Why can NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang make politically sensitive remarks about Taiwan and still receive a warm welcome in Beijing, while ordinary Chinese citizens risk punishment for expressing private opinions? The answer reveals a deeply entrenched double standard in China's political system: the rules change depending on how powerful or useful you are. This commentary examines the contrasting treatment of Taiwanese entertainer Cai Kangyong, Jensen Huang, and ordinary citizens, while exploring the role of China's Little Pinks in enforcing official nationalism. From selective outrage and technological dependence to online censorship and political conformity, it exposes how patriotism can become a tool of political control—and why those who attack the weak often remain silent before the powerful.
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dong Xiong. Welcome to Digging into China,
where we take a deep dive into what's
really happening in China and share some unique insights.
Over the past few weeks,
we've seen another round of accusations about people insulting China.
But three very different
cases reveal something interesting.
In today's China, whether something is considered an
insult to the country often depends less
on what you say than who you are.
The first case involves Taiwanese television host
and entertainer Cai Kangyong. On October 4,
2026, Cai attended the inauguration
of the campaign headquarters of Shen Boyang,
the Democratic Progressive Party's candidate for mayor of Taipei.
Beijing has labeled Shen a Taiwan independence hardliner.
That was enough to trigger criticism from some Chinese internet users.
But Tsai did not make a political speech
or publicly endorse Taiwan independence.
He explained that he wanted to observe the event
and hear the candidates' different
positions.
He also indicated that he would welcome
the opportunity to interview all the candidates,
including incumbent Taipei Mayor Chang Wan-an.
In other words, he was doing what journalists
and television personalities commonly do,
observing politics and gathering material.
The second case involves Kylian Mbappe,
the French soccer superstar.
This time, the controversy had nothing
to do with attending a political event. It began with
an interview in which Mbappé
was asked about internet memes featuring his face.
He mentioned one that superimposed
his face onto the image of Mao Zedong,
referring to the figure as some guy, I think he is a Chinese dictator.
He said the meme had made him laugh
and that he shared it with friends online.
That seemingly casual comment triggered a major backlash in China.
Several Chinese companies
terminated their sponsorship relationships with him,
and the controversy spread across
Chinese social media and state media.
Mbappé eventually issued an apology.
And then there is the third case, which is perhaps the most revealing.
Jensen Huang, the CEO of Nvidia.
The importance of Taiwan.
Taiwan is one of the most important countries in the world.
One of the most important countries in the world.
Huang has repeatedly referred to Taiwan as a country.
He has made remarks that coming from
an ordinary Chinese citizen
or a Taiwanese entertainer might have triggered a furious
political backlash. Yet, Beijing's response has been remarkably mild.
When asked about Huang's remarks, a spokesperson from China's Taiwan
affair office essentially told him to study the matter more carefully.
Think about that for a
If an ordinary Chinese citizen made a similar statement,
would the authorities respond with
such patience? Probably not. So what is going on here?
Why can one person be condemned for
attending a political event
while another can make remarks about Taiwan and receive
Receive little more than a polite warning.
The answer is not particularly complicated.
Beijing's definition of an insult to
China is not always consistent.
It is heavily influenced by political convenience,
economic interests, and the power of the person involved.
In the case of Jensen Huang,
China has a very practical reason to be careful.
Nvidia is one of the world's most important semiconductor companies.
Its advanced chips are essential
to artificial intelligence development, data centers and
high-performance computing.
China wants access to that technology,
even as Washington imposes restrictions on the
The export of advanced chips.
Huang is, therefore, not simply a businessman visiting China.
He represents a technology company
that Beijing badly wants to maintain access to.
And this is where the story becomes especially
For years, the Chinese government has poured enormous resources
into building a domestic
semiconductor industry.
The ambition is straightforward, reduce dependence on
American technology and achieve self-sufficiency.
The government has established large investment
funds, provided subsidies,
and encouraged local governments and companies to develop domestic
Thank you very much.
The slogan is technological independence.
But money alone does not create technological
breakthroughs. China's semiconductor investment drive has
a long history of spectacular failures.
For years, Beijing has poured enormous amounts
of public money into the industry,
hoping to achieve technological independence from the United States.
Take Wuhan Hongxin Semiconductor Manufacturing.
Announced in 2017, the project
promised to build an advanced chip factory
with a planned investment of approximately
$18.5 billion. It was supposed to help China catch up
with the world's leading semiconductor
manufacturers. Local officials celebrate it
as a major technological achievement.
But the reality was very different.
The company lacked the technical capabilities to deliver what
it had promised.
By 2020, construction had stalled, suppliers were reportedly unpaid,
and the project faced a funding shortfall of roughly $16 billion.
It never produced a single
Back in 2006, the Hanxing scandal exposed how far some people would go
to manufacture the
appearance of technological success.
A Shanghai Transportation University professor Chen Jing
claimed to have developed
a domestically designed high-performance chip.
He received government funding and national recognition.
But investigators eventually
discovered that the supposedly home-grown chip
was actually a Motorola chip with its
original markings removed and replaced.
The celebrated breakthrough was a fraud.
Then came the National Integrated Circuit Industry Investment Fund,
better known as the Big Fund.
Beijing established to finance the country's semiconductor ambitions.
Its first two phases raised approximately $51 billion.
Yet, the fund itself became
entangled in corruption investigations
with several senior executives coming under scrutiny.
These cases illustrate a broader difficulty.
When political targets become more important
than technical realities,
companies and local officials have powerful incentives to exaggerate
their achievements. They want to demonstrate progress,
secure government funding, and please
their political superiors. This is why NVIDIA matters so much.
China may want to replace American technology,
but it cannot simply wish away its dependence
on it. Its artificial intelligence industry still has
a strong interest in Nvidia's
products, and its technology companies need
powerful computing resources to compete.
That creates an awkward contradiction for Beijing.
Politically, the government wants to demonstrate
that China can stand independently.
Economically, it still needs access
to technology developed by companies such as Nvidia.
And Jensen Huang understands this position very well.
He has been actively lobbying the American government
to allow Nvidia to sell more advanced chips
to Chinese customers.
From his perspective, this is business.
China is a huge market, and losing that market to
competitors is bad for Nvidia.
From Beijing's perspective, however, Huang is an important
person to keep close. Even if some
of his comments about Taiwan are politically uncomfortable,
attacking him too aggressively could damage
a relationship that China still wants.
This helps explain the difference in treatment.
It is not necessarily that Beijing has suddenly become more tolerant.
It is that the economic value
of the person speaking changes the political calculation.
If you are an ordinary citizen, you have little leverage.
If you are a celebrity whose actions can
be used to promote a political message, you may
You may become a convenient target.
But, if you control access to technology
that the country desperately needs, the authorities
may discover a surprising capacity for patience.
This is not a new phenomenon in Chinese politics.
It is a familiar principle.
Rules are strict for ordinary people
but flexible for those who possess something the powerful
want.
And that brings us to the Little Pinks.
The term generally refers to young Chinese
nationalists who aggressively defend the government
and attack people they believe
have insulted China. They are often portrayed
as spontaneous patriots defending national dignity.
But that description misses an important part of the story.
Nationalist anger in China is not always spontaneous.
It is often encouraged,
redirected, and sometimes quietly switched off. To understand this,
we need to distinguish between the little pinks
and the so-called 50-cent army.
The latter refers to people allegedly paid
to post pro-government comments online.
The Little Pinks, by contrast, are generally ordinary Internet users
who sincerely believe they are defending their country.
That sincerity is precisely what makes the phenomenon powerful.
Many of these young people
grew up in an information environment where
the government has enormous influence over what they
can see, read, and discuss.
They are constantly exposed to messages about national humiliation,
foreign hostility, China's rise,
and the need to defend national dignity.
There is nothing wrong with loving one's country.
Patriotism can be entirely healthy.
The problem begins when patriotism is defined
as unquestioning loyalty to a political party,
and when disagreement with the government
is automatically treated as hostility towards the nation
Once those ideas become mixed together,
Criticism of the government can easily
be presented as an attack on China itself,
and the authorities have learned how to use that confusion.
Look at the way nationalists' reactions have
developed around different international events.
Look at what happened in 2016, when Tsai Ing-wen
and her Democratic Progressive Party won Taiwan's presidential
and legislative elections.
Nationalist anger quickly spread across mainland Chinese social media.
Thousands of Chinese internet users found ways around
the Great Firewall to flood Cai's
Facebook page with hostile pro-China comments,
even though Facebook is blocked in mainland
China.
A platform normally inaccessible
to ordinary Chinese citizens suddenly became a battlefield
when it served Beijing's political interests.
Beijing also responded with military exercises
near Taiwan. The message was clear.
Taiwan's election result was not something Chinese
nationalists were expected to accept quietly.
Then came the South China Sea arbitration ruling
This morning in July 2016.
An international tribunal in The Hague rejected
the legal basis for China's expensive maritime
claims. Chinese state media portrayed the ruling
as an attack on China's national interests,
and the nationalist angle exploded online.
Some protesters took to the streets targeting
American businesses, particularly KFC restaurants,
and calling for boycotts.
But when these protests threatened to get out of control,
state media began urging people to remain calm.
The same system that had helped stir up patriotic
anger now wanted to contain it.
A year later, the controversy over South Korea's deployment
of the THAAD missile defense system produced another wave
of nationalist outrage.
Chinese consumers were encouraged to boycott South Korean products,
and the Lotte, which had provided land for the missile defense system,
became a particular target.
Its stores across China faced boycott and closures.
But nationalist anger is selective.
It does not always follow a consistent set of principles. It
follows political signals.
This is why I would divide Little Pinks into four broad categories.
The first group consists of those who respond to the whistle.
They become angry when official media
or influential accounts signal that a particular
person, country, or company has insulted China.
They may have paid little attention
to the issue before, but once the signal arrives, they join the attack.
The second group is selective in whom they criticize,
They are much more aggressive toward
people who have little power or influence,
but considerably more cautious when dealing with
powerful figures. They may attack
a Taiwanese entertainer for attending a political event,
yet find excuses for a business leader whose company
is economically important to China.
The third group consists of what we might call graphics card patriots.
They loudly demand
technological independence and condemn American companies,
but still want access to the latest
Nvidia graphics cards and chips.
They want the benefits of American technology
while denouncing the country and the companies that produce it.
The fourth group consists of the bill payers.
These are ordinary people who ultimately bear
the economic costs of political campaigns and nationalist boycotts.
When businesses lose customers, workers may lose jobs.
When international relationships
deteriorate, ordinary companies
and employees often suffer the consequences.
Ironically, the little pinks
who shout the loudest about defending national dignity are
often the ones who pay the highest price for it.
These categories are not mutually exclusive.
A person can belong to more than one, but they reveal a common problem.
Much of this nationalist
is not built on independent judgment.
It is built on emotional reactions shaped by political messaging.
And there is another reason this happens.
Many people have never experienced the full force of
political system they so enthusiastically defend.
When life is relatively comfortable, when the
economy is growing, and when the government appears powerful,
it is easy to believe that the
system is working perfectly.
It is easy to assume that the people who criticize it must be enemies.
troublemakers or victims of foreign propaganda.
But what happens when you become the target?
Consider the early days of the COVID outbreaks in Wuhan.
Dr. Li Wenliang and other medical
professionals tried to warn people about the dangerous new virus.
Instead of being treated
as people raising legitimate concerns,
they were reprimanded for spreading rumors.
The public eventually learned
that the warnings had been real. But by then,
the opportunity to respond earlier had been lost.
In a political environment where people
are encouraged to repeat approved opinions,
many gradually lose the habit of questioning what they hear.
They learn to identify which
opinions are safe, which opinions are dangerous,
and which people are acceptable targets.
Psychologists have demonstrated how powerful
this pressure to conform can be.
In the famous Asch conformity experiments,
participants sometimes gave an obviously incorrect answer
simply because other people in the group had given that answer.
The lesson is not that everyone is foolish,
it is that social pressure can make people
doubt their own judgment,
even when the evidence is right in front of them.
In a tightly controlled information environment,
that pressure becomes even stronger.
If everyone around you repeats the same political message,
and alternative views are censored or stigmatized,
it becomes increasingly
difficult to recognize how narrow
your information environment has become.
You may begin to believe that everyone agrees with you,
when in reality, many people are simply
afraid of disagree. And this is where
the little pink phenomenon becomes more troubling. Some of
these young nationalists
are extremely aggressive towards people they believe have betrayed the country
They may call for punishment, boycotts, or public humiliation.
Yet, they rarely ask a more important question.
What happens if the authorities decide that their
own words are unacceptable?
There have been cases in China in which people
People were punished for comments made in private online conversations,
Reports have described individuals detained
over insulting remarks about political leaders,
including messages shared in WeChat groups.
In one reported case, a person was punished for
posting a dog emoji in a group chat,
which authorities interpreted as an insult to a
political leader. The details of individual cases vary,
but the larger point is unmistakable.
In China, even private online expression can become
a matter of political enforcement.
Now return to Jensen Huang.
He can repeatedly make comments about Taiwan that would be
politically sensitive in China.
He can visit Beijing, meet senior officials,
and remain an important guest
because his company has something the Chinese government wants.
Meanwhile, an ordinary Chinese citizen may face serious consequences
for a private message
that authorities consider politically offensive.
That contrast tells us far more about the system
than any official slogan about national dignity.
If the government truly applied one consistent
standard, then the same principle would apply to everyone.
But that is not how power works
works in this environment.
The powerful receive room to maneuver.
The economically useful receive special consideration.
The ordinary citizen is expected to follow
the rules without asking too many questions.
And the little pinks are often encouraged
to direct their anger toward convenient targets
rather than examine the structure
that makes these double standards possible.
There is a final irony here.
The people who shout most loudly about
defending China's dignity often confuse
the dignity of a country with the authority of its government.
They assume that questioning the government means betraying the nation.
They believe that attacking a celebrity
or foreign company demonstrates patriotism.
The people they attack most viciously are always the weakest.
The people they are most afraid to challenge are always the strongest.
That's not patriotism. That's obedience to whoever gives the orders.
So the next time you see
the entire Chinese internet erupting over someone supposedly
insulting China, don't rush to judge what was said or who said it.
First, look at who blew the
whistle, look at who is allowed to get away with it, and who isn't.
Once you understand who holds
the power and whose throat is actually in whose hands,
everything else becomes clear.
Thank you so much for watching.
If this video was helpful, please like, subscribe, and if you are
watching on your phone, click hype right below.
It pushes this video onto the trending hype leaderboard
so more people can find my channel.
I'll be back with more content soon. Until then, be well.