Willett Pot Still Reserve Review: Does Cask Strength Fix This Bourbon?
Nov 14, 2026
Today on the Bourbon Bites podcast,
a 20-year-old whiskey for about 50 bucks.
Then we have the new Barrel New Year 2027
and Stranahan's Mountain Angel 14.
Plus, I have a bite-sized review
of the new Willett Pot Still Cask Strength.
Hello everyone and welcome back to the Bourbon Bites podcast.
I'm your host Clifton and this
is the week of Thursday, November 12th, 2026.
So last month I talked about this brand new release
from Willett where they were putting
their pot still reserve at cast strength. And there was
some speculation. Is this going to save the brand?
Because a lot of us out there that drink bourbon
for a while now that Willett Pot Still Reserve
is not much more than just a fancy bottle on the shelf
Well, now that it's being released at Cask Strength,
I've been curious to see if this
is really giving this whiskey the boost
that it needs to actually be a respectable bourbon.
So I'm very excited for a chance to try it here on the podcast.
As soon as I saw this hit the shelves in my area,
I knew I had to pick it up and give
it a try for you guys.
But before we pour the Willett,
we do have some news stories to talk about from across
the whiskey industry.
Some of these you guys brought up to me on our Discord server.
Others I just saw hit the newswire this month,
but most of all, I just want to share my thoughts
with you guys on what's going on in the world of whiskey this week.
And the first two stories are big comebacks,
Stolichnaya in the US and the Nelson brothers in
Nashville.
So a few of you brought this up on the Discord server, like I said.
There was a Whiskey Wash story about Stoli coming back to the U.S.
And some of you were wondering,
does this mean things like Kentucky Owl are back too?
So while Stoli announced on November 9th that they had reached
a settlement after their Chapter 11 bankruptcy,
they did say that markets will depend on distribution.
And they only really named two whiskeys with this announcement,
Riders Tears and The Irishman.
Now, if you remember back in 2024,
both Kentucky Owl and Stoli filed for Chapter 11.
And while there's a long list of brands being part
of this announcement, Kentucky Owl is not one of them.
So I wouldn't take this as news about there
being another Kentucky Owl release anytime soon.
Now, what's interesting is their chief commercial officer said
our products are already here.
They say they already have stock
in the U.S. based in their bonded warehouses.
So local availability can vary depending on the market.
So while the future of Kentucky Owl still is up in the air,
it is nice to see that some of these products will start making
their way back into the market.
Now over in Nashville, the people coming back
are the guys whose names are already on the bottle.
Again, thank you guys for sharing this on Discord.
This is a really cool announcement.
This is from Nelson's Greenbrier Distillery,
and they're actually buying back the brand from Constellation Brands.
So Constellation took a minority stake in the brand back in 2016,
ended up taking majority control in 2019,
and then full ownership in 2024.
Well now, Andy and Charlie Nelson have bought back the brand
and have full ownership of it again.
Now, it's interesting because they previously bought back
the Bellmead portion of the brand.
They actually bought that back a while ago.
But the distillery itself and the actual Tennessee whiskey that they
were making wasn't really part of their lineup again until right now.
Some of you have noticed that Bellmead has started returning
to the older variable cask strength versions, which is great to see.
I'm always been a fan of Bellmead.
I've not seen it on the shelves in a long, long time.
Or if I have, I just haven't noticed it.
But I'm excited to see Nelson Greenbrier going back to a family brand.
I think it's really interesting to see these big conglomerates starting
to break down and sell off their distilleries.
I mean, I'd rather see them sell them back to the owners
who created it than just close them down or just
so many other things that could go wrong.
I think this is a win.
For this brand, so we'll see what they have to bottle,
but I'm very, very excited for
the future of the brand to be back in their hands.
Now I teased this in the intro,
but I thought this was pretty cool. Now Black Velvet,
who is known for their blended Canadian whiskey,
actually caught my eye with this new product.
It is a 20 year old legacy blend coming in at 90 proof,
700 milliliter bottle, and about
$50 US. Normally I wouldn't give this brand a time of day,
but seeing an age statement like this
reminds me of some of the great highly aged
Canadian whiskey I've had over the years.
I mean, just recently I gave that JP Wiser's 23 year
a 9 out of 10 on the podcast, but
that was at cask strength.
I'm pretty excited to see this hit the market.
I think it's good to see more highly aged
or higher proof Canadian whiskey in the U.S.
in general, and a brand like Black Velvet kind
of gets a bad rap for its budget friendly
options.
I would love to give it a try
and see if this really does stand out as a premium whiskey
from their brand.
Now speaking of interesting blends,
Barrel has just announced their New Year 2027 release.
I've always been a fan of these.
Some of them have won some of my favorite whiskeys of the year,
so every time I hear about one of these I get very very excited.
This is the 11th annual edition of Barrel New Year.
It's comprised of seven different states
whiskeys from 5 to 16 years old and bottled at cask strength.
Now retail on it's going to be about $85 and it's funny
because the variety of whiskey in here is
pretty crazy. So some of the whiskey
is five-year-old distillate from Texas and Ohio
while they have some 13-year-old Wyoming whiskey
and a 16-year-old Tennessee whiskey. I think it's
fun because I feel like it really does celebrate all
the great whiskey coming out of the U.S.
We're really getting a wide breadth of different whiskeys
and sometimes these work together really
Now I know that the cask strength varies depending on the bottle.
I'm seeing some people review it for 116.6 proof
while other people mention it's 115.34.
So there is some discrepancy.
I think it's just different batches of this particular release
but I'm still very very excited to get
my hands on a bottle like I am every year.
So while the barrel release is seven states in one bottle,
Stranahan's in Denver moved one malt
whiskey through three different barrels.
So we got a lot of fun experimental
blending happening in the news today.
This is the announcement of Stranahan's Mountain Angel 14.
It's their oldest release to date.
So this whiskey started as a 10-year-old American single malt
in new charred oak barrels.
It then spent three years and three months in cognac casks.
Then an additional nine months in Hungarian Tokaj wine casks.
Now the Tokaj cask is what caught my attention
because I previously reviewed a Yellowstone whiskey that used this cask
and I really liked what it did to the whiskey.
So I'm really curious to see what it's going to do to a single malt
that's already spent over 10 years in New American Oak
and then three years in Cognac cask.
I feel like that's going to be a very complex single malt
and I'm 100% here to give it a try.
Proof of it's going to be 94.6 proof.
Retail is going to be about $130.
And luckily, California is going to be one
of the first markets that gets this bottle.
So I'll be sure to pick it up if I see it on the shelves
and let you know what I think of it.
A little bit high in cost, but again,
considering it's a 14-year-old American single malt,
we rarely see whiskey that old that's not a bourbon or a rye whiskey.
So I'll be picking it up if I see it.
If you guys tried it, let me know what you think.
All right, well, before we get into our bite-sized review,
there's a barrel pick story that I think some of you might be into.
So 15 Stars is announcing their new private selection program,
and they're opening it up to 6 to 10-year-old Kentucky bourbon
barrels available to retailers, restaurants, and private groups.
Now, they're including both wheated and rye recipe bourbons,
and each of them are going to be released at cast strength
with minimum filtration to remove the barrel char.
Again, I've not had 15 stars personally,
but I've heard some really great stories
from other whiskey reviewers.
I know Perry at This Is My Bourbon Podcast
has reviewed quite a lot of their products
and really enjoys what they're putting out.
I would love a chance to try it,
but it's great to see that they are releasing
these single barrels from six to 10 years old
and at cask strength.
Now I've not quite done a barrel pick on my own,
which we've talked about here on the channel
every now and then it keeps coming up.
I absolutely would love to do one. I just would have to find a
way to one, find a local distributor to be able
to get that out to people or to just partner with
another content creator or local store, maybe go halfsies on a pick.
Again, I would love to do it.
The logistics of it kind of gives me a lot of anxiety.
So maybe one day I will do a pick.
I love being parts of picks.
I did one with Jason from the Mash & Drum that was fantastic.
It was a Jack Daniels pick.
And I know there's been a few other people
who have asked me to be parts of a pick.
I love helping people do a pick.
But to do an official Bourbon Bites pick, I would love to.
It's just, I don't know.
I just don't have those local connections to make that possible.
But if you do, reach out to me.
Contact at bourbonbites.com.
Let's make it happen.
Alright, well with that being said,
I may not have a barrel for you, but I do have a bottle to review.
Let's go ahead and get to our bite-sized review.
All right, like I teased at the top of the podcast,
this is a bottle that a lot of you
guys have seen on the shelves and honestly ignored.
So this is Willet Pot Still Reserve.
It's constantly known as one of the prettiest bottles
with one of the worst whiskeys.
And I'm not saying that from personal experience.
I have reviewed this on the channel and I thought it was OK,
but a lot of people hate
on this bottle.
So when I saw they released a cask-strength release for around $65,
I had to pick it up and give it a try to let you guys know,
is it worth it at this proof at this price?
Now, while there's no age statement on this release,
we do know that its mash bill is 65% corn, 20% wheat, and 15% barley.
It did enter the barrel at 115 proof, and this release is 120 proof.
So of course, it gained some proof points in the barrel.
So we're going to see if this helps solve the problem
of it just being very thin and very bland of a bourbon.
Let's go and get it poured and then give it a nose.
Now, whether or not you could hear that, I will say this has
a really fun glug, glug, glug when you pour it with that long neck.
It definitely feels like you're doing a little bit
of some old science experiments here.
Alright well the first thing I get on the nose
is a bit of a like cinnamon brown sugar thing.
You know it almost reminds me of an Aberlour cask whiskey.
Those to me always give a cinnamon toast
crunch note. This isn't as extreme
but it does have some of those reminiscent elements to it.
A little bit darker though,
definitely more of a molasses than a typical sugar,
but man it almost tickles my nose with those baking spice
and cinnamon notes. It's very very
baking spice forward.
Not too much oak, it's definitely a little bit perfumey, a little bit
like very very sweet cream cheese kind of note,
a little bit tart, a little bit sour,
but overall very very pleasant.
The tartness is a little bit of a citrus zest kind of element to it.
I would maybe guess lemon zest,
but that's just because it's really triggering
like my nasal passages. It makes me almost want to sneeze, but
it's a good, it's a really good nose, especially for a fall whiskey.
So let's go ahead and give it a taste and see how it holds up.
Hmm, okay. More or less the same in terms of flavor profile.
It's still very, very like cinnamon sugar.
I would say a little bit more in the sugar category than
the cinnamon on the palate. It goes very sweet, almost like
the same sensation of putting like a spoonful of sugar on your tongue.
It kind of has that same sensation when it hits your palate.
I will say the cast strength does help out with the viscosity.
It doesn't feel as thin as the regular release.
It does carry some body with it, and I do appreciate that.
Surprisingly, it has some of those mineral qualities
that I typically get on a Tennessee
whiskey. And while it's sweet up front,
the mid-palate kind of lingers in this kind of savory
umami kind of territory. It's not like oak or,
you know, age that I'm getting there. I can't quite
put a finger on what's giving me that sensation.
It kind of feels a little bit like a salty
licorice kind of thing happening mid-palate.
And finish, I would say it's a medium to long finish.
It actually feels like an improvement over the small batch all across the board.
But I think people who have major faults
with the small batch release might still find some
faults with this as well.
One, it doesn't necessarily taste old.
While it's not super sweet like some young whiskeys are,
it doesn't really have that
oaky backbone that I really love in a well-aged product,
especially from Willet, because
we know they know how to make a good aged bourbon.
I was really hoping to find some
of those like tart zesty notes that I got on the nose.
I feel like that rounds out a weeded bourbon.
I think, you know, I look for maybe a little bit
of like an orange twist note on it.
This doesn't have it. It does finish nice and
intense with that high proof,
but the flavor profile again is still in that like kind of salty,
briny kind of note, which doesn't sound like
something you would like on a bourbon. But again,
I think it works. You just have to really like that flavor profile.
So here on the Bourbon Bites podcast,
we just give one score out of 10 based on all things like
nose, proof, palate, availability,
just overall thoughts of the whiskey. I like to keep it simple
here on the bite-sized review.
With this one, I do feel like it is a significant improvement over
the small batch. That being said,
it doesn't fix all of the issues that I think some people would
have with that whiskey. I think it bumps up the proof,
it gives it more body, it gives it more
more character, but
But whether you like that character is entirely up to you.
It's definitely a bit divisive still,
but I think it is worth revisiting, even if you
didn't like the small batch version.
For $60, no age statement, but cool bottle,
I'm going to give this one a 6 out of 10.
I definitely would pour myself another glass of it.
I think it's one that you could actually give as a gift
and not feel bad about, especially
the Cask Strength version.
So overall, I'm.
I'm pretty surprised with this.
It's better than I thought, but I don't think
this is going to win over fans of people that
hated the first release.
As someone that thought the first release was okay,
this definitely feels like an improvement,
and I'm excited to finally have this bottle on my shelf
and not have people make fun of me
So if you've had a chance to try this one,
please let me know what you think.
Have they broken their stigma of this pot still reserve bottle?
Or is it still a bit of a gag gift?
Let me know your comments either on this episode
or over on our Discord server.
You can find that as well as a link to join
our Bite Club for as little as $2 a month
at bourbonbites.com.
By the way, if you are listening
to this on the Thursday that it comes out, I'm going
to be live tonight with Brush Creek Distillery.
At 7 p.m. Pacific over on my Bourbon Bites YouTube channel.
But if you're listening to this later, the replay will be there, too.
I hope to see you guys there.
I'm really excited to have those folks on.
They sent over a really cool selection of their whiskeys,
and I cannot wait to give them a try.
For those of you that are part of the Bite Club,
thank you for helping me keep these episodes rolling.
I enjoyed picking up this bottle
and hope to do many more like it here soon.
Well, that about does it.
This has been the Bourbon Bites podcast,
a whiskey podcast with a gaming twist.
Cheers, and I'll talk to you guys next episode.

