Nervous system regulation has gotten oversimplified. Let’s clear up 3 big misconceptions about trauma, dysregulation, Polyvagal Theory, and healing.
Is your nervous system really “dysregulated”? Is the goal of nervous system regulation to feel calm all the time? And does past trauma permanently change or damage your nervous system? Nervous system dysregulation has become a huge mental health buzzword—and along with some genuinely helpful ideas, there are plenty of misconceptions, oversimplifications, and “vagus nerve hacks” floating around. In this video, I break down three common misconceptions about nervous system regulation. First, we’ll talk about why a healthy nervous system isn’t calm all the time. Mental health is less about eliminating anxiety, anger, or activation and more about becoming flexible: accurately recognizing problems, taking helpful action, and returning to safety and connection. Second, we’ll look at the idea that trauma leaves you with a permanently dysregulated or “damaged” nervous system. Past experiences absolutely shape our responses, but those patterns are playing out in the present—which means we have opportunities in the present to practice new responses, build safety, solve problems, set boundaries, and increase our sense of agency. Finally, we’ll talk about the controversy around Polyvagal Theory. Some aspects of the theory have faced scientific criticism, but that doesn’t mean we need to throw out everything we’ve learned about the mind-body connection. We’ll look at what the evidence does support, including breathing, mindfulness, exercise, biofeedback, exposure, and other body-based approaches. The goal isn’t to regulate your nervous system perfectly. It’s to become more flexible, discerning, capable, and able to take meaningful action toward the life you value.
So nervous system dysregulation has become the new buzzword.
It's super trendy and there's tons
of hacks and people selling stuff
and with that comes a lot of misconceptions and it makes me
wonder like have I contributed to this problem?
Like is it a problem? I mean I love nervous
system stuff but then I feel like
on the internet it becomes really distorted so
Like, have I made this worse? Maybe.
I was one of the first people making videos about the nervous
system, and I'm sure I've lacked nuance.
So let me do my best to clear these things up. I've got
three misconceptions about nervous system regulation,
and one of them really bothers me,
but it's not that comfortable to talk about.
So let's go. Let's jump in.
Um, here's misconception number one.
The goal is to be calm all the time,
or if I'm not calm my nervous system is dysregulated,
or I'm doing it wrong.
One of the members in my community, I'm gonna call her Barb, asked
basically like, how can I stop feeling anxious
and having panic attacks about my daughter's choice of partner?
Should I do medication? Should I do TMS?
Now her goal here was to remove feelings of anxiety,
which of course I get. I mean
no one wants to remain anxious.
Some people might say it this way,
my dysregulated nervous system is causing all my problems.
I need to make it calm down. What vagus nerve hacks
Can I use to make my problems go away?
The nervous system gets activated when it senses a threat.
It's like a smoke alarm, right?
It's there to detect danger and to mobilize you to solve it.
So of course, I needed a FigJam chart to,
because this stuff is kind of complicated.
So the goal isn't to get really good
at just turning off the smoke alarm.
It's to use the smoke alarm as something to get your attention.
So the alarm fires off and you're supposed to ask,
Is there actually a fire?
If the answer is yes,
there is a fire then just calming down doesn't work here
You need to get out of the house call for help the firefighters
or someone puts water on the fire
And then eventually like at some point maybe figure out what caused
the fire and prevent it from happening in the future in that case
It's like thank you fire alarm like thank you nervous system
for keeping me safe
Now, if we go back up this chart,
if there's not actually a fire, like, no, there is no fire,
then you might ask, like, oh,
what made my smoke alarm go off in the first place
when it wasn't a fire? And maybe it's like cooking bacon, right?
So then in that point,
if your smoke alarm is going off
and there's no fire, that's when you turn
off the smoke alarm. That's our analogy for nervous system regulation.
Now, in both these situations,
when the smoke alarm is going off, like panicking,
Is not helpful, right? So not panicking like being able
to take appropriate action is the best option
So what made it go off it was cooking bacon, right?
Like you're cooking bacon and made your smoke alarm go off in that case
We do want to turn off the smoke alarm,
which is our analogy for nervous system regulation and then probably
Solve the problem of what's making our nervous system go off
when it's not supposed to
In this case, it's like, oh, I should
be more careful about cooking bacon, or I need to air out the house.
If it keeps happening, like, maybe I should move my smoke alarm
a little further away from where I cook bacon, right?
Like, what it comes down to is, like,
how do we problem solve, like, making our nervous system...
Our smoke alarm a little bit more accurate
so that it only goes off when there actually is a fire.
And taking action to solve and prevent these problems is better than
just turning off this smoke alarm over and over and over again, right?
Okay, so there's the smoke alarm analogy.
Let's go back to Barb. Her anxiety goes off and
what her anxiety is actually asking is, is my daughter in danger?
Am I in danger? Am I a bad mom?
So let's look at like the yes answer here on this flowchart. Yes.
Your daughter's in danger.
Like, let's say her relationship with this person is really dangerous.
Okay, then we're going to ask, like,
what actions can I take that are actually helpful?
LOC stands for locus of control.
That's making a chart and saying, here's what I can change.
Here's what I can't change.
Some of the options in your here's
the actions I can take are, I could talk with her.
I could build a relationship of influence.
I could ask her more questions.
Or...
If I know about danger, I could call the cops, right?
Like, these are actions you can take.
In that case, the anxiety was not the problem.
Like, just taking medication or doing TMS
is not going to solve the problem of your
daughter being in danger.
On the other hand, what if your daughter's not in danger?
Okay, so if we go back up this chart, we go, no, she's not in danger.
Then, at that point, you're saying, why did my alarm go off?
Why is my anxiety going off when she's not in danger?
There's some perception of danger that's making me feel anxious
and panicky, like I'm threatened.
Okay, so that's where we look and say, like, where's the bacon here?
Where's the bacon?
Is it like a false belief?
Like, oh, my identity as a mom is dependent on, like, my goodness
as a person is dependent on my daughter having a very certain outcome.
Or are you having thoughts like, if she doesn't marry,
you know, someone who makes a million dollars a year,
this is going to be a catastrophe, right?
Like, so these catastrophizing
and these beliefs are making your smoke alarm,
your nervous system fire off when there isn't actually a real problem.
Okay, so then some of the things we might
do to make this smoke alarm be more accurate
is to accept what you can't change, to grieve it,
to process it, to talk about it, to go
to therapy, things like that.
Now, keeping yourself calm
while facing these problems can help your brain turn on and actually
solve them, right?
Panicking when your smoke alarm goes off does
not help you solve the question of like, am
I in danger?
Why is my smoke alarm going off when it shouldn't?
Panicking when your daughter
is dating someone you don't like is also not going
to help you have like nice calm conversations
with her and figure this stuff out.
So nervous system regulation can help us problem solve.
But it is not a replacement for problem solving, okay?
So Barb doesn't need to just calm down and stop feeling anxious.
Instead of that, we talked about how
to work through relationship problems.
And in the live call I do with members, Barb and I explored
what is the problem that she needed to solve?
Like, why are you panicking about this?
What about this makes you feel threatened or in danger?
And this is where like good therapy
is going to be so much more powerful
than just trying to make your anxiety go away
with like nervous system regulation hacks.
So if your problem was I built my identity
as a person on a specific outcome that I expected
my kids to choose, then we solve that problem
by helping you build an identity based on your values
and actionable stuff you can do and on clarifying your locus of control
and setting up healthy
boundaries and whatever, not by just making the anxiety go away.
Now Barb was awesome and
courageous about facing these questions
and I helped her find some good therapist options in
in her area to help her sort out the solution to her worries.
But again, our goal isn't just to make the anxiety go away.
It's to see if the anxiety, our nervous system,
is raising the alarm about something we need to solve.
If you're in an abusive relationship,
just calming down won't solve your problem.
Building a safe plan to leave and then following through
on that is more likely to make your nervous system calm down.
If you get angry all the time and blame others for your problems,
just calming down won't solve the problem.
Learning how to take honest accountability will. If you're depressed,
just calming down might make things worse.
Self-expression, action, exercise, hopeful
action will help. CBT, seeking support, taking ownership will help.
If you're having panic attacks,
just calming down won't solve your problem.
Changing your relationship with your body's sensations might.
If you think everyone hates you, but they don't,
we might need to question those thoughts.
So your problems and your nervous system are interrelated.
Problem solving is a much more lasting solution compared
to just like nervous system hacks or
nervous system regulation.
But nervous system regulation can really help you solve problems.
Okay. And not only that,
but a healthy nervous system is not calm all the time. It's flexible
and discerning. So what do I mean by this?
Healthy people get a little stressed out and
activated when they have a deadline.
Totally healthy. They have a burst of energy.
They turn in the task and then afterwards they relax.
They can both relax and get activated.
It would be unhealthy to feel like no stress
when you have a big task to accomplish.
You'd just be flat all the time.
No.
Healthy people might get worked up or angry when they see injustice
and then they figure out how to take appropriate action.
And then they after they do that they can go play
with their kids and have fun, right?
They're accurate in solving a problem and then flexible in returning
to a state of connection. People stuck in a trauma response
might see injustice everywhere.
Like every single situation is someone out to get them.
Or they might take things personally
and then they react in a way that's not helpful by lashing out.
Or maybe they constantly feel hopeless and powerless,
even in situations where they might be able to change something.
They see every email as a threat instead
of sorting through what is and isn't actionable.
So a healthy nervous system
is about discerning about perceiving threats,
and it takes helpful action.
A healthy nervous system can be playful, excited,
aroused, relaxed, competitive, grieving,
and then bounce back to appropriate helpful action,
and also quite a bit of relaxation and rest.
An unhealthy nervous system gets stuck in activation,
like stressed, anxious, angry,
tense, or struggling to relax, or it gets stuck in shutdown,
fatigue, hopelessness, despair, avoidance.
Now because most people get stuck in activation,
I've often emphasized learning how
to calm your nervous system as the goal,
but that's wrong, or at least like it's
not the accurate like correct focus we should be having.
It's learning how to solve problems in a way
that lines up with the kind of person you want to be
and to increase your sense of safety
and connectedness and powerfulness.
So being flexible, active, values driven,
and restoring calm after an event is really helpful.
So I'm just going to make sure to emphasize
that more moving forward as well.
All right, on to number two
and this is the one that bothers me the most.
I see some form of this whenever I scroll
through mental health social media.
Every couple of posts someone
is talking about nervous system dysregulation as
if it is something that happened to you in the past
and now it's a permanent state.
And I see comments like this all the time.
Oh my nervous system is constantly stuck in fight or flight.
I am unable to breathe ever
and regular breathing exercises don't work out.
Or someone else said,
can you be in the dorsal vagal state your whole life?
I was chatting with someone else
who told me he would always be dysregulated,
that no one would ever understand him, and the kicker he said was,
I have a good therapist,
but of course the damaged nervous system was given to me from birth.
Okay, when I hear or read these comments,
I feel like immense compassion.
Like, I wish I could speak to you directly
and work through each little issue one by one.
But I also feel like the good news of mind-body therapy has
been distorted into this new form of brokenness.
This nervous system dysregulation is suddenly a permanent thing.
It's like The Body Keeps the Score got turned into this idea
that all forms of trauma leave a permanent and unhealable wound,
and that the past will always harm us.
And that we can't escape that score.
Now as humans, we're constantly looking
for explanations for our experience.
From the four humors 2,000 years ago, to Freud's theory of hysteria,
to the chemical imbalance, to nervous system dysregulation.
Like is this the new trend?
And I think there's so much we still don't know about mental health.
So much that science in general doesn't know about mental health.
But I feel extremely confident that any set
of beliefs that makes you feel helpless,
that tells you this is just the way you are,
or limits your options for taking action to
improve your life, any theory that limits
your agency is either false or misunderstood.
For example, the chemical imbalance theory
helped people feel less stigma, but in some
ways limited their options to medication instead
of all of the powerful options that we have.
Which includes medication.
The body keeps the score in the influencer space has become
past trauma makes my nervous system dysregulated.
And I think this is a fundamental misunderstanding.
Like please read further than the title and like open the book.
There are so many options for healing in there.
And there's like 10 other books that about healing trauma
that I like better than that one.
Now when I say nervous system, I'm talking about the invisible thing
that's connecting our mind and our body.
It's our perception of safety and threat
and our physiological reaction
and our behaviors that are all fueling each other.
So when our thoughts are anxious,
our nervous system preps for fight or flight. Our
digestion slows, our muscles tense,
all kinds of physical stuff happens. And when the body
is hurting, inflamed, or tense,
it can also send a message to our mind like, I'm not safe.
So the nervous system is the link between these two parts.
I think there's undeniably a close connection
and science backs that up,
but this is only helpful
when we understand this as a present moment response.
Like yes, our nervous system develops
habitual responses due to past trauma.
Of course, the effects of trauma are real, they're impactful,
they show up in our mind, our body, and our actions.
But these responses happen in the present moment.
And there's a lot of simple and powerful things we can
do in the present moment to regulate.
And these don't have to be super fancy.
It's as simple as slowing down
and softening your muscles and exhaling longer.
It's as simple as looking around your room and reminding yourself
that here in this moment, you are safe and capable.
Please don't believe any psychology that tells you,
this is just the way it is. It's your past.
It's your parents. It's your genes.
I'm not saying those aren't factors,
but underneath those messages is an
underlying belief that you can't get better. And learned
helplessness is bigger and more harmful than those
other factors. I would say it's the most harmful factor
So don't fuel that by buying into an influencer
who tells you comforting but disempowering stories.
It's your parents, it's your nervous system,
or it's X or Y diagnosis.
If these stories make you feel...
Good or understood, but they don't give you actionability.
They probably aren't as helpful as they feel.
Your nervous system isn't wrecked by past trauma.
It's wrecked by ongoing habitual trauma responses
that happen in the present moment.
Me continuing to engage in these unhelpful
protective responses in the present moment
is what keeps that nervous system response going.
And understanding that gives me freedom to do something different.
Can you see why I get a little worked up about this?
That's misconception number
two. Nervous system dysregulation is caused
by the past, that trauma makes us
this way, and that this is inescapable.
Like, false. Autonomic reflexes are real,
and it's not your fault,
but these responses are not inescapable because
they happen in the present moment.
The nervous system can learn that it no
longer needs to raise the trauma response in the present.
And we get tons of chances to practice
this and rewire this in small ways every day.
By soothing our body, by facing problems, by setting boundaries,
by taking action that reminds us that we
are capable, safe, and powerful.
Okay guys, here's the third one and this one is a little bit nitpicky.
Polyvagal theory has taken some hits lately. This is a model I've used
Somewhat extensively for years.
I've never dove deep into, like, the nitpicky biological aspects of it,
but I've used the general model as a way to explain things.
Long story short, a bunch of researchers published another paper,
published multiple at this point,
saying that some very specific aspects
of the model are not biologically correct.
There have been some polyvagal theory is dead type posts out there,
and then rebuttals have been
published by the Polyvagal Institute,
and I'll link these in the description. Here's my take.
I still think that the big picture nervous system approach is correct,
that there are three states, activation, safety, shutdown response,
plus there's a lot of nuance and mixed states in there.
I think polyvagal theory still seems helpful clinically,
like there's evidence for that, but I'm probably not going
to keep using the big complicated words that make me or...
People or influencers seem super smart
and trustworthy because they're using big words.
I'm probably going to refer mostly
to the window of tolerance model by Dan Siegel
rather than polyvagal theory because it's just more user friendly.
I'm also not throwing the baby out with the bath water.
Here's what the research clearly shows.
Body-based interventions can have
a powerful positive effect on mental health
and there's tons of research for slow breathing,
heart rate variability, biofeedback.
Mindfulness-based interventions, yoga,
exercise, progressive muscle relaxation,
exposure therapy, interoceptive exposure,
which is a big word for learning to sit
with your bodily sensations.
There is evidence and research showing that
somatic-based therapies like polyvagal theory
and somatic experiencing do help,
but that evidence base just simply has
less studies than things like cognitive
behavioral therapy.
And I see this nervous system regulation
as one part of a mental health ecosystem
rather than like the cure for trauma or something.
If we want to improve our mental health,
we can't ignore any part of the mental health ecosystem.
And this includes physical health,
our nervous system, social support, cognition,
like how we think, right?
Learning our environment and our culture
and our spirituality and our purpose.
So we aren't going to like throw the baby out with the bathwater.
We're not ignoring the effects
of our body as part of our mental health,
but we also aren't just going
to keep it like top down and just work with our
like CBT or our thoughts.
And it doesn't have to be exclusively nervous system regulation either.
We tip the scales toward mental health by carefully supporting people,
their minds, their bodies,
their souls in a connective loving ecosystem of family,
friends, and society.
Okay, so the goal isn't to be calm all the time,
it's to be flexible and accurate in
problem solving. Your nervous system is not wrecked by past trauma,
but it might be actively stuck
in the present moment, and this belief frees us to take action.
Polyvagal theory isn't dead,
but I'm going to be referring to the window
of tolerance model from now on.
And again, all of this comes down to agency,
taking one small action each day to see clearly,
solve problems, improve your mental health,
so that you can live the life that you truly value.
Okay, thank you for letting me get this off my chest.
If you want to join me in my live calls,
check out what my membership has to offer.
I'll put that link in the video description.
And thank you so much for watching and please take care.