There is a debate about who wields power in America that's taking place among the activists of Occupy Wall Street, historians, economists, experts, and journalists. They are defining a new debate about Who Rules America. In the opening episode of the series, we asked David Degraw, the Occupy activist who coined the phrase The 99% versus the 1% where entrenched power can be challenged. Speaking to us at the movement's giant May Day Rally, he said, "Occupy shows that people are not suffering alone, their coming out, raising awareness - we changed the national discourse." And yet they are, increasingly coming up against a wealthy elite, that professor Stanley Aronowitz told us, "is, generally speaking, unresponsive to the people, unresponsive to democratic liberties, and democratic procedures." Is it a conspiracy? The Canadian economist Leo Panich rejects the ideas telling us, "I don't think there's an external force controlling the American state. The American state is capitalist to it's core in the very way it’s organized." Political analyst Chip Berlet agrees, "the people who have the wealth are not a conspiracy, we know who they are, we know how they collect this money, they take it out of our pocket, they put it in theirs and it's not a big mystery." And yet ordinary people like Erin Crowell, a waitress and student in a small town in Wisconsin is losing hope, "I think the dream has shifted to hopefully I wake up tomorrow and I'm able to pay my rent and keep a roof over my head." This first episode introduces the key ideas in a debate at the heart of a renewed struggle for democracy that is up against a permanent establishment, no matter who is in power.
Documentary Central is the home for compelling documentaries tackling subjects like history, climate change, wildlife, conspiracy and more. Subscribe so you don't miss out
Who Rules America? | S1E01 | The Debate Over Power
Your support fuels our exploration! Help us uncover new stories and share diverse voices by donating to our channel through Super Thanks!
**This film is under non-exclusive license from Sideways. All rights reserved.
All of the content on this channel is UNDER LEGAL LICENSE (We have written contracts) from various copyright holders and distributors. We ask you to please contact us if you believe there are any copyright issues via - [email protected] Documentary Central is owned and operated by VA Media Ltd. All rights reserved.
0:00 Wall Street: Money Capital of America 1:06 Elections, Ads and the Horse Race 3:40 Who Really Rules America? 4:06 The Power Elite Explained 8:21 Working-Class Voices on Power 10:17 Capitalism and the State 11:22 Big Oil and Corporate Influence 13:21 Media and War Propaganda 18:54 Occupy Wall Street 20:18 The Vanishing American Dream
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome to Wall Street, the epicenter of financial power in America,
perhaps the money capital of the world.
The globally oriented financial firms based here
in the New York Stock Exchange that operates here have extraordinary
influence on the politics and policies of this country.
No one has elected them
and in fact these financial firms are trying to undo the regulations
and new laws governing them imposed by the Congress.
The people on Wall Street are just one of a number of unelected
and very powerful forces that operate in the shadows behind the scenes.
They're the media forces. They're the military and industrial forces.
They're the corporate forces.
And they're the forces that we'll
be investigating in this television series.
Which asks a question that most of our media does not.
Who rules America?
Every four years, Americans go to the polls to elect a president.
It's a ritual that goes back to the founding of the nation in 1776.
Our economy seemingly on the brink of collapse.
High unemployment.
Every four years, politics
and politicians dominate our television screens,
dominate our news, and dominate our national discourse.
I'm Ron Paul, and I approve this message.
One independent watchdog's called this president...
President Barack Obama is running for re-election.
Mitt Romney stood with Big Oil for their tax breaks,
attacking higher mileage standards and renewables.
He is attacking and being attacked by Republicans.
He said he would turn this economy around in three years,
or he'd be looking at a one-term proposition.
We're here to collect, all right?
The two parties may be fighting a political war,
but pundits label it a horse race,
fueled literally by billions of dollars
in campaign contributions used for pervasive advertising.
Welcome to a place where one president's
failed policies really hit home, Avil.
The focus is on political personalities, not the forces they represent.
A large industry of commentators
and pollsters are paid to tell us who's ahead and who's behind.
The focus invariably is on the candidates, not the issues.
But everyone knows the campaigns are run behind the scenes
by professional strategists, media experts, and political advisors.
Then there's going to be a one-term proposition.
The political ads are cynical and slick.
Almost every word is scripted, symbols trump substance,
slogans are market tested, aimed
at promoting perception and reinforcing prejudices.
Better World Nation.
Marketing is the mission, selling is not telling.
On one level, this whole spectacle is presented
as a triumph of democracy, as if the candidate
who wins will run the country.
But being in office doesn't necessarily mean being in power.
Americans believe they are determining their future.
Are they?
Do most know or are they ever told who rules America?
I just think that these people, you can't really see them.
Yeah?
That's what I think.
The people who rule America?
People are behind the screen.
They are behind screen.
Invisible?
To the general public.
And do you think people really know what's going on?
To some extent, yes.
And to some extent, no.
To what extent, yes?
To what extent, no?
About 50-50.
Rules America. There's no one right answer.
Pulitzer Prize winning American historian Eric Foner says it's
a question that raises many more questions about power
that works from the shadows.
Rules America. You know, there's no one single easily defined group
who rules America, but I think.
You know, not just now, but I think for a couple of generations,
we have had what the sociologist C. Wright Mills called
in the 1950s a power elite, an interlocking set of connections
of people in business, in politics, in the military.
Pretty much determine the parameters of possible change.
It's not that they rule America in a conspiratorial way.
And of course, there are elected officials,
but the leeway of those officials is constrained
by what you might call the permanent government.
Presidents come and go,
but there's a kind of permanent establishment, what, you know,
President Eisenhower called the military-industrial complex,
but now it's more a military-financial
complex, that really, you know, as I say, determines the limits.
We're at the Left Forum, a gathering of progressive intellectuals
and scholars and students held every year here in New York City.
There are 1,400 speakers this year.
They don't agree on everything,
but they do agree that America is not the democracy it claims to be.
They all want to know who rules America.
Professor Stanley Aronowitz writes about
the research of this man, C. Wright Mills,
who a half century ago wrote about the existence of a power.
Power elite that activists today refer to as the 1%,
the people who run things.
His contribution to understanding the nature of power in America
is in the first place to identify three institutional orders
that really together form the power elite,
an elite that is generally speaking unresponsive to the people,
unresponsive to democratic liberties and democratic procedures.
And he said the three groups
were the corporate capitalist institutions.
The military, and the third one was the top layer
of the political directorate, he called them,
and they are the national leaders like
the executive branch of government, not even Congress.
He said Congress was in the middle levels of power.
It doesn't really share the decision to make war,
the major economic policies and so on.
It participates at some level, but basically it's out of power.
And he said that really has undercut...
The whole pretense of progressive and representative government.
This may be why in recent surveys, only 7 to 9 percent
of the American people in both parties believe that the Congress,
the so-called people's house of government,
is representative and capable of solving the country's problems.
If politicians are trapped in a polarized
and highly partisan stalemate,
who does exercise the power to decide what the country's priorities
and policies should be?
We asked J.K. Fowler, an editor of The Mantle, a political magazine.
I think it's extremely complicated.
I think there's not one particular answer for it.
I think that a lot of the stuff going on in America right now
is being led by money,
and moneyed interest in Washington in particular.
But I think there's a bubbling movement
from the ground up as well that's happening.
Is there a ruling class in America,
or is that an outdated concept?
Nice to meet you.
Oh, I'm a strong believer that there's a class.
In particular, in New York,
We put that question
to Erin Crowell,
a 30-year-old working-class
mother from a small town in
Wisconsin, who is working two jobs while pursuing her education.
If I was to ask you, like, who runs America,
who rules America, what is your perception of that?
People that have the money to do so, you know,
people that have the money and the resources
to send a lobbyist to Washington, you know,
like nobody from my town could afford to send
a lobbyist, you know, and say, hey,
Harley Davidson is, you know, threatening to move
their plants to China unless, you know, everybody takes pay cuts.
You know, and could literally shut our town down,
you know, we can't afford to defend ourselves.
Do you feel as an American citizen that you have power,
you know, in our country?
Do you feel as if you have the ability to get your dream achieved?
I feel like it's
slipping away.
I don't think I do, you know,
because it feels like the closer and closer I would get to that,
you know, like just a dream for me is to finish college, you know,
and take care of myself and take care of my son, you know,
but even that now, you know, and I understand like most,
a lot of people in my position aren't even able to get that far now.
So if the citizens who are supposed
to be in charge don't feel they are, who does?
What we found is that by and large,
it's the wealthiest Americans who call the shots
through unelected institutions
that drive agendas in their own interests.
There may be a cabal running things,
but in the end, the state and the system merges,
argues Canadian political analyst Leo Panitch.
I don't think there's an external force controlling the American state.
The American state is capitalist to its core,
in the very way it's organized.
It doesn't do it because there's too much influence from Wall Street.
It does it because it is structurally embedded with Wall Street.
It doesn't do it because there's too much influence
from the military-industrial complex.
It does it because the military-industrial complex is inside the state,
is funded by the state, is part of the state.
Sure, there are people who conspire
and there are people who act in secret,
but capitalism is not a conspiracy.
The people who have the wealth, they're not a conspiracy.
We know who they are.
We know how they collect this money.
They take it out of our pocket,
they put it in theirs, and it's not a big mystery.
There seems to be corporate forces in addition to Wall Street
that essentially help guide our political and economic direction.
Leading are America's top corporations.
Political analyst Michael Clare has studied
the political economy of oil for 20 years
and says a lack of media coverage keeps the public in the dark.
Does the media cover it?
The media doesn't cover this for the most part.
In fact, the media is largely in league
because of the advertising dollars that the oil and gas lobby provides.
They're very heavily dependent on advertising revenue,
so they're very careful in what they say.
Who are they accountable to?
Are their laws really controlling and regulating what they do?
There are laws, but they have been written largely
by their lobbyists to favor them.
So, in fact, the laws, for the most part,
are in their favor, not in the favor of most Americans.
Is there an issue where we've seen this very clearly,
where the interests of the oil industry
or the energy industry is in conflict with the interests of Americans?
Well, I would give an example that the oil industry has been pushing
...for drilling in the deep waters of the Gulf of Mexico
and off the coast of Alaska, for example,
and they get all kinds of tax benefits
for that kind of deep water drilling,
and they were able to do so during the Bush period
with absolutely no oversight whatsoever,
hence the Deepwater Horizon disaster.
Most Americans experience the oil industry in two places,
at the gas pump where prices often rise because of speculation,
not just supply and demand, and also through TV advertising that paints
this very profitable business in the most positive of terms.
I'm still here and so is BP. We're committed to the Gulf for everyone
who loves it and everyone who calls it home.
That's good for our country's energy security and our economy.
Which brings us to another set of corporations, the media companies.
Jeff Cohn has been in the media and written books about its impact
in shaping how Americans think about their country
and its system of power.
He says media companies push propaganda for war.
It's the same exact media quoting the same exact experts
that pushed our country and the world into a war with Iraq.
And we were told by these media, oh, we're so sorry, we didn't know,
you know, we made a mistake, next time we'll be more vigilant.
But here we are next time, 10 years later, and the same media
are blowing smoke about a weapons program in Iran that doesn't exist.
There was no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.
And so we're hearing, it's like, you know, when the war drums
are beating, and I worked in mainstream television news
in this country during the run-up to the Iraq war.
When the war drums are beating,
they don't let you put on opposing views.
We tried to get opposing views that questioned the evidence,
the intelligence that would justify an attack on Iraq,
but we were kicked off the air.
And now you're finding it's a nightmare.
It's a nightmare that's happening again.
At the same time, Jeff, most people who work in major media,
and I, of course, did as well, don't believe this.
They don't buy this.
They feel like they do have the freedom.
To cover issues
and that the networks are much more diverse in their point of view
than outsiders like you and maybe now me would say.
Well, the way to rebut that...
fiction is just to look at what happened
in the wake of the Iraq invasion.
Those of us who question the evidence that they
were a weapons of mass destruction threat,
we were totally right and most of us got kicked out of the TV networks.
The people who got it wrong have promoted up.
So this idea of diversity in the mainstream media
or good journalism will win out certainly
hasn't been proven in the last 10 years where
the journalists who got it right,
...have been punished, sanctioned, or kicked out of the media.
And the journalists who got it wrong,
most of them have more power today to blow smoke at Iran
than they had even when they were blowing smoke at Iraq.
Those people, the people who own institutions,
are usually very conscious of their power,
not just as individuals, but as part of a dominant class,
says independent TV producer Brian Drolet.
So there's a lot of talk here about Democrats
and Republicans who re-vote for the Democrats,
who re-vote for the Republicans.
There's a lot of talk about, you know, the rich versus the 99%,
but it's kind of, you know,
there's a certain kind of amnesia about the structure.
...of our society that at one point in this country
at least had some currency, you know, in the 30s and even in the 60s,
you could talk about the working class.
Nobody talks about the working class.
It's all about, there's a middle class and then there's the 1%,
as if there's, and I guess then there's some...
You know, poor blacks and Latinos or something, right?
And I think that that word has been sanitized
and scrubbed out of the vocabulary of the people of the United States,
including out of the vocabulary of the left.
Now, that's not the entire left,
but even the people that use the word class
don't seem to have the ability to phrase it
in a way that actually means something to people.
To talk about class is not to talk about a conspiracy,
but a complex system that's evolved
over the years, a system that is stratified
and uses campaign contributions and lobbying
to ensure that the politicians do the bidding of the companies.
So these are the building
blocks of the analysis we'll explore
in this series on Who Rules America?
The argument is simple but hard for many Americans to comprehend
because many of us want to believe the myths we learned in school
that make us feel superior to other countries and other peoples.
This has been called American exceptionalism.
Many in America believe that God created
this country as the greatest country on earth
and that's what makes it so special.
You really have to start with that as a basis
for how the United States was founded.
Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz is one leader of America's indigenous people,
the first Americans.
They were the ones to be eliminated,
because it was their land that was wanted, not even their labor,
like in Latin America, the indigenous people were enslaved
and made into peasant peons, but in North America,
the Anglo-colonialism in Canada, US, New Zealand, and Australia had
the motive of simply wiping them out and taking their land.
It's not just that they weren't included, they were to be eliminated.
And so questions about the custodians of real power
and who rules America lead back to debates
on how to remake power,
how to challenge its distribution and make it more transparent
and accountable.
These are the issues that the Occupy Wall Street movement
is raising as it challenges
institutional power in an attempt to revive grassroots democracy.
David DeGraaf explains Occupy's Origins.
I mean, it was like such a confluence of events,
you know, everything was moving in this direction.
You know, I was looking around the world,
you know, there's protests happening in Egypt
and then it moved to, you know, the Arab Spring,
Tunisia, and all throughout Europe, it came
back and it was just a matter of time before it hit the United States.
And really, if you look, the occupations globally,
you know, they became like the thing to do.
So it's just a natural progression for it to show up here.
I feel like it shows up here because, you know,
even though wealth is so concentrated,
you know, the people have a media system where they're
so propagandized and they feel isolated.
But, you know, Occupy shows that people are,
you know, not suffering alone.
They're coming out and raising awareness
and we changed the national discourse.
The movement is up against powerful forces with large budgets
and the backing of police forces and the political establishment.
While these activists are on the front lines
of the fight for a people-ruled America,
many of its people share the same hope.
Do you have a sense of class being important in this country,
that they're being like an upper class, a working class?
Absolutely, absolutely.
Absolutely.
You know, I'm a waitress at a very nice restaurant, and it's very clear
to me, you know, what my role is and who I am, you know.
And you can tell just from the dialogue
that I have with people, you know.
Recently, I talked to a general manager
of a fairly large business in our town, and, you know,
when I mentioned that I was going to a public school, you know,
I got kind of an eye roll, and oh yeah,
my tax dollars pay for that, you know, and it's...
Do you feel like there's all
this resentment against working people, kind of feeling like
they don't deserve what little they're getting?
Absolutely, absolutely, and especially, you know,
with the recent attacks on public sector
employees, like on teachers, and,
you know, people are saying, you know...
They don't deserve those benefits.
We all don't get those benefits.
So so they don't deserve them either.
You know, we're like, why is it the conversation?
Maybe we should all work to get those for everyone
instead of taking it away from the few that do have them.
You know, when I hear you talking,
I realize there's such a bigger picture here
that most people even understand
that we have a country where
the dream is slipping away for so many people
and they don't feel particularly powerful.
They don't feel like they can do anything.
They can achieve anything.
They can make a difference.
Right.
Well, I think the dream has shifted to...
Hopefully I wake up tomorrow and I'll be able to pay my rent
and keep a roof over my head, you know, or it's just like,
you know, I'll work on achieving my dream tomorrow.
But today, you know, I have to have to go to class, you know,
and I have to, you know, I have to get my work done.
I have to go to work and I have to try to squeeze
a couple hours of sleep in and then, you know, and it's.
Now, you're here at this conference with all
these brilliant theoreticians and analysts
and professors and experts and leaders,
and how do you feel about this, this idea that
people have to get together to make a difference?
I think it's wonderful.
I am.
I feel so blessed to be able to be here with people like
that because I want to learn you know somebody had you know had said
to me well why don't you leave where you are and I don't think
that's the answer. I think that it's my job as somebody
who cares about these things to learn from these people to learn
from these brilliant minds and so I can take this back.
to people and show them
and explain to them where we don't have access to this kind of
thing every day, you know,
and so hopefully try to enlighten them a little bit.
Erin expresses the hopes of many ordinary Americans who want to reshape
the nature of power so that the 99%, not just the 1%, can rule.
But as you can see and hear,
it's not a battle she feels she is winning.
Perhaps that's why she, like many, want to know who rules America.
Coming up in the next episode of Who Rules America,
how the history of conflict between the 99%
and the 1% goes back to the American Revolution.
The degree of inequality, never before has the very, very top, the 1%,
had so much of the national income and wealth in its own hands.
Next time on Who Rules America.