergonomics feel really really good I'm kind of noticing
see that stop paddling see what the boat does there
spins out that didn't happen in the pelican
and in that little blade kayak I stopped paddling and the boat just glided
straight again the whole design on this one's a
little bit more bean shape is what I call it was just rounded all over
whereas that uh that blade actually has a really good looking hole
a little bit more keel still has a good secondary edge here
but yeah I think this one actually surprisingly
takes a little bit more work just to keep it going straight
this pushes a touch more water than the other boat did too
than the old blade so it sure is hard to have a bad time when you're out here
doing this so pretty out here at nine and a half
feet it's easy to spin around easy to maneuver
all the boats are that way you know the longer the boat the faster it's going
to cut through the water right the shorter the boat the more
maneuverable it's going to be so you got to kind of figure out what
sort of water you're going to be in what's your priority
if you if you're in flat water lakes like this one
where it's just a small body of water you don't really need the speed because
you know if I had an hour to kill I could paddle
around this whole thing twice but if I was going out to say whiskey
town lake where it's a little bigger body of water and has some wind and some
waves I would definitely be looking at
something longer you know 12 maybe even 14 feet if it's available
I know there's not a lot available in this under you know $300 price point
but again if what you're doing is more open water stuff
you should spend a little bit more and get something that's more appropriate
I keep saying it but again these are close to shore boats
you don't want to paddle them further offshore than you want to swim back
so let's talk about kind of pros and cons but I would say the pros to this
boat indestructible construction this thing's
going to last you forever you can drag it you can beat it up it's
gonna it's gonna hold up to that overall comfort and fit of this boat is
really good the foot pedals the backrest
you know the bungees actually make sense I've got a little spot on the dash I can
I can put my paddle you know if I was doing a little fishing or whatever I
got my rod holders behind me the downside is is this right here
when I stop paddling the boat wants to kind of swing
I didn't notice that in the in the pelican
or the blade and I don't know to me if there's any sort of wind and
you're struggling to control your boat it can make kayaking a lot less
fun if you're working hard to uh to keep the boat going straight where
you want it to go and those other two I didn't even think
about it and again you guys my review might change if I was a 150 pound lady
and not a 230 pound guy and I think I said the same thing last
time I just feel like I push water in this
and that the bow locks in and the stern's kind of loose
um with that being said I felt too big for that blade
and it tracked and glided better than this one so
take that for what it is
all right so next up I've got the Mustang by Pelican
again I got the pink one just because why not this is basically the same as a
trailblazer if you look at the whole designs like from the waist down
it's exactly the same this one just gets a refined deck it gets a couple of rod
holders it gets a nice little little zipper hatch a little bit better
outfitting knee pads so I think I'm gonna I think I'm
gonna like this one a lot because I enjoyed that one
and just the added comfort and features this one should be sweet
all right again the first test is stepping down into that cockpit
and you can see six foot two I got plenty of room
and these have these nice little padded cushions nice job Pelican
you know cheap upgrade and I don't know how permanently attached they are
but man they feel so much more squishy than any of the other boats I've been in
they should sell it as an aftermarket upgrade because I mean
that just upgrades your comfort level so much remember what I was saying about
the boat going straight when I start paddling it
I get on the pelican I stop paddling the boat continues to go straight maybe a
little bit of veering I mean it is a 10 foot
but all in all quite a bit straighter than that uh than that perception
so if I was in the market and I had a $300 budget for my kayak
obviously you got to still get a paddle and you got to get a life jacket but I
think this kayak paddles way nicer and has way more features
and it's only 90 bucks more so I get it it's almost a third more if you're
buying a $300 kayak but I definitely feel like you're
getting a third more features and benefits from this kayak
nicer seat dry bag better ergonomics in the cockpit with the little pads
I would definitely spend a little bit more and get this one if I was in the
market well this is my last kayak I'm not ready to get off the water yet so
what I'm going to do is I'm going to take you guys for a little ride
I'm going to go across Lake McCumber into where Battle Creek comes in and
show you guys around a little bit because it's absolutely beautiful back
there and honestly a little 10-foot kayak
will be perfect for navigating through the little marshland so let's go check
it out so we're pulling into Battle Creek here
basically this is where the creek comes into the lake
it's pretty wild you guys I can actually feel through the kayak
the water drop 20 degrees like my feet are freezing cold
this is just fresh snow melt coming down off the mountain
look at all the wildflowers growing so pretty back in here
just like this lush mountain meadow with a little creek running right through the
middle and you guys this is what it's all
about it's not about what kayak you're in
it's about getting out and enjoying the great outdoor if this is a price point
that allows you to get on the water and come out
and enjoy places like this that are maybe right in your backyard that you
never knew about then I'm all for it and if this video
has inspired you share it with us I'd love to hear your stories about
how maybe something we've done has affected you personally
or gotten you into the sport or inspired you to you know to
to give kayaking a try that's the kind of stuff that fuels me it fuels my
passion and we'd love to hear it so go ahead and
follow us on instagram tag us in any of your stuff
at headwaters kayak at headwaters adventure company
we'd love to see what you're up to so I'm going to head back to the launch
give you guys my final thoughts and we'll wrap this thing up all right so
kind of lined them up here you guys my least favorite to my most favorite
and uh and honestly they were all fine they all did a good job there's certain
things I like about the certain ones and I'm just going to walk you through
give you my thoughts but let's start with this little trailblazer 100 the
reason I put this one is my least favorite
not because of how it paddles because it paddles really good at 189 bucks
it's a good value the only thing I really didn't care for this boat
is that back area and the fact that when water drains in it's going to drain into
the cockpit and could potentially make for a
dangerous situation and I think for not that much more money
the outfitting the ergonomics the the rod holders everything about this for 90
bucks more it's such a better product that I would
really just lean people towards the the mustang
uh next over here I put the perception and although I love the build quality
I love the seat when I was paddling it was probably my
my least favorite boat to to paddle which I'm kind of bummed to say that and
again I think it's my weight I think if you're a smaller paddler you
might have a different experience but comparatively to the pelican uh it
did not paddle quite as good the next up is the bandit and this boat
was kind of yeah for me it didn't like no fireworks went off when I paddled it
but it is very lightweight it's stable and it is sit on top so it's a very safe
boat for a family so if I'm husband wife you know they want to get a
couple of these I want to drag a kid around or a dog around
it's going to be plenty stable and it's going to be safe next up here is the
blade kayak and out of all the kayaks this was my
favorite one to paddle this one was really
really impressive a really nice easy paddling boat and at only 159 bucks
uh that has to be on your short list I mean it is such
a good little boat the only complaint on this guy was the cockpit size a little
bit short in the cockpit and I honestly think that if I if it
was mine I might take a jigsaw and just buzz this out uh other than
that I really like the seat I like the adjustable foot pedals
I'm definitely a big fan of the field and streams blade
but the reason this one right here is my top choice is for a couple things
one the ergonomics it's got a nice seat on it
it's got those padded thigh braces that were really comfortable and it's just
a really great all-around kayak it's stable it cuts through the water nice it
has good tracking a lot of features at the price point you
know it's little stuff but I like that little dry bag back there I like the
little rod holders definitely a great entry-level option and
again under 300 bucks guys so I hope you enjoyed this review
all the kites behind me were a blast to paddle
like I said some were a little bit better than others but let's be honest
they're all under 300 bucks and for what you're getting at that price
is really really cool you know I've been in this sport a long time and a boat
like this one right here would probably have cost me five six hundred dollars
just a few years ago so price of coming down and you guys are
the ones that benefit so hopefully this video inspires you to get out
get a kayak get paddling and then definitely as you get into the sport
look for your local club look for your local shops those are going to be your
community hubs for information for classes for events
there's so much to this sport and I want to see you guys get the most out of it
if you're in the northern california area look us up headwaters kayak we have
a shop in redding a headwaters adventure company a shop
in lodi headwaters kayak lots of community events full moon paddles
sunset paddles all sorts of great things to get plugged into
and I got to stop and just say thank you guys so much for watching the channel
subscribing to the channel if you're not already we hope you can
call this place home subscribe to our channels
we're doing all sorts of reviews this is three hundred dollar and under we'll do
five hundred dollar and under thousand dollar and under
all the way up to you know six thousand dollar custom builds we do it all
so subscribe to the channel click that notification button you guys so much for
watching until next time this is dan from headwaters kayak wishing you
happy paddling we'll see on the next one
