Russia's war on Ukraine: 'Americans want to have a deal whatever the cost for both Ukraine & Europe'

FMM - F24 Video Clips
25 followers
1 Video View·Nov 16, 2026
We can now bring in Grégoire Rousse,
director of the Europe and Russia and Eurasia programs
at Chatham House.
Thank you very much for joining us on the program today.
First of all, your reaction to this report
in RFI that French troops have been operating
on the ground in Ukraine for months, albeit in non-combat positions.
Hello.
Thank you for having me.
I think I would not overdo it.
It's indeed something that had not been disclosed publicly.
And it will not go without its challenges, especially on legal grounds,
mostly because Parliament had not been informed.
and according to article 35
of the French constitution parliament is supposed to be
informed within a couple of days following
the decision by the president to send troops
in a military operation
but the question is is this a military operation clearly not the idea
is to support Ukrainians maintaining French equipment closer
to the to the to the to the frontline
I would also add that this is not really new.
Britain had the knowledge,
sending engineers to do the exact same thing in Ukraine.
So the only impact I see is honestly in the French presidential
election campaign where obviously some candidates will.
Make the most of the argument to combat and criticize President Macron
and push most certainly for a more balanced approach
to the French support policy vis-à-vis Ukraine.
I want to ask about the upcoming peace talks, because you heard
that I was talking to our correspondent on the ground in Kyiv
and the Europeans seem to will be represented by five countries,
including France, Germany, Italy,
the UK and Poland at the next round of peace talks.
What do you make of the fact that it is five voices and not one?
Well, I know it's been a discussion
that the Europeans have had for quite some time.
There are strong arguments for both options,
so having several representatives that would
actually underline the diversity of standpoints.
Let's not forget, as your reporter stressed,
that it's not just about the EU, it's also
about other non-EU European powers,
such as the UK, which is perhaps the country that
I don't exaggerate in saying matters the most
because it's been the first country to really
show Ukraine support in the aftermath of the invasion.
The other option is to realize that it dilutes
the negotiating power of Europe, and I would
lean towards that.
I think if you look at what we would need, would...
What best profile would fit for such a negotiation?
I honestly think we have that person.
You need someone who understands the differences of the viewpoints,
the French, especially the E3.
So London, Paris, Berlin,
and two other countries that matter quite a bit,
like Italy and Poland.
You need someone who understands the battlefield
and the proximity with Russia,
so from a country from the immediate neighborhood.
And you need someone who has the trust of both parties,
especially the Americans.
That person is called Alexander Stubb, the president of Finland.
He is someone who studied in France, speaks French,
studied in the UK, knows the UK political elite
very well, lived in Italy, understands how Italians think.
There's a strong culture of pacifism and,
of course, understands the reality of the
Baltics, of Northern Europe.
And he is someone who has the respect of Donald Trump.
You might remember that last year he spent
a half a day playing golf with him.
I mean, it means something in the mindset
and the way of working of Donald Trump.
So the question is, does the E3, do London,
Paris and Berlin would accept someone?
To, in a way, take the limelight in their stead.
I'm not so sure at this stage.
There is a very thin window.
It is either now or after the French presidential election.
Given the uncertainty of who might become the president,
and as we look at the polls now,
Marine Le Pen is poised to become president.
Doesn't mean she will, but it looks good for her.
It's very likely that she would oppose such a step.
So the idea would really be to have someone who sits at the council
or at least has a strong political mandate.
So it has to be a head of state or government
and who understands the different stakeholders.
And I think the Ukrainians would back
the idea of having Alexander Stubb.
I want to ask about the European
and the U.S. approach going into the next round of talks,
because just today the EU has imposed sanctions
on Russia's richest woman.
This seems to be in stark contrast to the U.S.'s approach,
where we saw restrictions on diesel exports lifted and what have you.
Will there eventually be a clash between
the U.S. and the European position,
or is this going to be good cop, bad cop?
Well, I think both.
You might end up with a clash if the Americans do absolutely want
to have a deal, whatever the cost, for both Ukraine and Europe.
At the moment, I think it could be good cop, bad cop,
but I'm not sure that it's part of the American strategy.
Thank
Everyone is trying in that negotiation
to retain some kind of strategic relevance.
And in terms of strategic relevance,
the toolbox for Europe is very limited.
So sanctions are hurtful,
even if the Russians say that they can absorb the cost, the blow.
you.
And for the Americans, it weakens their position
because it shows that the so-called Western bloc
is not as united as they would like it to be.
So, the Europeans do not have much choice
but to intensify pressure on the Russians, who, by the way,
have done anything but to abandon their maximalist demands, because
if you actually look at the demands at the moment, they're not very...
Far away from the demands, the list they had sent Karen Donfield
at the U.S. State Department in December 21,
so less than three months before the invasion,
in terms of maximizing the security of Russia
by diminishing the presence of NATO at their border.
So at this stage, I don't see a direct clash.
There might be, if the White House specifically wants
to impose on the Ukrainians and on the
Europeans, an agreement that would simply
not just endanger Ukraine, but also endanger
Europe, and that is still possible.
But what do you make of these recent demands?
Because apparently there were some reports
that Ukraine was told by the Americans
that they could give up the Donbass and get membership to NATO.
And also one of the positions from the Russians
was for Finland to leave NATO,
which it just joined.
So it seems that the Russians haven't budged much, have they?
No, it's what I refer to by maximalist demands.
It's a way of testing the unity of the Western bloc.
It's a way of...
Breaking, to be honest, what remains of the transatlantic unity.
And thirdly, I think on this specific point
of having Ukraine accept relinquish to relinquish Donbass
in exchange for a seat at the NATO table.
First of all, it's not new. It's something that we've heard time
and again in terms of proposals from the Russians.
Second, President Zelensky didn't say no.
He said that in any case, should this were a serious...
um kind of of agreement it would in any case
not depend on his decision it would be submitted to
the ukrainian people through a referendum
and the second point is it would also require unanimity
within nato members for ukraine to join
and today i'm not so sure that all countries would be
willing to see Ukraine join.
Spain has been...
undecisive. Germany would need absolute reassurance
that it will strengthen European security.
The Belgian Prime Minister said that he was not so keen on the idea,
and Hungary and Slovakia
and a few other countries from Central
and Eastern Europe are also not convinced. So
I think at this stage it's mostly rhetoric.
It's really to increase pressure on Zelensky.
But if you look at how the level
of flexibility that both parties have showed.
It doesn't require to be the advocate of Ukraine to recognize looking
at the facts that President Zelensky has showed much more flexibility
in the negotiation thus far than the Kremlin has.
On Thursday, the Russian president will be rubbing shoulders
and meeting with Donald Trump and Xi Jinping.
Where does Europe fit into all of this?
Because once again, the Kremlin is succeeding in displaying
to the world that Vladimir Putin is not isolated on the world stage
and he's actually sitting down with the leaders
of the world's two largest economies.
Well, it always depends on how you define isolation.
If it's just to have a nice picture, very few people are isolated.
Even the North Korean leader is not isolated because every now
and then he can enjoy a nice picture with a world leader.
So I don't think that isolation
or integration can be assessed against the backdrop
of how many supposedly friendly leaders you can be pictured with.
I would look at what can be expected
from the meeting to decide
to reassess whether the Europeans
are losing much. I don't expect
anything out of that show.
Donald Trump wants to,
as always, admire strong authoritarian
leaders, so he will be more than happy
to shake hands with
Putin and Xi. Xi
is actually showing that
China is a
peace broker and an
increasingly important
country and on the world stage,
especially when it comes to conflict resolution.
And indeed, Vladimir Putin not only shows
that Russia is not isolated, but that Russia is a
big power because he's on par with the two biggest powers
on the planet, China and Russia. So for the
It's really a question of personal image,
but don't expect anything meaningful coming out of
the meeting. I mean, I've read about Yalta 2.0,
where we're not close to this in any point from
which we look at it. So I'm not sure the Europeans will miss much.
They might be disappointed not to
be on the picture, but I guess they will survive.
We'll see what comes out of that meeting.
We're going to have to leave it at that.
Thank you for joining us on the program today.
Thank you very much.
