2024 Election Gretchen Whitmer vs Glenn Youngkin
It's Governor Gretchen Whitmer of Michigan up against Governor Glenn Youngkin of Virginia.
Today on Political Access, we're going to play out this hypothetical 2024 presidential matchup.
This was suggested in the comments. It's similar to some previous ones I've done,
but let's just play it out anyway. Safe states are over a 10-point margin,
likely 5 to 10 points, lean under 5 points, and tilt 1 point or less.
So how would this one go? Well, both these candidates are moderately establishment,
and Gretchen Whitmer is going to try to bridge that coalition with the progressives,
Glenn Youngkin is going to try to corral the Trump voters along with his establishment,
Gretchen Whitmer is going to do better in the upper Midwest, as well as all the other typical
blue spots, Glenn Youngkin along with Whitmer will do reasonable in the suburbs, and he might
do a little bit better trying to bring back some of those Republican voters who may have left the
party since Donald Trump. Both of them are reasonably popular governors of their states,
Glenn Youngkin has only been in office for about a year, he's got some time left,
his popularity could fade or it could get even stronger, so it's hard to gauge,
plus the national environment, plus running mates, plus specific issues, there's a lot of unknowns,
but let's get started. In Alaska, that will be low double digits, safe for Youngkin.
Hawaii, very safe for Gretchen Whitmer. Washington, Oregon, California, very safe for Whitmer.
Would Glenn Youngkin get the margins reduced in a place like Washington and Oregon?
Yeah, I would think he would do a little bit better than Donald Trump there,
but not enough to get it into single digits. How about in Nevada, that will be a competitive state,
drifting slightly toward the right. I think Gretchen Whitmer is not going to have a lot of
appeal in some of these western states. She's from the upper midwest, she would do better there,
but over here in the southwest, I think Glenn Youngkin would probably do a little bit better
in a state like Nevada, it would be very close, but I have Glenn Youngkin winning it by a tilt margin.
Idaho, Utah, safe for Youngkin. Arizona, this state has been tough for the Republicans as of
late, even though it's trending toward the left, I think there's enough Republican voters there
that have been looking for something that's not Donald Trump to vote for, but they can't bring
themselves to vote for the Democrat, so I think enough of them would come back, especially in
the suburbs, and I have Glenn Youngkin winning this by a low 1-2 point lean margin. Montana,
Wyoming, safe for Youngkin. Colorado, that will be just under 10 points, likely for Gretchen Whitmer.
New Mexico, that will be just over 5 points, likely for Gretchen Whitmer.
North Dakota, South Dakota, safe for Youngkin. Nebraska at large, safe for Youngkin. The second
district, it is a bluer district, it's not as blue as it was prior to redistricting, but the trends
are not great for the Republicans there, I think this would go for Whitmer by low to mid single
digits, so lean for Whitmer. Kansas, Oklahoma, over 10 points, safe for Youngkin. How about in Texas,
that will go likely for Glenn Youngkin. Youngkin would not have as many people coming out to vote
against him, so I think Texas would kind of resort back to its default political status, and it would
be likely for Glenn Youngkin. Up to Minnesota, that will be likely for Gretchen Whitmer. There's
still a lot of working class vote in Minnesota, hasn't really flipped toward the Republicans yet,
I don't think they would do so for Glenn Youngkin. Gretchen Whitmer, she kind of has the Michigan
accent, she'd probably fit in in some of these upper Midwest states a little bit better than
Glenn Youngkin, and she would win that by mid to high single digits. Iowa, on the other hand, would go
likely for Glenn Youngkin, probably also mid to high single digits. Missouri, Arkansas, Louisiana,
safe for Glenn Youngkin. Let's go up to Wisconsin. Tough call. The state border is Michigan, where
Gretchen Whitmer is from. I could see this going either way. There are some sparsely populated
counties that are still light blue and still light red. They also haven't gone hard toward
the Republicans yet. So I could see Youngkin winning this, but given the proximity toward
Michigan, I have to slightly put this as a tilt for Whitmer. Illinois, that'll be over 10 points,
safe for Whitmer. Let's go to Michigan, Gretchen Whitmer's home state. There's no question she
would win this. I have it as a likely for Whitmer. Indiana, that will stay safe for Glenn Youngkin.
Kentucky, Tennessee, Mississippi, Alabama, safe for Glenn Youngkin. Let's go to Florida. I understand
the state is trending toward the right, especially after these midterms. I want to see how the trends
go on a presidential level. I do have Glenn Youngkin winning it by a lean margin. This would
be borderline likely, four and a half to five points. If you want to put it as likely, I understand,
but I just want to wait to see what the trends are. But I don't think there's any way Gretchen
Whitmer would win Florida. How about in Georgia? This is a tricky state. Democrats are feeling
much better about it as time goes on. The Atlanta suburbs, they've gone away from the GOP.
Could Glenn Youngkin be the one that brings them back a little bit while also still getting turnout
in the rural counties? Very close call for me. I'm going to say Glenn Youngkin is able to slightly
hold off the trends. And Georgia would go red one more time by a tilt margin. South Carolina,
over 10 points safe for Youngkin. North Carolina, low to mid single digits for Glenn Youngkin. It
possibly could even get too likely. Let's go up to Ohio. That will be likely for Glenn Youngkin.
I think the state is just too far gone for the Democrats. Even if Gretchen Whitmer is
from a neighboring state, Glenn Youngkin would win this easily by over five points.
How about West Virginia? Very safe for Glenn Youngkin. Let's go to Maine at large. This will
be just under 10 points likely for Gretchen Whitmer. First district, that's very blue,
that will be safe for Whitmer. The second district, that's gotten much redder over the
past decade. Donald Trump has won it twice. Glenn Youngkin would get reasonable turnout here. He's
not going to fire up people as much as Donald Trump did in his prime, but he would still win it
by a likely margin. New Hampshire, this is a close one for me. I think Gretchen Whitmer would do
better in the Northeast, in the higher educated wealthier states. I think Glenn Youngkin would
do well here 10 or 20 years ago, but I do have Gretchen Whitmer winning it by a tilt margin.
And that may even be a little bit too generous toward Youngkin. I could see her winning it by
even up to four points. Vermont, New York, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island,
New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland, Washington DC. Those are going to be safe for Gretchen Whitmer.
I think Glenn Youngkin would do okay in some of those states relative to some of the margins
Donald Trump got. Again, because I do not think people are going to be motivated to vote against
him, but he still would not get any of them under a 10 point margin. Let's go to Pennsylvania.
There's another state where Republicans, they've been able to have success here,
but not at all consistently. And in this matchup, I have Gretchen Whitmer winning it by one to three
points lean for Whitmer. And finally, the very last state is Glenn Youngkin's home state of
Virginia. And my thinking is it used to be a red state. It's just trended too far toward the
Democrats. And Glenn Youngkin did win as governor. That's true. But statewide politics are different
than national politics. I think Glenn Youngkin would do pretty well given the circumstances.
He would definitely get it under a five point margin. I just don't think it would get down to
a tilt or even flip. I do have it as a lean for Gretchen Whitmer. And that is my map. And that
would result in 268 electoral votes for Glenn Youngkin, 270 for Gretchen Whitmer. And Gretchen
Whitmer would very, very narrowly pull out a win here. This is very similar to a recent matchup I
did between Gretchen Whitmer and Ron DeSantis. So you could make some tweaks here. I understand
that this is what I settled on. I think with a lot of elections now, it would come down to the
suburbs and whoever could turn out their respected base. Could Glenn Youngkin win this matchup? I do
think he could win it. Obviously with a very narrow electoral win like this, this is anybody's
game. I do think Glenn Youngkin would be a better national campaigner than Gretchen Whitmer. I think
he's already been around the country doing it in the recent midterms. I think Gretchen Whitmer's
appeal would not be as strong as she would like outside of Michigan. And I also think Glenn
Youngkin could come off as a little bit like Mitt Romney. He's a little bit too elite, a little bit
too country club, and out of touch. So there are some different factors at play here. It's hard to
predict this kind of thing. But this is what I came up with. Let me know in the comments what
do you think about this matchup? Who do you think would flip which states and why? Let me know down
below. On your way out, don't forget to like and subscribe. Thank you for watching and I will see
you on the next video.

