Massachusetts communities spent thousands of dollars installing Flock automated license plate readers, only to shut some down months later. According to the ACLU, at least 40 Massachusetts communities have ditched the cameras since September 2025.
25 Investigates found a growing debate over whether Flock cameras are a powerful crime-fighting tool or invasive surveillance.
Answers uncovering the truth. Boston 25 News investigates.
Massachusetts Police Department spending thousands
of dollars to install and activate Flock cameras
in their communities only to ditch them months later.
25 Investigates examined Flock contracts in dozens of cities and towns.
Talked to local police and privacy advocates.
We found the fight over whether these cameras keep communities safe
or go too far is only intensifying.
Our data.
Our data.
The flock camera controversy stretches.
It violates our privacy.
From the South Shore.
It's my hope that through this hearing, we can address those concerns.
To the North Shore.
I am not convinced that flock safety
is the right partner for New Bedford.
To the South Coast.
We'll take a recess.
Thank you.
The automated license plate readers quickly went up
in communities across the state,
hailed an important new investigative tool.
It's probably the most significant improvement
in law enforcement since DNA.
Then just as quickly flagged as government overreach
and an invasion of privacy.
According to the ACLU, at least 40
Massachusetts communities have ditched
flock cameras in more than a year.
There was a massive sort of misinformation campaign going on,
and I literally brought people into my building
and showed them how it worked.
John Bonney's the chief of police in Abington,
which operated six Flock cameras before shutting
them off in August.
It's just a picture.
It's just a picture of the back of a car, and that's it.
There's no people.
There's no facial recognition.
It doesn't tell us where you're going 100 feet down the road.
Chief Bonney says the cameras helped them find stolen cars,
even bust a gun smuggling
ring that originated in Rhode Island.
Are there any cases that you can confidently say wouldn't have
been solved or a lot less
likely to have been solved without a flock camera?
No, no. But it makes it a lot harder.
Quincy Police Chief Mark Kennedy called flock safety a game changer.
Any real major investigation, that's the first tool that they go to.
But abuse is being documented in some Massachusetts communities.
The allegations are quite serious in the case.
Records obtained by 25 Investigates show
former Braintree officer Mark Sherrick
used the department's flock camera system to search
a license plate associated with an ex more than a thousand times.
Officers in Stowe, New Bedford, Lynn and Swampscott are on leave or have
resigned over similar allegations using Flock for personal reasons.
They are designed to track everyone on the road.
They are not designed to only track cars that police believe may
be associated with people who are suspected of crimes.
And so that is dragnet surveillance.
Cade Crockford is the director for technology
and justice programs at the ACLU of Massachusetts.
Crockford tells me Flock cameras
were activated without community input,
which came at a cost to public trust and coffers.
25 Investigates reached out to the communities
that have ditched Flock cameras.
We wanted to know how much money they spent on them in the first place.
And we found contracts ranging
from a few thousand dollars to tens of thousands,
depending on how many cameras that they had.
Many communities told us they did pay for them using federal grants.
Those are, however, funded through taxpayer dollars.
It's ultimately their decision, but it's a shame at the end of the day
because we, again, believe that everybody.
should be safe in their communities.
25 Investigates took the cost
of Flock concerns directly to the company.
Jalen Johnson's a Flock government relations manager.
At Flock, we've always been accountable
and transparent from the beginning.
Johnson says all Flock searches are documented as a permanent record.
Flock mandates audits of system usage,
which he says helps identify the bad actors.
The benefits outweigh the risks each and every day.
To offset the risk, police departments are enacting internal
safeguards around the use of and access to flock systems,
as many are looking to state lawmakers to make the next move.
That's always my hope, to have some reasonable legislation,
and this stuff can come back.
But it isn't going away.
The ACLU expects legislation in the next session
that will provide some blanket parameters
and regulations on how law enforcement can use Flock.
If you want to see how your local department is using Flock now,
we have a growing database you can see on our website with this story.