New movies and TV shows are coming out daily, with dozens of streaming platforms to watch them on. But where to even start? And how do we find media with characters as complex and diverse as the world we live in, especially when our algorithms keep recommending more of the same?
That’s where UC Berkeley Professor Abigail De Kosnik can help. She runs the Media Education Research Lab, or MERL. There, she and her students have investigated dozens of movies and shows to discover which are excelling at diverse representation and which have missed the mark.
“Good representation, which doesn't always mean positive representation — it means representing the fullness of people, including allowing them to be imperfect and make crappy decisions and be the villains and all of that — I think good representation is important for the culture and the society,” says De Kosnik.
This is the first episode of our new season of Berkeley Voices, featuring UC Berkeley researchers helping us think through how to focus and create space for what counts.
- Music by Blue Dot Sessions. - Photos (from top left, counterclockwise): Courtesy of Disney, courtesy of Netflix, poster art by James Jean/A24, courtesy of HBO Max; photo illustration by Neil Freese/UC Berkeley.
Professor Abigail DeKosnik discusses the shift from the network era to a fragmented, algorithm-driven media landscape. She emphasizes the need for authentic representation—portraying the \"fullness of people\"—and introduces her lab's rigorous tagging system to quantify diversity and bias in film and television to combat stereotypes and media bubbles.
Media is a portal and a gateway to other worlds
and to a larger sense of the world.
This is Berkeley Voices, a UC Berkeley News podcast.
I'm Anne Bryce. This season, we're
exploring how easy it is to feel overwhelmed
by the constant notifications, the stuff piling up
in our homes, the unending streams of things to watch
and like and engage with.
And we're talking with UC Berkeley researchers,
helping us think through how we can focus
and create space for what counts.
Today, I'm joined by Abigail DeCostecke.
She's a UC Berkeley professor
and chair in the Department of Theater, Dance, and Performance
Studies and a professor in the Berkeley Center for New Media.
She studies diversity and representation in media
and how fans engage with popular culture.
During our conversation, we talk about our fragmented media landscape,
what good representation
means and looks like,
and how and where to find diverse media beyond our algorithms.
Plus, the DIY media future she hopes to see.
I have been thinking about all of these different movies
and shows and platforms and franchises
just all competing for attention all the time,
and it can feel really overwhelming.
And so I was wondering from your perspective,
kind of what this abundance of different things
for us to watch and consume might feel like for audiences
and how it feels for you, maybe.
Yes, absolutely. So since the 90s,
we've been in what scholars call the post-network moment.
So the network era of media, especially television,
was from the 1950s until the 1990s. And that was
an era when only a very small number
of television networks really dominated the mediascape. And
I know that film was also very important through all those decades,
but in terms of what you
could view at home, you know, it was really just ABC,
CBS, NBC, and PBS, and then Fox
started as a network also in the late 80s.
And so to go from just those handfuls to this world that we have now
with, it feels like, thousands of options is really extraordinary
and I think has led to a fractured cultural landscape.
Everybody's in our own individualized, personalized media bubbles.
Well, it is true that we're all seeing what
our own algorithms are feeding us.
DeCostecke says this choice, multiplying,
has also led to the creation of more diverse media,
with stories of characters who are surprising
and as varied as the people around us.
I think that media representation, good representation,
which doesn't always mean positive representation,
It means representing the fullness of people,
including allowing them to be imperfect
and make crappy decisions and be the villains and all of that.
I think good representation is important
for the culture and the society.
But how do you know when a show or movie has good representation?
What traits do you look for exactly?
That's where DeCostecke can help.
She runs the Media Education Research Lab, or MERL.
There, she and her students have investigated dozens of shows
and movies, tagging them to
document which are excelling at diverse representation
and which missed the mark.
So can you talk a little bit about your media education research lab?
Yeah, why you started it and when and and what you do there?
Media education research lab is my research lab
that's been going since 2020.
And that moment was a hot moment for thinking about diversity
with nationwide Black Lives Matters protests throughout 2020.
The Stop AAPI Hate movement that happened at that same time.
Me Too was still unfolding in Hollywood
and other industries at that time.
So there was a real, there was a vibrant,
dynamic public discussion of diversity and representation.
They decided to look at 10 movies
and 10 TV series released each year between 2019 and 2022.
Ranging from Pixar's Toy Story 4
and the Oscar-winning comedy Everything Everywhere All at Once
to HBO's Hacks and Netflix's Beef.
The evaluation process is thorough.
Two people are assigned to review each movie or show.
First, they watch it and then extensively research
its audience reception online.
Looking at everything from critical reviews
in media outlets like the New York Times and the Boston Globe
to what people are saying on Reddit, TikTok,
and in the comment sections of places like IMDb
and Rotten Tomatoes. After that, they identify the top eight characters
and tag them with their ethnicity, gender,
sexuality, age, and nationality. The movies
and shows also get assigned bias tags. For example,
one would get an F if it only fetishizes
or sexualizes women of color,
or a C for colorism if all the people of color are light-skinned.
Or they get a T for tokenism,
when it feels like a minority character has been included
only for what DeKosnick calls diversity brownie points.
I think of our tagging
and scoring methods as ways of educating people in how to talk
about the ways that women and minorities are represented.
You know, like we lack a lot of common language.
So once you learn our tagging and scoring method.
I feel like that gives people a common vocabulary.
Each movie or show then gets a total score and a Merle bird.
That represents how well a text did in diversity scoring.
A flying bird is the best.
Then comes thumbs up bird, followed by side-eye bird.
And then finally, a dead bird with crosses for eyes.
The taggers then write a review, summarizing their findings.
I asked DeKosnick about a show
or a movie that was especially interesting for the team to work on.
The show Hacks was really great to tag and score and blurb
because Hacks is one of those few shows that centers on an older woman.
Our metric for whether a text is ageist
is if they have no women 50 years old or older.
And it is astounding how many films and television series get that tag,
the Y tag for young.
Hacks puts that older woman at the very heart of the series.
It's all about this legendary stand-up comedian,
fictional comedian named Deborah Vance,
played brilliantly by Jean Smart,
who won an Emmy every single year she played that part.
And she has decided to co-write with this younger millennial
or Gen Z writer, Ava Daniels.
And so a great show for feminism in general.
A great show for women, especially older women,
but it also doesn't have a lot of people of color
as the main characters. It does have a big cast
and there are significant players of color in the
cast. But when we decided to tag the top eight,
only one of the characters of color made it into
the top eight, meaning like how much screen time did they get?
How much story did they get? Character development
It was interesting, she says,
to see a show that scored high in representation of women and age
and may look very diverse in terms of race and ethnicity,
yet most of the top main characters
weren't people of color.
DeCostanzo also notes that while the cast includes many queer actors,
the show doesn't reckon with sexuality quite as much as it could.
Though imperfect,
the first and second seasons of Hacks both got flying merle birds.
Others that earned flying birds included
the Marvel movies Black Panther, Wakanda Forever,
and Eternals, as well as the series Abbott Elementary and Beef.
Some that received a
dead bird rating include the Irish romantic drama series Normal People,
along with the animated
movie Toy Story 4,
and the psychological thriller Joker.
What is the effect when people don't see
Themselves in the media they consume,
but also for the people who maybe do and it's misrepresented
or they do, but they don't see the other people.
Yeah, there have been quite a number of studies that have shown
that for people from minority groups who watch a lot
of mainstream media, that there can be negative effects.
So a lot of it is what is called stereotype threat,
that effect where minorities walk around with sort
of this dread that others will believe that they
will behave according to a stereotype and so they kind of mitigate
and change their behaviors to not come across as a
stereotypical Asian or a stereotypical Latino
or you know like to not behave in ways that will get them
pigeonholed
ethnically or in terms of gender or sexuality in these specific ways,
these negative ways mostly.
However, there is also countervailing scholarship that says
that people just don't care what media, how media represents them.
They know they're not those stereotypes and they trust their friends
also not to buy into stereotypes about their groups.
I've had students say,
I make my mom watch certain TV shows because she never meets these
different kinds of people.
And I want her to at least know a little about different cultures.
And I think that's a great goal.
So there are many ways that people interpret media
and apply it to everyday life.
Personally, I think if the media industry were to make it a goal
to represent this country in its fullness and its richness,
I think that would only help media.
I think it would attract more viewers, it would educate people,
and it would have people see that they have a place in this culture
and in this society, and that they have room to be more than one thing.
I'm wondering maybe what you do to find more diverse movies and shows.
Like, where do you go and what
do you suggest people do and how to find them?
Because it can be hard if an algorithm has decided
that you watch a certain thing.
And, you know, and you're like, where do I go?
How do I get out of this, like, box that I've been trapped in?
Yeah.
You know, first of all, lists are good.
Like, Emmy nominations are good lists to read.
As well as Golden Globe lists and other,
you know, Academy Awards nominations lists,
but also paying attention to the NAACP Awards,
the Independent Spirit Awards,
you know, the GLAAD Awards, like, I think look at more lists.
Not just kind of the big mainstream awards,
but the ones that have to do with specific communities
and the ones that are paying attention
to smaller productions as well
that may not have studio backing.
If you have an art house theater near you,
a theater that shows independent films
and films that are on the kind of festival circuit,
those are great for just expanding
beyond the sphere of mainstream cinema.
Television is, it is really hard to know where
to read about titles or find out about things.
I read Deadline Hollywood a lot for my research
and also my personal fandoms.
I stay on top of what's about to come out through industry,
through trade papers, essentially.
So through trade papers and following those social accounts,
I do find out about what is about to be released on TV.
But I do, I am always lamenting that we don't have
a kind of canon of past television that
people who are interested in, in finding out,
you know, great TV that isn't on right now,
but is in the archives and streaming platforms.
Right now, students in her lab are working
on a new project supported by a Google Academic
Research Award, where they're tagging
and scoring YouTube shorts to assess degrees of
misogyny.
And DeKosnik hopes that the lab will soon find more funding
to continue their work on shows and movies.
When you think about the media landscape,
what gives you hope for kind of our media future?
Yeah, okay, that's a great question.
Because there's a lot to not be hopeful about right now.
Like, media is consolidating heavily.
And that could be bad for diversity in a lot of ways.
I mean, it depends because the Paramount deal
to buy Warner Brothers has just struck
and they promise a slate of 30 or more films every year.
So maybe there will be more films in theaters,
but what will that do to the television landscape,
I think is a big question right now.
And also, are young people even interested
in these longer formats?
And maybe TikTok and other kinds of social media video
are pushing.
younger viewers towards much shorter form
and much different kinds of content like
more influencer content
or gamer content than narrative fiction content.
So the landscape is changing heavily because of a few things.
In terms of hopefulness, I still hope that participatory culture,
as Henry Jenkins calls it,
a culture in which the audience can also be makers, results
in a lot more kinds of content out there circulating in the world.
So I hope that a lot of kids that grow up shooting things
on their iPhones or their Androids,
that they become directors, editors, writers,
cinematographers, and performers too.
So, like, I hope that there is a democratization of media production,
and I hope we will just see many, many, many more kinds of stories
about more kinds of protagonists in the future.
That would be a really great media future.
To learn more about DeKosnik's lab
and to see the 80 shows and movies her team has reviewed,
visit merl.media.
That's M-E-R-L dot media.
You can also find a link in the show notes.
There, you'll also find a link to DeKosnik's new podcast,
Alpha 60, where she and fellow
researchers explore what online file sharing
reveals about global audiences for movies
and TV.
This is Berkeley Voices, a UC Berkeley News podcast
from Strategic Communications.
I'm Anne Bryce.
This is the first episode
of our new six-part season featuring Berkeley researchers who
are rethinking how to live, focus, and create space for what counts.
New episodes come out at the beginning
of each month from November through April.
You can find all of our episodes, including from the past two seasons,
at news.berkeley.edu slash podcasts.