Malcolm Gladwell Has A Challenge For America

World 360
1 follower
Why can’t America stop gun violence? #1 New York Times bestselling author Malcolm Gladwell joins Katy Tur for a thought-provoking conversation at 92NY, challenging what we think we know about gun violence, gun reform, and why efforts to solve the crisis have fallen short.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello and welcome to the 92nd Street Y on MSNBC.
I'm Nicole Wallace. Tonight, our own Katie Tur
sits down with Malcolm Gladwell,
the number one New York Times bestselling author,
to talk about one of America's most urgent crises,
gun violence. In his new book,
The American Way of Killing, Gladwell looks beyond the usual debates,
turning instead to other countries
and our own past for lessons about what actually works.
So here are Katie Tur and Malcolm
Gladwell at 92NY in New York City.
Hello everyone. It's good to see you all
in this newly renovated hall. Welcome.
Welcome.
Malcolm Gladwell is with us obviously.
This is your 45th thousandth time here? How many times
you've been here? I think it's 41. 41.
I'm still trailing Elie Wiesel. That's my,
he's my only one ahead of me.
So how many more books do you have to write to get there?
He's in 100.
He's over 100.
I'll get there, but I'll be 85.
I'm 35.
I'm really, I'm so honored that I was asked to do this with you
because I've been a fan
of yours forever, as everybody is.
Thank you.
I have to admit, when I first read the title
of the book we'd be talking about, The American
Way of Killing, I did get a pit in my stomach because,
as I'm sure you all do, thinking
about gun violence is difficult, it's emotional.
It also feels intractable in this country.
I agree.
With the society that we have developed.
But the book was wonderful
because it no longer feels intractable to me.
This is a prescriptive book.
So I'm excited to hear about all the ways
that you're diagnosing our problem.
I do want to start with the way you opened,
which was with an ER doctor who had lost,
I think, 15 of his close friends,
who was on his way to teach a bunch of fourth graders.
How to apply a tourniquet.
Yeah.
It's Abdullah Pratt.
Very early on in the reporting for this book,
I went to the south side of Chicago
to the newly opened trauma center
at the University of Chicago.
And I was meeting someone else.
And then she said,
oh, you got to meet Dr. Pratt while you're here.
And I was like, okay.
So I go down and then I meet him in the basement.
This young guy, he's in his 30s,
grew up on the south side.
He went to med school and decides to practice
as an ER doctor in the same neighborhood he grew up in,
which happens to be one of the most dangerous neighborhoods in America.
And like I said, one of the first things I asked him was,
well, how many people that you knew from growing up have you lost?
And he said 15, but before he said it,
he's like, do you mean that are in my phone,
like people I would regularly text with?
Because if it's just people I knew, it's in the 30s.
It was 15, including his brother, by the way,
who was killed while trying to break up a crime.
Thank you for your time.
And if you can imagine going to 15 funerals before
the age of 30 of close friends.
And he's in this position where on more than one occasion, someone has
been brought into the ER, you know, some Friday or Saturday night.
Suffering from a gunshot wound.
And it's someone he grew up with.
And sometimes those people don't make it.
And he has to inform the family.
It's someone he's known.
And he was talking about this weird thing that happens
because they see you and they're like, Abdallah.
Their first thought is, hey, it's good to see you.
And then they don't realize their son is dead.
At least to say, actually.
I mean, it's just like, I just thought that.
And he was telling me about this program he has in place.
He was on his way that day.
To an elementary school to teach the kids how to be first responders.
If somebody you know has been shot and the ambulance isn't there yet,
what should you do?
And the reason he was doing it is that he would ask,
he goes and talks to people in the community all the time.
And he said, in this particular school, when he asked the kids,
raise your hand if someone you know has been shot.
He said, all the hands in the room go up.
So he was like, well, sounds like they need...
These are a bunch of eight, nine-year-olds?
Yeah.
But I think there's this thing that's happened in this country
where the experience of people in those communities
is so different from the kind
of regular middle-class American experience.
That's one of the reasons for this
disconnect that I write about in the book,
that the reality of gun violence and the way we talk about gun violence
have diverged dramatically.
And it's because we don't...
I don't know anyone who's lost 15 friends.
To gun violence, right?
And so I have my own kind of, or people like me,
we have our own made-up notion of what's going on
that's disconnected from reality.
There's another scene where he...
Talks about having been to another classroom.
They give out packs full of first responder gear, gauze, et cetera.
And a girl raises her hand and says, I need another one.
And his response was, how'd you lose it already?
You've only had it for a few days.
And she says, no, I had to use it.
And she told him about how she used it.
And he said she did it exactly right.
It gives me chills just thinking about it.
Yeah, he was proud of her.
I mean, it's an odd.
I mean, one of the ironies...
I have another chapter in the book on,
I was really fascinated by the evolution of America's,
of the medical system's response to gun violence.
So one of the weird mixed blessings
of the fact that we have so much gun violence in this country
is that we have become really, really good at treating gun violence.
So no one, I talked, I have a whole chapter
about a guy called Eddie Cornwell,
who I think has treated more gunshot victims
than anyone else in history.
He was in LA and Baltimore.
He was in LA, South Central during the crack epidemic
and the big gang.
Then he goes to Baltimore.
Baltimore was a murder capital, is at Hopkins.
And then he goes to DC, to Howard.
You know, DC has its own.
So he's been in the three big hotspots
It's in the...
The three eras where gun violence was at its peak.
And he actually calculated for me how many gunshot victims.
He was like, well, you know, I work this many hours a week.
And I've been doing it for this many years.
And I've actually forgotten.
I should remember what the number was.
But the number is so high.
It's like 8,000 or maybe 13,000.
Some insane number.
But he described to me that chapter was all but.
I went to see him.
And he told me the story of his most interesting case,
which is a young man who should have died and doesn't.
Shot multiple times.
Multiple times.
And how he solved, how he came
to understand why this kid improbably lived.
But the whole thing is like, could only happen in America.
Because no one,
no other ER doctor in the world sees that many gunshot victims.
And so no other ER doctor in the world gets so expert.
I mean, the only way you get expert
at treating them is if you see a lot.
And he saw one in a million case.
Which changes his mind about some crucial aspect of,
but you only get to see a one in a million case
if you see a million cases, right?
It's this weird thing that,
it's our great, one of our great areas
of American expertise.
And there's a disconnect because we've gotten so good
at treating gun violence and saving lives.
It allows us to...
shield ourselves, basically put blinders on and say,
oh, the gun epidemic or the homicide rate
is down. Violence is not so bad any longer.
We've gotten better, but that's not the case.
So people forget this.
And this is a really, really crucial point that the homicide rate is
a function of two things,
the level of lethal violence and the ability of the medical system
to save you once you've been shot.
So I live in Hudson Valley, way upstate. If you shoot me
In any, you know...
In a relatively serious place.
It's going to take the ambulance in a good day,
I don't know, 30 minutes to get there.
And then we're an hour away from a trauma center.
So that's 90 minutes.
I'm dead.
Even a not-so-serious gunshot wound, if I go 90 minutes, I'm...
If you...
The exact same injury here,
outside the front of the 96th Street Y, I'm living.
A worse injury, frankly.
A worse...
I'm five minutes to a trauma center from here.
So the difference there is not the level of violence.
The difference is access to quality health care.
The second part of that equation, the health care part,
has gotten so much better over the last 25 years.
So someone once did a study on this,
and they estimated that if we simply held the quality of health care
constant at 1960 levels,
we would have 75,000 gunshot deaths a year in this country.
We have 15,000.
It's insane.
The doctors are making it easy for us
to pretend it's not a serious problem.
You call it the Cornwall effect based on that doctor.
You have actual numbers from Memphis, and I...
I gasped when I saw these.
I gasped multiple times when I read this book.
Between 1935 and 1985, you say,
Memphis's aggravated assault rate nearly doubled.
In that 50-year interval, the city became vastly more violent.
But all the extra violence resulted in far, far, far fewer homicides
on a per capita basis.
Is this because between 1935 and 1985,
the residents of Memphis became an expert with handguns
and clumsy with their fists?
It's because the doctors got better, you argue.
So the numbers are misleading.
And what does that allow us to do?
To shrug, not take it as seriously as we should.
I mean, we're hiding.
We could pat ourselves on the back,
but the doctors are allowing us to kind of turn away.
You said that we're having a dishonest conversation about guns.
Do you want to start with...
There's many ways to start.
Let's start with which guns are most deadly.
And I actually got an email about this
from an advocacy group ahead of this conversation
who was taking issue with your...
Yeah, they're not happy about this.
...writing about assault rifles.
Yeah.
Because you say the problem is not assault rifles.
You say it's handguns.
They've been lying for a while.
All right.
And it makes me angry
that they have chosen
such a deliberately dishonest strategy.
Assault rifle bans don't ban assault rifles.
If you're at all curious about this fact,
you should read, just go online,
pull up the latest Senate bill to ban assault rifles,
just read to the end,
particularly get to the appendix
where they list all the semi-automatic,
highly lethal rifles not banned by this ban.
And that lists probably a couple hundred rifles.
It goes on for pages.
And then when you actually read,
what are they defining, what are they banning in the bill?
Well, an assault rifle is a platform.
It's a...
It's been developed for the military.
It's relatively light, smaller caliber bullet,
but it's no different from any other semi-automatic rifle, right?
Except in one respect, that it's modular.
You can add all kinds of, you can go on the internet
and you can buy all kinds of things that you can like click in.
You can change the stock.
You can change the grip.
You can put on a scary looking grenade holder on the end.
You can put in a really cool looking sight.
You can do all these things to customize it.
What assault rifle bans do
is ban the number and variety of cosmetic attachments
that you can buy on the internet for your assault rifle.
That's all they do.
And all of these gun control groups go around saying,
we won a great victory.
If we win this one, we're really going to make a difference.
No, it's a total lie.
You're not banning anything,
and you're pretending to do so so you can raise money.
So you say the 35 mass shootings that have happened
since the lifting of the ban would still have happened?
It's nonsense.
By the way, if you look at mass shootings,
more people are killed by handguns during mass shootings
than assault rifles.
I mean, like, the whole thing is fiction.
It is like...
It is a classic example of a dishonest conversation.
Rather than have a serious conversation
about what might make a difference
with gun violence in this country,
they have chosen a completely trivial side issue
that does nothing to address the underlying issue,
and they've lied about it in order to raise money.
So why are handguns more deadly than assault rifles?
Think about it.
So I go in...
First of all, mass shootings are, let's be clear,
a tiny, tiny, less than 1% of the problem
in this country with homicides.
They get a lot of attention.
They get a lot of attention, but they are,
we could solve every,
if we prevented every mass shooting
in this country for all time,
it would make no appreciable difference
in the number of people being killed
by guns in this country.
The problem is like this,
and mass shootings are this.
But let's just go with this.
What happens in a mass shooting
is the killer typically comes in
with multiple guns,
And the rifle, if you get hit by a rifle shot,
it's incredibly lethal, right?
Because the bullet comes out a lot faster,
it's a larger caliber.
But with a rifle, because you're firing from far away,
your aim is not as accurate.
And also, because the rifle will put you down,
you're more likely to be hit just once.
With a handgun...
And also, I can see you coming, if you have a rifle, right?
With a handgun, I can see you coming.
You get really close to me.
You don't miss.
And you tend to shoot.
And I'll shoot you more than once, because I'm standing over you.
Boom, boom, boom, boom, boom.
That's what kills you.
I mean, this is an incredibly macabre conversation to be having.
But it's like, it's an example of how we just had this notion that,
oh, mass shootings are about assault rifles.
Well, actually, no.
You just have to look at the list.
And people have compiled very, very detailed analyses
of who gets killed how during a mass shooting,
and it's handguns.
So the problem is the guns, period.
It's guns.
End of the story.
It shouldn't just be assault rifles.
We should be looking at banning guns.
Guns.
Like, why are we engaging in these incredibly bizarre,
convoluted distinctions between lethal weapons?
Like, it's...
It's like, it's just a waste of time.
The issue is guns.
The reason we don't ban guns is the Second Amendment
and the way the Second Amendment
is worded and interpreted by the Supreme Court
is that everybody has a right to a handgun
or multiple handguns or assault weapons,
as many as they want, wherever they want to have
them.
You take issue with that.
You say that they read the Second Amendment wrong,
they didn't take the time to understand the grammar,
they didn't take the time to understand the context
when it was written, and that they knew it, willfully.
Whether they knew it.
is the court appears to do a whole lot of things
without realizing how dumb they are.
So I may be jumping to a conclusion there.
But yeah, they...
So what's...
Should I read the Second Amendment?
So we have...
Yeah, let's read the Second Amendment.
All right, unless you know it by heart.
You read it.
Okay.
A well-regulated militia,
being necessary to the security of a free state,
the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.
You left out the commas, which are crucial.
Sorry, excuse me.
A well-regulated militia, comma,
being necessary to the security of a free state, comma,
the right of the people to keep and bear arms,
comma, shall not be infringed.
I'm so happy I wrote that down correctly with the commas.
First of all, what does that mean?
Nobody knows, because we don't talk that way anymore.
It was written in 1780.
It starts with what linguists call an initial being clause,
a well-regulated militia being necessary
to the defense of a free state.
Right? We don't use initial being clauses anymore.
No.
There are something, there's these things
that linguists use called linguistic corpora,
which are these, basically Google, but for, you know,
dusty manuscripts that you can only find in academic libraries
that go back to the 18th century.
So we have, or earlier, we have these digital compendiums
of the way everybody has written sentences going back a thousand years.
And you can, so you can do analysis, okay,
who was using an initial being clause in that particular way?
In the 18th century, James Madison
was the author of the Second Amendment.
So then you look, when James Madison used an initial being clause,
how did he intend to use it?
He tended to use it in one very clear way,
to directly modify the primary clause of the sentence.
So when he says, when he writes, a well-regulated
militia being necessary to the defense of a free state,
the right of the people to bear arms should not be infringed.
What he means is, because we need militias,
You have a right to bear arms, right?
You have a right to bear arms in the context of militias.
So point number one,
unless you understand the particular linguistic norms
of educated 18th century writers like James Madison,
you don't understand that he means
for that initial being clause
to condition the primary clause.
Because gun rights people will say,
oh, he's just clearing his throat.
This has nothing to do with militias.
This is just about the right of the people to bear arms.
Thank you.
We talked about doctors being too good and the
crime stats being misleading, and it allows
us to put blinders on and to say things are getting better
when they are actually not.
There's also a misdiagnosis you write about
What leads to gun violence?
We think that it's what we see on television
in crime dramas, Law & Order,
that these are people who are plotting a murder.
They're thinking it through and they're grabbing a gun
or at the very least they're driving around in a car
and they want to rob someone and they have a gun
and it's instrumental violence.
You say that's not actually the driver
of all of the gun violence in this country.
It is on law and order.
I made a...
My old assistant watched an entire season of Law & Order
and created a spreadsheet of all of the murders on Law & Order.
And murders on Law & Order bear absolutely no relationship
to murders in real life.
It's astonishing.
They have to go out of their way to come up with ways
of people killing each other that have never actually happened
in the real world.
No, a murder in the real world is not somebody plotting
to kill their neighbor because they want to take over
their rent-regulated apartment, which is an actual plot line
Of a Law & Order episode.
How good was the apartment?
Really nice.
Nice.
No, in real life, what is homicide?
Homicide, with some exceptions,
it's people who know each other really well,
Uh...
who have a grievance with each other,
resolving that grievance with the use of force.
Yeah.
You know, you and I are both 18 years old.
We're both young men.
And then...
We have a fight over a girl.
It gets out of control.
I shoot you, then you shoot.
Uh, then your friend shoots me,
and then my friend shoots your brother, and that's what it is.
It's these cycles of revenge and retaliation.
It, by the way, has always been this. We went, I went
back, did this really fun thing in the book,
where I went back and just read through, I started with
late 19th century, just for fun, I just picked at random.
I started reading the newspapers of Chicago in the late 19th century
to see what was a homicide in Chicago in 1890.
It's gross.
It's exactly the same thing as a homicide today.
Two people have an argument, gets out of control,
one person shoots someone else.
Then I went back and looked at homicides in medieval England.
What are those?
Two young men get into an argument.
Somebody was throwing up guns.
Someone clocks someone over the head with like a mallet.
It's just young people having arguments.
So are we more violent?
Are we angrier?
Do we interact worse than people in other countries?
No, but they settle their arguments with fists
and we settle our arguments with guns.
It's hard to kill somebody with your fist.
It's quite easy with a gun.
If you settle your arguments with guns,
you're going to have a really high homicide rate.
That is the simplest, the one sentence explanation
for why we have a gun violence epidemic, or
a homicide epidemic in this country,
is that we settle our, our young men settle their
arguments with guns, not fists.
So people don't kill people.
Guns kill people.
So here it gets complicated, yes.
But also, my problem with, you know,
people on the left love to make fun of the statement,
guns don't kill people, people do.
And I would say there's some truth in that,
and that is the most successful homicide prevention
programs in this country are all
those that focus on the person, not the gun.
So you can't get rid of the gun.
This is the only thing.
When you talk to people who do homicide prevention on the ground,
they don't talk about gun control.
Not because they're opposed to it, but they're like,
when's that going to happen, right?
If that happens 50 years from now,
how does that help me now if I'm doing work in St. Louis or Detroit?
Because realistically, it's not happening anytime soon.
In fact, we're going backwards.
The court just struck down.
In New York State, we had, for 100 years, had what was hands down
the most effective anti-handgun law in the country.
Right?
What did the court do?
The court...
Threw it out.
That sounds like...
But what was crazy to me about that,
and this is the law that says that you can't have a gun,
you can't conceal a gun,
or you can't have a gun in New York City.
You just can't have one.
You have to have a special permit to get one.
And they're hard to get.
And they're really hard to get.
They just struck it down,
which means that you can't have a gun in New York City.
And it goes back to a murder...
When was it?
The early 1900s?
Early 1900s.
And it was a writer who was killed.
And the...
The state legislature,
a prominent writer was shot dead by a crazy guy in Gramercy Park
with a handgun 100 years ago,
and the city and the state were so appalled,
they passed a law that said, if you want to have a handgun,
you've got to have a really, really, really good reason,
and it's going to be hard to get.
That law was on the books for 100 years,
and there was some very powerful evidence
that it is one of the main reasons
why the suicide rate
Death rate in New York State
was so much lower than everywhere else in the country.
We had a, for many years,
New York State would have a suicide death rate that was half.
The rest of the country.
And that's because it's really hard.
The most efficient way to kill yourself is with a handgun.
And we don't have handguns lying around in the same way.
So, okay, what do we do about it?
One of the arguments that you make in the book
is not one that would have been popular
with the Democratic Party a few years ago.
And this is to add more cops.
Maybe not popular still with the Democratic Party
or some corners of the Democratic Party.
Why do you say more cops?
Because no country in the Western world
is more under policed than the United States.
It's astonishing.
So all you have to do is, there's two people you should talk to.
One is any American police chief.
And you say, when you go
to international police conferences, as they all do,
what do you guys talk about?
And they'll all say, oh, all the Europeans come up
and say, how do you guys do it?
Are you crazy?
Why don't you have more cops?
We don't have any cops in this country.
We think we do.
We're totally and completely wrong.
L.A., I use the example of L.A. and Berlin, which are the same size.
L.A. has 8,500 police officers.
Berlin has 18,000, twice as many.
The typical European city has twice
as many cops as its American counterparts.
And you would think that Berlin has fewer cops.
Everyone thinks that.
No, they have, it's, actually, now that I realize this,
I think back, I've been to Berlin
many times, and I realize, actually, no, you see them everywhere.
They have more cops.
And then you, so then you ask, so I talked to this guy,
Daniel Oates, this really wonderful
guy who's a very progressive police chief
who's been a big city police chief in this
country.
And I'm like, okay,
if I gave you European levels of cops, what would you do?
He was like, oh, my God.
And he talked for 40 minutes straight.
He clearly had never been asked this question before.
And he's been in law enforcement for like 40 years.
He's been waiting 40 years for someone to ask him this question.
So you have 40 years of like waiting, waiting, waiting.
Finally, Malcolm comes along and says,
so if I gave you twice as many, what would you do?
He goes, oh, my God.
He starts laughing.
And he goes, he starts talking about, I'd.
I could finally engage with the community
in a way I've always wanted to do
but never had the people to do it.
I'd find out about problems before they bubbled up.
I'd liaison with the schools to find out,
because the kids,
you learn about a troubled kid in the school first,
and then the kid starts doing crimes in the community.
So you've got to know,
have your undergrounds in the school.
I don't have the people to do that.
On a Saturday night, I could get to a,
as a fight breaks out in a bar.
I can get there in five minutes instead of 15 minutes.
And that means that's the difference
between someone being shot and someone not being shot.
He just goes on and on and on
all the things he can't do,
what he wishes he could do
and which his European counterparts can do, right?
Because they have the resources.
They know, they have big,
they have a big like chart
and they map out their response times on a Thursday
or they map out, it's a map of the city
and they'll say,
I can get here in five minutes,
but this part of the city, I just don't have the people.
What is accurate is that our police are more violent
and aggressive than other countries.
But the violence and aggression of American police
is a response to the fact that there's
too few of them, not that there's too many of them.
So the defund the police movement came
from what was a well-intentioned place.
They saw what happened with George Floyd.
There has been a history of violence, especially against people
of color, by the police, and it was a feeling of enough is enough.
These guys, these people that are working
in law enforcement, they're not on our side,
they're not here to protect us, they're here to harm us.
And so the reaction to that was to say we need fewer of them,
we need more social workers,
we need more people who are trained in de-escalation.
Why is that not the solution?
That is the solution.
I think you've got to do both.
So I've been recently doing all this work
on Baltimore to explain why Baltimore's had
I almost had this extraordinary drop in
Homicide over the last three years and they're pursuing the strategy.
It's called focused deterrence
Which is the the gold standard for reducing homicide
and if you look at what focus deterrence is it is exactly that it's
You have police officers team up with social workers,
conflict resolution people,
people who know the community, pastors, all this.
And you create teams of people
and you identify those who are most at risk for gun violence
and you go and see them,
talk them through their problems
and get them out of harm's way and all.
But it's not either or.
You have to solve, what we do in this country,
so European countries and American countries
Spend exactly the same share of their...
GDP on public safety, exactly the same.
But in Europe, they spend this much on cops
and this other community stuff
and this much on prisons.
We spend this much on prisons
and this much on police.
The problem is we're spending all our money on prisons.
So we have this sort of false scarcity.
We're like, well, we can't do more cops.
We want to hire these other people.
I don't know where the money's come from.
Maybe we'll take it out of the police budget.
No, don't take it out of the police budget.
Are you crazy?
Take it out of the prison budget.
Why is it that...
Once you explain this to people, it makes perfect sense.
Who in their right mind, what rational person on the face of the earth
would rather spend more money on prisons than cops
as opposed to the other way around, right?
In Europe, they'd spend their money
on preventing crimes from happening,
not on locking up people after they've committed a crime.
We somehow are like, let's impoverish.
the police and the community so that we have lots of crimes
and then just spend all our money
locking them up forever. Do you think the police are more violent
because they're just more stressed?
Yes, a hundred percent.
In fact there's a really brilliant work done by these two
Harvard sociologists where they do an international comparison
of first they measure levels of police
aggression and brutality police violence across the entire world
And then they do per capita police staffing across the entire world.
What do you find when you do this?
That all the most violent police forces
are in the countries where the police are least numerous,
and the best behaved police are in the countries where
the police are most numerous.
If this data exists, why is it not adopted by politicians here?
That's a good question.
Because we are walking around in a fantasy
thinking we have too many police officers.
Go to Europe.
Just, like, ask them.
Go walk into a station house in Europe.
Look around.
Well, they say those officers aren't armed.
I mean, they don't need to be armed.
I mean, the fundamental notion here is that
we convinced ourselves
that something like homicide cannot be prevented.
So once you have convinced yourself of that falsehood,
then the only thing you can do is spend money on prisons.
All you can do is say, well, let's just lock them up forever.
That's the only thing you can do.
That happens to be completely at odds
with a considerable body of evidence
that says there are things you can do to prevent homicide.
What about counseling, community resources, teachers?
You have a great story about a counselor named Tony D
and his Becoming a Man class.
Yeah.
So this is a program in Chicago that's...
has been shown to be remarkably effective
in reducing levels of gun violence among kids.
And it's just a conflict resolution class.
It's a class for teenage boys to teach them
how to resolve conflicts peaceably.
It just says, look, the kinds of things that a
kid in a middle class community would learn as a matter of course.
are hard to learn in a disadvantaged neighborhood.
These are unforgiving places
where you don't have a chance to kind of,
you don't get forgiven if you screw up.
You don't have, you're not surrounded by mentors
who are able to help you through troubled times.
So this is just a class that teaches kids
that there are more than,
that there are ways to resolve conflicts without violence.
And what you do when you give kids this class
for a year, it's quite intensive.
And then when you follow them five, six years out,
you discover they have far lower levels of criminal violence.
That's one of a number of programs
that have been shown to be very effective
that are alternatives to the kind of lock-them-up approach we have.
Because the argument is you teach them
that their decisions have consequences.
Yeah, and you teach them there's more than one way
to resolve an argument.
If the problem's young men having arguments,
you've got to address the young men having arguments, right?
So in Baltimore, what they're doing is a...
A version of that further down the line
where they're using, the police use their kind of intelligence
to figure out, a shooting happens.
You shot me.
So then the police go in and they figure out,
well, what's the social circle around us?
We know that homicides are overwhelmingly about
feuds between social circles.
Who are your best friends?
Or who are my best friends?
I'm the one who got shot.
Who are my best friends?
Who's grieving?
Who's looking for revenge?
Let's look at the social media of my best friend.
Because it turns out that in a lot of these areas,
kids will tell you who they want to shoot on social media, right?
Let's read Malcolm's Twitter or Malcolm's friend's Twitter feed.
Or what is it?
They're not using Twitter, I'm guessing.
They're using...
Snapchat.
I don't know what they're using, but it's not what I'm using.
I've got a 14-year-old.
I think she's here.
She uses Snapchat and it disappears.
But then they go into the community.
to those people who are who they suspect
are in at risk for either shooting or being shot.
They sit down with them and they have conversations with them
and they talk to them and they say
what can we do to help you and they give them counseling
and they they if they're a lot of
these people are in circumstances where they're totally stressed out
and terrified. We forget
when I had this conversation with a guy there's
a lot of homicide prevention work.
He's been doing it for 30 years.
And he said, he was telling me
all the kind of things you learn.
He said, the number one thing you learn,
this is a guy named David Kennedy,
who's here in New York City,
brilliant man who's done more to kind of save lives
in this country than almost anyone else.
He's like, the first thing you learn is,
when you talk to these kids who are involved in this,
is that they are not predators.
That whole thing that we were taught
about them being predatory is a falsehood.
They're terrified.
They are carrying guns
because they're scared that someone's going to shoot them.
That is a very, very different problem than they are carrying guns
because they're trying
to do harm to somebody.
Let's take some questions.
Please speak to untreated mental illness
and the correlation to gun violence in America.
Yeah, I think that's part of the reason why...
All right.
Why individualized approaches to ending gun violence work so well
and why mass population approaches don't work
is precisely for reasons like this.
That what's going on, for example,
and bring it back to Baltimore,
is they have a meeting every week
and they go through every homicide
and they go around the room like,
do we know that person?
Does anyone, someone invariably does.
And it's like, well, what's going on in their family?
What's going on with them?
Did you, and they talk about each case
and then they go and see the person
or the person's brother or the person's family.
And so when you have that kind of approach,
then you are treating the whole person.
You've got somebody, like there was one case
that we reported on where in the management meeting
where some kid has lost his best friend.
His best friend's gotten shot
and they're really worried about the kid retaliating.
Why?
Because the kid has got, the kid's clearly unstable.
He's had a history of handgun violations.
He's got a list of juvenile offenses
as long as your arm.
He's probably a kid who's got untreated, all kinds of things.
They're really worried about him.
So they go and they see him.
The only way you can get to that level
is if you completely change your mindset
and get away from, I've got to lock everybody up for 30 years
and go towards, I've got to go.
Meet these people face-to-face and talk to them.
All right, so here's another one.
I think we sort of answered this,
but I think it's well put, so I'm going to read it.
You don't have to.
You can go to the next question.
I know, I went through this.
That's what I do when I, on the 41 occasions
I've been in your chair.
No, no, no, hold on, hold on.
I've gone through them, but this one has,
they invoke the tipping point, so I want to do it.
What would the tipping point have to be
for our government to take this issue seriously?
Nothing appears to have changed since Sandy Hook or Uvalde.
Is it possible to have effective legislation?
No.
Why do you say that?
I mean, the one we would have,
if we had sat down
and with a bunch of really creative people
and said what would have,
what event would have to happen in America
to create a tipping point
around our approaches to gun violence,
we would have come up with Sandy Hook.
Yeah.
Right?
We had it.
That was it.
And I remember someone was telling me
that they had talked to Obama after Sandy Hook.
And that was his thing.
He was like, I thought this was it.
This is finally.
And, you know, people got upset and it all went away.
So if that doesn't work, I don't know what you do.
I don't think that's the, there is,
this isn't one where there's a tipping point.
I think this is the one where.
A hundred different jurisdictions on their own
have got to very quietly set out
to kind of do the kind of things
that we've been talking about,
the Baltimore or the Chicago.
So it's the, our best hope is the adding cops.
It's the counseling.
It's the counseling.
It's the intervention before it gets too far.
It's the personal interventions.
Because the guns are here to stay.
It's...
Well, the one thing we could do that would help is to stop putting so
much money into prisons and start putting money into everything else.
So unless you address, the problem is that, particularly now,
it's not like there's a lot of money floating around.
The money's got to come from somewhere.
I'm still stuck on the cops thing because
that seems like the easiest solution.
And it seems like it's the one that if there
were more education about it, more conversation about it,
Um...
It would not be so politically difficult for both parties to embrace.
If it wasn't about the Derek Chauvins,
but more about the community resource workers
that we see throughout this city.
Yeah.
Yeah, that's probably, I mean, if I had to list what is the likeliest,
what is the best place to start, it would be...
It's informing people about the fact
that we're way overspending in one corner
and underspending in another.
And I'm open to, you know, you don't have to just add police officers,
but you have to add resources
to the general practice of homicide prevention.
And you can interpret that however you want to interpret it.
Like in Baltimore, they have these management meetings
and this group of people around a room.
And it's cops, but it's pastors.
It's what they call trusted community voices.
It's social workers.
It's just people who are interested, right?
And you can mix, you can divide that up however you wish.
The point is that you have a large group
that's dedicated to the problem of preventing gun violence
and they don't want to arrest anyone.
Like the arrest thing.
In Baltimore, when Baltimore was the murder capital of America,
Baltimore is a city of 600,000 people.
When they were the murder capital of America,
they arrested 100,000 people a year, okay?
They have cut their homicide rate from 300 to,
like I said, it might be under 100 this year.
They are on track for 17,000 arrests this year.
The less they arrest people,
the more their homicide rate falls.
Arresting is the...
This notion that you have to change your conception
of what a police officer does.
And this is one of the reasons I got so mad
at some of the defund police people.
One of the arguments they made about
why we have too many police
was that they looked at arrest statistics
and they said that many cops
are not arresting anyone at all.
So why do we need them?
You don't want them to arrest people.
Have you ever walked around with a police officer
and watched what they're doing
when they're doing their job well?
When a police officer does his or her job well,
they are not arresting people.
They're trying to avoid having to arrest people.
This is like, it just like...
The degree to which this conversation is just so nuts.
Like, sit down and talk to people
who are actually engaged in this work.
And you'll figure out that what you want
is something very different from what you're asking for.
Are we still able to talk to people though?
I mean, we get so much of our information on phones.
We are, our algorithm sends us the stuff that it thinks that we want.
It's obviously the most provocative.
The stuff that's going to get a reaction from us.
Usually it's fear, it's anger, desire.
And it's very difficult to have a nuanced conversation
or even a conversation that goes past 30 seconds
when we are not, we're not just,
we're not set up for it any longer.
We're so attuned to our anger
and we've lost the ability to look somebody in the eye
and to hear them out.
Yeah, yeah, sort of.
I'm not as much of a pessimist on that.
I sort of feel like
To the extent that this issue will be solved,
it's not going to be solved
through discussions on social media.
But I do think that there is a,
I do have a sense that there is a growing frustration
among many kind of normal Americans
with the way these conversations have happened.
And there's a lot of normal Americans.
So you're hopeful?
Yeah, there's way more normal Americans than we think.
You know, we just listen to the crazy people too much.
Well, I'm happy that all of the normal Americans in New York City
showed up for this conversation today.
I enjoyed the book very much.
I thought it was informative, prescriptive,
and it made me feel like we can do something about this.
We have the agency.
We can make it better as long
as we stop being dishonest with ourselves.
Thank you, Katie.
Thank you, Malcolm.
Thanks for watching the 92nd Street Y on MSNOW.
To learn more about their upcoming
events in New York City,
scan the QR code on your screen or visit their website.
We'll bring you more from 92NY each month, right here on MSNOW.
It's Rachel. I am so glad to see you at the end of that clip
because this is where I get to tell
you about a new way to watch all our clips
and all of our shows and everything on MS Now on your
phone or your tablet or your laptop.
You can watch things live or recorded. Plus, you can ask me and
all the other hosts and reporters questions in our weekly live chats.
You can go to ms.now
/membership or just click below. Thanks.
