Lawrence: Decency WON in Ohio | The Last Word Weekly Highlights

World 360
1 follower
Nov 16, 2026
Watch some of the best segments this week from 'The Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell' and watch weeknights at 10pm EST on MS NOW.
AI Generated·May contain errors
The Wall Street Journal reports
this about Donald Trump's new chief of staff, Stephen Miller.
An early test for Miller, according to associates of the president,
is whether he can satisfy Trump's
desire to punish his perceived political enemies.
One of Trump's biggest frustrations with
Wiles, according to administration officials,
is that she and the Justice Department weren't doing
enough to go after people seen as leaking classified material,
to jail reporters who
to publish such material and to prosecute his opponents.
How the Justice Department has collapsed
into being Donald Trump's revenge department is the
story told in Rachel Maddow's new book,
Department of Fate, the Promise, the Power,
and the Collapse of America's Most Consequential Institution.
The book traces how the Justice
Department has wielded power over the course of its 150-year history
and concludes with this.
If the Justice Department, for all its flaws and failures,
is the means by which we effectuate
the protections of the U.S. Constitution,
then a revolutionary effort to end those constitutional
protections and thereby to end the Constitutional Republic must
also end the Justice Department.
Or at least render it comically inept.
And so that's where we are.
Not with the Justice Department being wielded
by an ascendant would-be dictator as a shield
and sword, as many warned us to expect,
but with it flailing, at best a bystander, and
at worst a feckless abettor to its boss's predations.
Under America's 21st century authoritarian leader,
DOJ has been rendered irrelevant and
vestigial.
It's still dangerous and potentially consequential.
Now, only in the way a defective firework is or a broken gun,
it can still kill, just
not in the manner or at the time you might intend.
When Trump's reign has ended,
the first order of business in the country will be to
refound a new Department of Justice for all of us
and properly this time.
for good. Joining us now is Rachel Maddow.
She's host of The Rachel Maddow Show, as you may have
heard. It's here on MSNBC.
And her new book is, I'm going to say it again, Department of Fate,
The Promise, The Power, and the Collapse
of America's Most Consequential Institution.
It'll be available. You can take one home
from your bookstores tomorrow. Rachel, I've got a
question for everyone. Lawrence,
thank you so much for reading the whole thing. The first one is on
On page seven.
But so, so one, the...
I love many things about it,
but it's one of those books that tells us that.
It wasn't always this way, but by that, I mean,
it wasn't always the way we thought it was before
Trump. Yes. If you if your experience
of the Justice Department is post Watergate, which is
the experience of most living Americans now,
you had a right to think it was being run and operated
at the ground level and at the high levels
by people like Andrew Weissman, honorable lawyers,
honorable FBI agents.
J. Edgar Hoover stopped working there a long time ago. But it turns out
That was just a brief moment,
a brief few decades of honor in the history of the Justice
Party.
And even in those few decades, in the Reagan years,
which is post-Watergate, we had some
Ed Meese trouble there,
which is when we got the first round of William Barr, who came
back in his second round as attorney general.
He came back under Donald Trump, and that was for a reason, too.
So even when it was good, it wasn't all that good.
And that...
I basically, Lawrence, felt like after the first Trump term ended,
given what Bill Barr did there, given the targeting of Peter Strzok,
given some of the others and Lisa Page, some of the other stuff
that we saw there, I really thought that Trump was going to supersize
the Justice Department and turn it into this mega funded,
outsized, gigantic agency, which he did not do.
He did that to the Department of Homeland Security and ICE and HSI.
He did not do that to DOJ.
And instead, DOJ has withered.
And I was wrong about that.
I really thought he was going to do it the other way around.
And so I wanted to look into the Department
of Justice for my own purposes to figure out
why I was wrong about this.
But also to figure out if my memory that like, oh,
the Justice Department used to be better was maybe a short memory.
And it turns out it was. The Justice Department has
been terrible in a lot of ways under a lot
of different terrible attorneys general for the last 150 years.
Yeah. You know, so many years of our coverage about the FBI and Trump
and all that, we've always talked about these honorable FBI agents.
And I was sitting here thinking, well, J. Edgar Hoover,
like I'm old enough to remember J. Edgar Hoover.
You can't tell me.
The FBI has this history of honor.
It's great when it works,
but how you're suggesting
that not only does it have to be rebuilt,
but it has to be rebuilt with solid structures
where we can actually,
that we could rely on.
Yeah.
Like what?
Well, I think that...
If you look at sort of—this isn't
the tip-to-tail history of the Justice Department.
It's basically a half-dozen periods,
half-dozen anecdotes over the course of the history of
the Justice Department.
And I think the thing that ties together
the bad news in this history is that you had bad
guys in the Justice Department,
and the Justice Department is so powerful and so consequential.
I argue, in fact, that it is the most
consequential institution in the country.
That if you have people who are either morally unsuited
or have ill intentions for the use of
the power of that department,
they can do just a tremendous amount of damage. And that's happened
both for people who are ideological radicals
and for people who are corrupt. We've had all of those
different kinds of bad guys at the Justice Department.
And we've also had the Justice
Department do remarkably good work.
And that's when you've had good people in there.
And people who aren't ideological radicals and people
who are committed to the practical and moral foundations
of what the Justice Department is supposed to stand for.
And so I think we just need to be way more careful about
who is allowed to get a job in the Justice Department.
You should have professional.
And experiential credentials
that are stronger than what we currently require for high-level
Justice Department officials,
I think there should be a higher-level threshold for what
kind of vote you need to get in the Senate
in order to get a job like attorney general
or one of the senior assistant attorney general positions.
I also think that the oversight function
at the inspector general's office should be overhauled
to make it much more like some of the other agencies that have stronger
Inspectors General, I mean, it's not like constitutional
amendment stuff that you need to do in order to make this agency.
It's governed in a way that's more commensurate with its powers.
It's doable stuff that you could definitely do with a Democratic
and reform minded House and Senate,
certainly with a Democratic president.
But we need to start taking the Justice Department seriously.
And the collapse of the department under Trump, I think,
gives us an opportunity to refound it in a different way.
You're doing something on Wednesday that I object to,
and that is you're going to Boston without me.
I am. Would you like to come?
You're doing it.
I'm going to be on a plane.
indirectly headed to Africa. I'll get to Ethiopia in a few days.
But you're doing an event for this
book in Boston. With Nicole Wallace. On Wednesday.
And later tonight, the much better version of this
interview will be on The Daily Show with Jon Stewart,
where it's going to be at least 30
minutes or more, and you're going to be able to really let it out.
So if you don't buy the book
between now and then, after you watch Rachel on Jon Stewart,
you will be buying this book.
Lawrence, thank you very, very much.
Rich, thank you very much for joining us.
The new book, I'm going to say it again,
Department of Fate.
Just type that into your laptop right now.
The Promise, the Power, and the Collapse
of America's Most Consequential Institution.
And it is by our friend, Rachel Maddow.
People from Youngstown are proud,
proud to be from Youngstown.
And they can be tough when they need to be.
And they can be loving and kind
and wise and loyal friends.
Always ready to help a neighbor.
The media likes to use the term working class
to describe a place like Youngstown,
an industrial city on Ohio's border with Pennsylvania.
But some people in Youngstown slip out of the working class
and end up homeless,
as the next governor of Ohio did when she was a child.
And being homeless wasn't the hardest thing about her childhood.
She was raped by her stepfather at age 12.
And when she was running for governor,
Amy Acton's opponent tried to use what her stepfather
did to her against her in what was, as Jen just said,
universally regarded as the ugliest
campaign ad of this or any other campaign season.
The despicable ad run by Vivek Ramaswamy
and fully supported and still supported.
By J.D. Vance and Donald Trump used video
of Amy Acton's mother calling Amy Acton a liar.
When the ad first emerged, voters did not know that Amy Acton's mother
did not just stay married to the stepfather who raped Amy Acton.
She fled the state with him so that he could escape prosecution.
And she lived with him as a fugitive for the rest of his life,
according to Amy Acton's family.
MSNBC's Nnamdi Agwamu.
Was one of the first reporters
to get candidate Amy Acton's reaction to that ad using her mother.
You know, the last time I saw my birth mother,
I was 12 years old in a courthouse after a grand jury hearing where
my stepfather was indicted. And then, as you know, he was a fugitive.
They skipped on bail and left. That's the last time.
I'm learning things that even I don't remember,
obviously, as a 12 year old child.
We're learning more about the kinds of things he did to other children.
We're learning more about the.
Troubled life, my mother,
who was not well then since I was probably three years old
and is not well now from things that have happened in her life.
I'm sure there'll be a day where I'll be able to step back
and reflect on this, but right now...
I'm remaining laser focused
because my mission is making life better for Ohioans.
We've been on the road for two and a half years.
We've gone everywhere in the state.
And I can tell you, people are struggling.
It's never known party in my race.
But people are longing for public servants again
who actually solve problems of our lives.
One interesting thing I'll share with you,
and this was before this happened.
We've never been in a room in two
and a half years where people don't tear up when I'm speaking.
Grown men, burly men.
Everyone is exhausted of living this way.
They're tired of the hate and the chaos and the vitriol.
I think we are all ready to see that kindness is not weakness.
I'm a tough person.
I've been through a lot.
I kept saying today to everyone, I'm a scrappy kid from Youngstown.
I'm not afraid of a fight.
This is a fight I have on my hands.
But kindness isn't weakness.
It's a fierce commitment to justice,
seeing the humanity in one another.
And decency is on the ballot.
In this election and decency won in Ohio.
Oh, my goodness. Everyone.
Oh, I am so honored
to be here with all of you.
So
incredibly
honored that
I have earned
the trust of
Ohioans to be.
This was a tough race, but the campaign is over.
And I want to make something very clear
to the people of Ohio.
I will be a governor for all Ohioans
in this fight for all of us.
My promise to Ohio, to those who voted for me and those who did not,
is that I will work with anyone and everyone,
as I always have, to make life better for Ohioans.
When Amy Acton finished medical school
and obtained her license to practice medicine,
there was a fork in the road ahead of her.
Down one road was the kind of high income
and wealth that can be obtained by highly paid
physicians in this country,
and down the other road were public service and government salaries.
She chose the road less traveled by physicians
and served five different governors in Ohio from
both parties, including as Ohio's director of health.
When she talks about breathing room now,
Dr. Acton.
is talking about the financial breathing room of the people of Ohio.
They're working harder than they ever have.
There is no more breathing room.
From the grocery and gas bills, to the utilities,
to child care, to health care costs.
Ohioans are doing everything right, but they just can't get ahead.
I hear this story everywhere I go.
It isn't about party for me. It never has been. It is about
making life better for all of us. What it's like
when people look the other way when you're
struggling. As a child, I experienced abuse and neglect,
and I could have never imagined
going
from homeless to
being a doctor,
let alone
standing here,
the next
governor of all.
Today,
Because of the Ohioans who refuse to look the other way.
You have been refusing to look the other way.
I'm here because of a couple who pulled me
and my brother up on their front porch
and fed us breakfast knowing we were hungry.
I am here because of every first responder,
every teacher, every librarian,
every mentor who lifted me up and gave me a fair shot.
So this is what drives me, the belief that everyone,
everyone deserves a chance to reach
their full potential too.
I love you too.
It's unbelievable to look
at you right now.
Look at the face and the joy I've
been seeing in crowds the last few weeks,
watching you with one another. This win is for all of us.
It is for all the scrappy kids.
been underestimated and overlooked or counted out.
This is my promise to Ohio. No one will
ever be unseen by me.
No one will ever be unseen by me.
What do most politicians see
when they see someone who is homeless?
Most of them certainly don't see themselves. The
The range of personal experience.
The story that Dr. Amy Acton has about the way people live
their lives in Ohio could not be greater.
Ohio's story is one of resilience, of grit,
of grace, and yes, of hope, of hope.
Hope is what drives this movement because when we are in this together,
we can build the Ohio of our dreams.
Tonight.
One journey is coming to an end,
but a new chapter in Ohio is beginning.
Tonight,
tonight,
let us
celebrate.
Tomorrow, let us get to work.
Together, we're going to build an Ohio where
no matter where you were born, you belong.
You can build the life of your dreams
and you can be whoever you want to be.
Maybe even governor.
Thank
you.
Thank you for trusting and believing in me.
I, too, will be with you,
fighting alongside of
you every step of the way.
And leading off our coverage tonight is Ohio Governor-elect Dr.
Amy Acton, thank you very much for joining us tonight.
Thank you, Lawrence. It's so wonderful to be here.
What is it like to see that moment again?
I'm sure on winning nights like that,
it's probably not easy to remember what it
was like to be up there on that stage.
It is a week ago right now, I believe, when the race was called.
And as you heard me sniffling a little over here, it was emotional.
To see that, it was emotional.
When I said the energy in the room,
sometimes when I'm speaking, especially over the last
few weeks, you know, Sherrod Brown and I had been doing rallies,
President Obama came in,
we did a rally.
I was in awe watching the people
because you could see it change and how people were being
to one another.
The love, the excitement about being in community again,
the want to be a part of something bigger than ourselves.
It has been something that I have been witnessing
and it gives me great hope.
The final days of the campaign were dominated
by the crazy situation with that ad.
And you said, you told Nnamdi in that interview,
you said, I'm going to stay laser focused.
And you did.
I did.
How did you do that?
Was that the Youngstown toughness, keeping you laser focused?
You know, we had been on the ground for two
and a half years going everywhere.
This was a long journey.
And as we approached the end, we knew we were very competitive.
I think the night the ad was first seen,
there was also a Marist poll that came out showing us six points ahead.
But in Ohio, we take nothing for granted.
And we wanted to, my husband, by the way,
is an elementary school teacher, 44 years,
and a high school coach, a cross-country coach.
And he kept saying, you've got to run through the tape.
You know, I've been through a lot in my life, my childhood.
You know, I'm 60 years old.
The last time I had seen my birth mother
was when I was 12 in a courthouse.
So I was able to sort of hold that someplace and just keep going.
So your husband is doing the work
that was part of what saved your life.
In your speech, you talked about teachers.
You talked about librarians.
You talked about mentors.
Talk about them tonight.
I would not be here if it wasn't for the kind
of town I grew up in, Youngstown.
I kept saying on the trail, in Youngstown,
we didn't know what party you were in.
We knew what union you were in.
We knew what military branch you served in if you belonged
to a civic group with strange hats people wore back then.
We knew where you worshipped,
and we knew what food you made from the country you came from.
But the thing I remember most growing up in Youngstown...
And I believe you know Ed O'Neill, the actor.
I do.
Very well.
He's watching right now.
Is he?
Yeah.
And we talk about this because he grew up
on the same streets of Youngstown that I did.
I would not be here if it wasn't for my neighborhood,
that couple I talked about who pulled me and
my brother up on their front porch as we walked
by on the north side to feed us breakfast.
If it wasn't for libraries, there are times I was kept in a cold,
dark basement, but I would bring a book home every day from the library
at school, and I could read about lives that were different than mine,
and that gave me hope.
This is the world I want to live in.
It's the systems and conditions that we create together.
You know, you have to work hard.
I was able to get in medical school out
of high school, an accelerated program.
I was able to work three jobs
and put myself through at Youngstown State University.
Mm-hmm.
But if it were not for those things, I wouldn't be here today.
And I know there are a lot of kids slipping through
the cracks right now as we speak.
It's not about my childhood anymore.
It's about the childhoods out there.
And so the work I've done my whole life.
It's been to create those conditions that give people a way forward.
And that's our work.
I am much more in awe of the title doctor than I am governor.
I tried pre-med, did not last a week.
Organic chemistry broke me in about three and a half days.
And I knew pre-med students and medical students
who thought they were going into this to do good.
They were going to go out there in the world to do good.
They come out of medical school with a lot of debt.
And then they need to make money,
and then they do make money, and that becomes basically
the focus.
You had that opportunity.
What?
Talk about that decision.
When you came out of medical school,
there was a road to riches right in front of you,
and you did not take it.
You know, I think
the riches I've had far surpass anything I could have hoped.
Four as a kid, but I'll tell you my story goes back here
to New York City where we're sitting
tonight. In 1990,
I came for a triple board program at Albert Einstein, and it was the
crack cocaine epidemic.
Half of the kids in my pediatrics practice were dying from getting HIV
in utero. It was big rooms full of incubators with no parents
and one nurse.
And it was then that I decided I was seeing things much too late.
It was devastating to see this in our country
on the scale I saw it then.
And that's what led me to this specialty
called preventive medicine and public health,
where the whole community is your patient
or whole state or whole country.
And it's all about the social, environmental and economic conditions.
We gain 30 years life expectancy in one century, but only five.
We're due to what I learned in med school.
The other 25 years came from things that we have
to solve collectively in community.
It's why we have government, clean water,
safe food, child labor laws, traffic laws,
you know, maybe some antibiotics and immunizations, yes.
But it's these greater conditions
that we create that either help us move forward
or when they're absent, like they are in my state right now.
move us backwards. So this is the work I've done
my entire career. I'm 60 years old.
And it turns out, Lawrence,
that levers of a governor are those conditions.
Donald Trump is still a sore loser.
Two days after Democrats won decisive victories in the
House and Senate, he told ABC News' John Carl,
quote, I think we can get along.
It's good for the country if we do. The country has had enough.
That was then, y'all.
Now, with the prospect of Democratic investigations
into everything from the Trump family graft
to the Epstein files, Donald Trump is attacking Democrats as,
quote, the most corrupt and
anti-American groups of political leaders
and hacks in the history of our country and
even the world.
The Democrats are corrupt and evil.
That's in all caps if you're listening.
And I am the exact opposite.
Girl, what? That's what he actually said.
And his tirade of attacking Democrats as corrupt
continued throughout the day.
In one post, Trump called for the prosecution of six Democrats,
including our next guest, Congressman Jason Crow,
who simply made a video telling members
of the military and intelligence communities it's
their duty to refuse illegal orders.
Trump's Justice Department already tried
and failed to indict those Democrats
when a grand jury refused to approve the charges earlier this year.
All this comes as the White House is pursuing
a more aggressive posture towards Democrats investigating Donald Trump
and his administration, including threatening criminal investigations.
In a letter, White House counsel Will Scharf warned incoming
House Oversight Committee Chair Robert Garcia that, quote,
Threats to executive branch officials designed
to deter them from public service or
process designed merely to abuse or instill fear in the recipient
may cross the line into blatant criminality.
Congressman Garcia said this in response.
Everything that Donald Trump should be taken seriously,
he has weaponized the DOJ, he's someone that goes after
his political enemies, but as a matter of something
that is going to change our posture, I mean, they're mistaken.
We are going to continue to aggressively investigate
these serious allegations of crime.
We are a co-equal branch of government,
and so it is crazy that Donald Trump is now going after his enemies,
and somehow he thinks it's going to stop us.
It's only emboldened us more.
Donald Trump is also apparently using lies about fraud
in Democrat-led cities
to get out of trying to end his disastrous war in Iran.
Today, he posted that he wants Vice President J.D. Vance, quote,
to focus his complete and total attention on those bogus fraud claims
instead of ending the war in Iran, adding, quote,
We don't need a deal with Iran. Those days have long since passed.
We've got their money, hundreds of billions of dollars,
and we've got their straight.
The New York Times reports, quote,
The Post deepens questions about what Mr. Trump, Mr.
Trump's plan is to end the war.
The president has been weighing a number of options,
including ramping up military strikes,
withdrawing and leaving the matter to Arab allies
or simply maintaining the status quo.
The people paying the highest price
for Trump's failure in Iran are members of the U.S.
military and their families.
MSNBC reports that at a town hall,
Navy leaders told families of sailors aboard the USS George H.W. Bush
to prepare for an extended year-long deployment of their loved ones
who would not be home for the holidays.
According to town hall audio reviewed by MSNBC,
at times family members yelled at Navy leaders
saying they were not answering their questions
and were giving them the runaround.
One family member asked what the Navy was doing
to push back on President Donald Trump
so the conflict would not become another, quote, forever war.
One spouse said her husband, quote,
saw an apple for the first time after like three months
and almost cried on the phone.
Another spouse said, quote, my husband has wanted
to try to kill himself four times while on the bush.
She said nobody gave him help.
Joining us now, Democratic Congressman Jason Crow of Colorado.
He is a member of the Armed Services and Intelligence Committees,
and he is a former U.S. Army Ranger.
Congressman Crow, as always, thank you for coming to The Last Word.
What do you make of Trump's comments about the war in Iran
as we're learning about yet another extended deployment
for more service members dealing with deteriorating conditions?
Well, what you just talked about and teed up there,
Jonathan, shows us what's at stake, right?
Behind these policies,
behind these deployments and these wars are real people,
real Americans, our brothers and sisters, our sons and daughters,
our mothers and fathers, our neighbors who are without leadership.
who are without the support
and without the resources that they need because of Pete
Hegseth's failed leadership, his corruption,
and Donald Trump's corruption. And that is our
obligation. You know, I will not stop
and I will not rest until Pete Hegseth is out of the Pentagon
because another day of putting our service members
at risk is unacceptable to me.
What's your reaction to Trump again calling for your prosecution
given the consistently aggressive posture from his DOJ?
Bring it. That's my reaction. Bring it, right?
It's a vow protest too much. Every time he fails,
every time he swirls,
every time there's a setback or a loss, he lashes out.
So he's lashing out, again, at the wrong people.
He tried to indict me twice this year.
He said he wants to have me executed along with my fellow veterans.
Thank you.
Bring it, Donald Trump.
We're not going to back down.
I have a defense fund we're setting up.
We are raising money for my legal defense.
We will do whatever is necessary to protect ourselves,
to protect me and my family, but
at the same time, do our duty.
There is nothing that Donald Trump is going
to do that's ever going to get me from back
Backing away from my duty and my oath to this constitution.
So once again, if he thinks he's going to make us cow
or intimidate us, he's chosen
the wrong people because what's happening
in this country right now is that courage
is far more powerful than the fear
that he has tried to instill in this country.
America has said enough and we're rising up.
We can get your reaction to big news today.
The Trump donor, Jensen Huang, stepped down
as NVIDIA CEO after reports he had an affair
with a woman accused of being a Chinese spy.
China denies that. Despite claiming otherwise,
Trump reportedly knew about it, but did nothing.
What are the national security implications of all this?
Yeah. Well, almost everything that Donald Trump
and the cronies and the incompetent clowns around him
do can be explained by one of three things.
Either it's corruption,
they're trying to make money and monetize the federal government and
U.S. taxpayer dollars just to fill their own pockets,
or it's vengeance against their perceived
enemies or settling scores, or it's incompetence.
They just don't care. They just don't care about
the job because they're more concerned about filling
their own pockets. So I want to figure
out which of the three categories are we dealing with here. If we have
A critical national security company
and we have information about a compromise, a security
compromise. What is this? What's going on?
Is it your incompetence category? Is it your corruption
category? Or is there some kind of vengeance
or cronyism going on here? So we're going to ask
questions. This has nothing to do with settling scores
or going after people. This has everything
to do with actually doing exactly what Americans,
the Tuesday before last, voted us to do.
What millions of Americans, Republicans,
Democrats and unaffiliates alike voted for Democrats
to do was to conduct oversight, to stop corruption,
to lower the cost of health care, to end the war in Iran.
And that is exactly our agenda
and exactly what we're preparing to do come January.
Since you invoked his name earlier, let's talk about him.
And that is Pete Hegseth. I'm sure you
saw that he awarded a medal to the guard
who scolded him and his group at the Tomb of the Unknown
Soldier yesterday. What do you make of this?
Well, he's clearly trying to cover up for the
fact that he walked in in a very cavalier way
and disrespected our most sacred ground.
And this follows on the heels of Jonathan.
Donald Trump repeatedly trying to build his arch
in front of the view of our most sacred
ground in America, Arlington Cemetery,
where paratroopers that I served with in Iraq,
their final resting place.
I am not going to allow this to happen.
We will do everything necessary, cut off funding, litigate.
He is not going to build the Donald Trump vanity arch
in front of our sacred ground.
And I'm not going to allow Pete Hegseth
or anybody else desecrate that sacred ground
and where our brothers and sisters are laying in rest.
Congressman Jason Crow, thank you for joining us tonight.
Thank you.
Joining us now, Congressman Adam Smith of Washington.
He is the top Democrat on the House Armed Services Committee.
Congressman Smith, thank you, as always, for coming to The Last Word.
With this ground stop now lifted, what, if anything,
has been communicated to you and your colleagues in Congress?
Well, we've been trying to pry information out
of the administration all day.
Rick Larson, fellow Washingtonian,
who's the ranking member soon to be chair of the
Transportation Committee, and I have spoken.
And there's just been a lack of communication
in this administration, as David just said.
I mean, it seems most likely
that this was a software upgrade that overloaded the system,
but they haven't said that.
And they ought to know.
I mean, they really ought to know what happened.
And the other interesting part about this is,
As Sean Duffy gets up there and says,
just give us $50 billion and all the world's problems will be solved.
Well, they got $12 billion last year, 18 months ago now,
in the H.R.1, the reconciliation bill that the Republicans passed.
To date, they've only spent a billion of it.
Sean Duffy's got $11 billion just sitting in a corner somewhere,
you know, so go get after the problem.
And I think that points out something
that really hasn't been brought up.
President Trump's government, every branch,
whether you're talking about the Justice Department,
Homeland Security, whatever, there's a level of incompetence
and indifference to actually getting the job done that is,
you know, placing the American people at risk.
You got $11 billion.
I know we got a lot of upgrading to do, but let's get started.
Let's replace some of those analog systems with new IP systems.
So, you know, let's get rid of the copper wire. Let's move forward.
So they've been moving very, very slowly. And yes,
they do not communicate with the American people or with Congress,
which is supposed to have or does have oversight about what's going on.
Congressman Smith, listen to how Transportation Secretary Duffy tried
to explain what happened today.
Our switches, our routers actually got overloaded with data
and they went down.
And I shouldn't say they went down.
They started to give us inconsistency in the data
from those routers. And because of that, we shut the system down.
Now, you hinted at the lack of clarity here. But
what does that even mean that we just heard from Secretary Duffy?
Yeah, it's hard to tell unless he gives
a specific answer as to what happened today
that didn't happen yesterday or two days ago or three weeks ago.
You know, why were they overloaded today?
Thank you, Chad.
Was there some routers that went down
and then fewer had to accommodate more?
Was there more information coming into the system?
Presumably, the FAA would know what their system can handle
and they would make sure
that there was an adequate buffer.
Because this, as I think someone has already pointed out,
was not the busiest air travel day, you know,
by any stretch of the imagination of the year.
So understanding those details better,
I think, would make a huge difference.
Congressman Smith, listen to more of Secretary Duffy.
We can play politics. By the way, play
politics all you want on all kinds of issues.
That's great. And there's a lot of issues to play politics on.
This is not one of those issues. This is an American issue,
an American build with an American president that knows how to do it.
Congressman Smith, talk more about the lack
of leadership this shows, not just from the
Republican Congress the last two years,
but also the White House itself.
Yeah, well, I mean, I think the president has been absent.
I mean, he talks about his ballroom.
He talks about the arch.
He talks about the golf course.
He talks about the reflecting pool.
He talks about the butts of Republican presidential candidates.
I think having a president
who is so disconnected from reality is a problem.
It's also and let's not forget the Doge process.
That went in there and gutted so many of our federal agencies
of highly talented, very experienced bureaucrats that undermined
our ability in every single one of the departments out there.
Now, I do want to make one other point.
There's no question that we need more money
for our infrastructure system.
And certainly not just their health care system,
a whole bunch of different systems.
But meanwhile, the Republicans cut taxes by $4 trillion.
All right. You know, and the debt is thirty nine trillion dollars
and counting to the point where it is a real problem.
If we are going to fix these things
and I'm going to say something that most people don't want to hear,
we're going to have to find the revenue somewhere.
OK, we can't keep borrowing to fix all of the problems that we face.
So when we, you know, restore the Medicaid cuts
and restore the ACA cuts, as we should well do.
I personally think we should get rid of the whole bill,
including the tax cuts that were put in
there. We have to be willing to pay for the improvements that we need.
And Congressman, what worries you most
from a national security standpoint
about what happened today?
Well, it's hard to say.
You know, I don't know for sure if this makes it clear that
the system is more vulnerable to cyber attacks.
But certainly from a national security perspective, cyber attacks is,
you know, and they take on a whole bunch of different forms.
You've seen I think it's in France that, you know,
some cyber system is coming in and shutting down the freezers,
you know, and spoiling food all across the country.
There was a lot of different ways to get into systems
and undermine them in ways that place lives at risk.
Just the overall vulnerability of the systems and how old they are.
What worries me the most is so much of the infrastructure that we have
was built in the, I don't know, 30, 40 year post-World War II boom.
And it's getting old. It needs to be replaced
and upgraded because there's been a lot of improvements.
So I guess the infrastructure worries me the most.
And then again, you know, being intelligent about how we use
our resources, given how far in debt we are,
so that we prioritize the things that are going to keep
the American people safe and make our country prosperous.
You know, Congressman Smith,
Thanksgiving is right around the corner. What assurances
do you need before Americans can be confident this won't happen again?
Well, it's what we talked about at the top.
Why did it happen this time?
If you can come in and say, ah, here's what happened,
here's why, and we're going to fix it.
That would be the number one most important thing.
Instead of saying, eh, it kind
of seems like the router's got overloaded.
Again, why?
Why today?
What happened?
So we need soon an explanation as to why this happened
and what they're going to do in the next couple of days
or immediately to make sure that it doesn't happen again.
Congressman Adam Smith, thank you for joining us tonight.
Hey, it's Rachel.
I am so glad to see you at the end of that clip
because this is where I get to tell you about a new way
to watch all our clips and all of our shows
and everything on MSNOW on your phone
or your tablet or your laptop.
You can watch things live or recorded.
Plus you can ask me and all the other hosts
and reporters questions in our weekly live chats.
You can go to ms.now slash membership
or just click below.
Thanks.
