He Was Right About The Golf Swing - But Golf Kept Trying To Fix It

Golf - Sport of Perfection
164 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
For 40 years, golf called it
the most beautiful swing the game had ever seen.
Teachers studied it frame by frame,
fans stood behind the ropes just to watch it,
and for those same 40 years,
the people standing closest to it kept trying to change it. The swing
belonged to Fred Couples, and he was right all along.
In March 1992, Sports Illustrated ran a
long feature on the hottest player on the PGA Tour.
The writer kept reaching for new ways to describe
It was delicious. It was a true work of art.
It was so slow and unhurried
that a painter could have used it as a subject.
The numbers behind it were harder to believe.
His driver carried around 340 yards.
He could hook or slice the ball by roughly 100 yards on purpose.
On a par 3 of 180 yards, a 6-iron for most players,
he could pull out a driver, cut it hard,
and drop the ball softly onto the green.
Yet the swing had already been changed
by the time that article appeared.
His longtime coach Paul Marchand
and Dick Harmon had worked on shortening his backswing,
and Fred had started finding more fairways.
Asked about teaching a swing like that,
Marchand answered with a question of his own,
how do you teach Mozart music?
Decades later, Fred explained how he had lived
with all those instructions.
In 2025, at a celebration for Gary Player's 90th birthday,
Nick Faldo asked Couples whether he had ever used a swing thought.
Fred poked fun at himself before answering.
Marchand, he explained,
always wanted everything shorter, shorter, shorter.
So when Fred played, he stood up to the ball
and imagined his coach right there with him.
And I'd say Paul's right behind me,
swing shorter, and I would do it, Couples said.
Then he gave the reason.
Instead of saying, swing shorter, I had to throw something out there.
The most admired swing of its generation, and the man who owned it,
had to invent a voice in his head just to keep it in check.
But what exactly were they trying to shorten?
To see it, you have to slow the swing down one frame at a time.
In April 1993, with couples about to return
to Augusta as the defending champion,
Golf Digest asked Harvey Penick to break down
a sequence of his swing photos.
Penick did not glance at them.
He studied them every night for a week.
He started with the hands.
Fred's grip was strong, with both Vs pointing at his right shoulder,
and that detail explained much of what followed.
Anyone with a strong grip has to make a fast turn
and get their left hip out of the way, Penick wrote.
The flared front foot made it possible.
He couldn't make that fast a hip turn without
his left toe being turned out.
Going back, the shoulders turned more than 100 degrees.
Pennick's own teaching said the left heel should rise
on the backswing if it wanted to.
Fred simply did not want to.
Fred is so flexible that he stays in balance
and shifts his weight without his left heel needing to rise, he wrote.
Then came what Pennick called the magic move.
Through impact, Fred's right arm rolled over his left,
while the left arm held the arc steady and never broke down.
His right arm is pouring in the power, Pennick wrote.
That crossover, he explained,
was where the enormous clubhead speed came from.
Penick did not hand the swing back with a list of corrections.
He offered it to everyone else instead.
It would help the average golfer to take
a free swing as Fred does, he wrote.
That doesn't mean a loosey-goosey swing, but one that is free.
Two years earlier, in October 1991,
Dick Harmon had tried to answer the question every amateur was asking.
How could a man who looked like he
was barely swinging hit the ball so far?
His answer started before the club even moved.
Fred stood with his feet slightly wider than his
shoulders and set the ball about an inch farther away than normal,
giving his arms room to extend
and his turn room to grow.
The takeaway drifted outside the target line, the natural shape of a
player who liked to fade the ball.
At three quarters, his wrists were fully set and his
shoulders had turned 90 degrees.
Harmon noted that most amateurs would stop right there.
Fred kept turning.
Your turn is the power producer, Harmon wrote.
Coming down, Fred pushed off his right foot.
The right elbow dropped toward his hip,
and his body unwound while his arms and hands stayed loose.
That was the trick behind the look.
The hands were relaxed, so the swing appeared slow.
But the coil underneath was producing clubhead speeds
of more than 120 miles per hour with the driver.
That gap between what people saw and what was really happening
caused all the trouble.
Amateurs copied the slow look.
Then, anxious to hit it hard,
they cut their turn short and jerked the club down with their hands.
Harmon closed with a warning.
Fred was not double-jointed, he wrote, but he was gifted,
and the chances of an amateur reproducing
his enormous shoulder turn are slim to none.
As a boy, Fred had no teacher to explain any of this to him.
He built the swing himself on a nine-hole public course in Seattle,
where keeping up with the older players meant hitting
the ball as far as he possibly could.
Years later, he boiled the whole education down to one discovery.
I learned when I was a kid,
the faster I get my hands on my left shoulder,
the farther it goes. Speed, to Fred, started with a soft grip.
I think a lot of amateurs hold the club too tight,
he said at 50, while still one of the
longest hitters on the senior tour.
The tighter you hold anything, the slower you will be. His
own grip was so light that, as he put it,
when I'm at a dress, you could walk up and take the
club out of my hands easily.
Even his clothes served the same idea. Before a shot, he adjusted
his shirt sleeves. I could never hit a ball with my sleeves down,
he explained. I just try to feel
I feel as free as I can.
Over the ball, his only real thought was the target.
I just take the club back and hit it.
When Golf Digest asked him in 2014 for the key to an effortless swing,
he gave two things and nothing more.
The first was the turn.
The first thing I do is make a big shoulder turn, he said.
Once I get the shoulder turn back,
I don't need to think about the change of direction.
The second was where the club went afterward.
What I try to do is turn my hips and release the club down the target.
If the club swung too far around his body,
he warned, the ball would go a mile right.
That was the entire method, and Fred never pretended otherwise.
As far as swing and techniques are concerned,
he once said, I don't know diddly squat.
While his own coaches worked on the swing,
a generation of teachers was busy studying it.
In 1988, a young Couples appeared in an instruction series on tempo.
Sean Webb, who would later become one
of Golf Digest's top teachers, never forgot it.
I had this VCR tape, he said. I watched it on loop.
Jim Flick, one of the most respected instructors of his era,
turned the swing into a teaching tool.
When Pupils came over the top because they rushed
the start of the downswing, he gave them a simple picture.
Imitating couples' rhythm
also helps those who get too quick starting down, Flick wrote.
Paul Marchand, who knew the motion better than anyone,
described Fred's whole approach as freedom of motion.
Fred never forced a position or tried to steer the club through impact.
To Marchand, that was the great paradox of the swing.
The harder a golfer tried to control the club at the ball,
the less control he had over the shot.
Even Butch Harmon became a student.
When he began working with Fred,
he noticed that his own wedge swing got short and quick,
while Fred stayed unhurried. So Butch borrowed it.
Over a 40 or 50-yard wedge, he would tell himself,
just like Freddie. Later, when a pupil tensed up over a half wedge,
Butch had a one-line lesson.
Give me a Fred Couples.
In his view, no player in the modern era is more associated
with a swing trait than Fred is with rhythm.
Caddy Jim McKay saw the results up close.
Fred, he said, doesn't miss more than one
or two shots a month and in 1996 near Palm Springs,
a 20-year-old Tiger Woods spent part of an evening in his hotel suite
impersonating the swings of famous players.
Fred Couples was one of them. The impression
was flawless. Admiration was never the whole story.
Some of the same people who
loved the swing could list exactly what was wrong with it.
Golf writer John Hawkins pointed to two habits
no swing expert would ever sign off on.
Fred stood open to the target,
and he made a small pause at the top, which Harmon was blunter.
Fred has a lot of flaws, he said,
but he saves himself because his rhythm is so good.
The biggest objection was in his arms.
Ben Hogan's most famous advice was to keep
the arms moving with the body in one connected motion,
and most great players only let
their arms run on a little past their turn.
Fred did the opposite.
His arms and club went out and up toward the sky,
far away from his turning body. Golf Digest's Luke Kurdenien,
studying the film years later, called it a controversial move
because arms and body that separate
that much are hard to bring back together.
That separation also explained the famous pause.
The club traveled so far that Fred needed
an extra moment to reverse it,
less a pause than a change of direction,
like a car shifting from reverse into drive.
For years, rhythm was enough.
Then, in March 1994, at Doral,
Fred swung an 8-iron minutes before his final round tee time.
Something in his lower back gave way, and he was forced to withdraw.
The injury never truly left.
It followed him through withdrawals,
treatments, and missed events for decades.
Years later, he described the problem with total honesty.
I can't make my back feel better when I swing, he said.
It's impossible.
The critics had their evidence.
Some pointed to the very things Penick had admired.
A shoulder turned past 100 degrees
while the front heel stayed planted on the ground.
Others looked at where the swing finished.
In 2014, Jim Suddy, a teacher with a doctorate in biomechanics,
warned that an open body position at impact,
with the hips already turned through and the
right shoulder dropped well below the left,
was a hallmark of back trouble.
He named Fred and Lee as examples.
They were getting back surgeries
when they weren't winning tournaments, Suddy said.
But golf had not waited for the scientists.
Years before that warning,
the swing had already been handed to the most famous coach in the
game.
At the start of 2003, Fred was discouraged.
His back was fragile, his game had drifted,
and he had not won on the PGA Tour in five years.
At Pebble Beach that winter, he began working with Butch Harmon.
Butch's first idea was simple,
shorten the swing and take the pressure off the back.
The effect came almost at once.
In April, Fred won the Houston Open and ended the drought.
So the work continued.
In 2008, at 48 years old,
Fred spent five days at Harmon's school in Las Vegas,
trying to tame a backswing that still had a mind of its own.
He described the problem himself.
I get long and drop underneath and hit them high and to the right.
Together, they rebuilt the start of the motion.
The famous lift in his takeaway,
the one that sent the club outside the line,
was replaced with a lower,
wider sweep that started the club back along the target line.
At the top, the shaft no longer pointed so far across the line.
Fred liked what he saw.
Driving it a long way has always come naturally to me, he said,
but now I'm hitting it straighter than ever.
He gave part of the credit to new equipment
and part to his work with Butch.
On the range, the repair looked complete.
On the course, the old swing kept coming back.
In 2024, standing beside
a practice green before another trip to Augusta,
Fred admitted it plainly.
He and Marchand could work on anything they liked,
but once he was playing,
muscle memory took over.
The swing slipped back into what he called this flippy. It's not good.
Golf had spent decades trying to fix Fred couples.
By then, it was already busy fixing everyone else.
While Fred's coaches were taming his backswing,
golf instruction was moving in another direction
entirely. In the 1990s,
teacher Jim McLean gave the game a new phrase, the X Factor.
Studying the biggest hitters,
he found that many turned their shoulders a long way
while their hips barely moved.
That gap between the two became the new source of power,
and across the game, golfers began holding
their hips back to stretch it as far as they could.
The bill came later.
In 2019, a study in the Journal of Neurosurgery, Spine,
warned that the X-factor swing could injure the back.
The extra twist strained the lower spine.
And the powerful downswing could damage the discs and joints.
Amateurs, meanwhile, took the wrong lesson from Fred himself.
They saw a slow swing and copied the slowness.
But the stopwatch told a different story.
Even with his damaged back,
Fred moved the club from the top to the ball
in 32 hundredths of a second, counted frame by frame,
the way John Novosel did it in his book Tour Tempo.
Fred's swing takes 24 frames going back and 8 coming down,
the same 3 to 1 ratio found in the best players in the world.
His swing was never slow, it was smooth.
Amateurs chasing that look often ended up at 4 to 1 or even 5 to 1,
slowing their backswing until the whole motion turned jerky.
Yale physics professor Robert Grober found that anything slower than 3
to 1 was a sign the golfer's muscles were not loading properly.
In trying to copy Fred's tempo,
they had removed the very thing that made it work.
Phil Mickelson eventually saw where the modern game was heading.
He worried about young players copying
the aggressive lashes they see on tour telecasts.
In his words, a lot of the young guys get hurt
as they create this violent connected movement.
Mickelson argued for swinging motion rather than a violent one.
Fred had been describing exactly that for decades.
At his 40th Masters, Fred opened with a 71.
His playing partners could drive the ball 30,
40, even 50 yards past him.
It made no difference.
Fred was still the one people could not stop watching.
It had been that way for decades.
Wherever he played, the same two words kept moving through the gallery.
So smooth.
The coaches had shortened it.
The doctors had worked on his back.
Instruction had moved on to positions, numbers, and force.
Still, the swing people stopped to watch
was the one Fred had built on a public course as a boy
and the one it kept slipping back to on the course.
When Nick Faldo asked him what he thought about After Impact,
Fred's answer was simple.
He held his finish.
I would pose, he said. Even on bad shots, I would still pose.
