Val Demings challenged Nikki Haley's "red state" argument on the Meet the Press roundtable about the South Carolina Senate race for Lindsey Graham's former seat. Haley said South Carolina wants to stay a red state and backed Sen. Darline Graham. Demings answered that voters in every party are worried about gas, grocery and health care costs, and said she expects Dr. Annie Andrews to be the next senator. #AnnieAndrews#DarlineGraham#NikkiHaley#MeetThePress#SouthCarolina
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Nikki Haley and a panel discuss the political landscape in South Carolina, Alaska, and Michigan. The conversation focuses on the South Carolina Senate race, where Republican Darlene Graham faces scrutiny over her qualifications despite the state's red leanings, alongside broader debates on electoral ethics, party infighting, and the tension between national party brands and individual candidate appeal.
Nikki Haley went on national television yesterday
to insist that South Carolina wants to stay a red state.
That's a strange thing to have to insist on about
a place Donald Trump carried by almost 18 points two years ago.
Hmm, two years ago?
And it gets stranger once you remember who she was vouching for.
The Republican nominee she was selling
is the same candidate Haley spent part of August trying to beat.
And she put her doubts in writing.
This was the Meet the Press panel a few days to go before the midterms,
where Haley went back and forth with Val Demings,
the former Democratic congresswoman from Fort Myers, Florida,
over Lindsey Graham's old seat.
Graham died suddenly in July, and his sister
was appointed to finish his term
and is now running for a full one against Annie Andrews,
pediatrician and the Democratic nominee.
What I want to know is if Haley's right that South Carolina
will bring it home for Republicans tomorrow.
I think it still might, but not for the reasons she gave.
And the person who did the most damage to her case is Haley herself.
Listen to how she makes it.
Places he was talking about was your home state as well,
South Carolina and the race down there.
And I've been talking to my Republican sources
and they say they're stunned by just how close this race actually is.
What are you feeling and seeing on the ground?
Well, the first thing I'll say is, you know,
if you go back to Lindsey Graham's last race,
you know, Jamie Harrison raised $57 million in a quarter.
Everybody said he was going to win.
They were basically saying that Lindsey
was losing it, and he won by nine.
South Carolina is a red state.
They very much care about low taxes.
They very much care about being pro-business.
They very much care about the Second Amendment.
And so what you have is you have Darlene Graham
that is not an experienced candidate.
But they know she cares about affordability.
They know that she's going to fight and be a conservative.
They know she's going to vote the right way, as opposed to an Annie
Andrews who's run before and lost in the first congressional district
and has said she is for transgender surgeries for minors.
She has said that she is upset with police having guns.
All these things that she said, she's walking it back.
But people remember.
And so I think that at the end of the day,
South Carolina is going to bring it home.
We're a red state.
We want to stay a red state.
And I think that that's what's going to happen.
Congresswoman Demings, how do you see it?
Well, let me say this, Amy.
Whether it's a good night or a historic night, we'll take it.
Thank you.
And, you know, I hear what Ambassador Haley has said,
but let me just say this.
These are not usual times.
These are unusual times for all the reasons that Ryan laid out.
South Carolina may be red,
but people are still paying too much for gas, too much for groceries.
They're worried about their health care.
They're worried about their children's future.
The difference is whether you're Republican, Democrat,
independent or no party affiliation, everybody's feeling it right now.
And the voters want somebody who hears them,
see them and cares about their issues.
Look, I think it's admirable that Darlene Graham wanted
to step in in her brother's shoes.
But the bottom line is...
Whether you're dealing with issues that people care about
or your national security is really not your thing.
I believe the times will dictate
who's the next senator from South Carolina.
And I believe that Dr. Andrews will be that senator.
I think that Americans,
if they feel like Republicans have not done enough.
They have not forgotten what the open borders were like.
They have not overlooked the fact that you've got
these socialist candidates coming in that, you know,
not too long ago we were talking about DEI and girls and boys sports.
They still remember who they are.
So, you know, everybody remembers Joe Biden.
And I think they're going to be focused
on whether there's a Democrat Congress or not.
Yeah, and this is what's fascinating.
And Steve Kornacki pointed this out, that unlike 2018,
the Democrats' approval ratings as a party, much lower.
The difference in these Senate races,
and this has been the remarkable thing in places like Texas,
think of the millions and millions of dollars
that have been spent in advertising,
much of it against James Tallarico, the Democrat.
His favorable ratings are positive.
They're about 20 points higher than the Democratic
approval rating in that state.
So the individual Democrats in some of those
states, that's why it's close,
is that they've come above, they've raised up
above the national image,
which is pretty toxic in these red states for Democrats.
Republicans, even in those red states,
are as unpopular as Donald Trump. So Trump is
more of an anvil in those states than the Democratic Party.
But remember too, Republicans don't poll.
Like, they typically don't like responding to polls.
So when you look at these numbers, like, they've done this before.
They said Lindsey Graham was going to lose.
They said Joni Ernst was going to lose.
They said that, you know, in Maine, Susan Collins was going to lose.
And she, you know, won by a lot.
So we've been through this before.
All right, guys, hold their paws.
We've got more panel coming up.
We've got more panel.
Don't go anywhere.
Welcome back. The panel is still here.
Amy Walter, let's talk about Alaska. The fact that
there are two Dan Sullivans on the ballot,
this revelation that the Peltola campaign was behind
it, the Peltola campaign denies that.
What are you watching for? Could the Senate come down to
Alaska? It absolutely could come down to Alaska.
This is already a very, very close race. And
And remember,
The election is very, very close.
We've been talking about this idea
about whether the race will be certified or not,
but you could also see a situation
where we're getting down to lawsuits, right?
We're getting down to recounts.
Already there is 15-day window
where the state of Alaska can count absentee ballots
that have been mailed on election day.
So if it's close, we know we already probably
have a two-week window before we know maybe who's ahead,
and then we have ranked choice voting.
If nobody gets 50 percent of the vote.
Just as a reminder, we've been here before where
we've had very close races that went to recounts.
There was litigation in Minnesota in 2008.
Then before he was a senator,
Al Franken was ahead by just a handful of votes.
The litigation and the recounts continued all the way in 2009.
He wasn't seated until the summer of 2009.
The summer, Ryan.
Just imagine covering Congress with that.
Get comfortable.
But I think the thing about Alaska is I think the controversy itself,
we shouldn't understate that it could have an impact on the race
just because the volume of votes, right?
I think at the end of the day,
we're only expecting somewhere in the range
of 300,000 people voting in Alaska.
And I don't think there are too many Alaskans
that are confused by the two Dans.
In fact, you know, our reporters
The voters roll their eyes
when they suggest that they might be confused.
I think the question is, will Alaska voters penalize Mary Peltola
for the perception that she might be lying?
That's a question we don't have.
What say you about that?
Well, I say that Alaska knows Mary Patola and she knows Alaska.
They trust her. They believe in her based
on the work that she's done on the ground.
Well the bottom line, Alaskans are not confused about this race.
I think the state Supreme Court has taken every step to make sure
that the voters clearly understand who they're voting for.
This is yet another attempt by the administration
to abuse their power and authority.
As a former police chief, you want to bring a thorough and legitimate investigation,
you've got to have two things.
You've got to have jurisdiction
and you've got to have elements of a violation of law.
They don't have either.
Ambassador Haley, what about that argument?
It's amazing to me that even the speakers you had before want
to talk like this random Dan.
Sullivan just happened to come and do this,
and there's nothing wrong with it.
This is deceptive.
This was corrupt.
There's no question about it.
Alaskans will take notice.
If you can't win on your own merits.
And you've got to go and do something to the ballot.
It's dirty politics.
I don't know if it's illegal or not, but it's dirty politics.
That's the question.
And I think Alaskans are going to judge her for that.
I think she's going to pay a price for that.
Keep in mind, the Department of Justice has
been investigating this since over the summer.
Julia Ainsley broke that story.
There was actually a crime.
The idea that this Department of Justice would be holding back on that,
especially at this stage of the game, I think is a bit eye-raising.
But to the ambassador's point.
It's not necessarily about legality,
it's about ethics and whether or not Alaska voters
will penalize Mary Peltola as a result.
Ambassador Haley, let me ask you about
the other big development we got this weekend
on Michigan, this Democratic infighting.
I've been talking to Republicans,
they say this is a gift, the fact that you have Abdul
Al-Sayed feuding with Haley Stevens.
How do you see it?
Because, boy, polls do show that he has a narrow lead.
I am shocked that you have Chuck Schumer putting millions
Going and fighting for El-Sayed,
who this is a person who rallied and stood beside someone
who said that America deserved 9-11.
He's a socialist. He says he can't tell which is
more dangerous, Iran or Israel. That is amazing.
If that's the direction the Democrat Party is
going, then God help us all.
And I think that this election is so much bigger than Michigan.
This will really tell you that should Democrats win
in Congress, that this is
Who you want to represent you.
And so I think this infighting
in the Democrat Party is more fascinating.
You've got here a pro-law enforcement guy in Mike Rogers
who's tried to save our country
with a guy who clearly has a problem with our country.
And so I think that Michigan's got a real decision to make.
When Haley Stevens lost the primary by one point,
she immediately endorsed Abdul El-Sayed.
Not only did she endorse him, but Governor Whitmer endorsed him.
Congressman Jim Clyburn,
who will be campaigning with him this weekend, endorsed him.
She urged her supporters to endorse him.
The fact that she made a suggestion to him to pull an ad down
defining Israel or talking about Israel, she gave him some advice.
He didn't take it.
They need to stay focused on winning affordability, the cost
of health care, those issues that Michiganders really care about.
But it's not worth putting an anti-Semite in office like the Democrats.
Really, this is who you want to represent you.
I think this is very telling.
And everybody going and endorsing him and saying it's OK.
And no one talking about bringing that ad down where he goes
and blames Jews and Israel for the fact that groceries are high.
Isn't that's not his ad.
We should we should note that's not.
It's not from a super PAC, it's not his.
When Republicans are desperate, and they are,
because Democrats are positioned to win in
some places they shouldn't win, like Kansas.
When they're desperate, they start with the name calling.
People want you to reduce the cost of gas and groceries.
But the problem, Kristen, is that this is not what
Democrats want to be talking about
48 hours before Election Day.
And the fact that they're not all singing
from the same hymnal at this stage in a state
they have to win.
Could be a problem for them, especially in a race that's so tight.
Well, and this fight is not going to end with this election.
The debate within the Democratic Party between that wing of the party
and the more sort of
whatever we call center left of the party
is going to be at center both in Congress in
twenty twenty seven and the center
of the twenty twenty eight fight for the nomination.
But could it make a difference in this late stage?
I think I think well,
I think that if this were a different year, if this were a
More problematic year,
the environment was worse for Democrats this year.
Yes, I think it could. But I think at this stage,
the environment is strong enough to overcome it.
All right. All right, guys.
Thank you very much for a great conversation. 48 hours to go.
You came away thinking Haley changed the subject on gas
and groceries, you heard it right. But the
bigger hole in her case is the nominee she barely mentioned.
Back in August, she endorsed Graham's
opponent in the Republican runoff,
Congressman Ralph Norman, and wrote that he had never let the state down
So, the real question is, if the state's red streak can carry
a nominee Haley herself didn't want.
Look, Haley had a reason to want someone else.
When Graham was asked in that runoff debate if Taiwan
and the South China Sea mattered to American security, she said,
I'm not that informed on national security.
That's a sitting senator telling statewide TV audience she wasn't
that informed on what was her brother's signature issue in the Senate.
And she wanted to run off anyway with Trump's endorsement behind her.
The doubt didn't go away though.
In the New York Times and CNN poll that came out last Wednesday,
51% of South Carolina voters said Graham lacks
the experience to be an effective senator.
And the same poll has the race tied at 48
with Andrews winning a majority of independents and
pulling a slice of Republicans away.
Keep in mind how Darlene Graham got here matters,
because she didn't win the seat in the first place.
The governor appointed her to finish
her brother's term and she decided to run
for a full one after Trump publicly urged her to.
So, that's the honest difference from the best fact on Haley's side,
which is what happened the last time
Democrats fell in love with a seat.
In 2020, Kamim Harrison raised a record $57 million in a single quarter,
and Quinnipiac had
him tied with Lindsey Graham that September.
Graham still won by more than 10 points.
Harrison was up against the famous incumbent, though,
while Andrews was up against the senator a lot
of voters had barely heard of before this summer.
Of Haley's two points, that the state is red
and that Republicans would rather not answer polls,
the second has 2020 behind it, and nobody should wave it away.
But the first one only works if Darlene is a normal nominee,
and Haley is the one who said in August
that she's missing something the job needs.
Less than a week after endorsing Norman,
she posted this about Graham's debate answer.
Quote, this is not something you inherit,
and it's critical in the U.S. Senate.
She meant knowing national security,
and basically she meant that Graham doesn't.
Honestly, I think the gap is why the closing pitch skips the candidate
and stays away from prices for a reason, too.
The Times poll found voters think Andrews would
do a better job on the economy and the cost of living.
And the culture war turn didn't start with Haley either
because at the start of October,
Trump used an anti-trans slur against Andrews in a post that also
says she's for defunding the police and would take people's guns.
Andrews, who isn't transgender,
answered by talking about lowering costs.
Again, Nikki Haley told South Carolina in August
that Darlene was missing something critical for the Senate.
Yesterday, she asked them to elect her anyway because the state is red.
If you're thinking the polls said the same thing about Haley Harrison,
they did.
And that's a real reason not to count this one for Andrews.
But a polling miss doesn't explain why Haley herself doubted
the nominee she's now vouching
for.
That matters even outside South Carolina
because control of the Senate is on the ballot tomorrow,
and a seat this safe isn't supposed to be in play.
Inside the state, it's about what you get from a senator
who said after that debate
that voters are more worried about
their pocketbooks than the South China Sea.
That's a fair point, you know,
and it's also not the one Haley made for her yesterday.
In the South Carolina Policy Council's late October survey,
36% of voters named the cost of living
and inflation as the most important issue facing
the state.
Senate seat is in a family business where
the old staff keeps things running while you
learn, even though she did keep many of her brother's aides.
Judging by that experience number
in the Times poll, a lot of voters seem to agree.
Point is, the damage goes past one seat.
Because when a party fills a Senate vacancy with a sibling
and then defends her on the color of the map,
it's treating the seat as if it were family property.
South Carolina hasn't elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1998.
998.
And that streak is what Haley was really defending.
But a streak is a habit, and voters break habits
when the person on the ballot gives them a reason.
That's why I met her a week ago when David Beasley,
a Republican former governor of the state, endorsed Andrews.
I mean, this is endorsed Andrews.
Because I hear him telling Republicans the habit.
Isn't an obligation.
Meanwhile, Haley's charges against Andrews
were supposed to keep those Republicans in line,
and they don't hold up much better than the red state math.
None.
She said Andrews was for transgender surgeries for minors,
but Andrews has said on the trail
that she doesn't support gender surgery for minors.
And what Andrews is backing in the past is hormone treatment for kids,
which Republicans have hit her on over and over and over in this race.
And that's a real record, just not the one Haley described.
As for police and guns, I couldn't find
Andrews saying anything along those lines.
And the closest thing on the record is Trump's own post.
And at the same time, a poll with a race tie found some
Republicans telling interviewers they're voting for Andrews.
So, at least a few of them are answering.
I think all of this is about giving Republicans
who aren't sold on this nominee a reason to show up anyway.
That's an odd job for the person who warned in August
that what Graham lacked isn't something you inherit.
Now that split between culture fights and prices.
How Scott Huffman...
A political scientist at Winthrop
University described this race last month.
He said Graham is on firmer ground with issues such
as abortion and transgender topics,
while Andrews does better when voters
are thinking about prices in the economy.
He also said that after 15 to 20 years of Republican control,
a statewide race within single digits is surprising
because the usual baseline is about 10 points.
And he was clear that Andrews still has
an uphill climb as long as Republicans turn out.
I think that's what Haley was really talking about yesterday.
Even if she dressed it up as confidence.
Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha.
With the vote tomorrow,
Trump has rallied for Graham twice in the last two weeks.
First in the Upstate and then Rock Hill last Thursday.
Norman, the man Haley backed,
chose not to campaign for her after losing the runoff.
The late October polls don't all agree either.
The Times and the Policy Council have the race within a point,
while two other polls released last week have Graham up four,
which is still way under the 10-point head start Huffman described.
So it comes down to F Republicans
who doubt Graham vote for her anyway or stay home.
And Norman's voters are the ones I'd watch.
What this shows about the administration
is that the president pushed the senator whose
biggest asset is her family name.
And when that got shaky, his answer was a slur.
So does South Carolina bring it home for Republicans tomorrow?
It might.
And if it does, it'll be because the habit
of voting red carried a candidate Haley herself
said was missing something critical for the Senate.
That's a darker kind of win than the one she described yesterday.
I mean, a state Trump carried by almost 18
points shouldn't need a former governor on
national TV insisting it wants to stay red.
The fact that she felt she had to tell you
the map isn't a guarantee, it used to be.
Voters there are being asked if the party label is enough by itself,
and Haley already answered that question in August.
And if you're in South Carolina, the State
Election Commission site will show you your
polling place for tomorrow,
and everyone else can check their own state's election office.
Every source I used is shown on DrewSources.com,
and the link is in the description
so you can check the numbers yourself.
If you're a South Carolina Republican,
I honestly want to know in the comments
if you're voting on what Haley said
yesterday or what she wrote in August.
Subscribe because the thing I'll be tracking after the polls closes
if Haley's theory about Republicans ducking
pollsters actually shows up in the count.
Whatever happens tomorrow, you know,
Haley's August post about Darlene is the thing I'd
check out before giving much weight to what she said yesterday.
Whatever Haley's August
post about Darlene is the thing I'd check out
before giving much weight to what she said
yesterday. Thanks and please go out and vote tomorrow.