In October of 1957, on her fiftieth birthday, a Richmond woman named Jeanette tried on a dress her daughter had chosen, and the saleswoman at Miller and Rhoads told her the truth in one sentence: the dress was younger than she was, and everyone could tell. Women of that generation knew a short list of things to put away at fifty, and for every one of them, they knew what to wear in its place.
In this video: the cropped pants Katharine Hepburn never needed, the short topper that stopped at the widest point, the spike heel that dented kitchen floors, the little hat perched on the back of the head, the sack dress of 1957 and the princess line that beat it, satin at noon, the fox fur with glass eyes, the woman who measured thousands of real customers to cut clothes for grown women, the swimsuit designer who turned fifty in 1956 and walked away from her own company over the bikini, and the one view of yourself most of us never check.
On the Saturday she turned 50, in October of 1957,
Jeanette Pruitt stood in a fitting room at Miller
and Rhodes in Richmond, Virginia,
wearing a dress her daughter had picked out.
The saleswoman studied her in the three-way mirror,
then said one sentence.
Honey, that dress is younger than you are, and it's telling everybody.
She laughed.
Then she took it off.
Her generation knew what to put away at 50,
and what to reach for instead.
One swap came from a designer who turned 50 that same decade,
then walked away from her own company in a fight over what replaced it.
The dress went back on its hanger,
and Jeanette went looking for something her own age.
Number 10. The Pants That Stopped at the Shin
They went by a dozen names in the 50s.
Pedal pushers, clam diggers, toreador pants.
Every one of them ended somewhere on the shin.
And a young wife in a pair of them,
with flat shoes and a ponytail, looked like summer itself.
At 50, a woman watched where that hem landed.
It cut her leg where the calf is widest, drew a hard line across it,
and left a band of bare skin above the ankle that belonged on a girl.
The tight toreador kind was harder still
because it followed every curve on the way down.
One woman had been showing the country another way since the 30s.
Katharine Hepburn turned 50 in May of 1957,
the year she made Desk Set with Spencer Tracy.
She wore slacks long before most women would be seen in them,
and the story goes that studio staff once hid hers to make a point,
so she went without until they gave them back.
In photographs from those years, her slacks are long and easy,
high at the waist and falling straight to her shoes.
So the swap was full-length slacks
with a crease pressed down the front,
in gray flannel, navy, or camel,
hemmed long enough to rest on the top of the shoe.
With nothing to stop the eye on its way to the floor,
the leg reads longer.
Try a pair the way she might have.
Sit on a kitchen chair and cross your ankles.
If the hem climbs halfway up your shin,
those pants are too short for a woman who sits as often as she stands.
The pedal pushers stayed in the garden.
With the trowel and the straw hat.
Over those slacks went a coat, and it had a length problem of its own.
Number nine, the topper that ended at the hip.
In the 50s, women often called a coat a topper,
and the shortest ones stopped at the hip.
They swung out from the shoulders in soft,
wide folds, with big buttons and big pockets,
in cream, red, or a fuzzy wool that looked like a lamb.
Over a full skirt on a slim girl of 20,
it was the smartest thing on the sidewalk.
At 50, the topper ended at the widest place she had.
The flare made a broad triangle from the shoulders down,
and then the skirt came out from underneath and kept on going.
From across the street, she looked shorter and wider than she was,
as if she'd borrowed her daughter's coat.
Full coats of that decade came either short,
to the hip, or long, to the middle of the
shin, and women past 50 reached for the long one.
It covered the skirt.
It kept the wind off her knees.
It made one column of color from the collar to the calf,
which is the most flattering
shape a coat can draw.
A camel or navy coat that fell well past
the knee could go over a work dress on Monday
and a church dress on Sunday, and it never looked borrowed.
To judge any coat, put it on and lay both hands flat on your hips.
If the hem sits right under your fingers,
it ends at the widest part of you.
Look for one that reaches at least a hand's width below the knee.
The short toppers went to the daughters for football games.
The next swap could ruin a kitchen floor.
Eight to go!
And that saleswoman at Miller
and Rhodes had an opinion about every one of them.
A tap on the subscribe button keeps a chair
for you outside the next fitting room.
Number 8. The Spike Heel
A heel no wider than a pencil at the bottom, three or four inches tall.
By the late 50s, young women everywhere wanted a pair,
and floors all over America paid for it.
The pressure under a spike heel is greater than
the pressure under an elephant's foot,
and kitchen linoleum, wood floors,
and carpets came away marked with rows of tiny dents.
For an older woman, the damage showed in her walk.
A heel she couldn't stand in shortened her step,
tipped her hips back, and made her move carefully.
And a careful walk looks older than any gray hair.
She didn't run to the other end of the shoe department either,
to the black lace-up Oxford with the thick heel
that her own mother had worn to every funeral for 30 years.
That shoe said grandmother before she opened her mouth.
What she bought was a pump with a low, solid heel,
about as high as two fingers held sideways,
with a toe that came to a soft point instead of a dart.
Shoe companies made plenty of them.
In Auburn, New York,
a firm called Dun & McCarthy named its line Energetic,
a play on the word energetic,
and put its advertisements in every national women's magazine.
The whole promise was right there in the name.
Test a pair on the porch steps.
Walk down at your usual speed without touching the railing.
If you find yourself watching your feet,
or your hand drifts toward the rail anyway,
the shoe is setting your pace, instead of you.
A low pump in navy, taupe,
or soft black goes with the long slacks and the long coat
already on this list.
And once the feet were settled, the eye went to the top of the head.
Number 7. The Little Hat on the Back of the Head
The half hat was a clever piece of millinery.
It covered only part of the head,
a crescent of felt or velvet,
or a band of silk flowers.
And it's credited to the New York milliner Lily Dash,
who won an award for the design in 1941.
By the 50s, it was everywhere.
In 1952, the fashion reports from Paris told women
to uncover the front of the head and cover the back.
So the little hat slid backward
and perched behind a row of short curls.
On a girl, that looked fresh.
Her whole face was on show, hairline to chin,
and she had nothing to hide from the noon sun.
Past 50, the same hat left the face without any frame at all.
The eye skipped past her, to the back of her head,
where a scrap of velvet sat like a decoration on a cake.
Women of that age didn't give up hats.
They changed the shape.
They chose a small brim, in soft felt for winter or straw for summer.
Tipped up a little at the front so it lifted off the forehead.
A brim does for a face what a mat does for a photograph in a frame.
It gives the eye a place to stop.
Before you buy one, face a window while you're wearing it.
If the brim puts your eyes in shadow, tip it back an inch.
If it's sitting so far back you can't see it in the mirror at all,
it isn't doing anything for you.
The next swap reached Richmond the same autumn as that birthday.
Number 6. The Sack.
In 1957, two great couture houses in Paris,
Balenciaga and Givenchy, showed a dress without any waist.
It hung loose from the shoulders and narrowed a little toward the hem,
and the papers called it the sack.
American stores had their own versions on the racks within months,
and women bought them in huge numbers.
Men, by most accounts, couldn't stand it.
All through 1958, the newspapers argued.
One side called the new dresses modern and simple.
The other called them ungainly and ugly.
A singer named Jerry Granahan put out a record called
No Chemise Please, and it climbed to number 23 on the Billboard chart.
That same year, seven baby girls in America were named Chemise.
Jeanette's daughter bought one in beige.
Her mother tried it on in the living room,
turned sideways to the hall mirror,
and saw a woman standing inside a paper grocery bag.
On a girl with a 22-inch waist, the sack was a joke she was in on.
On a woman of 50,
It buried the waist she still had and added width everywhere else.
The answer was the princess line.
A dress cut in long panels from the shoulder
to the hem with no seam across the waist.
All the shaping came from those long seams,
curving in where a woman curved and out again over the hip.
It skimmed the middle instead of squeezing it or hiding it.
And it had been flattering grown women since
the couturier Charles Frederick Worth made it popular in the 1870s.
Stand sideways to a mirror in any loose dress
and lay one hand flat where your waist is.
If the fabric in front of your hand stands out more than an inch,
the dress is drawing a bigger woman than you.
Princess seams are still sewn into dresses and coats.
On the hanger, look for two long seams running down the front.
The sack had its moment.
The trouble with the next one was in the cloth itself.
So, where did a woman like Jeanette learn everything else?
From her morning cold cream to the way she ran a house all week?
The Forgotten 1950s Feminine Routine Manual answers
in 150 beautifully illustrated pages,
already owned by more than 1,900 women.
You'll find NostalgiaWomen.com heading the description below.
Number 5.
Satin at Noon.
Satin and taffeta made a sound when a woman walked,
and that sound meant a party.
A taffeta skirt whispering down the aisle at a June wedding.
Satin at the Christmas dinner, under a string of colored lights.
In daylight, at a luncheon or a club meeting,
shiny cloth did a woman past 50 no favors.
Shine catches light on every curve and fold,
so a satin dress laid a bright stripe across the bust,
Another across the stomach.
And one over each hip.
Stiff fabric stood away from the body
and made it look bigger than it was.
A 1955 book on dress and appearance by Grace Margaret Morton
told women with fuller figures to stay away
from fabrics that were shiny, stiff, or bulky.
A fit too tight, it warned, makes the figure appear larger.
What she wore to lunch was crepe.
Wool crepe in the cooler months.
Rayon or silk crepe in summer, with a dull,
pebbly surface that soaks up the light instead of throwing it back.
A navy crepe dress could go to a luncheon, a funeral,
and a bridge party in the same month and look right at all three.
Crepe had one more kindness.
After an hour on a folding chair at the women's club, the back
of the skirt still looked the way it had when she left the house.
The satin wasn't thrown out.
It waited for evening, when lamplight is kinder.
And everyone in the room has dressed up, too.
Hold the fabric up to the window and crumple a handful of it.
If every fold flashes white, save it for after dark.
If the light sinks into it, it can go to lunch.
Mat crepe, a fine wool knit or a soft jersey, does the same job today.
Starting in 1945, ordinary women let Edith Head take
their outfits apart in front of a radio audience.
She was the top costume designer at Paramount.
and Art Linkletter invited her onto his program,
House Party, once a month.
In 1952, the show moved to television, and she went with it,
critiquing women from the audience until the program ended in 1969.
Her advice hardly changed in all those years.
Fewer accessories, more color,
and clothes cut for the woman wearing them.
She called it her chance to turn America
into a country of neat and natty women.
The boldest swap on this list happened far from any studio,
at the beach, a few swaps from now.
Number four, the fox with the glass eyes.
Every Easter of Jeanette's girlhood, it rode on her mother's shoulders.
A whole red fox, head, paws, and tail,
with amber glass eyes and a little clip hidden in its jaw,
so it could bite its own tail and stay put.
Children stared at it all through the sermon.
Some of them were certain it was staring back.
It had a smell, too.
Cedar, a little mothball,
and the face powder of whoever had worn it last.
Furs with heads and paws were the height of fashion through the 30s,
and interest stayed strong through the 40s.
After that, it faded, and by the late 50s,
a fox with a face on it told everyone
in the pew roughly what year it had been bought.
That was the trouble for a woman turning 50.
She might have inherited one,
or kept her own since 1938, and it was still good fur.
But the minute it went around her shoulders,
it added a whole generation.
The swap was a stole, a long wide rectangle worn around the shoulders
and over the upper arms.
A woman with money had one in mink.
Far more women wore wool or cashmere,
soft and plain, in camel, grey or black.
It kept her shoulders warm in a drafty church,
went over a dinner dress in a cool restaurant,
and folded into a drawer all summer.
For evening, the same shape came in chiffon or velvet.
Test any wrap this way.
Put it on and lift both arms,
as if you're about to hug someone taller than you.
A good stole moves with you and settles back into place.
If it slides off or bunches up around your neck,
it's too narrow or too stiff.
Plenty of those foxes still lie folded
in cedar chests and garment bags.
If one is in your family, it's a piece of history,
not a piece of your wardrobe.
Then there was the dress itself, and the body it had been cut for.
Number 3. The Dress Cut for Somebody Else
Off the regular rack, a dress was often cut for a younger shape.
Long through the waist, high in the bust, narrow in the hip.
A grown woman could usually get into one.
What she couldn't do was reach for the car door without feeling
the seams pull across her back.
Much of that changed because of a girl
who had arrived in New York alone.
Lena Himmelstein came from Lithuania at the age of 16.
When she opened her first bank account,
a clerk wrote her name down wrong,
and Lena became Lane, the name that went on the store, Lane Bryant.
Her first big success was a dress for expectant mothers.
In 1911, the New York Herald finally agreed
to print an advertisement for it.
And the next day, the whole stock sold out.
Then she went after a bigger question.
She and her husband measured about 4,500 of their own customers
and gathered figures on some 200,000 women
to learn how grown women were really built.
They found three main types of fuller figure
and cut clothes for each one.
When she died in 1951,
Lane Bryant was the sixth largest mail order business in the country.
And through the 50s, its catalog pages offered suits,
coats, and even swimsuits cut for fuller figures.
So the swap at 50 was a dress cut from grown women's measurements.
Whether it came from a catalog page, the half-size rack downtown,
Or a dressmaker with a pincushion strapped to her wrist.
Plenty of women kept a cloth tape
measure rolled up in the sewing basket
and knew their own measurements by heart.
In a fitting room, cross your arms over your chest
as if a cold wind just came through the door.
If you feel a pull across the shoulder blades or the buttons gape open,
that dress was made for somebody else.
Petite, women's, and women's petite sizes all come from that same idea.
That a tape measure beats a guess.
Whatever the rack misses, a good alterations shop can finish.
The Miller and Rhodes Tea Room held fashion shows,
and in the spring of 1958,
Jeanette and her sister had a table beside the runway.
The room smelled of coffee and warm rolls,
and the silverware chimed against the good china.
Models wound between the tables,
while ladies in hats and gloves ate chicken salad
and chocolate silk pie.
A suit went by, then a cocktail dress,
then a coat she made a note about on the back of her napkin.
The last model came out in a bathing suit, and the room went quiet.
Her sister leaned over.
You'd never, she set down her fork.
Not that one, she said, but I'd wear one.
Number two, the two-piece bathing suit.
The two-piece was a young woman's suit in the 50s, a top cut like
a brassiere and bottoms that stopped at the waist or a little below it.
On a beach towel at Virginia Beach, with a transistor radio playing
and a bottle of suntan lotion going warm in the sand,
it announced that a girl of 19 had arrived.
On her mother, the same suit laid a bare stripe across
the one place she least wanted the sun, or the neighbors, to study.
The woman who solved the bathing suit
for every age didn't start out in fashion.
Rosemarie Reed spent part of her girlhood on a farm in Wiser, Idaho,
and began making swimsuits in 1936
because her husband kept complaining about his.
Ten years later, she had her own company in Los Angeles.
She was the first swimsuit designer to sew
a brassiere right inside the suit, and the
first to sell swimsuits in dress sizes,
so a woman who wore a 16 in a dress could buy
a 16 for the beach.
Panels to hold in the tummy, legs that stayed down,
and little skirts came along too.
She said she wanted a woman to look as lovely
in a swimsuit as she would in an evening gown.
Rita Hayworth and Marilyn Monroe wore her suits.
Rosemarie Reed turned 50 in 1956.
She was making suits for women like herself.
Then the bikini came along, and she refused to design one.
In 1963, after a dispute over bikinis,
she left the company that carried her name.
So, at the beach, a grown woman wore a one-piece in her own dress size,
with the support built in,
and sometimes a short skirt across the front.
Try one on the way you'd try on a dress.
In the fitting room, sit down on the bench,
lean forward, then stand up again.
If the straps slip or the legs ride up,
it's the wrong suit, whatever the tag says.
One-pieces sold by dress size or bra size,
instead of small, medium, and large,
are still made today.
They do the same thing hers did.
On her birthday, before Jeanette took off that dress,
the saleswoman put a hand on her
shoulder and turned her halfway around,
away from the front panel of the mirror.
What Jeanette saw from that angle made her laugh a second time.
Number 1. The Three-Way Mirror
Picture that fitting room in Richmond. Three tall panels of glass,
hinged so a woman could see herself from the front,
the side, and the back at once.
Most of us look straight ahead, at the face we know.
Everyone else sees us from the side at the counter,
and from behind as we walk away.
After 50, she stopped dressing for the front view alone.
Every hem, every coat,
every heel on this list was checked in all three panels.
And the one she trusted most was the one that showed her back.
At home, a hand mirror held up
to the bathroom mirror does the same work.
The woman walking away was the one she dressed for.
Which of these 10 is still hanging in your closet?
And which swap are you ready to make this week?
Jeanette kept the receipt from that birthday
in her jewelry box for years.
One navy crepe dress, princess seams,
in the size she had finally stopped arguing with.