Staggered Age Of Consent Wouldn’t Be A ‘Silver Bullet’ | Labour MP

Breaking News
8 followers
40 Video Views·Nov 16, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis panel discussion examines the proposal for a \"staggered age of consent\" to address power imbalances between adults and minors. The conversation explores the limitations of current legal frameworks, the necessity of cultural shifts regarding consent, and the potential for legislative reform to prevent predatory behavior by older adults targeting teenagers.
I would just warn. We're all scrambling around after
these latest allegations for sort of a silver bullet.
This wouldn't be a silver bullet because we know a lot
of abuse happens between 14-year-olds and other 14-year-olds.
You know, we have to be clear that we have a much wider and bigger
problem where we accept sexual assault, where young men think it.
It's all right to choke their partners during sex
or that all girls cry when they're having sex.
We have a real crisis on our hands.
All my panel and everybody at home,
I mean, everyone's been really shocked by the news cycle
over the last sort of week to 10 days,
the conviction and sentencing of Russell Brand
and, of course, the allegations coming out against David Walliams,
which, of course, it's important to say
that he denies all of those allegations.
But it has led to a very big conversation about violence.
against women and girls and the culture
which exists in the entertainment industry,
but also in wider society.
And now the conversation feels like it's moving on.
to a bigger conversation about the age of consent
and something described as a staggering of the age of consent.
Now, a woman who says she was raped by Russell Brand
when she was 16, Mia Latta, has waived her right to anonymity.
She has done an interview with the Sunday Times,
which is out in the paper today.
She's spoken with Ross Irwin.
And she has said that people in their 30s
should not be having sex with people who are 16.
And 17-year-olds, Russell Brand,
denied the allegation when this was published.
Let's just listen to what Pat McFadden had
to say about this issue of staggered age of consent.
He spoke with Adam Bolton earlier today.
Mia has certainly raised the question.
I think people will think that through and discuss it through.
I couldn't give you a conclusion to that today,
but she has certainly raised the question.
of the abuse of power by older men
who may also sometimes be in positions of authority.
And I think it is something that will be discussed.
Caroline Lucas, what are your thoughts on this idea
of maybe re-looking at the age of consent?
Well, let me just pay tribute to the bravery of Mia Latta, frankly.
I mean, it's quite a big thing to waive your anonymity
in order to speak out about this and campaign about it.
And I know that actually all of these kind of resharing of clips
is re-traumatizing survivors of sexual abuse and sexual predators.
So I just want to acknowledge
that this is a really difficult time for a lot of people.
But in terms of the substantive proposal that she's making, I think
To my mind, at least, from what I've looked at it so far,
it seems to have a lot to commend it. I
mean, I would like to see more evidence just
in case there are unintended consequences. And one
of the things that struck me was that maybe it could mean
that young people might be more likely
to hide a relationship in order to protect an older partner.
And would that potentially put
them at greater risk? I don't know the answer to that question.
But I certainly think that Mia is
is right to put the question on the table,
and it certainly feels as if.
There ought to be a difference between a 16-year-old girl having sex
with someone else who's of a similar age
to the kinds of power relations that come into play
when you're in a relationship with someone who is so much older.
So I think my gut reaction would certainly be to say
that we should look at this very seriously, that it feels like there
is a lot to commend this proposal at the moment.
It's been pointed out that there's a kind of a...
A staggered cliff edge that goes in the other direction
in terms of the fact that if you're
under 13, consent is deemed to be legally impossible
and therefore sexual relations
are raped.
Between 13 and 16, it can be,
it's called sexual activity with a child, which carries
a lower sentence.
I think it's right to question, is that really what we want to do?
I think most people would probably agree
that it's still probably right to call that rape.
So I've got a lot of sympathy with what Mia Latta is doing
and all credit to her for speaking out.
Emily Darlington, do you think this is something
that a Labour government will look at?
It's been reported in today's Sunday Times
that Louise Haig is keen to explore this further.
We heard there from Pat McFadden, you're very active.
in terms of violence against women
and girls issues within the women's parliamentary Labour
parties. Is this something you would like
to see ministers take forward and have a discussion about?
First of all, I think Mia is incredibly brave as a survivor
to step forward like that and put yourself forward.
Of course, we need to consider whatever she is proposing.
I would just mourn, we're all scrambling around after
these latest allegations for sort of a silver bullet.
This wouldn't be a silver bullet because we know a lot
of abuse happens between 14-year-olds and other 14-year-olds.
You know, we have to be clear that we have a...
Much wider and bigger problem where we accept sexual assault,
where young men think it's all right to choke their partners during sex
or that all girls cry when they're having sex,
whether we have a real crisis on our hands and not just for.
girls who are experiencing the sexual assault,
but also for boys who are growing up not
understanding what a consensual, equal relationship is.
And that will just continue
on to their adulthood.
And we need to be absolutely just changing attitudes right
the way across. And I don't care if they're famous, you know, like.
Russell Brand or Andrew Tate
or there is somebody that's just in their school they need to be
harshly dealt with because this is not the way that we protect women
and girls and we have a
commitment to have violence against women
and girls and it is so important that we challenge
those attitudes and start preventing this kind
of experience happening as well because Mia should
never have been in that position ever
and we should have protected her. I think one of the
It's really worth reading Mia's interview.
I think one of the really heartbreaking bits of Mia's interview
is that she says that a taxi driver,
when she was going with Russell Brand,
the taxi driver said to her,
I know this, I mean, I'm paraphrasing,
but basically he says, I know this guy.
You're you look really young. Don't go in his house with him.
Don't because that taxi driver just knew wasn't a question of the law.
He just knew on a kind of moral gave him the ick kind of thing.
And sometimes it we I think there's the law,
which I think it is important that let's have a look at this.
But there is a much bigger, I think, cultural discussion
that that we that taxi driver knew what was right and wrong.
Russell Brand didn't know what was right and wrong.
But I think Mia has raised a really important issue.
I mean, Gawain, what are your thoughts on this idea?
Well, for many years,
I've thought that the Swiss approach is actually quite sensible.
There is the age of consent at 16 in Switzerland,
but from a no penalty, I take what Louise was saying just then.
But if there's a under the age of 16,
if it's within two or three years.
There is, whilst it is illegal,
there are very rarely charges because it is, it's, should
a 16-year-old be convicted of statutory rape with a 15-year-old,
I don't think so.
And I think the Swiss have actually done this very well.
And they also focus not so much on the age gap,
but the power relationship.
And we do have aspects of power relationships in our law.
But they are better at it, I think.
And it is, I know that this process
is looking at the Florida law,
but I would say the Swiss law
is certainly worth taking into account
and taking very seriously
because it seems to have done it rather well
in comparison to what we've been able to do.
And I do think something we've missed out here,
everybody's talking about violence
against women and girls.
There's two things.
One, there's quite a lot of coercion
against young men and boys,
and they are completely forgotten in this equation.
And I think that that's a problem.
It's always, young men are,
and in the entertainment industry particularly, this is an issue.
So I think we forget them at our peril.
And I don't think we can honorably have a discussion about violence
against women and girls without addressing the whole rape gang issue.
It's embarrassing.
That is the far biggest, that's the biggest single problem we've got.
And abuse of black women is appalling from anybody.
But that is something that we seem to forget
because it's a white man.
Well, Gawain, I hope you listened.
I hope you let go.
Gawain, I hope you listened half past four
because we had a 20-minute interview
with Maggie Oliver.
I missed it.
Well, just so you know,
I caught the last 10 minutes.
We had 20 minutes with Maggie Oliver
talking about the rape gangs.
So it is something that we are definitely...
I'm glad I didn't miss that.
I think, as I say, the Swiss example is
it's about power relationships.
And I think that is absolutely key.
Okay.
I think that's absolutely wrong.
Yes, if I could do.
So we've had some recent cases of 15 year old boys gang raping young
women and then the judge saying, oh, they're very well behaved.
No, this is why the Swiss law doesn't work, though.
They were very nice young men and they have bright futures.
So, well, well, we won't put them in prison for the rape. I'm sorry.
And it's just not acceptable at any age.
And that's what we need to teach our boys.
And it's not acceptable by anyone.
And if you don't tackle it at that age,
then what we'll see is the experiences that you're worried about.
Okay, go in. Do you want to come back on that?
Well, I 100% agree.
That sort of behaviour is absolutely not acceptable.
I doubt they'll be locked up at 15.
There'll be something else going on.
But the, and I wholeheartedly agree.
However, I suspect the vast majority of sexual encounters
by people under the age of 16,
the vast majority are not what we're talking about here.
Okay, but you would, you would, you would.
under a broad brush law
Okay, I mean, look, there is definitely, we've,
Touched on this before, we've been doing a lot of this on our show.
There is, of course,
a lot of stories about older men preying on younger men as well.
But Gawain, would you concede then that in terms
of the victims can be women and young women and young men,
but would you concede that the majority of the predators are men?
I would concede the majority
of predators are men, both gay and straight.
Yeah, OK. Right. Kevin, just your thoughts on where
this may go politically, because, of course, you know,
Louise Haigh making the intervention today in the Sunday Times,
I thought was quite interesting.
She's a very powerful senior woman in the Labour Party.
Do you think we will see movement on this?
Yeah, I mean, I did think that was hugely significant
when you get the effectively the deputy prime minister.
...in print, on the record, saying that they are in favour of a change,
in favour of a staggered age of consent.
And I think you can take that as read, that the Prime Minister agrees
and that the government will throw its weight behind those calls.
I wouldn't be surprised if there were movement on that relatively soon.
And I think that would be the absolutely right thing to do.
And do you think there'd be cross-party consensus on that, Kevin?
Yeah, I mean, I think, yeah, I would like to think so.
I'd be surprised if parties set their face against it, certainly.
There may well be, as Gawain's touched on there,
there may well be, this might be an opportunity
to have a look at the whole age of consent issue.
There may well be attempts to amend any legislation
that the government brings forward.
I'm sure there would be.
I would be surprised, very surprised,
if any party thought that this was a bad idea.
It's important to stress, of course,
You should never rush into any law
in reaction to a prominent news story.
I think that's how bad law is created.
So it would be good, you know, if this was kicked around
so that any law that is brought in is properly robust
and implementable.
And it's not straightforward.
I think it would need to be very carefully worded.
But I think...
By and large, I think it would have a standard good chance of passing.
And just we've only got a couple of minutes left
and quite a few questions have come in.
And I'll just put this to the three political people briefly,
if you will, because we haven't got a huge amount of time left.
A lot of people messaging in saying if if we're going to give the vote
to people at 16, why are we talking about maybe changing the age of?
Consent, a lot of people are kind of drawing
that parallel between votes at 16.
And if we're talking about raising the age of consent, is it a mistake
to think about bringing in votes at 16 briefly, if you will, Caroline?
I don't really see the connection, to be honest, because I don't think
anyone's talking about changing the age of consent across the board.
We're talking about particular power relations
which might need to be differently regulated.
But already we know that there are differences in terms of things like
when you're allowed to go drinking and so forth.
We know that that age of 16 isn't common across
the board for all of those thresholds.
And I think that's fine. So personally,
I don't have any problem with the fact that there would be a possible.
Difference in terms of the different ages here.
Egoine I
I share the concerns of your correspondence.
I do think we have, as a society, got ourselves terribly,
terribly confused about what we think is an age of majority,
social, moral, intellectual, physical.
Thank you very much.
These are all coming at different points, and it's very hard.
I don't think society actually knows what it's doing
when it comes to adolescence and post-adolescence.
It used to be simple with mistakes.
It's now mistakes with no simplicity.
Okay, Emily?
I agree with Caroline to a certain extent.
When we're talking about changing the age of consent laws
to reflect huge age disparities,
we're not talking about the fact that there'll be some kind of banning
of 16-year-olds having sex with each other.
But what we should be talking about, and it should be at any age,
is that if it is non-consensual,
there is a very strict and quick legal redress.
To ensure that we do not accept any forms of abuse
and that's for anybody at any age.
And Kevin, you know, a lot of people are messaging in
about this votes for 16.
Do you think there's anything in that
or do you think that's the sort of wrong comparison to make?
You know, I do think it's the wrong comparison.
I think
As far as I'm aware anyway, the...
Proposal isn't to raise the age of consent,
it's to keep the age of consent where it is,
but ensuring that there is no likelihood or ability for...
Older people to use that power imbalance to abuse,
effectively, young people, women,
and in some cases men, who are technically of legal age to have sex.
But if someone is looking to have sex with them who's in their 30s,
40s, or even older,
clearly I think that is immoral.
I mean, we've been discussing, we all remember, I mean,
I'm sure at the time we all thought, my goodness,
that's, you know, when Bill Wyman was with Mandy Smith
and there was that huge kind of ache. I mean, look.
So wherever you sit in the political spectrum,
you look at something, you think that that just feels really wrong,
that just, you know, it feels deeply, deeply uncomfortable.
I think, you know, wherever you are in politics,
you've got that kind of sense of sort of right and wrong.
I'm just going to finish on this message from Handyman about
the taxi driver. He says that the taxi driver also.
She heartbreakingly offered to drive me home for free,
she said, and he was a proper hero.
Absolutely right. Well, look, that has been a fascinating,
spirited and thoughtful discussion.
My huge thanks to Emily Darlington, to Caroline Lucas,
to Gawain Towler and to Kevin Schofield
and to you at home for all of your excellent contributions.
