Dr. Winawer explains new prostate test rules

Fox - 5 Atlanta
15 followers
Nov 16, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
After years of controversy,
the American Cancer Society is now recommending routine prostate
cancer screenings for millions of men.
But while screening can save lives, critics warn it can also
lead to unnecessary testing and potentially harmful treatments.
So here to explain the new
guidelines and the controversy is Emory Dr. Neil Winawer.
And Dr. Winawer, it's good to have you
here. Good morning. Good to be here. Good morning, Elise.
All right, so let's dive right in. American
Cancer Society has made really a significant change
to its prostate cancer screening guidelines.
So, what's different?
In 2010, they said shared decision-making,
talk to your doctor about the risks and the
benefits of screening, the double-edged sword.
Now they've recommended routine screening.
You can still have that conversation,
but really they just recommended getting the test.
Okay, so let's get into that. What are
the new screening recommendations?
In people of average risk between the ages of 50 and 69,
they recommended getting screened
every other year. And if you were high risk,
if you had a first degree relative,
who had prostate cancer or black men have twice the risk
so if you're in that high
risk group they recommend starting screening earlier
at the age of 45 and get it every
year and then when you turn 70 between 70
and 74 that's when they talked about shared
decision making because you're older and discuss it.
Once you turn 75 or older they didn't recommend any screening
because obviously you live a
long a longer time and the benefits
of screening you know are dubious once you get
that older. You can individualize the risk.
Some really healthy 75-year-olds, they may still offer
that, but really in general, most people will
not get screened over the age of 75. Interesting. Okay,
so really varies based on age.
Yeah, that was a mouthful, right? That was a lot. That's a lot,
right. Because we stratify it according to age,
because at some point, screening won't make a
difference if you've been fortunate to survive long enough
and then earlier, but you don't want
to get screened too early because
then the false positive rate goes up as well. Yeah, makes sense.
So we know an elevated PSA doesn't necessarily mean
that someone has prostate cancer.
So what are some of the common causes of that?
And then what should men do if their PSA is elevated?
Yeah, as the prostate gets larger with age,
that's the biggest one, BPH,
but also prostatitis infection or inflammation,
even vigorous exercise or cycling,
sexual activity procedures, they all could raise the PSA.
It's not a perfect test.
And if you have an elevated PSA,
What will happen is the recommendation
is to wait between two weeks and three months
and then simply repeat the test before you jump to any conclusion.
So basically repeat the test.
So why did they decide to do this,
the American Cancer Society, to change their position after
all these years?
Because it's...
Screening looks like it reduces prostate cancer mortality
and advanced disease
and also the harms associated with screening we're getting better at.
Now we're not just running right to biopsies, we're getting MRIs,
we're looking at biomarkers and urologists themselves.
In some...
Low-risk cases are taking a watchful waiting approach,
so less aggressiveness in certain low-risk groups
are avoiding complications.
How effective are these prostate cancer screenings
when it comes to saving lives?
And then on the flip side, the downsides.
Yeah, they looked at a big European trial.
They looked at over 150,000 men for 23 years
and showed that prostate cancer screening reduced
the risk of prostate cancer death by 13%.
Now, that might seem like a good number.
But when you look, that's a relative risk.
When you look at the absolute risk, it was a quarter of a percent.
So what does that mean?
That means for every thousand men
that you screened with PSA, only two...
So I had a reduced mortality related to that screening.
So one in 500.
So you might say, well, what happens to the other 998?
Well, a certain percentage of them will have positive tests,
which will lead to diagnosis
of cancer, which may have surgery or radiation,
which could have side effects, incontinence
or impotence.
It's usually temporary, but it's pretty significant side effects.
And that person who gets surgery may think
of themselves as cancer free.
and cured but the reality is in a certain number of those men
They were going to live just the same amount anyway
and needlessly have the surgery.
But we don't know who those men are,
so they get treated kind of with the same broad brush.
And that's a double-edged sword that people worry about,
that some people will not have
a survival benefit and have to undergo these procedures.
So, you know, given the benefits
and the risks that we've talked about, what's your advice,
Dr. Winowar, for men watching?
Yeah, well, I just want to let people know
that the American Cancer Society isn't the
only society.
U.S. Preventative Service Task Force
still recommends shared decision-making.
Now, their guidelines were from 2018,
so we'll see what they say based on new emerging data.
But I'm in the shared decision-making camp right now.
I think men should educate themselves on the topic
and talk to their doctors about it.
And some men, they say, listen, if you take out my prostate,
I'm never going to get prostate cancer.
And that's the biggest thing.
For me, by far.
Other men, they say, wow, two out of a thousand?
You know what?
I don't want to potentially have issues that really affect my marriage,
per se, and really have big complications.
You know what?
I'm going to not screen.
And I think the most important thing is to educate yourself,
become familiar with this, and then make the best decision for you.
That's my personal feeling.
And we'll see what other people think.
But right now, it's still controversial in my opinion.
Very interesting.
Breaking down these new guidelines for us.
Dr. Winter, as always, appreciate you coming in.
It's my pleasure.
And lastly, if you're in a high-risk group
or have symptoms, that's completely different.
We're talking about people
who are just living their life without any problems.
Okay, important.
We're talking about men's health this morning.
We'll see you next time.
Thank you.
My pleasure.
