Trump lost Congress in the midterms, and the new Democratic majorities are projected to take over on January third. Harry Truman, Bill Clinton and Barack Obama all took heavy midterm losses and came back to win the next election. So why does Trump's road look so different?
What can House Democrats demand once their committee chairs can send subpoenas? Who keeps the government open when its money runs out on December eleventh? How far can one veto go, and what happens to the judges still waiting for a Senate vote?
This documentary walks through the rules, the deadlines and the history behind divided government, and what each fight could mean for your paycheck, your health premiums and your grocery bill. No shouting, no spin, just the board as it stands.
Donald Trump has lost control of Congress,
and that leaves Washington with one big question.
What happens to a president when the other party takes the House
and the Senate away from him?
History's answer surprises most people,
because presidents who suffered midterm defeats like this
have often come back stronger. Harry Truman won the next election.
Bill Clinton cruised to a second term.
And Barack Obama was re-elected two years after losing
the House in a defeat he called a shellacking.
I'm not recommending for every future president
that they take a shellacking like I did last night.
Right.
But that road is closed to Trump,
because the Constitution won't let him run again.
For the next two years,
a president with no election left to win will face a Congress that
controls the money, the investigations,
and every judge he hopes to appoint.
So is this the beginning of the end of his power,
or the start of something much harder to predict?
To answer that, it helps to start with what Congress controls.
It holds three powers over
any president. The power to ask questions,
the power over money, and the power to approve the
people he picks for top jobs.
Trump holds his own set of tools to fight back, and one simple idea
ties the whole contest together.
What a president does by himself is written in pencil, and what
What Congress turns into law is written in ink.
For the last two years,
Trump worked with a Congress run by his own party,
and that Congress mostly said yes. It passed his biggest budget law,
confirmed his picks, and left most
of the Democrats' requests for answers sitting unanswered.
Starting in January, the same building can say no,
The new Congress begins its term at noon on January 3rd.
Until then, the Republican majorities
keep running both the House and the Senate,
a stretch Washington calls the lame duck session,
and that gap will matter more than it sounds.
The first power Democrats have won is the power
to ask questions, and it costs them nothing to use.
Winning the House hands every committee a
a Democratic chair, and that chair decides who gets called,
which documents get demanded,
And when the cameras start rolling until now,
a request from the party out of power
was like a knock on a locked door.
A request from a committee chair can arrive as a subpoena,
which is a legal order to hand over documents
or come in and answer questions under oath.
Robert Garcia, the Democrat expected
to lead the House Oversight Committee,
has already sent the president's circle a blunt warning to lawyer up.
His first targets are the Trump family's businesses
and its crypto-ventures.
And that trail starts with a number almost nobody expected.
According to Bloomberg, in his first 17 months back in office,
Trump, or the advisors who manage his money,
made about 28,700 stock trades.
That is more trades than all the members
of Congress made over the same months combined.
The White House says professional advisors run those accounts
and don't regularly talk
with the president about them,
and no court or agency has found that any trade broke the law.
The main federal law against conflicts of interest,
which bars officials from decisions
that help their own wallets, doesn't cover the president,
so the real test of those trades
is political rather than criminal.
The biggest question mark hangs over
a crypto company called World Liberty Financial, which
members of the Trump family helped launch and promote.
According to the Wall Street Journal,
a company tied to the ruling family of the United Arab
Emirates agreed to pay $500 million for almost half
of it four days before the inauguration.
Eric Trump signed that deal,
and months later the administration agreed to give the Emirates
access to advanced American computer chips.
No investigation has shown that one deal led to the other,
but when a foreign royal family
invests in the president's family business,
Americans have a reason to ask whether that
money shaped any decision their government made.
A similar question surrounds Binance,
the world's largest crypto exchange.
An Abu Dhabi firm used a crypto coin issued by World Liberty
to buy a $2 billion stake in Binance,
and later that year, Trump pardoned Binance's founder.
Both Binance and its founder deny any link between the two.
Hanging over all of it are the files on Jeffrey Epstein,
the financier who died in jail while
awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges.
The House voted 427 to 1 to force their release,
and the president signed the bill into law a year ago.
The Justice Department then released
more than 3 million pages,
but it held back about half of what it had collected,
citing the privacy of victims and an active investigation.
With the House in their hands,
Democrats can now demand the rest,
and the president denies any wrongdoing connected to
Epstein. But can a subpoena force anyone to talk?
Trump already knows the answer,
because the oldest defense in Washington
is to make the other side wait. In his first term,
Democrats subpoenaed Don McGahn,
his former White House lawyer, and the White House told
McGahn not to testify. The fight dragged through the courts,
and by the time McGahn sat down to
to answer their questions.
Behind closed doors, two summers had passed
and Trump had left the White House.
Congress can try to punish a witness who refuses,
but that fight runs straight into
one of Trump's own tools.
So, questions can expose and embarrass, and they can shape the
next election, but on their own they rarely remove anyone.
The power that can hurt the
White House far more is the second one,
because it reaches every American's wallet. The Constitution
puts it in a single sentence.
No money leaves the Treasury unless Congress passes a law to spend it.
Which means every federal paycheck depends on a vote.
Over the past year, the country learned that a party can use
this power to shut the government down from the minority.
Last fall, Republicans controlled the House,
the Senate, and the White House,
which should have made a shutdown almost impossible.
The government closed anyway, for 43 days,
the longest shutdown in American history.
Republicans held a majority in the Senate,
but most spending bills need 60 votes there to pass,
and that rule lets Senate Democrats block
the money in a fight over health insurance costs.
Jack Chris felt that fight in his own bank account.
He's a single father who guided
planes at Joint Base Andrews, the military airfield outside Washington,
and he kept working for weeks without a paycheck.
To keep up with the bills, he drove for DoorDash on the side,
pulled money from his retirement savings,
and took out a high-interest loan to pay his daughter's tuition.
Families far from Washington felt
the same closure at the grocery store.
Money for food assistance ran out at the start of November,
and about two-thirds of the states paid families part
of their benefits, or nothing, for weeks.
The next test arrives before the Democrats do.
The government's money runs out on December 11th,
three weeks before the new Congress begins its term.
So the outgoing Republican majority will
be the one that has to keep the lights on.
Trump has seen this kind of window before.
In his first term, his party lost the House,
but stayed in charge of Congress until January.
And in those final weeks,
he demanded more than $5 billion for a border wall.
Senate Democrats blocked the money,
Trump refused to sign any spending bill without it,
and three days before Christmas,
the government closed for 35 days.
After January, the leverage shifts
because every spending bill will need Democratic votes.
That gives them a say over the extra Obamacare tax credits
that had lowered monthly premiums
for millions of families before they expired last year.
It also gives them leverage over a new work rule
for adults on Medicaid, the government
health program for people with low incomes,
which came from the big-budget law Republicans
passed last year.
Republicans argue the extra tax credits
were a temporary measure that had grown too expensive
and that the Medicaid rule moves able-bodied adults toward jobs.
Democrats answer with an estimate
from the Congressional Budget Office, the nonpartisan
scorekeeper for Congress,
which says the budget law will leave about 10 million more Americans
without health insurance within about eight years.
Those spending fights come around every year,
but a rarer and far more dangerous one is on its way.
The debt limit is a legal cap on how
much the government can borrow,
and Congress raised it by $5 trillion last year.
Budget analysts expect the government to reach
that ceiling between late winter and midsummer
next year, and accounting moves can
then buy the Treasury several more months before any bills go
unpaid. What happens when a president
and the other party fight over that limit?
The closest call came during the Obama years,
when America came within hours of missing its bills.
After Barack Obama lost the House,
the new Republican majority refused to raise the limit
Without deep spending cuts, and the two sides argued for months,
Obama signed the final deal
on the 2nd of August, the same day
the Treasury had warned it could run out of room to pay its bills.
Three days later, Standard & Poor's took away
America's top credit rating for the first time
in history. On the next trading day,
the Dow fell about 635 points, and that's the same stock market
behind many Americans' retirement savings.
Democrats condemned that kind of standoff when
Republicans used it,
so demanding a price now would test their own words. But the borrowing
limit today is about three times higher than it was in that fight,
and whatever Democrats ask for,
Trump would face two bad choices.
He could give up policies he campaigned on,
or he could risk a crisis that might hurt both parties with voters.
The third power gets the least attention, and it may last the longest,
because it works by doing nothing at the right moment.
Every federal judge,
cabinet secretary,
and ambassador needs a yes vote from the Senate. With a projected
majority of at least 54 seats,
Democrats now decide which nominees get that vote,
And which ones are left waiting in a drawer?
Federal judges serve for life,
and they decide cases on everything from immigration to gun laws
to the limits of a president's own power.
A president who can't fill those seats loses one
of the few things he can leave behind for decades.
Republicans used the same power against Barack Obama in his final year,
when their Senate refused to hold a single hearing
for his Supreme Court pick, Merrick Garland.
If one of Trump's cabinet secretaries resigns next spring,
the replacement could wait for a vote that never gets scheduled,
An acting secretary can fill the chair in the meantime,
but federal law limits how long that
person can stay. A president can sometimes fill a job on his own
while the Senate is away,
but in 2014, the Supreme Court ruled that short breaks
of under 10 days usually don't count.
Once Democrats take the Senate in January,
Trump's nominees can sit in that drawer,
which is why Republicans want to confirm
as many judges as they can before then.
So Democrats can ask the questions,
hold the money, and freeze the nominees.
What can Trump do about it?
He has three tools, and the strongest is the veto,
his power to reject any bill Congress sends him.
To override a veto,
Congress needs about 290 votes in the House and 67 in the Senate.
Days before the election, Trump said that if Republicans lost,
he would become, in his words,
Mr. Veto, and veto everything.
History strongly favors the president who holds the veto.
Of roughly 1,500 regular vetoes in American history,
Congress has overridden about 110.
That veto reaches your shopping cart too.
This past winter, the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that the emergency law
Trump had used for many of his tariffs didn't give him that power.
He kept many of them in place under other trade laws,
and a late summer estimate from the Yale Budget Lab put
their cost at more than $1,000 a year for the average household.
If Congress passes a bill to cancel those tariffs, he can veto it.
Trump's second tool is acting without Congress,
and the wall fight showed how far that can go.
When the new Democratic House kept refusing to pay for the wall,
he declared a national emergency
and moved money from other accounts toward construction.
Congress voted to cancel the emergency,
with 12 Republican Senators joining the Democrats,
and Trump answered with the first veto of his presidency.
The House fell short of the votes to override it,
and a few months later the Supreme Court
let him spend $2.5 billion of Pentagon money on the wall.
Democrats won the vote and lost the
money. The same goes for executive orders,
which are written instructions a president
gives to the people who run the government. They work fast.
But they're written in pencil,
because the next president can erase an order on the first
afternoon in office and end an emergency with a signature.
His third tool is the Justice Department,
along with the power to pardon.
When Congress holds a witness in contempt for defying a subpoena,
the case goes to the Justice Department.
Late in the second Bush presidency,
the department declined to prosecute two White House aides
the House had held in contempt.
A president can also pardon anyone for a federal crime,
including an aide convicted of contempt of Congress.
In the same pre-election interview,
Trump reportedly signaled he would use that power
to protect his aides if Democrats came after them.
Unlike an executive order,
a pardon can't be undone by the next president,
which makes it one of the few things Trump can write in ink from here.
All of which leads to the question everyone keeps asking.
Could Democrats remove Trump from office?
The short answer is almost certainly not.
Impeachment works like a formal charge,
and it takes a simple majority in the House,
where Democrats are projected to hold more than 250 seats.
Removing a president is far harder,
because it takes 67 votes in the Senate,
and Democrats are expected to hold around 54.
Trump has been impeached twice already,
and both times the Senate voted not to remove him.
Hakeem Jeffries, the top Democrat in the House,
says Democrats haven't ruled anything
in and haven't ruled anything out.
The one impeachment push on the horizon comes from a Republican,
Thomas Massie of Kentucky,
and it targets the Secretary of Defense,
Pete Hegseth, rather than the President.
So if removal is off the table, what decides how this ends?
The answer goes back to Truman,
Clinton and Obama, the presidents
who bounced back after losing Congress. Each of them had
one more election to win,
and a hostile Congress made the perfect opponent to run against.
Trump has no election left to win.
The 22nd Amendment limits a president to two terms,
and Trump has said it's pretty clear he isn't allowed to run.
The closer match is George W.
Bush, who lost both the House and the Senate in his second term,
in the middle of the Iraq
War, Democrats sent Bush a war funding bill
with a deadline to bring the troops home.
He vetoed it, the override failed,
and within weeks Congress sent him the money, without
the deadline.
Bush won that fight, but two years later
his party lost the White House, in an election
shaped by the war and a financial crash.
The same kind of pressure is already building around Trump,
because every Republican who
wants the job next will need a record of their own.
As that race heats up, their attention will drift
a little further from the President
History carries a warning for Democrats, too.
When Republicans pushed to impeach Bill Clinton,
his party gained House seats in the midterm,
something a president's party hadn't
managed since the Great Depression.
The speaker who led the charge,
Newt Gingrich, stepped down within days.
That's the danger Republicans are pointing to now.
They warn that Democrats will spend two years on investigations
instead of lowering prices,
and some Democrats share that worry.
One of them is Adam Hamilton,
the new senator-elect from Kansas,
a state that hadn't sent a Democrat to the Senate in nearly a century.
He told a Kansas City television station that his primary interest
is not spending the next two years in investigations and trials.
After January, the president faces months
of hearings into his family's money
and a hard fight over the government's budget.
He also faces a borrowing limit coming due
and a Senate that can freeze his picks,
all without another campaign to rally his voters.
Democrats can't remove Trump
or overturn his veto without Republican help.
But Trump can't pass any new law without Democrats,
so most of what he does from here
will be written in pencil.
His pardons and any judges confirmed before January are the rare
exceptions, because neither can be undone by the next president.
That's the real answer to what
happens next. Losing Congress doesn't take away Trump's power to act.
It takes away his power to
make what he does outlast him.
Three moments will show how fast that happens.
The first is December 11th,
when the old Congress either pays for the government
or lets it close.
The second is January 3rd,
when the new Congress takes office
and Democratic chairs can start signing subpoenas
once their committees are set up.
The third is the first veto after that,
because the vote that follows
will show how many Republicans
are willing to stand with the president.
In last year's record shutdown,
An air traffic controller outside the Capitol kept
the planes moving on borrowed money.
For two years, Trump's plans could become law.
And starting in January, almost everything he writes will be in pencil.