Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin will meet in the first ever three-way summit between the leaders of the world’s three largest nuclear powers.
This episode was recorded on Monday, 16 November. 00:00 Introduction 01:50 Why is this trilateral so important? 03:19 What has the Kremlin said on the meeting? 04:39 State of the Russo-Ukrainian war 06:19 Xi Jinping’s role at this summit 08:38 Russia’s power over nuclear 09:32 Impact of Vladimir’s Putin attendance 12:10 Donald Trump and Xi Jinping’s agenda 13:35 Will this trilateral boost Xi Jinping’s image? 14:31 How will this meeting affect Ukraine’s future? 16:20 US influence over Asia
Instagram: @bbcworldservice Email: [email protected] Presenter: Mariko Oi Producers: Derek Cai, Cordelia Lee, Cheyenne Lim Camera: Muhammad Firdaus Bin Mohd Ansary, Rosalehin Bin Rosli Editor: Bill Birtles
AI Generated·May contain errors
So this year, we've seen the big two,
Donald Trump and Xi Jinping, meeting multiple times.
But now we're preparing for the big three
with the Russian president, Vladimir Putin,
expected to have a seat at the table.
And Vitaly, if this happens,
this will be a huge deal for President Putin.
Yes, extremely important,
because it would elevate him to the level that he is seeking,
sitting at the table with the big boys,
the heads of the two superpowers.
But what Ukrainians want to know is,
how will this meeting affect Russia's war against their country?
But it looks like those three men have
very different priorities for the meeting.
So today we're asking, who stands to gain the most?
And will this summit achieve anything?
I'm Mariko in Singapore,
and this is Asia Specific from the BBC World Service,
the podcast that brings you the biggest stories
from the region with experts who follow the stories.
And someone who follows the actions
of the Russian president very closely is Vitaly Shevchenko,
a chief analyst at BBC Monitoring in London,
and he's originally from Ukraine. Thank you
so much for coming on Asia-Pacific, Vitaly. Hello.
And Vitaly and I are joined by Jehan Pak
from the S. Raja Ratnam School of International
Studies here in Singapore,
who follows international politics very closely.
Thank you so much for coming on the pod.
Thank you for having me.
And guys, can I just say, this is our 100th episode on YouTube.
So it feels quite...
fitting to be talking about this historic summit.
As of now, the White House says that
the trilateral summit will take place on Thursday,
but what they're going to discuss,
it's still a bit up in the air. So let's dive in.
Jehan, if I can start with you.
Mr. Trump and President Xi met multiple times this year.
President Xi and President Putin met multiple times.
So why is this such a big deal,
this trilateral summit between these three leaders?
So the first reason why it is important is...
The three countries represent
the most capable militaries in the world with
large nuclear arsenals
and we have seen what militaries cannot do in recent years. Russia
struggled in Ukraine and the United States
struggled in Iran and so on and so forth.
But also military power is a prerequisite for great power status
and they represent
the biggest military powers
and they hold sway over a lot of different issues in a
lot of different countries
and that is the first reason why this is the first first meeting.
Where three powers are getting together.
A second reason is the timing.
So I've just mentioned that the United States
and Russia have been struggling.
But also China and Russia have
been getting close to each other as well.
Some people have called it Crank Alliance
or New Axis and so on and so forth.
And the United States, by some accounts,
is trying to drive wedge between the two powers.
What some analysts have called a reverse Nixon strategy.
So, these things are coming together,
and then finally, Mr. Trump has suffered what
some might call a historic defeat in the midterm elections,
so a lot of analysts are predicting
that he's going to fixate more on foreign policies
and domestic agenda, which might
be curtailed by the Democratic Party.
Vitaly, I'm just wondering, from what you've seen,
what has the Russian government
said so far about this trilateral summit between the three men?
You know, not much.
Bare minimum, in fact, all I've seen from the Kremlin spokesman,
Dmitry Peskov, who's normally the person who speaks about these things,
he just confirmed that it's going ahead, it's happening on Thursday.
the, uh,
The presidential foreign policy advisor, Yuri Ushakov, said
that this is an important meeting, and he hopes that it will make...
global political relations healthier,
but very importantly, Russia hasn't actually said what
they're going to be discussing.
At one point, this Manu Shakol kind of suggested that, of course,
Ukraine's going to be on the agenda.
But then we've seen reports from Western media saying
this isn't what the United States wants. So
To me, it says that it's really, really important,
but there are subjects that Russia isn't going to go public.
about discussing. So it's all we know that it's really, really big.
Yeah, I mean, Jehan mentioned how Russia has
been militarily struggling in Ukraine. Can you maybe
update our viewers and listeners, Vitaly,
on the state of the conflict, which has been going on
for what, four and a half years now? It's at its deadliest. The
The number of civilian casualties is at the record level.
Thank
Last month, the United Nations said that the number of...
Killed and wounded civilians in Ukraine
as a result of Russian attacks increased by 85%
compared to September 2025.
you.
And
And the reason why I think this is happening,
or a huge part of the reason why this is happening,
is because Russia is...
Bogdan, it's struggling on the front line.
This year, it hasn't really made any net gains
in terms of Ukrainian territory.
In fact, the Ukrainian armed forces have
been pushing back the Russians in parts of Ukraine.
And what we're seeing is Russia stepping up attacks,
targeting civilians and civilian infrastructure, facilities such
as electricity plants, heating plants, transport, bridges.
Residential housing, and because of that,
the numbers of civilians getting killed and
born in Ukraine are just through the roof.
Jehan, as we've been saying,
we still don't know what exactly they're going to discuss
at the trilateral summit.
But I remember when China was kind of trying
to play a role in the war in Ukraine.
What do you think?
President Xi Jinping wants out of this summit.
Is this an opportunity for him to play a bigger,
I guess, mediator role on the global stage?
China is a significant strategic player,
but I think its role in this particular summit will
be limited by design. What do I mean by that?
Well, there are a lot of media reports saying
that China was less certain about this meeting
when it was initially proposed by President Putin of Russia.
And then there are a lot of, I think it was Wall Street Journal
who reported that China wanted a very scripted,
tightly scripted meeting versus the United States,
which looks at it more as preparatory or exploratory meeting
to talk about a wide ranging issues that Mr. Trump isn't interested in.
And then when it comes to specific issues,
China has not much to gain if you look at the substantive ones.
So, for example, the arms control,
which Mr. Trump has been interested in, for example.
China is a short stack when it comes to nuclear warheads.
United States and Russia have 5,000 respectively,
give or take, and China has 600, and it's
looking to expand the nuclear arsenal to 1,000 around 2030.
And last time, when the Trump administration,
1.0, was attempting to bring in China and
Russia at the same time for an arms control agreement,
China basically refused to participate.
So China doesn't have much to gain from this, on this particular issue.
And then if you look at the Ukrainian war
and the Iranian war, there are both ups and
downs for China.
And today we have issues ranging
from intellectual property thefts of Russian companies by the
Chinese, North Korea, Russia's increasing role in North Korea.
And then there is Russia in the Far East.
So on a wide range of issues, Russia and China do not see eye to eye.
So I think coming into this meeting,
China is a strategic and significant player, but
its role will be limited.
Vitaly, just picking up on what Jehan mentioned about
the U.S.'s efforts, I guess, to cap
the number of nuclear weapons.
Do you think Vladimir Putin would be OK to talk about that?
Or, you know, that's something
that he's probably just going to nod his head and kind of.
I'm sure he'll be happy to talk about it,
but from a position that, you know, we have them,
what are you going to do about it?
Putin knows that nuclear weapons put Russia at a huge advantage.
This is something that he is never going to give up just like that,
because it's a bad thing.
Thank
I'm sure he will be trying to use them as, you know,
a tool of leverage, as a way of pressuring
others, because it's a huge arsenal.
There are questions about how well maintained it is,
whether, you know, those missiles still work.
I'm just wondering about the, I guess, optics of
you.
this trilateral summit, Vitaly.
I mean, from President Putin's point of view, what do you
Do you think he wants to show the world
by standing next to, I guess, the two?
You know, most powerful leaders of the world.
Yeah, he's sitting down at the table with the big boys,
the two biggest economies.
And for him, just the fact of this meeting happening,
that's a big deal.
He's going to be well and truly back in from the cold.
And his appetites, I think, go far, far beyond Ukraine.
And bilaterally...
I think his relations with Xi Jinping
and Donald Trump are in a pretty good place.
On Ukraine, Washington
and Moscow have been working together as allies, really.
So I'm not sure Donald Trump would particularly mind.
Handing Ukraine
and possibly Eastern Europe to Russia as a sphere of influence,
when it comes to Russia's relations with China,
I would argue that Russia's war against Ukraine would
not be happening were it not for China.
China is the biggest buyer of Russian fossil fuels.
Yeah.
Last month, I believe they reached another record level.
China spent more than 10 billion euros
last month buying Russian hydrocarbons.
Now, where do you think those billions are?
Of course, a huge chunk of that money is going
to be spent on funding the war against Ukraine.
So, bilaterally, that's kind of working for Russia.
The question for Vladimir Putin right now,
OK, I'm getting this from America and China.
If they work together, will that help me?
achieve more outside of Ukraine?
I think that's the biggest question.
Are his visions of a new Yalta,
his visions of a recreated Russian sphere of influence,
are they going to come true?
So it's quite likely that when Putin sees this meeting,
In China as Yalta 2.0,
where he sits down with the great powers and
carves up the world into spheres of influence.
Indeed.
Jehan, you were saying earlier about how China reportedly
was maybe reluctant to this summit
compared to the other two.
But as you mentioned, President Trump suffered
that rather embarrassing defeat in the midterm
elections.
I mean, one can argue he's a bit of a diminished figure
in Asia as he comes back to the region.
But also from President Xi's point of view,
what kind of optics do you think those two
men are after?
For President Xi or China, this is...
The first APEC meeting in a while, I think the last one is in 2014,
so they want this to be a successful one.
So let's just preface by saying that.
For the United States, there are a lot of psychoanalysis
of how President Trump might do or not do certain things.
When it comes to the United States or Mr. Trump,
this type of meeting is very much relevant for his political legacies,
especially, as you mentioned, in the aftermath of his historic defeat.
In the midterm elections,
but also he has been talking a lot about nuclear or dangers
of the nuclear weapons.
And then second reason,
domestic political coalition or domestic political reasons.
There have been some reports saying
that Trump's Mr. Trump's closest of the closest advisers
have been benefiting from participating
in the diplomacy pertaining to the ongoing wars
in Iran and Ukraine.
I'm just wondering, though,
in terms of optics, because we were watching
Xi Jinping hosting Vladimir Putin
and Kim Jong-un and how he was standing in the middle.
And if President Xi manages to do that with President Putin
and Donald Trump standing like sandwiching him,
I mean, that will be a huge, I guess, you know,
photo of victory for the Chinese leader.
Whereas I'm not sure how
the American public would see a picture like that.
Right. So that will definitely.
boost President Xi's domestic image,
especially given the fact that the economy is not doing
well and there is a whole host of problems domestically in China.
President Trump,
I'm not sure if he cares too much about domestic opinions, but I'm
not sure how that will be seen or interpreted by his domestic,
but also his international
audiences such as European allies in Japan
and South Korea and so on and so forth.
Vitaly, I'm just wondering, given...
These three leaders really seem
to have different priorities for this meeting.
And if this was just to be a photo op for the three leaders,
if nothing tangible comes out of this summit, what would
that mean for Ukrainians still battling the Russian aggression?
Well, given that it's not a meeting
of Ukrainian friends by any sort of measure,
I think no result is probably the best case scenario for Ukraine.
They're not holding their breath,
expecting these people to come up with a...
Fair and tangible solution that would end the war.
And as Jehan says, I think the key here
is to understand the concept of spheres of influence.
And for Vladimir Putin, it's such a familiar Cold War concept.
This is something he grew up with.
This is something he spent years working with.
And right now...
He's trying to undo
the Soviet Union's defeat in the Cold War.
What he has said
and done over the 26 years of being in charge of Russia
suggests that he is trying to bring back all these lands,
as he calls them,
that Russia lost as a result of the Soviet Union's collapse.
To me, it suggests that despite all
the efforts taken by American negotiators,
and I'm using that word in quote marks,
Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff,
Russia's appetites, they haven't diminished by...
I was also reading how China may not like to see
that parallel with the Yalta meeting of 1945,
because China was not part of it despite
its efforts to defeat the Japanese.
Do you think, I mean...
How much influence do you think the US still has over Asia,
given all the trade tariffs that caused quite a bit of chaos among
The trading partners, you know, a lot of America's allies
are wondering whether they can rely on the U.S. for,
you know, security purposes even.
So as he comes back to Asia, you know, what are Asian allies
and trading partners thinking of the United States?
There are countries still in the region, including Japan,
South Korea and the Philippines and Singapore as well,
that rely pretty much on the U.S. military for better or for worse.
And this reality was institutionalized basically
at the end of the Second World War.
So this basic reality will not change for the foreseeable future.
But as you said, and there are a lot of people in Tokyo
and other capitals in Asia who are
making the case that they should start thinking about
the putative plan B.
How to get around in this dangerous world without the United States.
So if this trajectory continues, one cannot guarantee what's going
to happen in 5, 10 years down the road.
But for now, I think the United States presence in the region
is still pretty firm, at least in the political military domain.
But I think there are some interesting subsidiary issues
that have been broached.
For example, I think there was a report
a few weeks back on how President Trump might.
Push for Viktor Orban,
the former Hungarian prime minister's bid for United Nations Secretary
of Generalship, in cahoot with Russians and the Chinese.
So there are some subsidiary
issues that might be discussed,
but I would wager that the Chinese would try to avoid
sensitive topics as much as possible
so as to make the summit at least a good photo of success.
And the ASEAN summit has been rather overlooked
with this three-way summit.
And the word is that not a lot
of substantive outcome will come out of the ASEAN summit,
especially pertaining to what people call the code of conduct,
non-aggression pact among interested
parties surrounding the South China Sea.
But the fact that Mr. Trump is visiting the summit two years in a row,
last year and this year in person,
It tells us that this region is becoming more and more important.
It almost feels like it's impossible to find
a topic that's not sensitive for those three
leaders to talk about.
Jehan, thank you so much for coming on Asia Specific.
Thank you for having me.
And thank you so much, Vitaly, for coming on the pod.
Thanks very much.
It was a pleasure to be involved.
You've been watching Asia Specific from the BBC World Service with me,
Marie Kooi, in Singapore.
If you have any comments or thoughts on what we covered
in this episode or any other stories from
the region, please leave us a comment below.
You can also get in touch with us on email,
asiaspecific at bbc.co.uk and click like
and subscribe so you never miss an episode. See you
next time.