Hunting for Nessie

Decoding Loch Ness
7 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello and welcome to the Historic Scotland podcast.
My name's Sarah McGilvery. I'm an actor
and writer with a passion for people, place and story.
Each episode we travel to a different site,
chat to the people that live,
work and take care of it and unearth its beautiful,
haunting and surprising story.
Today we're off to Urquhart Castle. We're chatting to Josh Graham
Graham, who takes care of tours at the castle.
What a view though that is, right?
Yeah, it must be nice coming to work every day.
It is, it's lovely.
But it's nice to just come out for a few
minutes and sort of take it all back in.
We're also off to the Loch Ness Centre in neighbouring Drumnadrochit
to talk about one very infamous creature.
At some point there must have been something that raised that eyebrows.
Like, there's got to be something that causes all this speculation.
Let's play a game.
When you search Scotland, what do you think appears?
If you said Edinburgh Castle, you get a point.
If you said pictures of Highland cows, you get another.
Arthur's seat? Sure.
Bagpipes? Of course.
But do you want to know what appears first?
I tried this. Genuinely.
It's a picture of Urquhart Castle,
positioned right on the banks of one
of the world's most famous bodies of water.
Lock.
Loch Ness.
Here's Joshua. Most people just call me Josh.
He takes care of engagement at Urquhart Castle
overseeing the talks and tours
so he's the perfect person to show us around. Geographically we're
just on the banks of Loch Ness at Urquhart Castle
and so what we can see now is the glens and the
loch heading sort of east towards well east
northeast towards Inverness. So I was reading
a bit about it so there's been am I right
in thinking there's some sort of fortification here?
Since Pictish times. There has been.
So when we're looking at the castle from our position
we can look to the left and we'll see the tower,
the Grant Tower, and if we look to
the right we'll see the Citadel
and up that hill there on the right side of the castle.
It was where the Pictish fort was found,
so it's difficult to pinpoint exactly,
but with that in conjunction with Saint Columba's diaries,
he said he visited here and went to the Picts, so that would have
been up in that area there, sort of around 500 AD time-ish.
So it's been there's been something here for a long time.
And is that because of where it's situated?
Is that because of the geography?
Yeah primarily. So with the Picts it's maybe more difficult
to say. It was possibly just
because it was quite a natural defendable position where it
was on top of a steep hill
with access to the loch for food and transport. As time went by
and it became way more of a more valuable position just
because of Loch Ness.
If you head north-east you'll eventually get to Loch Ness
and if you head south-west you get to Fort William.
So it's like the natural highway of the Highlands.
It spans about 21 miles and in a period where you
don't have any well-maintained roads,
you might have had a few sort of not poorly designed ones,
ones.
But without a proper road it was by far,
locks were by far the fastest method of transport
up and down the place.
Right, so you'd be on your boat going up
and down the lake rather than in your car going
up there.
Going up there!
I don't know if they'd be able to match 60 miles
an hour but they would definitely be
going faster than you could on the land.
So yeah, comparing it to the roads is the best way of looking at it.
Oh that's incredible actually, I never thought about that,
how busy it would have been, well...
Not busy but just like that it
was the easiest way to get along that stretch.
Yeah I mean it would have been busy-ish
and you definitely would have been able to see
anybody going up and down
which is also quite a fundamental reason for living here as well.
With the loch itself you can get food from there as well,
fresh water fish, you can get salt water
if you go to the seas on either side
so you've got a really good access to food, really good travel.
And yeah, you can monitor the loch, so if anyone's on it
that shouldn't be there, you can sort of intervene there.
Eventually, the castle became part
of the royal family's sort of assets.
So as a royal stronghold,
it had that significance of saying that we're here in the north.
And so anybody that was traveling up
and down would have had that in the back of their mind,
saying that, you know, the royal powers are here,
and so don't do anything sort of dodgy.
The loch is long, it's deep, and it's dark.
Urquhart Castle sits partway along the Great Glen Fault,
a geological scar that splits Scotland almost perfectly in two.
And as Josh was saying,
this natural route made the site vital for centuries.
You've got this natural corridor running coast to coast,
so whoever controlled
Urquhart held incredible power through the Highlands,
and this is true throughout time.
The castle's a ruined stay
but the earliest signs of defence here date back over a thousand years.
The Picts themselves didn't write anything down.
They drew symbols but nothing that could be
properly recorded as like a written word
and so we don't have any records up until the late 1200s.
So to put you in the picture Scotland's sort
of similar with the way the map looks.
There's some disputes down south
and some issues with the islands so they're not fully into the
the map yet, but
Basically the north was in sort of open rebellion
and it was the McKeiths and the McWilliams that
were rebelling at the time
and obviously that's really not good for the Scottish king who's
Alexander II and so he wanted to re-establish his power in the north
and so they decided to
build a castle that would sort of signify their power
and to squash the rebellions that were
nearby. So initially Alexander sent
his son-in-law Alan Durward with his dad Thomas
to come up and put down the rebellions, which they did
with relative ease because they had quite a large force.
But the king realised that if they went back
to the central belt without leaving anything here in its place,
that the north would break out into rebellion pretty soon after that.
So, he instructed Alan to stay here, build the castle,
and oversee the north, sort of in the royal power name.
So they built the castle, they made the big ditch initially,
there wouldn't have been a tower there,
the tower would have been on top of the hill there,
where the Pictish fort was,
so there would have been a small tower with two kind of walls coming
around to sort of signify that castle structure, if that makes sense?
Yes, it does, yeah.
So Alan came here
and he stayed here for the next sort of 50 years until he died.
So Alan and his wife, they had three daughters.
They all had partners and they lived down south
so none of their partners were keen to come and take possession.
So the castle itself reverted back to the crown
and eventually to Alexander III.
At that time, we're coming up to the Scottish Wars of Independence.
So Alexander III,
he eventually dies and Scotland has that succession crisis.
Where they don't know who to choose as the next monarch.
And that's primarily because he didn't
have any living descendants left.
He had a granddaughter that they tried to bring across from Norway,
but she didn't make it on the voyage and she died.
And so, as I was saying, Scotland had a succession crisis
and had to decide on a new monarch.
Right, yeah.
They elected to...
get some outside help. So they asked
their neighbouring country for assistance,
and the neighbouring country at the time,
England, and neighbouring monarch at the time,
Edward, who's nicknamed the Hammer
of the Scots for a reason. So he came up,
helped them choose a monarch.
They chose John Balliol and he did it relatively a good job
for a little while until Edward kind of,
his true plan came into place and he invaded.
Edward invades and there's chaos everywhere.
The Highlands are suddenly swept
And I
have
some
news
for
you.
Because there's an episode all about
Stirling Castle waiting for you right now.
It's available exclusively to Historic Scotland members
who also have access to extended episodes
with exclusive behind-the-scenes content too.
Historic Scotland membership
also gives you free entry to sites across the country
and helps support the care and conservation of the places we explore.
It's a really great episode.
There's some info in the show notes.
Okay, right. Where were we?
Ah, yes. Edward invades. Chaos.
It culminates at Stirling Castle and the Battle of Bannockburn.
Here's how the story of Urquhart continues.
So after the sort of initial first stage
of the Scottish Wars of Independence,
when Edward's army is defeated at Bannockburn in sort of 1314,
the castle and its lands,
they are sort of, the last people
to hold it were supporters of the English.
I am so
They were obviously removed from the castle's sort of ownership
and it fell back to Robert the Bruce
but they were kind of...
too concerned with the central belt
to deal with anything going on up here
and so it sort of fell to the duty
of constables to look after the castle
until and the next sort of notable family were were given it.
It's difficult to say who got the castle next entirely
and as there's not really many records
to kind of like before those before the
wars of independence started and what we do know
It comes a little bit later.
That raids, again, sort of take place in the Highlands,
and this time it's by the island lords, the MacDonalds.
And they come into the north,
basically to sort of plunder, and their ancestors were
Norse and Viking, and so they sort of take up that way of living again.
They come into Scotland
and they sort of take the more valuable bits where they can.
Eventually they kind of end up at the sort of Glenurquhart area,
and the castle's quite
a juicy place to come and raid if they've got lots of valuables here.
So there's a little bit of back
and forth between the Scottish crown and the MacDonalds.
At the end of the 1300s the MacDonalds take take
a place quite a big raid and they gain access to
the castle and the stuff that's here
and they take possession of it for roughly 15 years and
that kind of goes back and forth.
In sort of in 1509 the castle is given to the Grant family.
And they're given the castle for the same reasons
that Alan Durward came down here,
and that was to help put down rebellion
and to regain a bit of control in the north.
So the Grants do quite a good job, there was parts of the castle
that had fallen into disrepair, they repair it, they repair the tower
that was there and they transform it into the Grant Tower on the sort
of left hand side if you're looking at it from our point of view.
Quite a famous part of it isn't it?
Yeah, a famous part.
So they build that Grant Tower and in 1545 the MacDonalds come back.
And it's a sort of time in history where it's known as the Great Raid,
because the MacDonalds come here.
The Grants, unfortunately, aren't actually here at the time.
They're up at their estates in Grantown-on-Spey,
and they leave a token force of around 50 men at arms.
So they're here.
They see the MacDonalds with their much larger forces.
It's difficult to sort of imagine what there were,
but there was a vast amount more than
what they had defending the castle.
They take one look and think,
That's not for us, we don't want to die today.
And so they'd leave, they'd open the doors
and they'd let the MacDonalds come in
and they'd take everything from livestock
to a small chest full of money
to anything else that was valuable in the castle.
It's even written in...
in the sort of royal financial part for the time
that they even took the doors and gates
because they had some valuable stuff on them.
So the McDonald's kind of do what they want with
the castle and the Grants have conveniently left
them three large ships which they take, load up
and hightail it back to the islands. Really? Yeah.
That is a big raiding and then back in the boat.
And off we go.
I know.
Yeah.
And then the castles?
The castles here, the grants and the government rebuild it.
The grants do actually seek legal sort of awards
and the courts give it to them but
there wasn't anyone to go and collect it.
So the McDonald's owe the grants
this money but there's no one to get it.
But what does actually happen is they do start
to rebuild parts of the castle to what it
was before the McDonald's kind of came and ruined it.
The Grants themselves live,
a branch of the Grant family lives here way up until the middle
of the 1600s.
They eventually leave and go
and build quite a nice stately home in Drummond Rocket which
is still there to this day.
If you're ever in the area.
So the Grants have moved out the castle, they still legally own it,
but they're not living here.
The next big moment in Urquhart's story comes in the late 1600s.
At the time King James 7th of Scotland,
also James 2nd of England, is on the throne. He's a Catholic
and in a country where the Protestant church
is very much in power that's problematic.
People aren't happy with his religion and tensions are running high.
To make a long story short, James already has two daughters,
both Protestants, married to Protestants.
So everyone assumes that when he dies, the throne will pass smoothly
to them and Protestant rule would continue.
But then James has a son with his second wife.
And suddenly the idea of a Catholic king ruling
the United Kingdom again becomes a real possibility.
The Protestant establishment? Not having it.
This is the Glorious Revolution.
James is deposed, his daughter
and her husband are appointed monarchs instead.
James is furious.
He's also not having it.
He wants his kingdom back.
And that's when things start spilling north.
James makes his way into Scotland trying to rally support
and it's here in the Highlands
and around Urquhart that the drama really unfolds.
For those living near Urquhart it must have felt like
the whole world had tipped over.
Even today the castle walls are scarred by centuries of conflict.
So it's James and his supporters
which were called the Jacobites and that's just because
Jacobus is Latin for James.
Okay that's where Jacobites comes from.
That's right so him and his supporters they come into the north.
And they look at Urquhart Castle to take it, and there's a few,
it's said that they tried a few times, but there's nothing documented
to say it, but it's said that they tried a couple of times
and were unsuccessful, so the Jacobites moved on, not James himself,
but his followers would have tried to come into the castle.
So once they realised it wasn't going to be working,
they went sort of northeast.
The people of Urquhart Castle, they still belonged to the Grants.
And
And the grants allowed the government
to have troops here to defend the location and so
when the troops saw the Jacobites leave
and they were ordered to go and sort of head towards that
area northeast area to meet them.
But the castle itself would be a problem if they'd left it.
Okay.
So to stop the Jacobites from gaining the castle
or gaining entry to use it, they decided
to sort of use a scorched earth technique where they blew up
the gatehouse and some
of the defending walls
so that no one could use the castle as a military stronghold.
When I say no one, they specifically did
that for the Jacobites so they didn't have access
to it to use it.
Probably because it would be a good base camp for them.
Again, if we were allowed to use a bit of common sense,
as the castle's been a status of royal power through the ages,
it would have also signified maybe his right to rule.
And so they didn't want that in any of the ways,
so they just blew it up and
made sure that no one could use it as a military stronghold again.
After the Jacobite rebellion, Urquhart Castle was badly damaged.
The Grants and the royal forces had done their part
and the castle just started to fall apart.
By 1715, a storm hit and part of the Grant Tower collapsed.
You can still see the slope where it gave way.
The Grants still owned it, but they weren't interested in rebuilding.
Military architecture was changing and the old walls just didn't fit
the new style of fortifications designed to withstand cannon fire.
So they let it go.
Slowly, over decades, the castle became a ruin.
That's when something interesting happens.
As Urquhart slips from fortress to ruin,
Loch Ness acts as a passive witness.
By the time visitors start arriving again in the late 1700s
and early 1800s, they're not just coming here for history,
they're coming for the atmosphere.
This is the Romantic Era,
when people are drawn to wild places and half-forgotten stories.
Ruins are seen as beautiful, melancholy, poetic.
And Urquhart, sitting right on the edge of this vast black loch,
becomes part of a much bigger imagination.
And speaking of imagination,
we are on the edge of Loch Ness, so...
Shall we address the elephant in the room or maybe the...
Monster in the Loch?
Don't talk to me about it.
That was quite funny though.
He's coming up there, you can see him coming up.
I actually looked!
Look, we're all about the facts here at Historic Scotland.
And you can't deny that one of the big draws
of Loch Ness is the legend of the Loch Ness monster.
So you haven't seen Nessie?
I see.
No but I've seen a lot of Nessie hunters.
Do people actually come hunting?
Yeah there's annual sort of viewings in that and so...
Annual viewings?
People across the loch sort of look for the monster.
You're a monster.
You've wangled your way into me talking about this.
No it's okay.
We're going to turn this history podcast
into something of a detective one,
just for a little moment.
When people think of Nessie,
they usually picture blurry photographs in tourist boats.
But the first Nessie wasn't a joke, it was a warning.
The earliest account of a creature
in Loch Ness comes from the 6th century.
It's a text called The Life of St Columba written by a monk in 697 AD.
Columba was an Irish missionary
who travelled through the Highlands spreading Christianity.
Amen.
At the time, this landscape was already rich with folklore,
spirits and rivers and creatures that marked
the boundary between the human world and the wild.
According to this text, Columba was travelling near the River Ness,
it flows out of Loch Ness,
when he encountered locals burying a man
who had been killed by a water beast.
He vows to find it and vanquish it with the power of his religion.
Saint Columba, in his writings,
he tended to embellish a lot of his achievements and maybe
it wasn't him but maybe his team, his writers,
they embellished a lot of things that happened,
so any myths that came from his kind of era
were probably upscaled to make it exciting.
That was the voice of Josh.
This is the voice of Charlie from the Loch Ness Centre
in neighbouring DrumnaDocket.
The first claimed sighting was Columba in 500
A.D. who banished a water beast from the loch.
Myth, misidentification, mysterious creature, which one?
The centre is based at the old Drumnadrochit Hotel where
the manageress, Aldie Mackay,
she was not the first ever sighting but the one that's kind of...
It started this snowball effect of bringing people to the area.
So it was her and her husband, they were on their way into Inverness
and she claims that she saw a water beast of some form,
its head popping out of the water.
But by the time she got her husband, elbowed him to have a look,
it had submerged against the water again.
But it was her account of telling that.
to the community in Drum that's really,
yeah, that's what made the news spread.
Moira's also from the centre.
The whole centre is very much born of all the activity
and the research that was undertaken
during the 70s where Adrian Shine, he created the Loch Ness Project.
He was one of the original people that came to the Loch in the 70s
and he just never left.
He's been here for 50 years and he just has spent his life
amassing information and we have so many artifacts
and within this building we have artifacts that
haven't seen the light of day for many many years
and we now run the experience to let people come
to Loch Ness to find in one place this is the birthplace of the legend
this is dates back to when Aldie Mackay in 1933
Saw something, but she wasn't quite sure.
Actually, I have been told she didn't want anybody
to know about what she'd seen.
She thought it was bad for tourism.
I miss him.
What is the impact on the village of, like, you know,
one of the most famous lochs in the whole world?
And I suppose it's this village in the Highlands, yeah.
I mean...
For maybe two thirds of the year like the footfall
and it just rapidly increases.
The summer, spring, even autumn it can be busy.
I think you just get flooded, these people wanting
like a proper Highland experience kind of thing.
And yeah there's so many places that offer
different components of that in the village.
So it's good to see like you drive down and you just
see it's swarmed. I think people are pleasantly surprised
when they come here because
I think sceptics are like, oh, it's all going to be Nessie-focused,
everything's going to be the existence of that,
but we take a wider scope perspective
of why what's been done is so important,
but the impact it's had on the village and surrounding areas.
Nessie is cryptozoological.
That's a creature that may or may not exist.
There are tons of eyewitnesses, and yet no credible evidence
that there might be something lurking in the loch.
But the story crops up time and time again, in folklore,
at the Drumnadrochit Hotel, in a now infamous photograph captured
in 1933, even today people log their sightings online.
The last was a few days ago.
From the 1960s, Nessie becomes a subject of scientific curiosity.
Sonar sweeps, underwater cameras, expeditions,
military-grade equipment to search a Scottish loch.
It has led Loch Ness to be one
of the most studied bodies of water in the world.
So it was always sort of known that there
was maybe like a monster in the Loch and then her
sighting sort of started to confirm that and started to grow.
Yeah I think it's always been
Ness has always been known kind of thing but that's really when the
They're, they're...
The attraction to drag people here kind of started
and then from there it's just spiraled.
You've got the Loch Ness project that started in the 80s,
the government commissioned research
that was done, and that was also based here,
it's actually the gift shop now, that was
all the location.
I do remember absolutely believing there was a Loch Ness monster,
I had my nose pressed
I messed up against the
The window of the car as we drove down Loch Ness.
There must have been at some point something,
but like whether there is still now, I'm not too overly sure.
It's got to be something that causes all this speculation.
And do people in the village, do they tend to believe in Nessie?
Is there anyone who's like, do you know if there's anyone local
who's like, yeah absolutely I've seen her?
I think there's a few locals who have their stories.
I know our skipper,
he's got his own and he'll often be out and come back with photos.
Nothing conclusive from anyone, but they do have their stories.
Their own experiences of seeing something out on a loch,
which I suppose is a bit inevitable
of being around the surrounding area their whole life.
So I suppose it's inevitable that they're going to have
at least one experience where they thought
they saw something a bit strange in the water.
It's not the longest loch and it's not the deepest loch.
The deepest loch is Loch Borer.
The longest loch is Loch O, I think.
It's the biggest loch by volume,
so it's got more water than all the lochs in England and Wales.
So it's long and deep and dark.
And mysterious.
Delirious.
We have our very own Coast Guard station.
It's not usual to have a Coast Guard station on an inland waterway.
We obviously usually expect to see them on the sea,
but because Loch Ness,
it's just a haven for people to have their holidays.
We've got the Caledonian Canal going from one end to the other,
so people just pass through.
People enjoy the waters, the canoe,
but we do need to keep everybody safe because
these big waves appear
and these are the waves that sometimes create ripples and ripples cause
shapes and shapes can mean anything.
I'm starting to sing.
There's talk of like something
from the canal maybe getting in and out into the loch but
But, but...
I don't know what it could be that is the scale
that people regard as but yeah at some point there
must have been something's my thinking whether it's still there I'm
not too sure. I personally
Like driving from Inverness here on A82, I've never actually seen
anything that's made you have a double look, but not yet anyway.
Not yet. Do you keep an eye out?
No, normally, you've got to watch out
for the tourist drivers and the rentals.
Yeah, that's true, you can't do it on the road.
Yeah.
So no, not normally.
Yeah.
But yeah, you hear people like, oh, there's like a ripple in the water
and they double take, but no, not for me.
I've never seen anything that's been raising an eyebrow.
So, what do you think?
No, seriously. For most of human history this landscape was dangerous.
Then it became romantic.
Then it became searchable.
To medieval monks, Nessie proved the power of saints. To Victorians,
she proved the wildness of the highlands. What about you?
We kind of present like a balanced argument kind of thing
and then at the end we've got our debate
which presents the guests with the opportunity to vote what they think.
So you've got the three options of I see Nessie,
I see Nonsense, I see Possibility.
And the very last thing visitors can see is the overall votes,
the outcome of what everyone's voted.
So I think we're at 46% Possibility.
The other vast chunk of it goes to I see Nessie.
We then translate that into we've had a new sculpture made by...
a local company so people are able to take a little bit of ribbon,
coloured ribbon, and each
ribbon represents whether they are a believer
or a non-believer and then they tie that onto a
sculpture that we have so we've got quite
a good visual representation of what people think and
very much people are still believing in Nessie which is great.
When you search Scotland, Urquhart Castle appears.
This image, this castle, this water,
it's all come to represent Scotland to so many
people around the world. The stories are intertwined
and it's not hard to see why Urquhart Castle
and Loch Ness are inseparable.
One is built to dominate the landscape, the other refuses
to be dominated at all.
And as I leave, I find myself doing what people have done here
I've been here for over a hundred years.
Look out across Loch Ness.
This has been the Historic
Scotland Podcast.
It was produced and edited by Adam Stoner.
I'm Sarah McGillivray.
Next time, how one small corner of Scotland changed the world forever.
We're off to Kenilworth House in Bowness.
It played home to inventor James Watt
and his creation, the steam engine.
See you then.
