Lawsuit over HBO's 'The Pitt' moves forward

Fox - 2 Detroit
22 followers
Nov 16, 2026
It's an interesting case out of Hollywood that I thought
was going to get dismissed, but it has not.
It's moving forward. A California appeals court recently ruled
a lawsuit against the hit series The Pit will move forward.
The suit was filed by the estate of Michael Crichton,
who created the long running series ER.
Jehan Crump Gibson is here from Great Lakes Legal Group,
and you can explain exactly what it is,
because it's specifically probably about Noah Wiley,
who was on ER, that is now the lead of the pit.
So what's the lawsuit that's moving forward?
Yeah, the lawsuit that's moving forward
is actually a breach of contract case.
So this is not about, oh, the pit is similar to the.
And we're going to figure out
if there's actually a copyright infringement.
That's not what this is.
Right.
Michael negotiated a contract with Warner
Brothers that specifically gave him
what we call frozen rights.
And that means if you're going to do something similar
to what I came up with, you got to
come back to me and get my approval.
And then I need to be able to negotiate
to see if I can get some money out of this.
Yeah, that doesn't seem right because actors play a variety of roles
and some roles they go back to.
But when you see the pit,
I don't think you think of the guy on the yard, do you?
Well, you may not, but it comes down to the contract language.
That's why it's so important to focus on this being
a contract case and not just a typical.
They stole my idea, right?
So whatever the actual contract document says
and how it lays out and defines what is a
similar show, that's what the court is going to take a look at.
Does the fact that they moved forward after the appeal,
the appeals court said, no, this
case can go forward.
Does that bode well for Warner Brothers, who's bringing the suit?
Does that make, in the legal opinion,
just an opinion, does that make this suit more
viable?
Maybe, maybe not.
So in any lawsuit when you file, cases are going
to get to a point where someone's going
to file a motion to get rid of it, right,
and tell the court there's not enough evidence
to move forward with this.
Well, the court didn't agree.
So at least there's enough to move forward and get to trial.
In those cases, sometimes people go,
listen, let's just cut a check, right?
We don't want to go through the expense of a trial,
but I don't know what Warner Brothers
and their lawyers are thinking.
So it's kind of hard because then you
You say, can this guy, Noel Wiley,
take another job where he plays a doctor?
I mean, in any case, and is it similar?
Sure.
It's an emergency room.
The other show was literally called ER.
Literally.
And now he works in an emergency room, but they called it The Pit.
I could see where the case could win.
But in that case, does that mean they get part of his money
or the whole production's money?
It's interesting because he plays Dr. Robbie in this new show.
The suit actually against him individually.
Got dismissed, it's not moving forward
because they were trying to claim what we call tortious
interference so that he knew that there
was some business relationship and he interfered
with it.
And the court did decide there wasn't enough evidence for that.
So he's not getting sued, he's free to move forward
and act an executive produce as though
he's been doing.
So the production company or producer HBO,
they're the ones who are gonna have to pay.
Yeah, Warner Brothers
who Michael had the contract with is who's gonna be on the
hook for.
Wow.
Wow.
Yeah.
That is fascinating to me.
Super fascinating.
What's even more fascinating is it's
not Michael, you know, Michael passed away.
Yeah.
So it's literally his estate bringing these claims.
Wow.
Yeah.
I can see more of this stuff happening.
For sure.
Prince's estate, Michael Jackson's estate.
You never know.
I mean, you never know who it's going to be.
Thank you.
We appreciate the legalese.
Always glad to be here and give it.
Jehanne Crump Gibson, you can check her out
at Great Lakes Legal Group, their website
and phone number at this, on your screen right there,
Great Lakes, Great Lakes Legal Group.
GL legal group.com. I had to lean into it.
I can't see it at all. We'll be right back.
