Can good people go to hell? And can you get into heaven without believing in Jesus? In this episode of Theological, Orthodox Jewish host Shabbos Kestenbaum sits down with Christian evangelist Ray Comfort for a candid conversation about sin, salvation, repentance, and the afterlife.
Shabbos asks Ray a question other Christian guests have struggled to answer directly: “If I don't accept Jesus as my Lord and Savior. Am I going to hell?”
Ray responds by putting Shabbos through his famous Ten Commandments test, challenging what it means to be a good person in God's eyes. But Shabbos pushes back: If God is merciful, why isn't repentance enough? Why is Jesus necessary for forgiveness? And could even history's worst criminals be saved?
They explore: Can good people go to hell? Do you need Jesus to get into heaven? Are you a good person according to the Ten Commandments? Can God forgive every sin? Is repentance enough to earn forgiveness? Could someone like Osama bin Laden be saved? What happens to people who never hear about Jesus? Why does God allow suffering and death?
Ray also shares his personal journey from a Jewish family in New Zealand to becoming a Christian evangelist, and discusses his memoir Compelled: My Story.
Is being a good person enough—or is salvation something we can never earn? Subscribe to Theological with Shabbos Kestenbaum for candid conversations where faith meets reason.
Why would you say that you're a good person who's going to heaven?
I'm not going to heaven because I'm a good person. I'm a wretch.
I was like every other red-blooded guy.
I lived for the pleasure of lust.
You know, I thought I'm in big trouble on Judgment Day.
I had a Solomon experience. You know what that is?
Cut a baby in half?
No. Tears streamed down my face as I cried out,
why does everything and everyone have to die?
I didn't realize I was praying,
but I was. And I just started reading the Sermon on the Mount.
Can a good person still go to hell?
I want you to tell me.
You're going to be giving the yes or no in a minute.
OK.
You had sex before marriage.
I was not expecting a grilling.
Well, you wanted it.
Just say no.
You break one point of the law, you break them all.
Right.
You don't have to break 10 laws to have the police after you.
Just one.
If that is true, that God is forgiving people,
then why the need for Jesus?
Boy, that's a big question.
Welcome back to Theological.
We're joined by someone who I want to call pastor,
but you've been very clear I cannot call you pastor.
Maybe I can call you your eminence,
but instead I should just call you Ray Comfort.
So thank you for being here, Ray Comfort.
You are, if I were to remember your Wikipedia page correctly,
you are a televangelist slash street evangelist.
And number one, I'd love for you to tell me
what the practical differences are between those two things.
And then number two, when you walk into the room,
you handed me an In-N-Out burger.
gift card, which no guest has given me presents before.
So number one, you're welcome to come
back on the show. But number two, I'm just curious,
is that part of proselytizing? Is that
part of your mission to bring people back to Christ?
I'm just curious what the strategy is
when you meet people who are disconnected from the church.
Well, that was a pregnant question.
Yes, we go straight into it.
Yeah, well, Wikipedia, I don't trust.
We've tried to change Wikipedia.
I've written 100 books.
Every time I put the books there,
somebody goes in and cuts it back to about 15 books for some reason.
And a lot of stuff on there isn't true.
Like, I'm not a televangelist.
I want to get far away from televangelism.
I can.
They've got a bottomless collection bag.
They're always asking for money.
They've got a bad name.
Down in New Zealand, when Jimmy Swaggart was doing this thing,
I had to almost answer for that.
Worldwide, there was a reproach on Christians because of hypocrisy.
So I don't like being called a televangelist.
I don't like being called a street preacher,
because you immediately conjure up thoughts of some guy
on a street corner with a bullhorn and a sign saying you go to hell.
Don't do that.
I've been doing it.
Regularly, for 30 years, I did it every day
for 12 years in a place called Speaker's Corner
in Christchurch, New Zealand.
I actually engage people and talk to them,
believe it or not, I don't yell at them.
I ask trivia questions to begin with, like,
what's the capital of France, and someone
says Paris, and I say, here's a dollar,
good work, and makes people laugh, and they say,
what's your name?
He says, Eric, that's correct, and I give him
a dollar for getting that right.
That creates good feeling, and then I say.
Okay, there's a lot there
to unpack, but let me start
with the last point
of are you a good person.
So I would say I'm...
Relatively, and that's probably a key word
for this discussion, a relatively good person.
I can't say I pray three times a day
as Jews are commanded to do, but I do pray.
I give charity.
I lie like most people, but I can't say I'm an overt liar.
I can't say I'm a pathological liar.
I haven't killed anyone.
I haven't really stolen in measurable ways.
So let me ask a twofold question.
Number one, why am I not a good person?
And number two, why would you say
that you're a good person who's presumably
Going to heaven.
No.
Totally wrong.
You don't think you're going to heaven?
No, I'm not going to heaven because I'm a good person.
I'm a wretch.
And I use that word, not lightly, amazing grace,
how sweet the sound that saved a wretch
like me.
I'm a sinner.
I loved to sin before I was a Christian.
I did what the Bible says, I drank a nickery like water,
that's a biblical phrase, to show
To show that we love that which is wrong.
I want to talk about you being a good person
or not being a good person a little later.
I'd rather talk about In-N-Out Cards first,
because I don't want to get on a meet straight away, if that's okay.
Yes, yes.
Okay, now why do I give out In-N-Out Cards in California?
Because it makes people feel good.
I go to a local college twice a day
and have done for about 18 years to film for a YouTube channel,
which has 350 million views,
and we talk about what happens after people die.
I say to students, are you afraid of dying?
They say, a little bit.
I say, what do you mean a little bit?
Someone's going to bury you six feet under the ground.
That's not a little bit.
That's terrifying.
And I can see in their eyes, they're saying,
how does this guy know I'm terrified of death?
I think about it all the time.
So we talk about the issues that matter.
And I begin by giving them an in and out card, or even at the end.
And sometimes I say to people,
would you like to do an interview on YouTube?
And they say, no, I'm too shy.
I say, well, here's an in and out card anyway.
Anyway, and they go,
I said, what?
I didn't do anything.
I said, it doesn't matter.
I just like you.
I care about you.
I know you'd like In-N-Out.
It creates incredibly a good feeling between us,
immediate, you know, I just leave.
Some people say, why are you doing this?
And I say, it's because there's not enough
love in this world, and this is the way you
can express love in Southern California.
Give somebody an In-N-Out card or two of them
so they can get a double-double.
And so that's the only reason I give it out,
give them out, and I've given out quite a
few.
If you don't mind me asking, how much have
you spent just on these in-and-out burger?
Well, $34,000, no, $35,000,
and they're $5 each, so whatever that comes to.
Wow. And that's all in an attempt to reach people
and show them that you love them?
That's about it. You've summed it up.
You quite literally put your money where your mouth is.
Okay, I do want to talk about bad people, good people.
But before I do, to your point,
it is fair of me that we first understand who is Ray Comfort.
Because I don't know many people who were born to a Jewish mother.
who believe in Jesus Christ as their Lord and Saviour.
So I was wondering if you could just unpack that for us.
Where did this come about?
Well, I've been born twice in New Zealand.
I was born physically and then I was born again at the age of 22.
My mum was Jewish.
She married a Gentile and was kicked out of the family.
And so my mum and dad decided they'd put Methodist
on my birth certificate
because I was born in 1949, not too long after the Second World War,
and they were afraid of a Holocaust,
another one, so they just put Methodist.
So I was left without any instruction whatsoever about God.
I believed in God, intuitively, we all do,
there's no such thing as an atheist.
But I had a Solomon experience, do you know what that is?
Cut a baby in half?
No!
It was just a thread. He didn't actually
do it, but you know, that's good.
No, I didn't have the wisdom of Solomon,
the riches of Solomon, or the wives of Solomon.
I only had one wife, but I did have the philosophy of Solomon.
At the age of 20, I grew old prematurely. I had my own business.
I used to make leather jackets,
classy jackets like this, to order for people,
plus cowboy jackets with fringes, and a surf shop.
It was a combined shop called Leather Gear. It was very prosperous.
And I had everything I wanted at the age of 20, 21.
And I thought, what's next?
I'm waiting around to die.
And I remember looking at my wife,
because I didn't want to travel anymore.
I didn't want to make more money.
I was there.
I looked at my wife who had just gone to sleep,
and I wept.
Tears streamed down my face as I cried out,
why?
Why does everything and everyone have to die?
Why is it that my beautiful wife,
who I love with a passion,
could be snatched from me by this thing called death,
this great big elephant in the room
that's stomping on everybody,
but no one talks about.
And I didn't understand it.
And that's when I wept.
I didn't realize I was praying, but I was.
The Bible says God hears everything you pray and you earnestly cry out.
And six months later, I was on a surfing trip,
and some guy left a Bible on a desk.
And I just started reading the Sermon on the Mount, and it said this.
Jesus said, you've heard it said by them of old,
you shall not commit adultery.
And I just halted.
I said, well, if there's a heaven, I'll get there
because I've never committed adultery.
But then I read what came next.
It said, but I say to you, whoever looks upon
a woman to lust for her has committed adultery
already within his heart.
It was like an arrow hit my chest
because I was like every other red-blooded guy.
I lived for the pleasure of lust.
And I thought, I've got to see my thought life.
And I didn't realize that.
I mean, shall he who formed the eye also see?
Gave man a brain?
Doesn't he know what we think?
And I got that revelation.
And I thought, I'm in big trouble on Judgment Day.
I'm heading to hell.
And that's when I understood why Jesus died on the cross.
We broke the law of the Ten Commandments.
Jesus paid the fine in full.
And if you're in court and someone pays
you fine, you've got speeding fine.
Someone pays it, the judge will legally let you go.
So you're out of here.
Someone's paid you fine.
That's legal, even though you're guilty.
Well, God can legally take death off us
because Jesus paid the fine in full on that cross
and rose from the dead, defeated death.
And if we simply repent, which is what I did that night,
trust in Jesus like a trusted parachute,
God promises, and he cannot lie,
he'll grant us everlasting life.
And all it is is a fulfillment of Old Testament prophecy
where God promised he would destroy death for humanity.
New Testament tells us how he did it.
So that's Ray Comfort, born again,
Christian from a Jewish family.
So you're not scared of death, but you embrace it?
No, no. I'm not excited about it, but put it this way.
Before I was a Christian,
I was like a man standing on the edge of a plane 10,000 feet,
in the dark, having to jump. Horrific.
In Christ, I have a parachute. A parachute changes everything.
When you jump, you're still scared, but you're not going to land
at 120 miles an hour on your face.
You're now going to land on your feet at 15 miles an hour.
So what happens when you trust in Jesus as your Savior?
He takes the sting out of death.
Oh, death, where is your sting?
Grave, where is your victory?
And my faith in a parachute or my fear when I jump out of a plane
will be determined by how much I trust the parachute.
If I trust the parachute 100%, I'll go whoopee and jump.
If I'm scared, it means I don't trust the parachute.
So when I pass through death, I'm coming up to 77,
so I may not finish this interview.
My fear will be in direct proportion to my faith in Jesus.
If I totally trust him as my savior, I'll have no fear.
If I've got fear, it means I don't trust him.
Ever dishonor God by having fear in my heart because faith honors God.
Like if you've got a wife and you say,
I don't trust you, honey, your marriage is
shot.
If you say to your boss, I don't trust you, you're out of a job.
And if we say to God, I don't trust you,
it's an insult to his integrity.
That's why the Bible says, have faith in God.
Trust him because he has faithfully promised.
So I'm curious how you would respond to the following.
In Bill Maher's Religious Documentary,
he speaks to an actor who plays Jesus Christ
at some biblically themed amusement park.
That was awful.
Yeah, so he asks this Jesus character.
Thank
You know, why do you believe in God?
And he says, well, God promises eternal paradise when I die.
I just have to have trust in him, and I
so look forward to the afterlife.
you
And Bill Maher, in his typical cynical way, says,
well, then why don't you just kill yourself
and just go to eternal paradise now?
very
And so I'm not asking you, why don't you kill yourself?
Because to your point, you're 77, so the
choice may not be yours pretty soon.
But, um...
What is it about this life that makes you excited
much.
and happy and content?
What is it about your relationship in Jesus Christ
that makes you not want to have not merely eternal paradise,
but also heaven on earth as well?
Well, I used to have a look around
at the genius of God's creative hand.
Flowers, birds, trees, the sun, the moon,
the stars, the sky, sunrise, sunset.
Hummingbird, a newborn, baby just come out of the womb,
living human being, all these
things show us the genius of God's creative hand,
but at the same time, we have cancer,
disease, pain, suffering, and death,
all these terrible things, and what some people tend
to do is say, I don't believe in God because of suffering,
no, no, don't use suffering
as an excuse to reject God,
use it as a very real reason to believe what the Bible says
All these things exist, these sufferings,
because we live in a fallen creation according to Genesis.
So when we see suffering,
all it does is confirm exactly what the Bible says.
But the Bible promises there's a new world coming.
God's kingdom is coming on this earth,
and God's will will be done on this earth as it is in heaven.
The coming kingdom,
God says he'll restore the earth as it was in the Garden of Eden.
No disease, pain, suffering, or death.
Earthquakes, tornadoes, all these things
are signs of a fallen creation.
In fact, the Bible puts it this way.
No eye has ever seen, nor ear heard,
neither has it entered into the imagination of man
the things that God has prepared for those that love him.
And the way to be part of that kingdom
is simply to acknowledge your sins
and put your trust in Christ as your savior.
That's good news for Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists.
All these great religions are trying to earn heaven, Jews,
trying to earn heaven by their good works.
And you can't do it.
It's impossible to buy everlasting life from God.
It can only come by God's amazing grace.
So let me understand, and I'll respectfully push back.
You talk about this fallen creation and this broken world.
So my response would be, okay,
so now it's up to us as mortal men to kind of fix it.
But everything that you have been describing up until
this point is, it's a fallen world.
But, God is going to restore it.
And I also have faith that God will restore the world.
But in Hebrew we have what's called Heshtadlos,
which literally means effort.
Meaning it's not up to God alone.
God can certainly help you complete the work,
but you as a person also have to do that thing.
In fact, in Pirkei Avos, The Ethics of Our Fathers,
it's a 2nd century rabbinic text,
it literally says this, lo alecha hamlacha ligmor,
it's not up to you to see that the
work is completed, ava lo ata ben horin,
but you're not free or absolved from simply doing
nothing.
So can't you do both of those things at the same time?
As in have faith and trust in God,
but at the same time recognize that God created me
for a specific purpose.
Perhaps that purpose is to help repair
the world that I would agree with you is still
obviously broken.
Yeah.
Totally agree with you.
Okay.
That was easy.
Let's go.
Do you want to expand on that?
No.
I totally agree.
We've got to look after the earth.
You don't pollute it.
I'm from a surfing background.
I hate pollution in the ocean.
Well, I don't just mean protecting the world in a physical sense.
I mean, certainly it's true, but in every way,
in the sense of, you know, there is corruption
in this world, there's theft, there is tax evasion,
and we have an obligation to build
a more moral, just society and not merely say,
well, Jesus, take the wheel.
Because it's true, Jesus can take the wheel,
but I would imagine Jesus would prefer if
you're a competent driver who passed an exam
and has an ability to drive a car too.
Like, that would help, no?
Yeah, Tesla would work too.
Right, Tesla would work too.
So if it's okay with you, I'd love to go back to the original point
that I certainly jumped the gun on before,
but that's this dichotomy of good person, bad person, heaven, hell.
As I said, I agree, I would concede
the point that I'm not a perfect man.
In fact, in Chabad Hasidus, specifically the Tanya,
which is the magnum opus of Chabad's philosophical work,
there's something called the Benonani, which...
Literally means the middleman, but even then, the Ulta Rebbe,
the Bal Tanya, who's the founder of the Chabad Hasidic movement,
he would agree that most of us will strive to be a middleman,
because really, we're not even that.
We're so beyond imperfect.
But nevertheless, as I said, on a mere objective level,
I don't commit adultery, I don't steal, I don't murder.
I sin just like the average human being on planet Earth sins.
Can you be specific?
To my specific sense, well, I don't want...
The IRS is listening, so I don't want to be on record.
I just want to put a little bit of heat on you then.
I mean, I...
I'll put it this way. In Judaism, you have to pray three times a day.
I do not pray three times a day because I'm lazy.
You have to put on the phylacteries, those black leather boxes.
I do it. I can't say I do it every single day.
You have to make blessings before food. I'm pretty forgetful.
I don't think they're big sins.
So, okay, whether they're big sins or not sins,
point being, even if they were huge sins,
does that really disqualify me from heaven?
And I guess the question I'm really getting at here...
Is we've had so many Christian guests in that chair,
and I will ask them a straightforward question
that I think you know what I'm about to ask,
and they don't really answer it, which is to say as follows.
I think I'm a pretty good person, more or less.
There are certain things I have to be held accountable for.
Agreed. But I'm kind of okay.
But I don't accept Jesus as my Lord and Savior. Am I going to hell?
Let me answer that with...
Okay, but you do have to give me a direct answer,
and I won't be offended.
And the last point I'll say, and then I'll shut up.
I actually get more upset when people in that chair
who get asked the exact same question say,
well, just say yes or no.
And I'm actually, I will respect you more if you just say yes,
because I know the answer is yes,
but I just want a Christian to tell it to me.
I want you to tell me, but give me a minute.
Okay.
Okay.
You're a doctor.
You've got a patient in front of you that is incredibly well-looking.
He goes to the gym every day.
Physique like this.
What's so funny?
And you know he's got cancer because you've looked at x-rays.
He's dying.
He's going to be dead in three weeks.
Slymph node.
And he doesn't know it.
You've got a cure in your pocket.
Do you show him the x-rays or give him the cure?
You're the doctor.
It's your call.
I would just give him the cure?
That's a huge mistake.
Okay.
This is why.
He thinks he's well.
He looks good. He goes to the gym every day.
You slide a cure across the table to him and say, what's this for?
Look at me. Look at my physique. There's nothing wrong with me.
What are you doing? This is insulting.
Now, if you're a good doctor, you'll show him the x-rays.
You'll say, look at these x-rays.
This is your x-rays. We just took them.
See this poison seeping through your system?
You can be dead in three weeks.
And as a doctor, you look at him and say, he's starting to sweat.
This is good. He's seeing the seriousness of the situation.
And after a minute, that healthy guy says, doctor,
I can see there's a serious, what should I do?
Now he's ready for the cure.
He's going to appreciate it.
He's going to appropriate it
because he's seen his disease, so he'll appreciate the
cure.
Does that make sense?
Sure.
Okay.
Now, the reason I told you that,
because I've got a cure to death, but you don't want it.
What I'm going to do is show you the x-rays,
and those x-rays are the Ten Commandments.
You say you're a good person.
Let me ask you a few questions.
All I want from you is your honesty. Can you be real honest with me?
Yes, but you still cannot evade the yes or no answer.
I am not evading it. You're going
to be giving the yes or no in a minute.
Okay.
I want real honesty from you. How many lies have you told in your life?
Many.
What do you call someone who tells lies?
A liar.
So what are you?
A liar.
Have you ever stolen something in your whole life, even if it's small?
Yeah.
What do you call someone who steals?
A thief.
So what are you?
A thief.
No, you're not. You're a lying thief.
Have you ever used God's name in vain?
Yeah.
That's taking God's holy name and using it as a cuss word.
Would you do that with your mother's name?
You hit your thumb with a hammer,
and you want to say what we use for human excrement,
beginning with S.
Would you take your mother's name
and use it in place of that filth word?
Right.
You wouldn't, would you?
Right.
Because you'd dishonor her.
You'd love her.
But you've taken the name of the God that gave you a mother
and used it in place of
human excrement.
It's called blasphemy, punishable by death in the Old Testament.
Appreciate your honesty.
Two to go.
Jesus said, if you look at a woman and lust for her,
you commit adultery with her in your heart.
Have you ever looked at a woman with lust?
No comment, but you can figure, yes.
Yes.
We can edit that part out.
Okay, how about this part?
When did you last look at pornography?
I actually don't watch porn.
No, I didn't ask that.
I said, when did you last look at pornography?
Willingly?
Never.
Never.
But it does pop up on social media, yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
So when you look with lust, you commit adultery in the heart.
You have sex before marriage.
No comment.
I was not expecting a grilling from you, buddy.
You wanted it.
Just say no or say yes.
If you want to lie, go ahead.
Listen, it's very hard for women to resist.
Yes, I can understand that.
So, you've just told me, and I'm not judging you,
you're a lying thief, a blasphemer, an adulterer at heart,
and probably a fornicator, and you have to face God on Judgment Day.
If he judges you by the Ten Commandments,
we've looked at four, on Judgment Day will you be innocent or guilty?
I mean, guilty, but, you know, I'll just go with your example.
I'll be guilty.
Yeah, heaven or hell.
Again, I'm Jewish, so our perception is very,
very different than how you're describing it,
but just based on your standards, hell.
Yeah, well, it's not my standards.
This is God's standards.
He says in Scripture, all liars will have
their part in the lake of fire.
And what adds to our guilt is conscience.
The word conscience means with knowledge.
God has taken the time to give a light to every man,
the word conscience, with knowledge.
So every time you lie, you steal, you fornicate, you blaspheme,
you do it with knowledge that it's wrong,
and what you do is store up wrath.
It's going to be revealed on the day of judgment.
Man, I don't want you to go to hell.
I've just met you, but I love you.
If there's no tears in my eyes, there's tears in my voice.
Do you know what death is according to the Bible?
It's wages. Ever heard the Bible verse, the wages of sin is death?
Very famous. It's saying
this, that God is paying you in death for your sins.
Like a judge who looks at a criminal
who thinks lightly of raping a woman and killing her.
This is just prostitutes. The judge says,
I'm going to show you how serious your crime is.
I'm giving you the death sentence. This
is your wages. This is what you've earned. This is what you deserve.
And sin is so serious to a holy God,
he's given you the death sentence.
You're on death row,
and your death will be evidence to you
that God is deadly serious about sin.
And yet in that same Bible verse,
it says the wages of sin is death,
but the gift of God is eternal life
through Jesus Christ our Lord.
You cannot earn eternal life.
It's too precious.
And yet people think they can earn it
by praying three times a day,
five times a day,
fasting.
Doing good works. No, you can't bribe God to forgive sins.
It can only come by his amazing grace.
And that was extended in Jesus. God became a human being,
a perfect sinless man, as the Lamb of God, the Passover.
That's what Jesus was, our Passover. Yes.
Died on the cross, and his blood means God can let death pass over you
because he satisfied eternal justice with his life's blood.
Defeated death. And as I said,
all you have to do is repent and trust in him.
Acknowledge your sins and say, I need a savior.
I need the Lamb of God.
I need the promised Messiah.
Look at Psalm 22 or Isaiah 53 speaks of Jesus suffering,
dying for our sins.
Very clearly a suffering Messiah, Isaiah 53,
is bruised for our iniquities, the Bible says.
And so that's the promise of God.
He didn't leave man in death.
He's offered us eternal life upon our repentance and faith in Jesus.
So I didn't say you're going to hell.
You said you're going to hell.
And I just got to agree with you.
And as I said, that breaks my heart.
I don't want you to go to hell.
So I have lots of questions.
I don't even know where to begin.
This might be unfair of me to say this,
because I actually don't want to engage in a discussion on this,
because I don't believe in debating theology.
But just because you mentioned Isaiah 53,
I would argue you can't read Isaiah 53 without reading Isaiah 52,
where it's quite obvious that God is referring
to this suffering servant as the Jewish people.
It's a metaphor, not an actual physical person.
I know that's unfair of me to say this, because I
actually don't want to dwell on that for this episode,
but I promise we can talk about this right
after, and you can tell me why I'm wrong.
But I do want to get into something
that you had said that, to me, doesn't make a...
sense because you are wrong, because...
I know, but...
But just for the sake of this episode,
you can tell me why I'm wrong offline, and then
we could, I'll go back on your show, and you'll tell me why I'm wrong.
It doesn't fit.
Okay.
But you said that God doesn't merely just want you to fast
or repent, but then how do
you understand the Hebrew Bible that literally says,
in reference to the Day of Atonement,
Yom Kippur,
That God has created this day for you to repent for all of your sins.
I mean, God literally says, I will create a day where you can repent.
So I agree, we're sinners.
Where I think we probably disagree
here, and again, I don't want to engage...
too much in a debate, really just to get your understanding,
how do you understand the
Hebrew Bible when it says there are days that you can repent
and I, God, can accept that
teshuvah, we call it in Hebrew, that repentance.
And you can be saved.
I think just the crux of the disagreement here,
and this is not a revelation here,
is that you believe our repentance is only through a third person,
and we believe that repentance is through ourselves.
We ask God, and God hopefully will say yes.
So how do you make sense of something like the Day of Atonement,
at least is how it's spelt out in the Hebrew Bible?
Where's your blood sacrifice?
Well, because we can't give sacrifices
because there's no temple, the Torah has said, and
this is corroborated by the Talmud,
that our sacrifices are in our daily prayers.
In fact, when we pray, especially on the Sabbath,
one of our prayers is literally just talking
about, from the Hebrew Bible, the daily sacrifices,
and we conclude the recitation of the daily
sacrifices by saying, it is as if, God,
we have given the sacrifices, we can't because
there's no temple, but please consider
our prayer as if it was a sacrifice.
Okay, let me give you another analogy.
Yeah.
I'll put you in a courtroom.
Okay.
Serious crime. You've raped a woman, then she died.
Okay, we'll take...
You robbed a bank.
Yeah, you pick really awful cases.
You robbed a bank.
Okay, I'm okay with that.
And shot a guard, and he died.
Okay.
And you say to the judge, judge,
I'm really sorry, and I won't do it again.
Is the judge going to let you go?
No.
Of course not.
Because there's accountability.
Yeah, you should be sorry.
And of course, you shouldn't do it again.
So in man's court, repentance cannot save you from man's justice.
There must be punishment given.
And in God's court on Judgment Day,
all the repentance in the world cannot save you.
There must be a...
Punishment for sin, and that's where
the sacrifice comes in, and that's where Jesus
was the ultimate sacrifice.
John the Baptist, when he saw Jesus for the first time,
said, behold, the Lamb of God
who takes away the sin of the world.
I speak to a lot of Muslims.
Muslims rest in their own repentance to save them.
They always do.
They can't save you.
Not man's court won't save you on judgment day.
You need a savior.
You need a lamb of God who washes away sin once and for all.
The Old Testament, those sacrifices were just temporal sacrifices.
When Jesus came, it was permanent.
His blood was perfect, and it washes sin instantly.
So the moment I became a Christian,
all my sins were forgiven, past, present, and future.
When I stand before God, I've got boldness
on the day of wrath, the Bible says.
Because of my own goodness?
No, because of God's amazing grace.
Yeah, and to be clear, as much as I was discussing repentance,
It's also true that in the Hebrew Bible,
and this is further again corroborated by the rabbis,
the full expression is uteshuvah, utefilah,
utzedukah, ma'avirin, eserol, gazardinenah,
which literally means repenting, teshuva,
tefilah, prayer, utzedukah, charity,
which also just means good deeds, broadly
speaking, can remove the evil decree.
So it's not enough that you just pray.
In fact, the prophet Isaiah says,
I think it's Isaiah, who said this as well,
that God doesn't just want your sacrifices to absolve you
from the difficult work of improving yourself.
He needs you to do things as well.
And, in fact, even on the Day
of Atonement Yom Kippur, God himself says,
I can only grant you forgiveness
for sins you have committed against me.
So when you're meant to make blessings on food
and you don't, I can forgive you for that.
But when you wronged your fellow man, I can't forgive you for that.
Only your fellow man can forgive you for that.
Where does that come from?
That comes from the rabbinic tradition.
That's corroborated by the Hebrew Bible.
So God says in the book of Deuteronomy,
I need to set up a system of adjudication whereby
if you have questions, you go to these rabbinic sages
and the rabbinic sages will be able
to deduce what is it that I want from you.
So that's been our understanding for at least 2,500 years.
So you remember what David said to God
when he sinned with Bathsheba, he committed
murder.
He skittled all ten of the Ten Commandments, didn't he? The whole ten.
Yeah, we had Pastor Rob McCoy, actually,
who discussed David violating the Ten Commandments.
He coveted his neighbor's wife, lived a lie,
stole his neighbor's wife, committed adultery, committed murder,
dishonored his parents, and must dishonored God.
I think he kept the Sabbath, though.
No, you can't keep a Sabbath with adultery
and murder. You violate everything.
You break one point of the law, you break them all.
Right.
You don't have to break ten laws to
have the police after you. Just one.
So what did he say in Psalm 51?
Have mercy upon me, O God, according to your loving kindness,
according to the multitude of your tender mercies.
Blot out my transgressions against you,
and you only have I sinned and done us evil in your sight.
That was adultery and murder.
It was God's law that he violated. It wasn't man's.
So when we sin through lying or stealing or lust, we sin against God.
He's the one that's angry because this is a law that's being broken.
And so the only way to be forgiven is through a blood sacrifice.
Without the shedding of blood, there's no forgiveness of sins.
Repentance can't help you.
Just humble yourself and trust in the God-given Messiah, Jesus Christ.
You know, answer me this.
It just seems weird to me.
You know how people use the name of Jesus Christ as a cuss word?
Through Hollywood?
It's worldwide.
Always has been.
Why?
They haven't used Hitler's name as a cuss word,
didn't use Mussolini's name as a cuss word,
didn't use Mother Teresa's name, not even Rasputin.
But why do they take the name of Jesus Christ,
the kindest man that ever lived?
The most forgiving man that ever lived,
the one that cried, Father, forgive them.
They know not what they're doing when they're crucifying him.
Why do they use his name as a cuss word?
Well, John 7, verse 7, Jesus told us.
He said, The world hates me
because I testify of its deeds that they're evil.
His name is hated for the same reason criminals hate the police,
because they stand for righteousness, and the criminals stand for evil.
We're sinners by nature, and that's why
the name of Jesus is so used as a cuss word.
Again, I have so many questions because this is really fascinating,
but the immediate question
that comes to mind is throughout the Hebrew Bible,
God forgives people constantly, and
he gives, Moses was called the Yud, Gimel,
Midos, Harachmim, the 13 attributes of mercy
of Hashem, Hashem, Karachm, Hanun, Erech,
Hapayim, Rech, Hesav, Yemen, Ozer, Hesav,
Lafim, Nozei, Avon, V'Heshav, V'Hatav, V'Nakeh,
you know, God all-merciful, compassionate,
all-knowing, and I guess if that is true that God is forgiving people,
then why the need
for Jesus?
And if there's still a need for Jesus,
then shouldn't Jesus have been created first?
Yeah, great question. Are you familiar with the words of Jesus?
Remind me, we didn't learn about it in rabbinical school?
He said crazy, crazy things that make no sense, no sense whatsoever.
He said things like this,
Marvel not at this, for the hour is coming
when all that are in their graves,
that's billions and billions of people, shall hear my voice.
He said, I'm the way, the truth, and the life.
No man comes to the Father but by me.
He said, I'm the resurrection and the life.
He that believes in me, though he dies, yet shall he live.
And whoever lives and believes in me shall never die.
He was either the greatest liar that's ever lived,
deceiver, or he was God in human form.
This is where I'm going with this.
He said, Abraham rejoiced to see my day.
That's a crazy thing to say.
Abraham was, what, 1,500 years before him?
And he said, Abraham rejoiced to see my day.
So did Moses rejoice to see the day
when God would give the sacrifice once and for all that would...
Balance the scales. Justify us. Our big problem is equity.
God's going to have his day of equity.
Equity is when the scales are balanced.
You're in your sins on judgment day. God's wrath will
come upon you justly. And you need someone
who can wash away those sins in an instant. And that's
what Jesus promises to do.
So what does that mean on a practical level? Because let's say I agree
with what you're saying and I come up to you after the show
and I say, Pastor, or I'll say, Ray,
you're right. I totally put my trust in the Lord Jesus.
What does that practically do?
Thank you.
Conceptually, it almost seems as if I'm absolving myself
of personal or individual responsibility,
and as I was alluding to earlier, simply putting it on a third person.
Jesus died for my sins.
Okay, fine.
So I will keep sinning, because I know
I'm a sinner, I'm a terrible person,
but I'll just put my trust in Jesus, and he'll save me.
Why is that any better?
Yeah, it's the same reason putting on a parachute and jumping.
Okay.
Is that made clear?
What does that mean on a practical level?
On a practical level, he saves you from wrath to come.
The Bible says, put on the Lord Jesus Christ.
But here's the miracle of conversion.
The moment you repent and trust in Jesus,
God promises in the Old Testament, he says,
I'll give you a new heart.
I'll cause you to walk in my statutes.
That's what happens.
And I found the moment I became a Christian, I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus.
Burn with a desire to do the will of God.
Never even thought about God for 22 years.
And it's because I've been born again.
God gave me the Holy Spirit.
And God will change your desires so you love to walk in his statutes.
You're not better than anyone else, but like wearing a parachute,
you surely are better off than someone who's not wearing a parachute.
So I'm not better than you.
And I still have my sinful desires.
When I see a dirty billboard, I'm tempted to look at it.
When I see a lustful lady, I'm tempted to look.
But I don't want to play the hypocrite.
You know, God's forgiven me, so I want to stay in his perfect will.
And God says, I'll give you the Holy Spirit
to help you overcome that sinful nature.
And it really is a sinful nature.
It's so strong.
A man says, I've got no problem with cigarettes.
I smoke 40 a day.
Well, take the cigarettes off of them and watch what happens to them.
And when we try not to sin, we realize how sinful we are.
When you give yourself to it, you've got no problem with the lust.
Yes, because you're giving yourself to it.
You try and stop and see how powerful it is.
Jesus said, he that serves sin is a slave of sin.
And we certainly are a slave of sin when we give ourselves to it.
So being a Christian just means your sins are washed away.
And on judgment day, you're clean.
The slate is clean.
So I don't want to sound like a Pharisee.
I'm not trying to be difficult.
I am just trying to understand your perspective.
I love it.
Thank
I actually asked Pastor Sean McDowell this,
he was the first guest of our show in that chair,
and I said something that I never truly understood
about Christianity is if what you just said is
you
correct, which that is your belief system,
that the belief in Jesus alone is enough to
very
save someone from the eternal damnation.
If SEAL Team 6 is knocking on Osama bin Laden's door
much.
and he really is convinced in his heart of hearts,
I was doing the wrong thing my whole life,
And he really does accept his Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ.
That's it? That really is enough?
That's question number one. And then question number two is,
let's say I do accept Jesus, which I will be very forthcoming.
I'm not convinced, not from you,
but just in general, I'm very comfortable with my Judaism.
I find a lot of meaning and purpose
in it. I think it's also quite logical.
But if I am to accept Jesus, well, I don't want to share
heaven with Osama bin Laden. That doesn't
sound like something I would enjoy very much.
Why didn't you go straight to Hitler?
Osama bin Laden's probably down here. Hitler's up there
There were 11 million people.
So if he accepted Jesus, yeah,
these are scenarios that we play with in our minds.
But let me go to someone else that was just about
as nasty, but not to the same degree.
There was a man that hated Christians
to a point where he would arrest them and torture them and kill them.
Saul of Tarsus.
He was on the road to Damascus.
Suddenly there was a voice from heaven
and light that shone brighter than the sun.
And he said, Saul, Saul, why are you persecuting me?
He said, who are you, Lord?
And that word, Lord, means master of the universe, the ultimate master.
Who are you, Lord?
And he says, I am Jesus, whom you are persecuting.
This is what the Bible says of Jesus.
He was in the beginning with God.
All things were made by him, he is the word of God, and that word,
the voice of God, so to speak, became flesh and dwelt amongst us.
That's why Jesus said strange, strange things about his voice.
He said, marvel not at this, the hour is coming
when all that are in their graves shall hear my voice.
When Jesus comes, the Bible says there'll be a shout from God.
In other words, his voice will raise the dead.
Because his voice is the creator
that created all things in the beginning.
And so, um,
He is able to save to the uttermost.
That means someone like you, a lying thief,
a blasphemer, a fornicator, an adulterer at heart,
someone with a multitude of sins,
he's able to save to the uttermost those that come to God by him.
And the thing is, too, you talked about believing in Jesus.
I don't believe in Jesus.
I believed in Jesus before I was a Christian.
When you're a Christian, you come to know him in the same way.
That if I said to you, a little kid's looking at a heater,
and the little kid is told not to touch the heater because it's hot.
At that point in time, the kid has
an intellectual belief the heater's hot.
But when Dad goes out and reaches out and grabs the heater bar,
he no longer believes the heat is hot.
He knows it's hot.
He's moved out of the realm of belief into the realm of experience.
That's what happens when you come to Christ.
And you don't become a Christian by giving your life to Jesus
or asking Jesus into your heart.
It comes through repentance of sin and faith in Jesus.
They're the two things that are necessary.
We have masses of hypocrites and false converts who have...
Given their hearts to Jesus,
but there's no repentance and they're not, they're not saved.
There's no genuine conversion.
So Bin Laden would not be saved.
I don't know.
God is his judge.
So fine.
So let me, let me just be annoying then.
If Bin Laden really was in this hypothetical
scenario, he really did believe it and he
really did regret and he really did not just believe,
but know Jesus in the final moments
of his life, then presumably based
on your philosophical outlook, he would be saved and
he would be sent to heaven.
Assuming everything I just said is true.
He really did believe it.
Well, that's kind of my question of like,
so how do you make sense of that?
Well, you don't have to make sense of it.
If your whole outlook, and this is not an attack,
I'm really trying to just understand this.
Your whole outlook is if one comes to know God
and puts his trust in him, whatever the right terminology is.
In Jesus.
In Jesus Christ, yes, to be clear.
Well, if that's true, and anyone can do it, including Osama bin Laden,
right before SEAL Team 6 puts the bullet in his head,
or right before Adolf Hitler bites into the cyanide,
then they would be able to go into...
But he shot himself.
I think he did both, actually.
I think he did a cyanide capsule and shot himself.
He shot himself first.
Shaddam's right. Two bullet holes.
But by your own perspective then,
those people would be accepted into heaven.
Okay, now let me give you a scenario.
I agree with you, but listen to this.
Well, I don't agree with me. I'm just using your words.
I'm going to just play along with it to make
this point, and it's very important.
The day comes when you stand before God.
Maybe you die as a 40-year-old or car accident,
but you get resurrected.
You stand before God in judgment
because God will bring every word to judgment,
including every secret thing that is good or evil,
according to Solomon, according to Scripture.
And as you stand before God,
you say, that day, God says,
that day, Ray Comfort gave you the whole gospel,
but you rejected it because you had this scenario
with some of Bin Laden.
You'd say, what a fool I was.
You use that as an excuse.
To reject eternal life.
Because if you want to carry on your sins,
you could think of a hundred scenarios like that
that can be an excuse for you to reject the mercy of God.
Don't do that.
Go and play with forked lightning,
but don't reject the mercy of God.
He offers it to you.
He's given you life.
He gave you eyes to see with,
ears to hear with,
a brain to think with.
You know life is better than death,
so why would you embrace death
when God says in this word,
the gift of God is eternal life?
Eternal life. Not as this miserable life we're in now,
but eternal pleasure.
Pleasure forevermore, as the psalmist says.
That's what's in the offering.
Right. I think it would just be easier for me
and millions of others to come to Jesus
if we had clear answers on those things.
But I do get your perspective, though.
Yeah.
So let me move on, unless you want to answer.
No, no. I love this.
Okay. Let me ask then, somewhat similarly,
I can understand the theological problems with theodicy.
You know, why do bad things happen to good people?
Why do good things happen to bad people?
Why does God create a very dark, evil world?
Well, there's no good.
Okay, that's also perspective.
But let me just ask the question, and then I'll let you respond.
Why would God create people knowing full well
that they would never accept Jesus?
If he loves us so much, why would he condemn?
Hundreds of millions of people, if not billions of people,
cumulatively over time, to eternal damnation.
Well, firstly, let's go back to the good
people thing and we'll get over it.
Okay.
David said, Psalm 14, God looked down
from heaven upon the children of men and said,
is there any good?
And they said, there was none, altogether given to evil.
Jesus said, there's none good but God.
Good in God's book means moral perfection.
Look in the dictionary, there's 43
different definitions of the word good.
Number one is moral excellence.
So the scriptures don't paint us as good people.
Nobody is good.
It says, our heart is deceitfully wicked.
We drink iniquity like water.
And someone says, I believe people are good.
I say, well, put your wallet down there.
Let's come back in an hour.
Why would you lock your door at night if you think people are good?
People have got wicked hearts.
And even with the law, people are wicked.
Imagine if law was removed from America
and any guy could grab any woman he wants,
do anything he wants.
What a terrible world this would be.
So why did God create humanity,
knowing humanity would sin because he has foreknowledge?
I don't know.
I have no idea.
But I do know that God is a God of justice,
and that's what the Bible paints him as right through Psalms.
It said he's going to judge the world in righteousness.
Solomon, God will judge the world in righteousness.
That's a fearful thing, and that's what we should be worried about,
not some intellectual exercise where we get to understand things.
I mean, I can't understand how my eye works.
I can't understand how my dog's eye works.
I can look at my dog's eye and talk about what we did during the day
and see all these emotions in the dog's eye.
I said, we saw a cat, didn't we?
So how could I understand God
when I can't figure out how he can make an eye, a dog that
has all these emotions, that loves me,
that knows what faithfulness is, that will chase
a cat instinctively.
All these things that are inherent in that dog.
God knows every single hair in that dog,
every direction it's been pointed at to grow.
How could I know the mind of God?
So I have these theological dilemmas,
but I just let go of them and say, I trust God.
Like a little kid trusts his father.
It seems like a theme from this conversation has
been that while I may not be able to ascertain
certain specifics about God's plan or my role in God's plan,
ultimately my belief supersedes
those specific questions I may not have an answer to just yet.
And that I think is a very powerful affirmation,
not just of your belief system, but of the
belief system that you're trying
to persuade essentially millions of other people across
Let me ask you because we've
also been talking about damnation and repenting,
are there any sins by which God will never
be able to forgive you? And the reason I
ask you is because in Judaism there's
something called Chayiv Kares. Kares
is essentially translated into a spiritual excommunication,
whereby there are certain
things where you're spiritually cut off.
Interestingly enough, one of them is going
on the Holy of Holies, the Kodesh HaKodeshim,
on the Temple Mount, which is where the high priest
would go only once a year on the Day of Atonement
for a very short amount of time. And in fact,
the Bible relates that the priest would tie a string around him.
So in case he died on the
Holy of Holies, they would literally pull him out.
And so that's actually one of the things that you would
be spiritually cut off from, even today,
which is why the majority of Jews do not go on the Temple Mount today,
because we don't exactly know where the Holy of Holies was.
Anyway, that's a long way of me asking,
are there sins today that even Jesus says,
I can't, I can't forgive you, it's too far, it's too much?
Well, the Bible says he's able to save
to the uttermost them that come to God by him.
So I wouldn't worry about...
The wickedness of our sins, I meditate on the grace of God.
God is rich in mercy to all that call upon him.
There's one sin that Jesus spoke
of that called blasphemy of the Holy Spirit.
Most people don't really know what that is.
As Jesus said, it has no forgiveness.
But in the Holy of Holies,
that's where you've got to enter the judgment day.
You've got to stand before a holy God,
and you don't want to be there in your sins,
because the wrath will come upon you to the uttermost, the Bible says.
That's why you need a Savior.
Boy, if I could just hug you into the kingdom, I would do it right now.
I really do love you, and I want to see you saved.
I want to see you in heaven, not in hell.
It's the same.
Oftentimes when I speak to members of the Church
of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints,
one of the questions I ask them is,
if Joseph Smith was chosen by God
to bring about the Word of God to the Americas,
well, that only happened in the 1830s,
so what about everyone who predates the 1830s?
And they say, yes, that's why it's so
important we do these baptisms by proxy,
Baptize those who have already died.
And that's why they're very invested in genealogical research
because they want to find their ancestors
so they can save them from eternal damnation.
So my question to you is if we need Jesus to be saved,
what about infants who die at birth?
What about indigenous tribes in the Americas
who've never been contacted by missionaries?
What happens to them?
So there's two questions there.
The Bible speaks of the sins of our youth.
I think we're not held responsible for our sins until we deliberately,
willfully begin sinning against God, doing things we know are wrong.
I don't know, but I'm pretty confident in that. And the other thing is,
you find me a tribe that's without sin, and then you've got a problem.
You go to those tribes, they eat each other.
They'll befriend each other
and kill their best friends, some of these tribes.
They commit adultery, they rape, they murder, they lie, they steal.
And God will punish sin wherever it's found.
Your location doesn't mean to say you're
going to be free from the wrath of God.
That's why we send missionaries to say all
those sins can be washed away in a second
if you trust in Jesus.
Well, are they sent to the same level
of hell that actual deliberate sinners are?
Is there sort of a middle ground between heaven and hell,
or it really is a binary black and
white heaven, eternal peace, and the same hell,
eternal damnation for everyone else?
No.
That's a mythology to believe that hell
is going to be the same for everyone.
That would be very, very wicked of God.
It's like a judge condemning someone
to the death sentence that had a speeding ticket
Ray, before I
let you go,
you're
a prolific
author.
To your point, you've written more than 100 books,
even though Wikipedia will only say about 15,
and Compelled, my story, is your latest book.
I guess I'm curious, why write this book now, and what
do you hope listeners or readers of the book will gain from it?
Well, the book's written in a New Zealand accent,
and the question you're supposed to ask
when you see that photo on the front is, what happened?
Right. Maybe we could do a side-by-side comparison.
It's about 29, and it really shows the Genesis curses in play.
It's my life from the moment I was born right through,
and I was born without talent.
I couldn't run because I can't run.
I've got short legs.
I couldn't do the high jump in school.
I couldn't do the long jump, short legs.
But I could do the hurdles because I'd go straight under them.
I couldn't sing, couldn't dance.
I can't even clap.
I've been preaching in churches down south
where they're doing that fancy clap.
I was up on the platform.
I pretended to read my notes because I couldn't clap.
So I'm all about telling them, when you become a Christian,
God goes for the talentless people,
the Davids, he walks past the sons of Jesse,
and that's because faith is the level playing field.
Jesus said, if you've got the faith of a
Mustard seed, you can move mountains.
It doesn't mean physical mountains.
Where would you put them?
It means that if you will just trust God, you'll do great things.
And that's what that book shows,
that if God can use a little nobody like me
to accomplish very interesting and great things, you can use anybody.
That's what the book's about.
Okay, really before I let you go, what message would you want to give,
especially to the young people who are watching this episode,
who are looking for solace, looking
for answers, looking for a value system?
And they don't even know where to begin.
What would that message be to those young people?
Boy, that's a big question.
The Bible says righteousness exalts a nation, Old Testament scripture.
We're a nation that's turned against God.
You hear blasphemy everywhere.
Which is very, very wicked.
There's fornication and lying and stealing, adultery.
We've lost the fear of God.
And the fear of God is the beginning of wisdom.
And Solomon said that.
So we need, who as a nation, get back to fearing God.
And the way to fear God is to show that you love him by obeying him.
Confess and forsake your sins.
Put your trust in Jesus.
And God promises he'll heal the land.
And that's what we must do.
Wow.
Ray Comfort, I want to thank you for your time,
for the In-N-Out Burger gift card, and
Compelled, my story, is officially out now,
so I assume people can get it wherever they
get their books, and really appreciate it again.
I apologize if I came across as a...
As an adversary, nothing is further from the truth,
but I very much just wanted to clarify your points, and I think you did
a really, really good job of clarifying your points,
and I know that my faith is always not just restored, but is amplified
by having these types of conversations, so I appreciate it.
I'm honored to be here, seriously.