Alton Brown Cooks Food | Episode 45: Mac To Basics

Creative Food Art
312 followers
9 Video Views·Nov 16, 2026
Just taking a quick break from tour to grab some clean underwear and knock out a couple videos. Thanksgiving is comin' in hot - we must hasten to gird our casseroles!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAlton Brown explores the history and science of macaroni and cheese, evolving the dish into a precise \"Version 4.0.\" By combining historical context with technical culinary principles—such as starch concentration and temperature control—he transforms a simple casserole into a gourmet, custard-like masterpiece.
Hiya, food fans. Alton Brown here.
You know, despite the fact that I'm indeed in the midst
of touring the fall leg of my stage show,
The Evening of Alton Brown, you may have heard of it,
I wanted to swing by, grab some clean underwear,
and knock out a couple of videos because
Thanksgiving doth approach it,
and thus we hasten to gird our casseroles. That's right.
Casseroles. The term, of course, French for saucepan.
It's come to mean just about any
vessel that's meant to go directly from the oven to the table.
And in America, of course, a dish
composed in such a vessel of a mishmash of ingredients,
often including, but not limited
to leftover meats, vegetables, and or starch products.
More often than not, a processed
ingredient or two like potato chips
or cream of mushroom soup are included. Now,
You can go on and on about turkey, okay?
I know I've gone on and on about turkey for 27 years.
But the truth is, as far as I'm concerned,
Thanksgiving is National Side Dish Day,
and the side dishes I like best are indeed casseroles.
Now, this week, we will begin with the big dog on the block,
the must-have as far as I'm concerned, macaroni and cheese.
And if you think you know my mac and cheese, and in this case,
I mean baked mac and cheese, well, you don't, okay?
Because we just finished rebuilding it
and renovating it and retrofitting it.
And what I'm about to show you, I have never shown anyone before.
So, unless I've gotten it wrong,
I think this is mac and cheese version...
4.0. But first, a wee bit of history, okay?
Now, cheese and noodles, of course, one of the grand
old couples of cuisine going back
to at least 13th century Italy. So really...
I can only really hit some high points here,
things that I think are interesting.
Now, for instance, late 14th century England,
right, the chief master cooks of the court
of Richard II, the king, wrote a recipe collection
which came to be known as the form of curry,
curry from the old French,
Korea, yeah, yeah, yeah.
meaning cooking.
And in it is a procedure for a dish called
Macraos, Macraos, which apparently is an early form of macaroni.
It is composed of boiled pasta, layers of butter,
grated hard cheese, probably Parmesan, in fact.
Now, I will read it to you because I can speak Middle English.
Okay, take and make a thin foil of dough and curve it
on pieces and caft them on boiling watt and feep it.
Well, take cheese and grate it,
this was probably the parmesan, and butt-caft, benign
enough is, and above as, loffins, and so forth.
Okay.
It's not exactly the mac and cheese we know of today,
but it's a start in the right direction.
Okay, I'm going to jump to 1755.
A British army surgeon named Dr. Richard Shockberg wrote a song
to make fun of American soldiers,
and he calls it Yankee Doodle. And in the lyrics,
there's a line about referring to a feather stuck into a cap macaroni,
referencing a foppish
Type of English male dandy of the day
who having visited Italy,
adopted a fancy continental mode of dress and manners
and was thus referred to derisively as a macaroni.
What's this got to do with food?
Not one damn thing.
Okay, we're gonna jump forward now to 1769.
English cookery writer and entrepreneur Elizabeth Raffald
publishes the Experienced English Housekeeper
In which he says, to quote,
I'm not going to try to impersonate her, of course.
She's going to dress macaroni, okay, with parmesan cheese.
That's how she said parmesan.
Amazon.
She said one should boil four ounces
of macaroni until it be rather quite tender
and lay it on a sieve tray to drain and then put it in a tossing pan
with about a gill of good cream.
That's like half a cup, I think.
A lump of butter rolled in flour.
Boil it five minutes, put it on the plate,
lay all over the parmesan, toast it, send it to the
table on a warm plate for soon it gets cold.
So, milk sauce thickened with flour and butter with
grated cheese parmesan noodles.
Recognizable, still far from modern. Okay, now, 1787,
during his five years in Europe,
Thomas Jefferson, a man credited with inventing
Damn near everything he touched at one time
or another was in Naples where he saw a pasta
extruding machine which he later sketched and he
also copied down a recipe for pasta. Now we know
he purchased dried noodles which he had shipped to Monticello,
his home, and he served it at a
dinner party. But despite what you may have heard,
Jefferson did not in any way, shape, or form
invent macaroni and cheese any more
than he invented helicopters or lasers.
Okay, over the next several decades,
multiple recipes for various forms of mac and cheese
were published, culminating, in my opinion,
with the Rosetta Stone of Mac and Cheese,
the 1890 edition of the White House Cookbook,
which presented three distinct approaches.
Okay, there's macaroni and cheese,
pasta layered with grated cheese, butter, milk, cream,
topped with cracker crumbles, and baked, sound familiar, timbale.
of macaroni this is an egg bound form resulting in a firm molded dish
and macaroni a la creme
sorry a mixture of butter and flour thickened milk
grated cheese incorporated to make
a sauce served over the pasta so by this time
It's also important to note that American cheese,
which is to say our version of cheddar,
business was booming, in part due to creation
of factories like this that allowed for the centralization,
the pooling of dairy resources from many farms.
Ditto the pasta industry.
By the dawn of the 20th century,
companies like Omaha's Skinners made dry pasta a staple,
Specifically, the long hollow tubes known as
And America's appetite for dry noodles only increased
with the influx of Italian immigrants
who, unless they were from Naples,
which seemed to always have pasta, had never been able
to get their fill of the stuff.
Oh, then the big breakthrough, 1937.
Food manufacturer Kraft.
I figured out a manufactured cheese mixture
containing emulsifying salts like trisodium
citrate which allowed for the creation
of a smooth cheese sauce from a shelf-stable
packet of powder.
Fully modern, cheddar-y, well, pretty cheddar-y,
and instant, the stovetop version was born.
Now, to me, the true macaroni
and cheese is that casserole that so many 19th century cooks
strove for, and in my newest iteration,
and hopefully my last, depends on the deft use
of starch in two forms
and an egg to pull it all together like a custard.
Shall we?
Let's.
A casserole, of course, requires a casserole,
or at the very least, a baking dish.
I am using a three-and-a-half-quart model.
This is made by Le Creuset.
It doesn't mean I'm fancy or French.
Now, you could, if you wish,
use a clear baking dish, such as this Pyrex model.
I just don't think that it looks quite as good coming to the table.
And it cooks a little faster,
which I don't know that I'd like for this.
So, we need to lubricate.
Not too liberally, but not, you know, don't go mean on it either.
Butter, I just like to use the whole stick while it's cold.
And something I always remember when I'm buttering a dish like this,
and this is a line by my favorite military sergeant,
Sergeant Apone from the film Aliens,
who told everyone, watch those corners.
In fact, when you do this,
you're probably just going to have to get dirty.
Kick things off by setting your oven to 350 degrees,
bake if you've got that, and make sure
that you've got an oven rack in the middle of the box.
Now, the heart of our mac and cheese is going
to be a Mornay sauce, which is a cheesy béchamel.
And a béchamel, of course, is a little more than
milk thickened by a roux, which is a combination,
equal parts by weight, of all-purpose flour
Okay, the milk.
Which makes up the bulk of the sauce, can certainly be flavored,
which is what we're going to do first.
So I'm going to combine 12 ounces each whole milk,
and half and half, all right,
and this three quart-ish saucier pan. Sauce pan's fine too.
And add one large shallot. That should be minced.
Okay.
Okay, thank you.
And one minced shallot, and a tablespoon and a half of dry mustard.
And a single...
Bay leaf.
Now, I know what at least half of you are saying out there.
Bay leaf, but trust me on this, all right?
Okay, whisk those together, and then park over medium-low heat.
We're going to bring this not even to a simmer, just like 175 degrees,
which should take five minutes, probably maybe six, at this heat level.
We don't want to go much more than that.
A few degrees would be okay, but we don't want the milk to curdle or...
Coagulate, which it could,
especially if you bring it to a boil,
which you do not want to do.
So whisk often and do check with a thermometer.
All right, when this hits 175-ish,
I'm gonna kill the heat.
Cover and steep for 10 to 12 minutes.
Okay.
Now, remove the bay leaf. It's done all of its work,
and you don't want it hanging around in there.
Now, if you don't want to dirty another saucepan,
go ahead and move this mixture to a thermos for thermal containment,
because we do need it warm.
Then just to wash the pot, and then we'll move to the pasta step,
where we will introduce nine ounces of dry elbow macaroni.
I know nine seems like a strange amount, but trust me on this.
Also, trust me on the fact
that I don't I don't actually use elbow macaroni for this
I hate elbow macaroni for everything but cold macaroni salad,
which is another show altogether. So for mac and cheese
Baked or stovetop, I vastly prefer cavatappi,
a beguilingly complex shape, essentially a hollow
helix with a grooved exterior,
supposedly invented accidentally at the Bria factory in the 60s and
named after the springy dance steps
of pop sensation Adriano Celentano. Whether that's
true or not, I don't know. He was in La Dolce Vita,
doesn't matter. Anyway, cavatappi is,
It is to my mind the perfect shape for mac and cheese.
and cheese because the springs kind of intertwine,
thus providing structural support for the finished dish.
Again, nine ounces dry of whichever you want to use.
Now to the pasta add two teaspoon kosher salt
and then pour on just enough cold water
to completely cover the noodles by half an inch of water.
Now I know,
This is freaky. We've all been taught for so long
to use massive amounts of water because, of course,
supposedly the thermal recovery is faster, yada, yada,
yada, keeps it from sticking. But it's not really true.
You don't have to use all that water with modern heat control.
And besides, this method will be much faster.
We'll use less energy and we'll have super.
Starchy water left over, which we are going to take advantage of.
All right, bring this to a boil.
You are going to have to stir this often, though, to prevent sticking.
That is the one downside to this method,
but it's not that big of a deal.
You need to be here anyway, small price.
All right, stir often until just barely al dente.
That is until it provides a pleasant...
Yet ultimately yielding struggle
to the intrusion of the tooth.
And it kind of gums up in your molars.
Nobody ever mentions that, but it does, it gets gummy.
It'll take six minutes after first bubble break,
approximately.
Perfect.
Okay, when the pasta's done,
you are going to drain it through a colander. But make sure
you set that colander inside another vessel,
like a big bowl, so that you capture that
starchy water, which has got all kinds of uses as a thickener.
Why? Well, think of it
this way. All the starches, a lot of starches,
just leached off of the noodles.
starch and that starch was mostly gelatinized during
the extrusion process meaning it's not in
little capsule wads anymore it's
in big open structures like this these are this is a big
Polysaccharides, okay?
And once they're all out in the water,
they can tangle up with each other,
which will certainly increase the viscosity
of whatever liquid they're in.
It's the secret ingredient to a lot of Italian dishes,
especially pasta dishes.
I mean, you go to a really good Italian restaurant,
they almost always finish the sauce
with a little bit of that pasta water
and then reduce it to tighten it up a little bit.
Polysaccharides, that's what they do.
I almost forgot, we need a half cup of this magic elixir for our pasta,
for our mac and cheese.
Not only is this going to provide a bit
of a starchy boost for the béchamel sauce that
we're getting ready to make,
it will also provide an environment in which we can
use to introduce our egg. More on that in a moment. To the fridge!
Move to, move your watery remains to airtight containment
and then chill thoroughly and use
within a week to tighten up sauces.
Heck, I even use it in some cakes to modify their texture.
We'll get into that another time.
If you don't use it within a week, just put it into ice cube
trays and freeze it. Then it will keep indefinitely.
Whatever you do, don't get rid of it because this
This stuff is gold.
Now, we build...
Our roux, the base for our sauce,
we're going to melt 23 grams of unsalted butter.
Again, the same pot, rinsed and dried,
of course, over, we'll call it medium-low heat.
Now, you want it to melt, and then you want it
to bubble to know that most of the water is cooked out.
The bubbles will start very, very small.
And then they'll get bigger.
And then you'll kind of notice that the whole circle
of bubbles starts to slowly reduce on itself
and the bubbles begin to pile up on each other.
That lets you know that most of the water is gone.
Now, when that has happened,
go ahead and sprinkle on the flour
and whisk hastily in order to disperse.
It's going to create this paste that will cook.
And that's our roux.
A roux serves two purposes.
First, it allows for the actual cooking of the flour granules,
and depending on your goal of flavor,
it could be cooked to several different degrees,
light to dark. But the darker the roux,
the deeper the flavor, like maybe for gumbo,
but the more reduced the thickening power
is as the starch is damaged by high heat.
Indeed.
But the roux, above all,
is about starch suspension or grain suspension.
You want each granule to be surrounded by fat,
and that allows for smooth integration
into the liquid to come.
The importance of the roux, especially in French cuisine,
cannot be overstated, as it
is the root of two major sauce families,
stock-based veloutés and the dairy-based béchamel,
which is the way that we are going today.
I really should have some kind of witty model here
or a puppet or something.
But honestly, I got to get back on the tour bus.
So did I mention?
Yeah, I did.
All right, when the roux looks like this,
and it's not going to take very long, go ahead
and quickly whisk in paprika, one and a half teaspoons,
sorry about that, of sweet or hot
paprika, up to you, and whisk 15, 20 seconds.
So the paprika, which has fat-soluble flavors,
can open up the bloom, if you will.
There. And then we're going to gradually
Whisk in the warm dairy, being sure to work it in smoothly as you go.
If you just dump it all in, it's going to clump no matter what.
So go slowly.
And yes, there's going to be hissing, and that's okay.
Strictly speaking, the fat-coated granules should not clump,
but the slower the slurry comes together, the better.
All right, once all the amount is in, just keep...
Keep it over a gentle simmer, whisking often,
constantly, for maybe three minutes or until
all the starch is fully gelatinized
and the sauce will coat the back of a spoon, like this.
The French call this nappé,
which sounds like what I like to take in the afternoon
after I eat all the macaroni and cheese in that.
Now, we're going to remove this from the heat,
just kill that, and we're going to let it cool
to about 145 to 150 degrees. Why?
Well, simply put, there's just too much energy in the pot,
and if we leave that in here, then the cheese will get in.
It won't just melt. It'll break
into its component parts, protein and fat,
and we do not want that to happen.
Now would also be a good time to prepare
our physical reinforcement, if you will.
Now, the flour in our sauce is certainly going to thicken it,
but I would like to have
the interior set just slightly in a gel-like way,
a little bit of coagulation, the way a custard would.
So, the way I figure it,
why not bring the active ingredient of a custard, which is an egg.
So, I'm going to beat one.
And then add half a cup of the reserved starch water.
Now, we could just beat this into almost any liquid,
or we could do an old-fashioned tempering
where we take some of the hot béchamel
and add to the egg and then add it back,
but that could curdle it.
So I'm just gonna beat this with that half.
cup of reserved water. The starch in the water will
also help to reinforce what we've already
going on in the sauce,
and it will provide a liquidous phase for the egg to disperse in.
You understand what I'm saying?
That was kind of confusing. That's fine.
All right, still with our young béchamel off the heat,
whisk in the egg and pasta water mixture,
nice and slowly. I mean, truth is,
nothing bad should be able to happen here if you just dumped
it, but we're gonna play it safe.
There, once that is in, we can turn our attention to the cheese.
Speaking of cheese it's time
to do a little bit of grating. We require five
ounces of cheddar cheese.
Sharp cheddar cheese, not aged. Aged cheddar cheese
would be a little on the dry side
and its proteins are a little fussy when it
comes to melting. So just sharp.
We're also going to need a total of eight
ounces of Monterey Jack cheese.
This is actually 14. I'm gonna use like one and
a fraction of this. We can mix five ounces each of the the cheddar
and the the Monterey Jack and
then we'll need three alone of the Monterey Jack for the topping.
And I'm just going to do this
into a paper plate, got some water on there,
and weigh it as I go and make sure that I do
a tare weight on the on the bowl. There we go.
So just the large side of the holes there.
There's absolutely no reason to try to grate it any smaller than this.
We want a slow melt, and if we were to do a really small, fine grind,
we might end up with a faster melt than we want.
And if there's a couple of little clumps in there,
that's absolutely fine.
I know that some people would just measure away
the entire piece of cheese
and then grate the whole thing.
Have you ever tried to grate the last quarter ounce of cheese?
It's like, oh, my knuckles are in there.
A
tear.
The Monterey Jack tends to be softer,
so go gently.
I've used a lot of different cheeses.
It's taken me a long time to settle
on this
particular
mixture
Thank you, thank you, thank you very much.
I mean,
I'm your old one.
All right, and now three ounces for the topping,
and this is where things are gonna get a little,
I could always just like save this
and start over with this one.
Is this exact science?
Do you have to hit these exact numbers?
Yes and no.
You could go more on the topping,
but I wouldn't go more into the combo
that we're gonna be melting into the sauce.
That's a rather precise amount.
Perfection.
All right, set aside, don't set aside.
When it comes to integrating the cheese,
I usually switch from the whisk, which would
you know get loaded up with cheese like a big club,
to a plastic or rubber spatula,
silicone spatula.
And we're going to work this in in installments, we'll say
three to four installments.
Now there's enough heat still in the béchamel to melt
The first two installments, but as you get more
and more cheese in, you're going to notice
that it doesn't melt all the way.
It stays kind of intact, and I like that because I want some of it
to actually melt in the oven.
It's a subtle point, but one that I appreciate.
All right, final seasonings.
One teaspoon of freshly ground white pepper. I like the flavor
of white pepper, and I also appreciate the fact
that I'm not going to see a lot of little
black dots in the mac and cheese. I don't like that.
And we'll go with a half a teaspoon of
kosher salt. I know there's some salt in the pasta from the water,
and the cheese can be salty,
but it always needs more. There we go.
All right. Nothing left to do but to fold in the cooked pasta.
We want to really get that
worked in there so that the cheese can start working
its way into all those little holes.
Now into the prepared pan.
You will notice that not all of the cheese is melted.
In fact, only about three quarters of it is.
This is exactly as we want it
because we do want some of it to actually melt
down into the noodles when it is in the oven.
So that is also going to be kind of an insurance policy
against this sauce breaking anywhere
while it is still in the pan.
I'll lick this out later.
There, just kind of smooth that over.
I want this to sit on the counter for about 10 minutes.
And a lot of that has to do with allowing time
for the sauce to kind of soak in
or migrate into all of those little open tools.
I don't want a lot of air pockets in there.
So what I'm gonna do is just kind
of give it a jiggle,
you know, shake its money maker, you know, there.
And now I'm gonna go ahead and top with the remaining
Monterey Jack cheese, just sprinkle that over.
It's okay if that just sits there.
If it starts to melt a little, it's no big deal.
But at this point, the stuff's down to room temperature
because remember,
we refrigerated the cheese.
If you happen to go four ounces instead of three,
I mean, nobody's gonna call the cops.
All right, panko.
By panko, I mean, of course, panko breadcrumbs,
which will provide our crumbly, crisp topping.
So, melt three tablespoons of butter in a small skillet.
And then, of course, let it bubble so
some of that water cooks out, like we did with the roux.
And when it just starts to turn gold,
the butter, that is, add a cup of panko breadcrumbs —
not regular or Italian breadcrumbs,
Japanese-style panko breadcrumbs — and half a teaspoon
Kosher salt. And just cook over like, you know,
medium-low heat, just keeping it moving until the
crumbs are nice and toasted.
It'll take three to four minutes tops.
Perfect. Now just sprinkle
over the mac and cheese.
Try to get it as evenly as possible. Do not pack it down,
no matter what you do. We want it
to be able to brown a little bit more.
And if you pack it down into the cheese, that's not going to happen.
If I'd let this cool down more, I could have done this with my fingers.
It's a little on the hot side.
Oven's
ready.
A little hot, maybe.
To
the
oven!
A little more than 150.
That is fine.
We just want to make sure...
I'm going to make sure that this makes it all the way up to 160 degrees
because that's what's recommended by the FDA for making sure
that that one egg is safe. Texture looks good.
We've got nice browning. I'm going to cover with not one
but two layers of kitchen towel just to kind of keep it insulated
while it rests and the temperature rises a little further.
I do not want to put foil over this.
Because that would hold in the evaporation,
that would result in condensation,
that would mean puddles of water on top of my macaroni
and cheese, and I just don't want that.
I'll be back. You rest well.
So, how many servings do you think?
Depends. Could be six, could be eight.
I guess you could squeeze ten if you want.
But if you're serious, and I think you will be once you taste it.
All right.
You're not going to want to share it, all right.
You're going to see this as a serving for one.
It's going to take you a little bit of time
to finish it, but if you dedicate yourself,
I'm sure you can do it. Up to you completely.
Now, if you'll excuse me, I am going to devour
a goodly portion of this, and I know how you guys are.
You do not want to watch each cheesy,
succulent, yet ever
so slightly crunchy mozzarella be slowly devoured while little
A little bit of buttery goodness runs,
you know, down my chin, onto my neck.
No, because that's going to make sound,
and we know that offends some of you terribly.
So, I will bid you adieu until next time.
Oh, oh, crap, I almost forgot.
If you happen to have leftovers, okay, okay,
you can slice the leftovers into wedges and bread them
and pan fry them, and then they look like this.
If you're interested in that, that recipe is on my website.
Just type in fried and mac and cheese, and you'll have it.
Okay, see you next time on...
