Why This Masterpiece of Joan of Arc Is Actually a Tragedy

The Ancient Beliefs
23 followers
13 Video Views·Nov 12, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
I was in my thirteenth year
when I heard a voice from God to help me govern my conduct,
and the first time I was very much afraid.
These are the words of Joan of Arc,
spoken during a heresy trial that would end her life.
Yet for centuries,
popular culture has refused to allow her to be afraid.
We demand our heroic icons to be pristine and fearless,
wrapped up in triumphant armour.
But the heavy psychological torment captured on the canvas
represents the historical reality
of Joan far more accurately than any film or TV show ever could.
John Everett Millais' 1865 masterpiece today sits quietly
in a private collection.
It stands as an act of rebellion against
traditional neoclassical paintings.
For generations the academic style insisted
on painting heroes like ancient unblemished statues.
Painted versions of the Prima Porta or the Roman Emperors.
But Millais was a founder of the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood.
They hated that sanitized fake perfectionism.
Millais didn't want to paint a sterile state
propaganda piece. He wanted to capture
a living human being collapsing under the sheer weight
of divine isolation
and the very real psychological torment this would have caused.
Unlike the weaponized propaganda of the Death of Marat,
Millais wasn't serving a political regime.
He was exploring the Victorian obsession with the medieval past
to strip away state mythology and reclaim the fragile human soul.
What we're looking at is Victorian romanticism
and technically brilliant brushwork.
Look closely at how Millais handles the environment.
There are no vast French armies,
and Joan is not a heroic soldier on horseback.
She's trapped in a dark, claustrophobic, shallow space.
It feels less like a military camp
and more like a medieval monastic cell.
And the lighting is not natural.
There are no windows or candles. Instead, a striking
supernatural spotlight cuts through the dark, illuminating her face.
It's a direct visual
callback to the Renaissance paintings of the Annunciation,
the moment the Virgin Mary is
illuminated by an angel
and told she will bear a burden that will change the world.
But the most stark aspect of the painting is Joan's eyes.
They are entirely devoid of joy
or awe. Her eyes are glassy and mournful,
heavy with the weight of foresight. Though modern
science is quick to diagnose Joan's visions as epilepsy
or psychological hallucination,
to Joan the voices of saints Michael,
Catherine and Margaret were entirely real. And those
voices didn't just bring the promise of glory,
they brought the warnings of doom.
By the spring of 1430,
her voices told her explicitly that she would be captured and
subject to terrible suffering before the summer passed.
Millais captures a young girl violently
grappling with her determination
to fulfil God's will whilst her human mind trembles at
the consequences. To emphasise her youthful nature,
Millais paints her hair loose and unbound.
Today it looks like a simple stylistic choice,
but in the 1400s it was a symbol reserved for
unmarried maidens.
It was a visual testament to her virgin purity and vulnerability,
spilling out under her cold steel armour.
We know from contemporary accounts and wax seals
that Joan actually had short black hair
and sun-darkened skin from working in the fields.
Millais paints her pale and blonde,
as this was a Victorian standard to reflect purity and innocence.
This aspect of the painting is interesting, as Millais
was prioritising religious symbolism over historical reality.
However, the armour is a different story.
Millais actually rented a genuine,
historically accurate suit of 15th century plate armour
to paint this piece with absolute fidelity.
Joan's maiden nature was important religiously,
but the armour was important politically.
Whilst the armour evokes images of the battlefield,
Joan's reality was far more abhorrent.
During her trial, she testified that she wore men's clothing
and bound her armour tight,
not out of military pride, but out of necessity.
Surrounded by rough guards and enemy soldiers alike,
the steel was her only defence against
the constant threat of sexual assault.
For Joan, the armour wasn't just a symbol of power,
it was a cage of survival. We see her as
a divine hero, but we mustn't forget that she was still a teenage girl,
existing in the rough
landscape of 15th century medieval Europe.
These human atrocities were a well-documented fear she
had to grapple with throughout the trial and her whole campaigns.
Beneath the cold steel,
Millais drops a violent splash of her blood-red skirt.
Historically, we know Joan wore a simple red dress
when she first set out to meet the king,
but in Christian iconography, red is universally a colour of martyrdom,
as it depicts the blood of Christ and the blood of the saints.
Millais is using the fabric to actively foreshadow her execution,
the red garment practically mirroring the licking flames
at the stake that would eventually engulf her body.
Another key detail is the weapon she holds.
Look at her sword. It isn't unsheathed or raised in triumph,
it's not being used violently outwards.
It rests horizontally across her lap,
its hilt forming the unmistakable shape of a crucifix.
She isn't preparing to kill, she's preparing to be sacrificed,
because the ultimate tragedy of Joan
of Arc is that she didn't just face cruelty of the English,
but she was also abandoned by the French.
Joan was a brilliant tool for a desperate French court.
Her divine fervour broke the siege of Orléans
and successfully legitimised King Charles'
coronation at Reims, but once Charles had his crown,
Joan became a political liability.
She wanted to keep fighting. The king, however, wanted diplomacy.
When she was captured by the
English-aligned Burgundians, she was put up for an astronomical ransom.
Her subsequent trial wasn't
just a quest for justice,
it was a highly coordinated political show trial meant to burn
her as a witch, thereby proving the king's coronation invalid.
Despite this, her sharp wit
stunted the English prosecution for weeks,
until they eventually had to burn her at the stake.
She was an uneducated French peasant,
yet she theologically outsmarted the English scholars
who could not technically trap her into a confession of heresy.
The final verdict was absurd.
She was killed for wearing men's clothing, something spoken of in
Deuteronomy, a verdict that would never have
been a death sentence for any other normal woman.
But when we look at the broader history of the Hundred Years' War,
we often lose ourselves in the politics and the famous battles,
but Millais strips all of this away
and forces us to look at the key thing, the individual.
The crux of this canvas is the quiet, devastating reality of a miracle.
Without context she is simply a devout girl in prayer,
but with context her expression is a
mirror of isolation. She is looking up at God,
realising that the state has taken what it wanted
and left her to burn, and that the very voices that guided her to glory
are now guiding her straight to this stake.
Being chosen by God is a miracle,
but in the world of human politics miracles often demand
the ultimate sacrifice.
Her eyes tell the whole story,
and Millais's masterpiece captures the emotion perfectly.
I've been Diadochi, and thank you so much for watching.
