Who should fill Minnesota Gov.-elect Amy Klobuchar’s Senate seat? Listeners weigh in

Amy Klobuchar's News
1 follower
Nov 15, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Just when you thought you were rested from the midterm elections,
there is a Senate seat that everyone in Minnesota is talking about.
And that's the seat that will be vacated
by current Senator Amy Klobuchar when she is sworn
in as Minnesota governor.
She'll have to appoint someone to her seat and whoever it is,
could immediately head into campaign mode
if they decide they want to keep the seat for a normal
term. The special election for Minnesota's second
U.S. Senate seat will be about a year from now,
in November of 2027. And no matter what,
it's an appointment that's already attracting a lot
of speculation and a race that could attract a lot of attention.
So this hour, we're talking
with two DFL party veterans
who can help us understand what happens next, what the law says,
and what calculations Klobuchar may make.
as she narrows down her choice. We have Jamie Tindur.
She served as chief of staff to former
Minnesota Governor Mark Dayton.
Most recently, she served as deputy mayor of St. Paul under
Mayor Melvin Carter. She now leads In Your Corner.
That's an executive coaching and consulting firm.
Good to see you, Jamie. Good to see you. Okay.
We also have Abu Amara. He's a DFL political analyst
and Twin Cities attorney. Hi, Abu. Good to be here.
All right, let's just lay out the process for the audience,
which may not be something they're
totally familiar with. When a U.S. Senate seat becomes vacant,
the governor of Minnesota appoints
a temporary senator until a special election can be held.
That's according to state law.
Jamie, what happens next? Like, what's the process from here on out?
Sure. So Senator Klobuchar, Governor-elect Klobuchar, is going to be
talking with a lot of folks. She's going to be thinking about the
The decision that she's going to make,
I think she's going to be looking for someone with
ability to do the job.
And I think she's going to be looking for someone with integrity and
judgment and make a decision in the next couple months.
And I know what's really
critically important is she said that she intends to
complete the work that she has in the Senate.
So these next couple months, while she has
a big agenda of getting prepared to be governor,
she's also taking on finishing up some work in
the Senate that's really important
to her and Minnesotans. Yeah, a lot on her mind. Abu,
what do you think is going through the senator's mind right now?
Yeah, I mean, I agree with everything
that was just said. I think at a macro level,
though, the first question will be,
is this a caretaker position
that then it opens things up for an election?
Or is this really giving somebody a head start
who she believes fundamentally can do the job?
And I think once you make that decision,
it kind of informs the decisions from there.
Right. And so my guess is this is a question
that she's asking potential appointees like,
are you serious and do you want to stick around?
Do you want to just hang out for a few months
and then leave it to others to run, run for that seat?
Now, Jamie, you kind of went through this.
My recollection is that you left Governor Mark Dayton's office.
Kind of in the months before he appointed now Senator Tina Smith,
but help us like pull
back the curtain a little bit.
What was going on at that time?
Sure.
You know, for Governor Dayton,
I think the most important thing for him was recognizing
that the gravity of this position, you know,
you're going to be one of two people who represent
millions of Minnesotans
and arguably the most powerful legislative body in the world.
Thank
The ability to do that job,
the ability to show up on day one and get things done for Minnesotans,
from constituent services to the farm bill to, you know,
you
all of the important things that need to happen.
so
And for Governor Dayton,
the ability to do that job was really critically important.
much.
I think his selection of Tina Smith was also about his...
Just profound trust in her integrity,
her judgment, the relationships she had across
Minnesota, her knowledge of what's going to be important
and how to get things done. So
I think all of those factors are going
to culminate in what is a governing decision
with a whole lot of political implications.
And what about the vetting process? Like how,
what is someone kind of looking at behind
the scenes to make sure that this candidate is,
you know, there's not going to be any surprises, I guess.
Well, I think, you know, thinking about not wanting surprises,
to be in a position like
this with so much public scrutiny,
with so much pressure, it tends to draw a person to
look at people who have had experience being in that spotlight
and know what it is to hold
an office like that, to have that scrutiny.
Thank
But I don't think that that's the only thing to look at.
And again, the capacity to represent Minnesotans in this moment,
I think, is going to be what
you
weighs really heavily on the decision.
All right.
We already have a lot of calls coming in.
I think people really want to share their personal feelings here.
so
So we'll take our first here from Sandy in Two Harbors.
much.
Sandy, what do you want to share?
I would like to give my support,
along with a lot of others of us up here, of Trina Swanson.
She is so qualified for this position.
She's an immigration attorney, and we all love her.
I mean, she beat out, as far as votes, she beat out both Amy.
and Peggy in the 8th District, which is absolutely amazing.
Okay, thank you, Sandy. Abu,
I'm not sure everyone who's listening right now might know who Trina
Swanson is because she was running in the 8th District.
What do we know about her? And like,
how important would name recognition be in a situation like this?
Well, so first, I mean, Trina ran a fantastic campaign.
If you think about the fundamentals
of the 8th Congressional District,
they've actually gone against the broader trends.
And so she really overperformed.
Just a couple points would have been the difference.
You know.
More broadly, I do think name ID is going
to be a big consideration here because number
one is, and I think it's rightly laid out by Jamie,
can the governor trust you, trust
your judgment, and trust you will always do what you believe is right?
That doesn't mean she's always going
to agree, but you believe what is right.
That's kind of point number one.
But point number two is, do Minnesotans trust you?
Do they know you?
Do they have a sense of what you would do in office?
And I think Amy Klobuchar is the standard.
I mean, literally, she ran an ad saying, Minnesotans, you know me.
And I think Minnesotans actually do know Amy Klobuchar.
And so that trust is not simply about, do I know the person?
It's when they're far off in D.C. and I'm
with my kids putting food on the table, I
firmly believe in my gut that they are doing what
is best for my family and for this state.
And I think that's why name ID matters.
Yeah.
Jamie, what about you?
I agree. I, you know, with Tina Smith, she was the lieutenant governor.
She had been on the ballot with Governor Dayton, but her name
recognition wasn't what it was after she ran a campaign on her own.
So I think, you know,
all of the names that I've seen that are being tossed about, I think.
I could make a case for all of them,
and I think that's what's going to be really difficult for
Governor-elect Klobuchar. Because when you're appointed,
you automatically gain some name
recognition. Everyone's going to be real interested
in where you stand on the issues. Speaking of,
I want to now get to Nancy in Windom.
Nancy, what do you want to share with us?
Well, my priority is that the appointee be someone
that can carry on the committee work that
Amy Klobuchar did in her years in the Senate.
Particularly the Agriculture Committee,
because I live in rural Minnesota and agriculture is a
very important part of our economy in Minnesota.
And I think that giving a head start to a candidate
to run in 2027 would be a good idea.
And so I think that that appointee should be someone
from rural Minnesota that could sit on the Agriculture Committee.
This is so interesting, Jamie, because just to remind our audience,
Senator Klobuchar is the top Democrat on the Senate Ag Committee.
She's also on the Judiciary Committee, which has a great deal of power.
Right. But but what we have learned
from recent elections is that there is this.
pretty big divide between urban parts of the state
and rural parts of the state. How important
do you think is it to pick someone
who can really cross those boundaries, much like Amy Klobuchar
has? I think that's critically important.
And I think that's what Governor-elect Klobuchar is
going to be really thinking about.
That's exactly what Tina Smith did. She came in and she was
a senator from day one for every Minnesotan.
And I think that that's going to be really
It's really critically important.
Yeah. Abu, what about you?
Yeah. I mean, we are losing leaders who have been leaders in ag.
I mean, if you just look over the
past eight to 10 years, Colin Peterson in Western Minnesota,
Amy Klobuchar, who's no longer going to
be in the Senate, and Angie Craig,
who was also a leader on agricultural issues. And so Minnesota
really needs to lean into this issue.
One, it's because it's who we are. But second, we're losing
a lot of institutional knowledge.
And so I imagine this will be part of the tapestry that Amy
Klobuchar is looking at in terms of picking an eventual successor.
Let's talk about
Representative Angie Craig,
because I think for a while people assumed that she would be the
natural pick if she lost in the primary to Peggy Flanagan,
which of course she did. Looking at
Some of those election results,
if you're Amy Klobuchar right now, looking at how maybe she
performed in the primary,
how Peggy Flanagan performed statewide, do you think that that's
playing into her calculation at all?
I think it's one of a million factors, right? And so it's maybe
kind of the backdrop. I fundamentally don't think it's going
to make the decision. Now, I do think
more broadly, you know, Senator Klobuchar is going
to be thinking through who has broad support
across the various coalitions within the Democratic Party,
but also just within Minnesotans in general.
I think that's the way we would discuss kind
of the election results, quote unquote.
It's really about do you have credibility
with the various coalitions that you need in Minnesota
so that when you step into this role, it's not, oh, well,
we just kind of appointed you there kind of by happenstance.
It is this is a serious person who is worthy of the position they're
in, and they're ready to not just govern in the next nine to 10 months,
but also to ultimately win election next year.
OK, we're going to go now to Solomon in Minneapolis.
Solomon, what do you want to share?
As an immigration attorney,
that's obviously a very important issue for me.
Peggy Flanagan ran on ripping us apart during
the primary where she got a resounding win.
And this is a still serious issue across the whole of Minnesota,
especially as we see a new private facility about to open in Appleton.
So I really hope the new senator is going to work
with Peggy on avenging Minnesota and ripping ISO apart.
Jamie, you're nodding your head here.
This kind of gets at a bigger, you know,
question I think we all have is like, what is the Democratic agenda now
that they can control both houses of Congress in Washington, D.C.?
Right. I think it's a really important point.
It's the moment that Minnesotans are in right now.
And Minnesotans want justice for the collective community trauma
that our state has gone through
because of the Trump administration's immigration policies.
We saw...
Our neighbors be murdered in the streets and on video,
and I think it would be disingenuous to not.
Focus on Minnesotans want someone who is going to go and get justice
and accountability for what we've suffered. And I think they
also want someone who is going to be focused on results.
And this administration, you know, the cost of our lives,
the health care, groceries, gas, all of those things that are direct
results of this administration's corrupt and bullying policy agenda.
And Minnesotans want all of that.
And I think they want our entire delegation to go
to D.C. and get results right away, day one.
And Jamie, do you have a sense of how,
I mean, again, off your election,
you're going to have to remind voters that there is one to begin with.
I'm
We saw maybe not quite as much money come
into the U.S. Senate race here than we thought we would this year.
Would you expect there
to be maybe significant attention on this one race?
There will definitely be significant attention, significant investment.
One of the reasons we maybe saw less than we would otherwise expect
is because Chuck Schumer has been very clear that his campaign strategy
was to expand the map, which meant they were,
you know, using resources in a lot of different places.
As Abu mentions, this is going
to be potentially the only
on this race and a lot of money,
U.S. Senate race in 2027, which
a lot of effort on both sides of the aisle.
We've sort of been talking around this a
little bit, but we've been talking about
means all of that attention
Democrats, but obviously a Republican will have
to run too. Michelle Tafoya,
probably the strongest Republican Senate
is going to be on the U.S. Senate.
candidate that's been put up in the state
in quite some time. Who do you think might run
on the Republican side, Jamie?
You know, names that I have heard,
former Governor Tim Pawlenty, former Senator Coleman.
It will be interesting to see who who puts their name
in in 2027, particularly after we see, you know,
what happens with the Democrats agenda and, you know, the things
that that are going to unfold in D.C. over the next few months.
What would they be reacting to?
I actually think there's going to be a ton of Republicans.
Here's why. First, it's really a free run.
If you're in elected office,
you don't have to choose to lose your current seat to run
for this seat because it's a special election.
So you get a free run.
Point number one.
So if you're a Republican, that's a consideration to make in our state.
So you want a job when you want a job.
Second, which I alluded to just a couple of minutes ago,
was that the electorate is going
to be much different.
This is not going to be the 2026 electorate where you have.
2.8 plus million people voting in the election.
I wouldn't be surprised if you see
a drop-off of somewhere around 15 to 20%.
And if that's true, all of a sudden the modeling around
that electorate is very different than
it was just a year before.
So that's point number two.
And then finally, I think because
of what Jamie just alluded to, this is going to be
the Super Bowl for Republican Senate folks.
They're going to be able to say,
we get to put our best political talent, our best operatives,
our best donors.
On this race, and they just took a shellacking,
to borrow from Obama, they just took a selection.
This is their first opportunity to kind
pick themselves up, dust themselves off.
Experiment a little bit.
Experiment a little bit, and do it
in a state that they believe is purple.
And so if they want to get back the Senate map over
the next four to six years, this
is a really good test case to kind of try some new things out.
And so I think for those three reasons,
I think you'll see a lot of Republicans jump
in more than we would normally see in an election like this.
Yeah.
Jamie, any thoughts there?
I think it will also be interesting to see how they run
with Donald Trump still in the White House.
And, you know, are they going to distance themselves from him?
You know, did they get a message from the voters that this election
was very much about a check on what he has been pursuing?
And, you know, his selection to put Stephen Miller
in as chief of staff doesn't indicate that he's going to.
Take any guidance from what voters across the country were saying,
in my opinion, really loudly.
Right. And at the same time saying, yeah,
I want to cut some deals with Democrats.
It feels hard to predict at the moment where the president.
is headed. I want to go now to a call from Heather in Anoka.
Heather, what do you want to share?
Hi there. I'd like to see the introduction
of more integrity into the local medical markets,
because that's a concern that's really grown up
from a grassroots level in Minnesota.
The feds took it on and they've made a lot
of progress there recently. I know it's a
bipartisan issue. Senator Klobuchar
was long term chair of the Antitrust Committee.
She's published a book called Antitrust,
and I'm hoping whoever she appoints can make some progress there.
This raises a question for me, Heather,
and I want to get both of y'all's takes on it. I mean,
it takes a while to work your way up the ranks of the U.S. Senate.
You don't just go in and get
a choice committee appointment.
Abu, how far do you feel like this might set Minnesota back with
two freshman senators who are sort of untested in that environment?
Look, there's no question with experience comes seniority,
and that seniority comes with power.
There's no question about that.
And that's something that will be a delta.
But there's also an opportunity to bring in new voices
who understand the moment.
And I think Heather's pointing out exactly
the types of issues Minnesotans are talking
about.
This entire election was about costs and corruption.
And on the cost side, people are saying everything costs too much.
And as an antitrust lawyer myself,
so when you said that word, I was like, you got me.
I think Minnesotans really want people
to focus on what are driving the costs in the
economy and its massive consolidation with corporations.
And people are seeing it.
That's number one, around costs.
And number two.
Minnesotans know gas is too expensive.
And so they want people to do something on that.
And so I absolutely agree in terms of these markets
that are highly consolidated. We should see our next senator,
whoever it may be, continue the legacy of Amy Klobuchar.
And that's a legacy piece I was going to talk about later.
I think whoever Amy Klobuchar picks in some way.
should be extending the legacy of our great senator
from Minnesota because she has been
instrumental in so many areas, agriculture,
antitrust, et cetera. I want to see someone
who continues that legacy both for her,
but also in their own way as well.
Yeah. And I mean, this is just to remind our audience,
Senator Klobuchar has won statewide
elections over and over again by very comfortable margins.
Right. So that's kind of the data behind
what you're saying here, Abu. And Jamie, what about you?
Like, how does how does this position
Minnesota and the U.S. Senate with.
Two newbies there.
I agree with Abu. I think that the perspective
that they're going to bring is going to be really
valuable and meet the moment.
I also think that when we look at our delegation, we have
Representative McCollum,
who is going to be incredibly powerful in Washington. And so
I think it's succession planning.
As long as you have somebody who can bring things back for
Minnesota and has that power, I think we'll be just fine.
That's right. Okay. We have Darlene
Michael, who's been waiting patiently, Darlene,
what do you want to add to the conversation?
Yeah, hi, great comments.
Thanks for taking my call.
I would like to put forth a name.
I don't even know if it's possible,
but I would like to say Doug Chapin would be my choice.
He ran a phenomenal campaign in the 6th District.
He's got legal acumen.
He's built a wonderful coalition of really strong support out here.
He's willing to work across all the aisles.
He's just got what it takes, personality,
drive, knowledge, articulate man,
and my concerns are data centers.
So that's just my two cents worth.
Doug Chapin, if I got to say it.
OK, thanks.
Thank you, Darlene.
Again, Abu, this might not be a name
that everyone in the audience recognizes.
Doug Chapin ran as a Democrat against Republican Tom Emmer
for the congressional sixth congressional
seat.
What do we know about him?
Well, so if anybody was following his campaign, this guy was energetic.
I mean, he was really holding Tom Emmer accountable.
And he did it in a way that was.
Kind of the happy warrior vibe, right?
And so he excited a lot of people,
not just in the sixth congressional district, but across
the party.
And so if you're thinking about kind of these outside voices
or folks maybe kind of falling
under the radar, you know, we talked about Trina.
I would put Doug in the same category
of clearly has broad-based support.
Question's going to be, does that broad-based support kind
of extend to other parts of the
coalition?
But there's no question, again, this is the embarrassment of riches.
We have people who are insanely qualified
and no question Doug would be on that list.
All right. We're going to go next to Courtney in Duluth.
Courtney, what do you want to share?
I was just calling to add that the couple of people
that come to mind are Senator Erin Murphy as a leader.
State senator.
I think a lot about child care and affordability for families.
And she has been a leader in that.
I also think of Senator Rothschild up here on the range
and how he has balanced this very purple district in...
Child care, but all the data center, you know, he took a stance,
a little bit stronger stance on the data center and water,
boundary water issue.
He would be a great candidate,
but I don't necessarily want to lose them either.
Yeah. These are two names that, you know,
of course, are state Senate names, Jamie.
I mean, what's.
So hold on.
Is there any history there, I guess,
of appointing someone from the legislature to these roles?
Um, well...
Well, so, yes.
But I think what we haven't talked about yet is just
the vacancy implications with some of these choices.
Grant Hochschild ran a very close race, right?
Yes.
And so, you know, the political implications for any number
of these options in when Governor Dayton selected.
Tina Smith, she was the lieutenant governor, and one of the things that
was really challenging about that was the succession that happened.
So the Senate president, so Senator Fischbach.
Was in line. It's in law that that's what was going
to take place if she was a Republican and she's a Republican.
And so, again, I think the vacancy implications are important and kind
of have to think about those dominoes and what their impacts are.
And I think it's also.
It points to the value of, again,
who is the person and the integrity and the capacity to do
the job. For Governor Dayton,
that far outweighed the political implications, and we just dealt
with them. And obviously,
Tina Smith was the best choice, and we've seen that.
Yeah. I mean, yeah, there's a domino effect here, right?
And it's absolutely a consideration.
You know, sometimes you're punished for your success,
Right. And Grant Hauser would be an example of someone who
Who has competed in tough territory and has won.
And it was close, but it was kind of a
commanding win, if you will, in a very difficult environment.
If he were to leave, it's very likely
that the Republicans would pick up that type of seat.
And so, in an odd way, his success is kind of maybe could
be used against him in a conversation like this.
But I think he's ultimately a great profile of a candidate who can
reach across the aisle and talk to a variety of different folks.
But, yeah, as we talk about people, what is the domino effect?
Does, you know, if you appoint X, you know, maybe,
for example, Kelly Morrison in the 3rd Congressional District.
What does that mean for the third congressional district?
You could say that about a couple of other districts, right?
And so the domino effect is absolutely part
of that consideration, first on the competence
and policy, but the political considerations
are going to be real, as they should be, because
Minnesotans, we cannot lose this seat.
Let's see.
Let's go now to Don and Wayzata.
Don, what do you want to share with us?
I wanted to echo something someone else said,
mention of Kelly Morrison.
She is, to me, a non-controversial moderate in a complex district,
the third district.
And most importantly, she's a physician,
which I think in this day and age, having another
physician in the Senate makes an awful lot of sense,
given vaccines and the state of
health care in general.
And then finally, I think an important thing
that we saw in the last elections were that
non-career politicians were attractive candidates.
And Kelly is...
By no means a career politician,
and that might resonate with voters in Minnesota as well.
Yeah. This is Representative Kelly Morrison,
3rd Congressional District, Jamie.
But tell us a little bit more about her.
She was in the legislature prior?
Yes, I mean, she has experience in Washington.
She's, she would clearly be someone who on day one would
be ready to do what's needed in the Senate. And as, as a woman,
I would love to see her in that role as a doctor, particularly in
The conversations that are happening in D.C. right now
around reproductive justice and reproductive health, I think
that she would bring a really important voice to those conversations.
Yeah. So primaries can get really messy,
especially when there are a lot of candidates flooding the field.
We're hearing Democrats talk now about
the importance of unity now that they have been
so successful in winning the midterms.
Could this get really messy, Jamie? And how does the party
stay united in a process that is sort of set up
for a lot of fighting in the spring and into the
summer? It could get messy, but well,
I think policymaking is always messy. It's the sausage,
Right. And.
I am hopeful that all of the Democrats
who came in to office at whatever level,
I am hopeful that they take this opportunity to be all in,
like all the chips are on the table.
There is so much work that I, you know,
I think when people say this was a check on Donald Trump,
I think they mean that in all of the different levels around
the justice that people want for
for the trauma that's happened, the corruption.
accountability for all of those things.
And they want real results to happen for their pocketbook.
And so I think we need all of those perspectives that one,
I think we need all of all of our leaders to be
You know, pushing agendas
and getting things done across that entire gamut.
And I think that's what voters want.
Yeah.
So at the top, that's why I mentioned,
is this a decision where you put a caretaker
position in and someone is just going
to be in the role until we elect somebody?
And if that's the case, then all of a sudden we
are in a Democratic food fight, if you
will.
Now, I'm not as concerned about
that because just moments after that election.
There's going to be a presidential primary
where Democrats are contrasting themselves
and choosing a variety of different candidates for president.
So with that said, that is a consideration.
Do we stay unified here in Minnesota by having
the governor appoint somebody who we all can
get behind, right?
A consensus type of candidate.
And therefore, that person is the nominee going into November.
And then we reserve the presidential
politics for the presidential politics.
That is a factor.
And I think Amy Klobuchar is going to be thinking that through, you
know, at a time when you saw historic gains, not just with Democrats,
but with independents and even certain strains of the Republican Party,
that if we can maintain that coalition, a broad based coalition.
Throughout the course of next year,
going into the 2028 presidential election, I think
that's better for us than taking resources internally
and kind of having a circling.
Spending a lot of money, yelling at each other,
drawing out contrasts and also running a lot of ads
that potentially could be used by Republicans moving forward.
And I think it's confusing to voters. Right. Primaries.
The primary season can be sort of confusing to voters because there's
so many names, so many personalities flooding the field.
And I think, you know, because the time frame on this is so very short.
Right. It's it's like behooves the party potentially to just say, OK.
Here's our person and that candidate.
And yeah, because ultimately,
whoever this person is going to be just in terms of the campaign,
they're going to have to raise eight to ten million dollars.
I mean, at a minimum, because this is going to be the Super Bowl.
Of Senate seats that are on the ballot
because nothing else is going to be around.
And so we've really got to focus
and kind of keep the big picture in mind.
OK, so you've kind of been through this before, Jamie.
If you had one piece of advice to give to Senator Klobuchar right now,
as she is in the process of picking her successor, what would it be?
Trust your instincts.
Yeah.
Abu, what about you?
Listen or look for the people who aren't the loudest.
And what I mean by that is I imagine right now there's all kinds
of campaigns going full court press on the senator and her team.
That necessarily isn't the indicator
that you'd be looking for in the next senator.
Thanks to both of you for being here today.
Thanks for having us.
Thank you.
And for more coverage of the midterm results, keep it tuned to NPR News
and make sure you've subscribed so you don't miss any new videos.
