All Signs Point to a Disaster in Columbus...
Nov 18, 2026
All signs point to a disaster in Columbus
if they are not able to pull out of this early
rut quickly. We talked about it going
into this season that with the Columbus Blue Jackets,
this really feels like one of,
if not the most important seasons in history. And to get off to
this start with all that's at stake,
it is not ideal for the Blue Jackets. To be honest, I don't
want to be making this video. I want Werenski to stay there long term.
Early on, it is not looking encouraging.
And as we'll talk about in this video,
with everything going wrong with this team,
a lot of Werenski being committed to the Columbus Blue Jackets
was contingent on this being a playoff team
and potentially being able to build off of what they have now.
So if they regress from last season, that is a really bad sign.
But let's start by talking about what is wrong.
And with this team, it really feels like
a conversation of what isn't going wrong
because there are so many issues with this team.
It really feels like a window is closing before it opens.
And this has to be really devastating for the fans.
Talking about Columbus and what's going on wrong so far this season,
you take a look at just the energy around the team.
Recently, there was a post here from The Athletic,
and we're going to quickly touch on some of the points here.
With Columbus, with where they are in the standings right now,
you take a look, as we will right here.
This is a team where it feels like
a miracle is needed for them to come back.
Last season, we saw that.
They were in last place, and somehow they turned it around.
A big part of that was the new coach bump,
a new enthusiasm with the team.
You were expecting that to be more.
more of what they started with,
that has not been the case, and I really thought, even
though Marchenko is a much better player than Matthew Nyes,
at least in the short term,
I thought by getting that bad energy out
of the locker room, there would be more unity
here, and maybe there is,
but the play just has not been great, and as we'll touch on
in one second, Adam Fantilli has not been helping,
but you do have to start this by
looking at the standings,
after the Flyers had one of the worst starts this season,
I've seen in a long time.
Somehow Columbus has found a way to have less points.
Like their point percentage is worse.
Columbus only has 14 points in their games so far.
They've played 18 games.
That's four points below NHL 500.
And look, I understand it as part of this is they're
not getting loser points like these
other teams, or we can have that argument about like
who really is the worst team all
day.
I think they are better than the Penguins.
I think they maybe are better than the Flyers.
They didn't show it in their last game.
But after that, I don't think you can really make,
and this is not me being biased.
I know I have the Islanders in the background behind me.
I don't think you can make an argument at this point
that this team is better than Washington
or the Islanders or definitely not the New York Rangers.
And you can forget about the Carolina Hurricanes
and the New Jersey Devils.
And considering all has been built in Columbus
towards having this season be the season
they take the step forward.
That's really concerning, and I understand
this is a situation where everything went
right, this team could have made the playoffs,
but is this a situation where the goal is
for everything to go right,
just to sneak into the second wildcard or the third Metro
Because really, you look at this team, that is the peak.
And absolutely, everything has not gone perfect so far.
In fact, it has been close to the opposite.
Well, a part of the concern, too, for Columbus,
I know they've had defensive injuries, but
these forwards, and this team was supposed
to be built around these forwards, it just
has not been good.
And after the last loss in Philadelphia,
Zach Werenski, who we're going to end this video
talking about, had this quote, we're behind the eight ball.
I think everyone knows that.
Obviously, we've had some games we probably should have won.
And when you don't, the next thing you know, you fall.
And I get this sentiment that, oh,
there's a couple of games that we could have won.
We're playing good hockey.
It's just not good enough.
But that's just the reality of what this team is.
You don't have enough talent
to win games where you're not perfect, right?
You have to play that perfect style of hockey.
Wierenski is an incredible defenseman.
You have some interesting forwards,
but really you don't have other than Wierenski that game
breaking talent.
And now after last season, so far,
Jack Graves has not been that difference maker in net.
It shows just how fragile this team is.
And I really don't know if there's a way.
Now, if there is something that I
do think can improve the play of Fantilli and Nyes,
there has to be more to these players.
So far, they have been a part of the problem.
I put currently here because I don't think
this is going to stay the situation.
I do think there is more to both these guys' games.
And Columbus fans, I think this is where you have hope on this season.
So far, Adam Fantilli, let's just say he's been horrible.
I know people will be like, oh, yeah, well,
there's been some chances that he didn't finish.
He's going to face off all this stuff.
I'm sorry, you're getting paid all this money
to be a first line center.
So far through 18 games, you have seven points.
Not only is it not good enough,
it's not even close to good enough, right?
Adam Fantilli, with what he's getting paid at this point,
if he's producing at a 65 point pace, you want more.
I know he hasn't hit that point total so far in his career,
but that's where he is getting paid.
You're getting paid to take a massive step forward
in the positive direction.
Instead, he has taken a step back.
And what's a little alarming for me
when it comes to Adam Fantilli,
The shooting percentage isn't all that low.
Now, it could be higher, but at 9.4,
his career average is closer to 12-ish,
somewhere around there.
He's not shooting enough, and I think that is the big takeaway.
You need this guy to score more goals.
The playmaking hasn't been there either.
I know some of that is attributed to luck,
but this year, age 22, this is where you expected.
Really, you expected a breakout last year from Adam Fantilli.
It didn't happen.
You paid him despite it not happening,
and then for this year, how he's started so far,
it is very concerning.
And look, Don Waddell has reassured that he
is confident in this player from the moment
that he signed this contract.
He said, Adam Fantilli has all the tools you look
for in a player's speed, size, skill,
along with a competitive drive to succeed
and for the most part I agree I think Adam Fantilli
is going to come out of this but is it going
to be too late for this season and what does that mean
for the rest of the things with the team
because the problem with the Blue Jackets it's not just
Fantilli it's that when you don't have Adam Fantilli
as your star young forward
Well, what exactly does this offense have going for it?
And I do have to give credit to Kent Johnson.
I think he's been incredible.
There's been a lot of talk about him being inconsistent
on and off player.
I hope this is the real Kent Johnson
because he has been awesome so far.
But other than him, this has been a rough look.
And for a team that's been building for so long
and will go into the prospect pool,
it's concerning.
If Adam Fantilli cannot be that guy,
and we saw a similar situation recently with the
Kings where Byfield just cannot
be that number one center that they projected him to be.
The Kings didn't sign him to a big contract.
If Fantilli can't figure this out,
this is a death sentence for this team, not just now, but long term,
because you have to wonder, too, when it comes to the salary cap,
how much is Columbus going to be willing to spend?
They're not a team that makes as much as some of the big dogs.
This can be a factor going forward.
I know they spent to the cap now.
We'll have to see what that looks like in the future.
I also have to bring up Matthew Nyes,
who they traded for the start of the season.
He has also not been anything close to what I expected.
So far, he has nine points, averaging a half point per game.
It's not good enough from Matthew Nyes.
Now, I do think this is more a situation where he's
a player that's going to take time to
transition.
Matthew Nyes is a heavy straight line forward.
Because of that, I do think he's going to eventually figure it out.
Maybe this is a part of the thing, too,
where Adam Fantilli just isn't working.
But this is also not too encouraging for the Blue Jackets.
Now, he is younger than Kirill Marchenko,
but I think the reality of the situation we're
looking at here is he just can't replace that dynamic offense.
And without that dynamic offense, I just don't think there's enough.
For the Blue Jackets to really...
Get something going going forward in this season.
And if there is one concern I have
for this team behind some of the things we also talked
about, I really starting to wonder if maybe
if some of Adam Fantilli's production was
more of a product of playing
with a player like Kirill Marchenko, that is something that
you definitely don't want to see
because I don't see another play driver coming when
it comes to the prospect pool.
And this is where a big concern comes in when it comes to Columbus.
I don't think there's help on the way.
I don't see this as a team.
I don't think they have a terrible prospect pool
We're going to go into right now,
but I don't think this is a pool that really gets you
excited.
Taking a look at some of the pieces they have here,
looking at their top prospects and their
timelines.
Jackson Smith, I think is the best prospect in this pool.
I think he's really good.
He has 12, 14 points in 12 games played in the NCAA,
three goals, 11 assists.
This is a very solid selection for where he went in the draft.
Maybe not the best player available, but pretty close.
And considering you have the concerns
with Zacharensky, it's good to know you have the
next generation of defense there.
He does have to work on his defensive play, but he has some good size.
This is a really good defenseman.
After that, though.
It's not really looking great for the Blue Jackets.
While I think Jackson Smith is going
to be a really good top four defenseman,
maybe third best guy on the team,
I don't really see him as being that number one guy.
I don't see him as a true impact difference maker,
at least not yet in his development.
There is still plenty of time.
Defensemen do take a while.
He has taken steps from last year.
But Yuka Porter and...
Sorry.
Porter and...
Porter Andronov, sorry, I had it prepared before.
I completely butchered it.
Apologize, Blue Jackets fans.
The save percentage in the KHL has not been great.
It is worth noting the KHL is,
and I understand he's 19, like he's young, he has time,
but the KHL is a level that you typically expect goaltenders
To have a .900 and above.
There's not a lot of shots.
There's not a lot of scoring in the KHL.
That's why sometimes teams get way too
excited about their goaltending prospects.
They have like a .915.
A lot of goaltenders have .915s in the KHL.
A lot of them have .920s and above.
So early on, this is not the most encouraging.
I...
I don't really agree with the Blue Jackets
in this situation, especially with their
team needs going for a goaltender
as early as they did in the first round.
I think this is something they could have handled in the second round.
I wouldn't be surprised if Porter was available in the second round.
So that was definitely a questionable decision.
Oscar Hemming so far has been solid in the NCAA.
I think he's taken steps.
But again, this is a player who I think is going to be a role
player, the third guy to put on your second or third line, right?
He's not going to be the guy driving the offense.
You don't have that guy in the system.
If there's one critical mistake that I believe sunk
this Blue Jackets team, it is signing
Cayden Lindstrom to, sorry,
it is drafting Cayden Lindstrom as early as they did fourth
overall.
This pick was absolutely a mistake.
Any way you look at it, it just continues
to feel like the age is worse and worse.
And I understand why they did it.
In hindsight, hindsight's 2020, but, uh,
you look at his production this year in the NCAA,
it's good to see him healthy, but five points in 10 games played.
This is his second year in the
NCAA. He's just not taking that step that you want him to.
Yes, this would be ahead of where
he was the year before, but it's just not where you want to see it.
And you can't miss on a pick
that high. I think that's, what's really sinking this team.
You look at the forward core,
they need another impact guy.
Uh, Cayden Lindstrom was supposed to be that guy.
I think it's clear at this point.
I think he can be an NHL player.
Let me make that really clear.
I'm not writing off this kid's career.
But I think this idea, this guy coming
in and being this number one, number two center.
I don't think it's realistic at this point.
You look at how other players have progressed to this point,
how many players have drafted behind him,
have made the NHL and are not expected to be top line guys.
I don't think it's realistic anymore,
especially with all the development time he missed.
I think Cayden Lindstrom can be that guy,
which is where we go to some of the other problems with this team.
Briefly, Dmitry Voronkov.
It's a really strange situation where this guy at one point
was trying to be a consistent 20-25 goal scorer
when the Blue Jackets were trying to trade for Noah Dobson.
He was a big piece.
6'5", gets in front of the net, at least when he's playing his game.
Doesn't play that much.
10 minutes on ice on average.
He spends a lot of time on the fourth line.
They don't know what to do with this player.
And I think this is a concerning situation where you're going
to have to end up either
holding on to him or selling him at a low
because I don't see them extending him, especially
for the value he would cost on his next contract.
It's just a really rough situation.
This is the type of player that if he broke out,
became a 40, 50 point guy, it would really
help this offense.
Instead, you're getting the opposite.
To make things worse, I mean, you have
contracts like Connor Garland, $6 million.
You look at Charlie Coyle being one of your impact forwards.
I like Charlie Coyle.
I think he's a really...
Good leader for them to sign him until he's 40 years old.
That huge six year,
$6 million contract.
I think this is going to cost his team a lot in the future as Charlie
Coyle continues to age.
It also ties up a lot of money to a player that frankly,
the production is good right now,
but it's only going to get worse.
I don't know how much you can expect when Charlie Coyle,
the 13 points in 18,
it's solid production,
but he does so much for this team.
This is a situation where you would love to see young players step up
Up and force Charlie Coyle.
down the lineup, force him to play less than 19 minutes a game.
It's just not happening.
And this is not me knocking Charlie Coyle.
It's just the fact that this is pretty
much all they have going for them
on their forward core, aside from Kent Johnson,
who, like I said, has been really good.
And all this, it really makes you question what
the future is for Zach Werenski.
And I'd love to know what you guys think in the comments below.
Look, Zach Werenski has not played at a Norris level
so far this season, but he has been
everything this team needs.
He is a reliable elite defense.
You talk about the offensive struggles.
He has 15 points so far in 18 games.
He is absolutely doing his part.
It adds a lot of struggles to the Columbus Blue Jackets
because for him to be playing so well
and you're still not getting anything beyond that,
it adds to the questions of what's...
And I think these questions are going to get louder
as the season goes on.
I mean, you look at what Don Waddell
was talking about going into the season,
what happened when it came to Zakharensky
and the contract discussions and how he...
Kind of wanted to move away from Columbus and then change his mind.
Don Waddell said on Zakharensky,
I think it's more of,
do you want to play here long-term?
And.
Going to answer that question,
Zakharensky was really focused on the fact
that this team could make the playoffs.
He said, I mean, I think we're going to be
in a good spot this year where people aren't questioning
what's going to happen with me
because I believe we are a playoff team, right?
This is what he said in September this year.
He thought the questions would quiet down
because the Blue Jackets would be a playoff team.
A reminder, let's take a look back at the standings.
Not only is this not a playoff team,
If the season continues at this rate,
and I understand it's early, but it's not all
that early.
We have an 18 game sample size at this point.
If the season continues at this pace,
not only is this not a playoff team, this is a
team that's not close to the playoffs.
And I guess you can take solace
in the fact that they have all their picks.
They didn't go all in in that regard in terms
of making this team a true contender.
But it's really not that close.
And that's what I want to end this video on.
Let me know in the comments what you think about this situation.
Do you think Zakharensky will still be in Columbus next season?
I don't think so.
I really don't think because more importantly,
not just this is not a good team right now.
I don't see how they take that next step
because we see a lot of players are not willing to
go to Columbus.
And it's unfortunate that players like...
Krumarchenko wants to leave to go to Toronto,
but at the end of the day, they just don't
have the caliber, like they have decent prospects,
but those prospects are not going to be here next year.
So you got to ask yourself,
what's going to be different next time around?
I think at this point, you get closer to deadline.
I think the Blue Jackets best course of action
is to sell Wierenski when he's at his absolute premium value, right?
You get a Quinn Hughes type package and you rebuild from there
and hopefully the picks go better this time around.
But let me know what you think about this in the comments below.
If you are a fan of a team that really wants Zach Wierenski,
What you think the package should be like?
I understand this is a frustrating situation for Columbus.
I try to highlight some of the highlights,
but really there's not that much to be excited about
with how this team is playing right now
and how the future is looking up.
But be sure to subscribe to the channel
if you haven't already.
That's it for this episode of NHL Digest.
Yeah, it's looking tough in Columbus right now.

