I Fact-Checked Every Stunt in the Tesla Roadster Reveal

USA Autos
9 followers
#ford #fordglobal #cars #usacars #usaauto #tesla #autos #autousa #ram #chevrolet #buick #Cadillac #Jeep #Lincoln #Dodge
AI Generated·May contain errors
Absolutely insane, holy .
What a launch event.
Hey Elon, how come you-
invite me to your wildest parties.
Tesla has unveiled the new Roadster and in classic Tesla
fashion they have some wild marketing stunts to go along with it.
And I love marketing stunts
because their goal is to convince you they've created
the coolest thing ever but when you start
applying engineering logic
to these stunts sometimes they fall apart. So in this video
we're going to be looking at the three major stunts in order.
First, we've got climbing a wall and hanging upside down,
second, um, flying, the car does
a kickflip over a bunch of other cars,
and third, the car rockets to 60 miles per hour
in under a second.
So for each of these stunts we're going
to play a game called legit or nonsense.
We'll dive into the engineering of the stunt
and ultimately label it as legit,
Or nonsense.
But first, I've got to give Tesla some props for two big reasons.
First, that they didn't use a ramp for the kickflip stunt.
Using a ramp would have sucked all the air out of this trick,
so it's really cool that they used
the thrusters for both takeoff and landing.
And second, when Tesla did their 0-60 live in 0.81 seconds,
That number was WITHOUT rollout nonsense.
The timing starts at zero.
Thank you whoever won that argument inside Tesla's walls.
But let's get into these stunts starting
with the fact that the Roadster is now a fan car.
Also, I gotta give props to Tesla. The old Roadster, it was,
you know, very beautiful, very elegant, very difficult to draw.
This new design, much easier to draw, so I appreciate that, Tesla.
So, much like the McMurtry Spearling, the new Tesla Roadster
is using fans, so it can literally climb walls and drive upside down.
The execution is a little different, though.
All right, so let's talk about fan cars,
and this is all about manipulating air pressure.
So we are surrounded by atmospheric pressure, right?
One ATM, about 100 kilopascals, or 14.7 psi pressure.
The thing is, that pressure is acting in every direction.
So it's pushing up on the car, and it's pushing down on the car.
It's pushing it back, it's pushing it forward.
It all equals out, so the car doesn't get pushed anywhere.
So the car is just sitting there.
But what if, what if we can make that pressure underneath the car zero?
Then our pressure pushing down on the car would
be equal to our pressure differential
multiplied by the area above that car, right?
The amount pushing down.
Pressure times area, that's going to give us a force.
So, what is the area above the car?
Well, we don't know the dimensions of the Roadster.
However, we do know its wheelbase
and there is a top-down view of the car.
So, we can use the wheelbase and the top-down view and get a...
Pretty good estimate of the length and width of that vehicle,
and that gives us an area of about 9 meters squared.
Okay, so our downforce is equal
to the pressure differential, above versus below,
and multiplying that by the area above the car.
So, we've got 100 kilopascals of pressure, ambient pressure,
multiplying that by 9 meters squared.
100 times 9, see it together, folks.
900. Good job, everyone.
900 kilonewtons, an absurd amount, or about 90,000
kilograms of downforce.
So we have an extraordinary potential
of downforce that we can create.
Keep in mind, this is a car about 2,000 kilograms.
So the amount of downforce we have is insane.
We have so much potential.
So we don't need to take out all of the air
underneath the car.
We just need to take out the pressure a little bit.
And so what do they do?
Well, they have little skirts that slide down behind
and to the sides and in front of the battery.
So you have these skirts that come down and you try to create a low
pressure area in that region using fans and sucking the air out of it.
And you actually don't have to do all that much.
So in the demo, we could see
that the car could generate 4,700 kilograms of downforce.
So let's use this equation here and try
and figure out what pressure differential they're actually creating.
So we can say 4,700 kilograms, multiply that by gravity,
that's equal to our pressure differential.
And let's say the area underneath that battery pack
where they've got these skirts coming down
is about four meters squared.
So that is going to give us a pressure differential
of about 11.5 kilopascals.
In other words, an 11.5% vacuum.
Yes, that's like, you know, a pretty good vacuum,
but also it's nothing crazy.
That means underneath the car in that four...
Meter square area, we still have a pressure of about 88.5 kilopascals,
or about 88.5% of atmospheric pressure.
And that is enough to keep this thing suctioned upside down
and to defy gravity.
How cool.
Now, it's worth mentioning, McMurtry is using two 30 kilowatt fans,
or a total of about 60 kilowatts,
in order to create the suction for their vehicle,
and they're using a bit smaller of an area.
Tesla is using four 20-kilowatt fans
and a larger area underneath the vehicle,
so 80 kilowatts, more power, larger area.
However, the vehicle is, of course, heavier, so pros and cons there.
But here's the bit you wouldn't have caught from Tesla's presentation.
Skirts that come down to form
a seal underneath the car are all wear items.
And the fans, too, unless Tesla has developed some magical filter,
are wear items as well.
McMurtry, who has been doing this fan stuff for some time, says they're
able to filter out 92% of the mass of debris their fan system sucks up.
But that means 8% of the finest debris is going through those fans.
McMurtry says you can get multiple track days
with the fans at peak performance,
But it's worth mentioning this party trick doesn't last forever.
You'll regularly need to be replacing
the ceiling skirts as well as the fans.
It's also worth mentioning downforce
is hugely dependent on the surface you're driving on.
Of course for the demo Tesla is using an ideal surface,
so we'll have to wait and see what the real world performance is.
All of that said, the science behind this first stunt is not nonsense.
It is absolutely legit.
All right, let's move on to the flying car stunt.
And it's worth mentioning,
I made a video about all of this over six years ago,
and honestly it holds up pretty well,
though now we have some different figures from Tesla to discuss.
Alright, so how does it fly?
Well, within the vehicle you have two storage tanks,
one 400 liter tank and one 200 liter tank.
Both of these storing up to 10,000 psi of nitrogen,
giving you about 250 kilograms of nitrogen to work with.
So, you then open a valve,
that nitrogen dumps out and, you know, rocket stuff.
So, on the car, there are 10 thrusters, four in the back.
Four underneath pointing down behind each of the wheels and then
two up front on the sides pointing to the sides for yaw control.
So if you use those four that are pointing down and you open up those
actuators and allow that nitrogen to rush out, just cold nitrogen,
The thing floats.
Neat.
Now, Lars of Tesla seems like an awesome dude.
He tells us that the maximum thrust
from these things is over 80 kilonewtons.
That is pretty absurd.
So to me, to determine if these stunts are legit,
we need to understand how much time
this car could theoretically hover.
Given the specs and to do so we'll use the equation
as discussed in my previous video for rocket thrust all right
So if we're trying to figure out how long it can hover
the first thing we need to figure out is how much force do?
We need to hold the car up in the air well
That's just the weight of the vehicle right so if you just assume
around 2,000 kilograms multiply that by gravity that means we need
20 kilonewtons to keep this thing hovering in the air now remember
we've got 80 kilonewtons to work with so that's no problem
Now if we go back to our equation force of thrust is equal to gravity
Mass flow rate is what we need to figure out in order
to determine how long can this thing float in the air
because we know how much mass we have, 250 kilograms of nitrogen,
but we don't know how fast we're using it.
So, if we fill this all out, you can calculate your mass flow
rate plugging in these variables and you get something like 37...
Kilograms per second. So we know we have 250 kilograms
of nitrogen stored on board. We divide that by
37 kilograms per second, our mass flow rate,
in order to hover and that gives us about
It's about 6.3%.
6.75 seconds or about 6-7 seconds of hovering in the air. Now
I think I speak for all nerds when I say I think 7 seconds
is a perfectly acceptable, perhaps even above average,
amount of time for thrusting.
Challenge accepted.
Okay, so are the stunts realistic?
Well, they're of course going to need
a lot more thrust than just hovering,
since they're going way up into the air or stopping from a huge fall.
But ultimately, if you look at the amount
of time it takes for each stunt,
They're both about four seconds.
So you're going to have less than seven seconds
because that's for hovering,
but ultimately this seems realistic.
Now, could they be using shells with less weight
or larger nitrogen tanks with more storage onboard?
Sure, but I think based on the numbers we know about the quote-unquote
Production roadster these stunts we see are certainly possible.
So I am labeling them as legit as well
Alright, so let's move on to the final stunt the insane zero
to sixty time of 0.81 seconds now
We know from interviews.
There are four Roadster variants. We've got base
performance thrust
and rocket. Each one getting quicker.
So let's work through each example.
Alright, so starting with the base version.
Now all the cars are going to be rear-wheel drive.
The base version is not going to have any of the fans
or the suction system.
It's just going to be the base Roadster.
And so there's a few assumptions we need to make.
to make. We know the wheelbase of
28-25 millimeters.
We're going to assume a front-rear weight distribution of 40-60.
Of course, we've only got those motors in the rear.
We're going to assume a center of gravity height of 460 millimeters.
This is actually about the same center
of gravity height as the Tesla Model S.
That's where that number is coming from, as measured by Car and Driver.
And then we're going to assume a tire frictional coefficient of 1.3.
So we can use these numbers, we can plug it into this fancy equation.
And that gives us, for the base model,
a maximum acceleration of about .99 Gs,
or zero to 60 in about 2.76 seconds.
Now it's worth mentioning,
even if this center of gravity were to be higher,
or you had a little bit more grip,
you could throw all of that.
Weight onto that rear tire, and using this grip right here,
1.3, the theoretical limit would be 2.1 seconds.
So I don't see any chance that the base version
of the car gets a 0-60 below 2.1,
and I think realistically, it's going to be around 2.5,
2.7 seconds, somewhere in that region.
Now here's the problem.
Franz, Tesla designer, said in an interview
with Motor Trend that the base version doesn't have fans.
And he said it will hit 60 miles per hour.
In just over a second, I don't see any scenario where this is true.
So, base car 0-60 just over a second? Nonsense.
But here's what I assume, Franz probably just misspoke
and he was probably thinking of the performance version.
That's the only real logical explanation,
unless the base version comes with fans.
Because it's not going to be under two seconds.
Now, it's still up in the air whether
or not the base Roadster is actually going to be made.
And I wouldn't be surprised if it wasn't made.
Because, thanks to all-wheel drive, almost certainly
the Tesla Model S Plaid is going to be quicker than the base Roadster.
Alright, let's move on to fans.
Alright, so looking at the performance Roadster,
on top of the base version, you're going to get more power,
you're going to get added fans, and you're going to get an added skirt.
So you've got this suction.
So, we know our base version can accelerate at about 1g.
What does our new system add to that acceleration?
So, we're told that it has 2 g's of downforce from the fan system.
If we assume that center of pressure is centered with the
center of gravity, so we're multiplying that by 60%
of that weight is going to be going on the rear axle,
and then we're multiplying that by our tires frictional coefficient.
A little bit lower here because as you add weight to a tire,
the frictional coefficient will go down slightly.
It's called tire load sensitivity.
So that gives us a number of accelerating at about 2.3 Gs
or zero to 60 in about 1.2 seconds.
Now it's worth pointing out,
this is very much so napkin math.
This is very real math.
This is very napkin math.
And the reason why I say it's napkin math
is because our frictional coefficient
will decrease with loads.
We don't know exactly what that will be.
We don't know what the pressure distribution is from Tesla.
They haven't said if it's perfectly matched.
With the center of gravity, if it's further back, if the center
of pressure that you're pulling out that suction is closer to the rear,
then this number is going to increase, so you'll have a better launch.
If it's closer to the front, that number decreases.
2 G's is, of course, based on, you know, the road surface.
So, a better road surface, that might go up.
A worse road surface, it might go down.
Also, if all of this is a really high number,
the amount of load transfer you have increases, so that number goes up.
So that's all to say, there's a lot of variables
that go into this, but.
It is safe to assume that in the low 1s,
which is again what I think Franz was talking about,
you could hit that with the performance version,
no thrust at all, just using fans, a 0-60 in the low 1s.
Very cool.
Alright, so let's move on to the thrust version,
which we saw on stage hit a 0-60 in .81s.
Alright, so the thrust version adds on top
of the performance version a 200L tank with nitrogen
and four nozzles all pointing out the rear.
So, if we look at 0-60 in 0.81 seconds,
velocity is equivalent to acceleration times time.
We're trying to figure out how much acceleration did
this thing perform with on stage.
88 feet per second divided
by 0.81 seconds times 32.2 feet per second squared,
that gives us an acceleration of 3.37 g's.
So, is 3.37 g's realistic for this thrust version?
Well, it's about a G-
quicker, about a G more in acceleration versus the performance version,
thanks to these nozzles at the rear.
And so we've already determined that we need about 40 kilograms
to provide this thing hovering for one second.
So if we have enough force for one G for one second,
all we need is 40 kilograms.
Well, this 200-liter tank is going to hold,
you know, maybe 80-some kilograms,
so we have plenty in that tank in order to make this happen.
This number checks out.
All right, and finally, we get to the invite-only Rocket Roadster.
Okay, so on top of everything that the Thrust Roadster has,
we are adding an additional 400-liter tank plus six additional nozzles.
So we've got 600 liters of nitrogen storage at 10,000 PSI,
250 kilograms of nitrogen, and 10 total thrusters.
Now, we know from an interview with Lars that the Rocket Roadster has
the maximum thrust, which is over 80 kilonewtons.
So if we take 80 kilonewtons,
we divide it by the vehicle weight, let's say 22.5 kilonewtons,
that's going to give us an acceleration
from the rockets alone of about 3.5 Gs.
Now, we can add about 2 Gs from the performance version,
giving us a total of about 5.5 Gs of acceleration.
For the Rocket Roadster,
a 0-60 of around half a second, if that is to be true.
Wow!
Now, just one final comment on the Rocket version.
Lars has said in an interview with Hagerty
that the Rocket version will have a 0-60 of 0.55 seconds.
And yeah, the math checks out.
So, I think the claim is legit.
So, as far as the three stunts Tesla conducted...
Everything seems legit
as in everything they presented can indeed happen with the technologies
They're using whether
or not there was any trickery involved. So that's good
But then the question becomes will a consumer ever own any
of this the production car will actually do better than that
Well, you see, the thing with Tesla
is you never really know until you actually have it in your driveway.
Right, like Tesla said they'd create a roadster that's seated four,
that had 620 miles of range,
and that had tons of storage. None of those became true.
And one of the most baffling things, it's not even a roadster anymore.
It's a T-top. Tesla T-top.
Not the same ring.
Right, and Tesla said they'd make a 500 mile Cybertruck.
They didn't.
They said they'd make a pack extender for the Cybertruck.
They didn't.
They said the Cybertruck would seat six.
It didn't.
Tesla claimed they'd make a 500 mile Model S.
They didn't.
And I haven't even mentioned delivery timelines,
which we've all learned to ignore.
Again and again and again, Tesla says things.
And then they do not do those things.
And Tesla stans will rage in the comments at me.
But you really don't know with this company until
the product actually ships.
Okay, rant over.
I do believe they'll actually make some form of this.
And I do think the performance numbers are going to be insane.
But I don't believe everything they've told us.
And I'm going to create another video explaining just that.
But for now, genuinely, huge props Tesla,
it was a heck of a show, and the engineering is legit.
Oh, and a special shout out to Kyle from Out of Spec
and Chris from Everyday Chris.
Both of them were very kind
and shared their footage with me from the event.
I will put links to their videos from the event
if you'd like to check those out in my video description.
If you have any questions or comments, feel free to leave them below.
Thanks for watching.
