Should Canada be engaging with China?

CBC English
15 followers
Nov 15, 2026
Thanks so much for joining us this Sunday.
As I mentioned, the prime minister is in Cambodia
this morning, the most recent stop
of his multi-leg trip across Europe and Asia.
Carney's most consequential visit comes in just
a few days at the ASEAN summit and the APEC summit
in Shenzhen, China. It's where the PM will meet
with Chinese President Xi Jinping as part of his
ongoing effort to deepen ties despite previous security concerns.
Earlier, I spoke to the former National Security Advisor,
Jody Thomas, about Canada re-engaging with China.
Jody Thomas, thank you for being here.
Thank you for having me.
The Prime Minister is getting ready to meet the Chinese President
in his second trip to China in under a year.
Thank
I wonder whether you think China remains a serious threat to Canada.
Has that changed in any way,
or is this just the approach that this Prime Minister is taking?
No, I would say that China has not lessened
as a national security threat.
you.
Their ambitions, their tactics are unchanged.
Canada is certainly not the only country on the receiving end of them.
But the prime minister is pursuing an economic relationship,
I hope, and I think with the
understanding of the national security threat posed by China.
When the Prime Minister talks about it,
he talks about pragmatic engagement.
How do you interpret that approach to dealing with China?
Well, I think it's the only way you can deal with China.
You have to be pragmatic.
So you have to understand them, which means that he would have
to be being briefed by the China experts in government,
the national security experts, foreign policy experts,
probably academics, private sector.
And understand what motivates them, understand how they operate,
and then plan our reaction to that and our engagement
with them based on what you've been told about how they behave
and what their intentions are.
You can't do it. You can't engage with China from a values position
or from a pure policy position.
You have to understand the motivations.
of the Chinese government and respond accordingly.
This past week, the Prime Minister said
security risks Canada might face with China
are much, much less than the security risks,
for example, of the United States.
I think he meant, you know,
compared to the U.S. and China and Canada and China.
I know it.
But would you agree with that,
that the risk to Canada is different than it is to the United States?
I think that's what he meant as well.
And yes, I would agree with that. The size of the trade
between China and the United States is enormous.
And the intellectual property
that resides in the United States,
you know, in AI, in chips, in defense.
The academic research that goes on in the United States,
you know, it outstrips what happens in
Canada significantly.
And those are areas that China is very interested in.
And so the risk to
the United States is significantly higher.
Yet, because of the size of China and the size of
their economy, they continue to trade with them just as Canada has to.
We saw this week that an agreement to deepen the financial sector ties,
so allowing for more market access for financial services,
some engagement with regulatory authorities.
Obviously, also the agriculture stuff has gotten pretty much worked out
with a bit of a trade-off from Canada.
Are those other issues things where you
think Canada should be engaging with China,
whether it be markets or regulatory issues?
I would be concerned about payment systems personally
and the amount of personal
information that you're sharing with China.
Regulatory issues, their regulatory system is
so different than ours. That would give me concern as well.
I think there are lots of places and
And, um,
commodities where we can trade
with China without putting personal information at risk.
However, to protect some of the agricultural communities and products,
I think this is
the deal that's been struck.
So my advice would be to Canadians is be eyes wide open,
understand what you're getting
into if you are engaging with any of these systems.
I want to ask you sort of about the broader global context,
because it is possible that
President Trump,
President Putin and Xi all meet at this meeting on the, I guess, the
sidelines of APEC.
Is it possible for, how should we interpret that?
Because I think a lot of people would
be very concerned about what that means for Ukraine
and why those three would be having a conversation
and sort of Canada's position in the midst
of all of that.
I think it's an enormous concern.
President Trump has aligned himself with dictators
and nobody really understands why it flies
in the face of 200 plus years of American foreign policy.
I think it does not bode well for Ukraine.
The interest in supporting Russia over Ukraine is contradictory to,
again, U.S. foreign policy.
And those three countries should not be deciding
the future of any other sovereign nation.
That right to self-determination should still be guiding everything
that is done in the foreign policy space vis-a-vis Ukraine.
And so I think it is enormous reason for concern.
Their interests are not Ukrainian interests.
Their interests are self-interest.
And I think it's something we all should be paying attention to.
I want to ask you one last question about AI.
You are on the Prime Minister's AI Council,
and as you and the whole world has seen,
this NVIDIA CEO resignation has seen their stock plummeting.
There are concerns also about the sharing of chip technology with China
and what this alleged Chinese spy may have been able to get.
What would be your concern about the impact on the AI bubble,
on AI in Canada?
As you watch that unfold.
I think there's a couple of things.
One, I would note that we've had in the last two months,
two incidents of Chinese spies, right?
The one in NATO, which unfortunately implicates Canada.
And this situation, which I think going back
to the original topic says something about what China is doing
and how they operate. So that's number one.
Number two, the AI bubble, just like the dot-com bubble,
although AI is a bit more real, it was...
The valuations of companies were unreasonable,
and anything that is based solely around one
individual should give rise to concern.
What I think it means for Canada is that the approach
the Prime Minister is taking with
having a minister responsible for AI,
setting up the council, advising in terms of how to
use AI, how to regulate AI,
and how to ensure that the safety guardrails are developed in
In concert.
With the opportunity of AI and the technology of AI is really important
because I would say that's why I'm on the council
is to give advice on the national security implications
because I'm very different from everybody else on that council.
So I think it speaks to the prime minister's interest in AI
and how Canada will use it and benefit from it, but also
the need to manage it and understand the security implications.
Jody Thomas, so glad to have you here.
We covered a lot of different topics. I appreciate it.
Thank you.
