French presidential election: Should centrists hold a primary to challenge far right and left?

FMM - F24 Video Clips
25 followers
Nov 16, 2026
Staying in France, a crowd filled of presidential hopefuls
is jostling for attention ahead of the country's
2027 presidential election.
This is mainstream candidates that seek to derail a showdown
between the far right and ultra-left.
But centrist candidate Edouard Philippe has already rejected
the idea of a primary vote among his fellow centrist candidates.
For more on this story, I'm joined by our French...
Politics editor, Mark Perelman.
Mark, the right and the centre for the moment have many candidates.
There's even speculation that Christine Lagarde
could indeed, might throw her hat into the ring.
But regardless, what are the polls actually showing?
They're showing very worrying signs for the right and the centre-right
because they're way...
Too many candidates and a poll taken by Elab over
the weekend shows that in the presidential
race for the first round, Marine Le Pen is well ahead.
That's been the case for several months, 31 percent.
Now, Jean-Luc Mélenchon on the far left is rising.
He's still far away from Marine Le Pen, but he has taken now.
A substantial lead over all the other candidates.
Raphael Glucksmann from the Socialist Party,
who has been designated through a primary process,
is around 10%.
Jean-Luc Mélenchon is at 17%.
And all the other candidates are under 10%.
And when you look at the chart we're seeing,
you have Édouard Philippe, David Lysnard.
Teddy Riner, judo champion who just threw his hat into the ring,
Gabriel Attal and Bruno Retailleau.
So there are too many of them.
And the polls are just showing them that it
is mission impossible to win the election,
but even to go to the second round
if there are so many candidates remaining.
And this is why you're having a lot
of discussions to try to see who would
Withdraw, how that person would support the other ones.
And this is why you have the call for a primary election,
but not everyone agrees to participate
and how wide it should be.
But they're still struggling to figure out
who indeed should run, aren't they, Marc?
Yes, and there are more and more calls.
We had a thousand local officials write this morning in Le Figaro,
we need to have a primary, we're not going to survive.
Mélenchon, Le Pen face off in the second round,
we have to take matters into our own hands because it's too late.
We had the President of the Senate, Gérard Larcher.
Who is the number two in the protocol order here in France,
but also a heavyweight on the conservative side.
He has convened all the leaders of the center
and the right to get together to figure out a way to decide
who will run and who will decide to withdraw.
All the participants, sorry, all the contenders have
said they would participate, including Edouard Philippe.
But he said again, I will.
Discuss, because there's no reason not to discuss about issues,
about strategy and so on.
But under one condition, I refuse a primary election.
He has been saying this for months.
The problem for him is that you can say this when you're.
Well ahead of the others in the polls,
which was the case on the right and the center right several weeks ago,
but as we just saw now, is not the case anymore.
You have one candidate who's been rising on the right,
the mayor of Cannes, David Lysnard, who's a free market candidate.
Some are saying he's like Javier Milei in Argentina.
This might be a bit far-fetched,
but he's clearly rising in the polls,
challenging Edouard Philippe.
So the pressure is rising on Edouard Philippe.
There will also be a meeting tomorrow, Tuesday,
between the chiefs of staff of Gabriel Attal,
of Bruno Retailleau and of David Lysnard
to try to figure out how there could be a primary.
So the pressure is on Edouard Philippe.
He has always said, I refuse a primary,
but if in February I see that I have no chance,
I will withdraw.
But the others are telling him it might be too late by then.
The election is in mid-April.
Round one is April 18th.
February might be way too late.
So it's difficult to see with all the pressure applied on him
and the polls showing that he is going downwards,
Edouard Philippe totally rejecting a primary process.
process, but, uh, you know,
Lots of things can happen.
Christine Lagarde could decide to become a candidate.
We have a judo champion.
We have a former journalist.
There are over 30 would-be candidates.
Not all of them will be on the starting line.
But if the right or the center-right and the Macron heritage,
if
if we want to call it this way,
want to be able to challenge Jean-Luc Mélenchon for the second round,
they need to get their act together very, very quickly.
so
Now, as the saying goes, a week is a long time in politics.
Five months is an eternity.
Thank you for that, Mark Perriman.
you.
