Georgetown vs. Lewes: What Each Place Is Really Like to Live In

Living In America Homes
9 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 5, 2026
Curious what the small towns of Coastal Delaware are like? Check out my guide:
https://preview.mailerlite.io/forms/1...
📅 Want to talk through your own situation? Book a free, no-pressure call: https://calendly.com/jenniferallan-realtor/meeting?month=2026-11
Jennifer Allan, Delaware Realtor
302.659.9851
[email protected]
AI Generated·May contain errors
If you pull up Georgetown and Lewis on a map,
they look like they're in two different worlds.
But when you actually drive it,
you will be surprised at just how close they are.
It's funny, you could come to a four-way stop and be in Lewis.
The other corner be in Georgetown and the other corner be in Millsboro.
That is just how close
they are. This is why you will often hear me say that Georgetown,
especially some locations,
is considered West Lewis because that is just how close you are.
And there's a total difference
between Lewis, in-town Lewis, Georgetown, in-town Georgetown.
And I'm going to break down all four places
that are hiding inside of the two names.
Okay, so here is the plan.
We are going to go over what it's like to live in these four places.
Then we're going to compare in town, Lewis and Georgetown head to head.
And then I'm going to take a whom from a Georgetown address
and a Lewis address.
And we are going to compare them side by side.
And at the end, I'm going to tell you who each place is for.
But here's something I want to share.
When you search coastal Delaware or just Lewis in general,
here is what those searches are
actually missing. There are so many cute little towns within
the coastal Delaware area that I
feel like just gets completely left out.
Harveston, Georgetown, Milton, Allendale,
they all get left out when you search just Lewis
or even coastal Delaware.
And each one of those little towns has something to offer.
N
Possibly you could get more bang for your buck if you looked there.
That is why I have broken all of these places down
and you can compare them in
my coastal Delaware comparison guide that is below in the description.
So go ahead and grab that and you can
actually follow along with this video by
using the worksheet that is included
in the guide. So without further ado,
let's jump in.
Let's talk about the four places
that I told you about because there are two
different places within Georgetown
and two different places within Lois.
The Georgetown zip code covers around 119 square miles,
but the town of Georgetown is around five.
On the opposite end,
the Lewis zip code covers around 47 square miles,
and the city of Lewis is around four.
And if you were to look this up on the MLS
and look at just the Lewis address,
about one in seven of those listings
is actually going to be in the city of Lewis.
The same thing with Georgetown,
when you look up the Georgetown zip code, about one in three is
actually going to be in town Georgetown.
So for most of the homes, they're on the outskirts of
the actual zip code. This is why when you Google these towns,
it's actually kind of frustrating
because what you're seeing is, is either the city of Lewis,
which is a very, very small section,
or you're seeing the city of Georgetown,
which a lot of people see that and go, I don't want that.
This is why you'll hear me explain that the house
that you're looking at isn't in town Georgetown.
You're actually nowhere near that.
You're actually looking on the outskirts of Georgetown.
And when you look on the map,
I will tell you that these places look like they are so far apart.
But I promise you, and I've heard this time
and time again from clients,
when you actually drive through Lewis and Georgetown,
you'll realize just how close they are.
Georgetown is about 15 miles from Lewis
and Georgetown to Millsboro is around 10.
But what I'll tell you is,
is that if you're looking in places like Liberty West, which
is considered Georgetown, right across the street,
Liberty East is considered Millsboro.
And that's why I'm saying they're so, so close.
But those are on the outskirts of the places that you're looking at.
This is why I say you have in-town Lewis, the outskirts of Lewis,
in-town Georgetown, and the outskirts of Georgetown.
Four very different places with different price tags.
But if you look at the address, it will say either Lewis or Georgetown.
And let me explain what it's like to live in all four of those places.
Let's start with in-town Lewis, which is...
Like a postcard, honestly.
This is where, when you're Googling, this is what you're seeing.
You're seeing this cute little town.
You're seeing the inlet, the beach,
Cape Henlopen State Park, and also the Cape May-Lewes Ferry.
You're seeing the historic downtown, all of the cute little houses.
Because, fun fact, Lewes is the first town in Delaware
when the Dutch settled here in 1631.
And you heard me correctly, 1631.
And trust me, you can totally feel that,
especially when you're walking downtown in Lewes.
On 2nd Street, you have these little mom and pop restaurants.
You have these little shops that you can go to.
You have King's Ice Cream, which is so, so good.
And you will not find a chain restaurant in downtown Lewes,
which actually is really nice.
There's also the Canal Front Park.
In season, we have the Farmer's Markets on Saturdays.
And like I said, you also have the Cape May-Lewes Ferry Terminal,
which is minutes from downtown.
You can also walk to dinner.
Lewes in town is very, very walkable.
Or you could take your bike.
So you could take your bike to dinner.
You could take your bike to the beach.
You could also take your bike to Cape Henlopen State Park.
And it's not something that is just...
Busy in the summer. There's something going on all year long,
which is one of the reasons people
absolutely love downtown Lewes.
Now let's talk about the homes. This is where you're going to
find very historic homes that still need work.
A lot of the homes in town actually run around
a million dollars. And if you're thinking about
in town, but beachfront.
You can put a price tag of over a million dollars.
They are not small houses.
They are mansions that sit up,
that are lifted off of the ground
in case we get a nor'easter or a hurricane,
and this way they're not getting flooded out.
But they are definitely not your typical homes,
and they run anywhere from five to $10 million, if not more.
So if you are looking for that in-town feel,
you'll pay for it because it is historic, busy,
and they price it like that.
Next let's talk about in-town Georgetown.
This is the county seat. Georgetown actually took that
title from Lewes in 1791. The whole town is built around the circle.
Yes, not to be confused with a
town square, it is actually a circle in Georgetown.
You have town hall, you have all of the county and
state offices, and the courthouse is all right there within the circle.
Restaurants and shops
are close by too.
And every two years,
Georgetown hosts what's called
Return Day, which is the Thursday after the election in November.
There's a parade and
the town crier actually reads the election results.
And the winners and the losers bury
the hatchet. And yes, there are actually free roast ox sandwiches.
But in-town Georgetown
isn't all history. There's also a theater,
there's a speedway, and an aviation museum
at the airport. Every October,
there is a festival with vintage planes and cars. Delaware Tech
also has a campus here.
There's actually an old saying that is Georgetown is 16 miles from
everywhere because it is literally in the middle of Sussex County.
There's about 7,100 people that
live within the town of Georgetown.
That's almost twice as dense as Lewes. There's a mixture of
single-family homes, apartments, and multi-family homes.
Now let's talk about the outskirts of Lewes.
It is a big mixed area.
You could find restaurants.
But you could also find farmland.
You could find a wooded area.
But you could also find an open field.
To me, it's like the melting pot of Sussex County.
Because if you're on Route 1,
you can find everything you can ever think of.
But that's still considered the outskirts of Lewes.
But if you actually go farther out in Lewes,
you're going to find farmland, woods.
And different communities that are popping up what feels like weekly.
Many of these communities have been built in the last 5 to 10 years.
The communities consist of a clubhouse or a pool.
They have access to the water in some cases.
Within those communities, they are walkable.
But what I hear a lot of clients get confused
by is that they think that all of Lewes is walkable.
And unfortunately, it just isn't.
In-town Lewes is walkable.
But on the outskirts of Lewes,
you are going to have to drive to different places.
So whether that be that you're driving to your doctor's appointments
or restaurants or clubs
or the gym or even to go to the water.
So if you wanted to go to the beach,
if you wanted to go to the bay,
you're going to have to drive to those places. And honestly,
I would not recommend biking to these places
because a lot of the roads in Sussex County
do not have sidewalks.
Even if there are sidewalks, I really,
really don't trust it because it's so windy that
a car coming around the bend may
not see you even if you are on a sidewalk.
So just my personal opinion,
I do not recommend biking to any of the places that we just talked about
A lot of the homes on the out...
Outskirts of Lewes run anywhere from $540,000 to $570,000,
depending on if you're purchasing
a new construction home or a resale home,
or if you put a bunch of options in your new
construction home.
This is where a lot of clients start looking
is actually on the outskirts because it is
more affordable than in-town Lewis.
Now let's talk about the outskirts of Georgetown because to me,
this is like a hidden gem because
like I said, it's almost like West Lewis.
It's very close to Lewes, it's very close to the beaches,
but you get a little bit more
bang for your buck.
I know I mentioned this before, but let's talk about Liberty West.
Liberty West is a new construction community
and it is built by K. Hovnanian Homes.
It is not a 55 plus community,
but they do offer a lot of homes that either have ranch
style living or the primary bedroom is on the main floor
and you can still have that
second floor.
It is considered Georgetown.
But across the street at Liberty East,
which is actually a Lennar community and you share
the clubhouse with them, is considered Millsboro.
And literally just on that same road,
you also have DRB, which is Weatherby.
You have Independence, which is Shell Brothers.
You also have Riverwood, which is Shell Brothers.
And you also have Walden, which is Shell Brothers.
So literally in a 10 mile radius of that one road.
You have many many different options
and fun fact Riverwood and Walden are actually considered
Harbison. What's nice about this community
is that it's centrally located because like I said
anywhere in Georgetown is almost 16 miles from everything else
so you are out of the traffic
you don't have to deal with fighting on Route 24 to get into Lewis.
You can enjoy retirement in a community that is brand new,
or if you'd like to purchase
somewhere else on that road,
you can purchase a resale home, and you don't have to deal
with the noise, traffic, and hustle and bustle of everyday life.
Because yes, you may want to be close to restaurants,
but are you going to a restaurant every single
day?
Probably not.
New homes in Liberty West.
Start at anywhere from $530,000 to $545,000.
Now keep in mind, that is the builder's base price.
So if you put a bunch of options in it,
it may be slightly more expensive,
or you could pick another home
that maybe the base price is lower than that
because there are many different options
when it comes to new construction.
That's not just for K. Hovnanian Homes,
that's also for Lennar Homes,
that's also for Shell Brother Homes.
Okay, so let's put these towns side by side.
First, let's start off with the price.
So in town, Lewis,
you are looking at anywhere from $870,000 to a million dollars.
In town, Georgetown,
you are looking anywhere from $400,000 to $430,000.
Now let's talk about the actual homes.
In Lewis, you are looking at more
of a single family home as opposed to an apartment or
a condo or even a townhome.
In Georgetown, you can actually find a mixture.
Now, I will say with new construction,
we are seeing more single family than we are townhomes,
but you can still purchase a carriage-style home,
which is connected at the garage, actually,
and they are still an option
if you are looking at new construction in Georgetown.
Next, the pace.
In Lewis, you are able to walk to everything.
Georgetown, you're going to have to drive to most...
Things, whether that be the restaurant
or your doctor's office or even getting to the beach.
But you can walk within your neighborhood.
And let's be honest, the pace of life in Lewis,
you are busy all year round
because you have tourists coming all year round.
It doesn't matter what season.
In Georgetown, you're not going to see that as much
because you are on the outskirts,
which means there's not much going on
and you can choose to drive to those things
and enjoy those things.
Clearly, if you are a beach person,
Lewis is going to be closer to the beach
than, say, Georgetown,
but it is actually less than 20 miles
to Lewis Beach from Georgetown.
Let's put two homes side by side.
One is a Lewis address and one is a Georgetown address.
We're going to be using these same budgets, so $540,000.
The Georgetown Address is a home in Liberty West,
so it is a new construction home.
It is around 2,800 square feet,
and the builder's base price is under $540,000.
Home two is in Bay Point in Lewis.
It is a resale home that was built in 2013.
It is around 2,000 square feet, and they are asking $540,000.
So for around $5,000 more,
the Georgetown address actually gets you
800 more square feet.
It is also a brand new home.
Now, the one in Liberty West, like I said,
is the builder's base price.
So you're going to add upgrades
because everyone adds upgrades.
But the Lewis address was built in 2013.
It is a resale home and it's already finished.
So any of the upgrades that you would wanna make,
you're not having the builder do it.
You would have to do it yourself.
And you're also going to want an inspection.
Now let's talk about the bills for each property.
The property tax on each of the homes is around $1,100 for the year.
Yes, you heard me correctly for the year.
So my New Jersey and my New York clients that are watching this video.
Yes, you heard me correctly.
$1,100 for the year.
Not $28,000, not $25,000,
or any of the other astronomical numbers that people have told
me that they're paying in property taxes in the surrounding states.
Now, both of these homes are in different
school districts, but honestly, that doesn't
really change the bills.
Maybe a couple dollars.
Then there is the HOA fees.
Liberty West pays $648.
quarterly. That's around $2,600 a year.
Bay Point pays $627 every three months, and that's around
$2,500 per year, which in the grand scheme of things is about the same.
Let's compare the list
of what that includes in that association fee.
Liberty West takes care of your lawn maintenance.
Bay Point covers the clubhouse and the pool,
but does not cover your lawn care.
So in Bay Point, you actually are paying
for lawn care on top of that association fee.
So even if you don't hire it out,
you still have maintenance on your lawnmower,
you have gas to put into it, and your time is worth something.
In both cases, you're going to have a transfer tax of 4%,
usually split between buyer and seller, or buyer and builder.
So 2%, 2%.
And on a $540,000 home,
that's around $10,800 for just the transfer tax.
Not included in those numbers is insurance,
flood insurance if you carry it, and repairs
on the home.
So at the end of the day, you really need to decide,
do you want a resale home that
was built in 2013 that is basically the same amount
of money per year as a brand new home
that has a Georgetown address?
That is a decision up to you.
But when you actually break it down.
Instead of saying, oh,
Lewis is just more expensive than Georgetown, or I don't want
to live in Georgetown because what you're really researching
is the circle of Georgetown,
I really would recommend taking a few extra minutes
and actually thinking about what you're
looking at.
So who is each place right for?
Well, if you are someone that wants everything walkable
and you're willing to spend the extra money,
then in town Lewis actually may make sense for you
because like I said, you can walk to everything
and you have that historic downtown feel
with all of these little mom and pop shops.
If you are someone that is very budget conscious,
then...
The outskirts of Georgetown may actually make more sense
for you where you could get
a brand new house.
You may have to drive to everything,
but you could walk within your actual neighborhood
and really you don't just have to look on the outskirts of Georgetown.
There's places like Harbison, Millsboro, Milton,
or even Allendale that you could get a little
bit more bang for your buck,
especially if you want to be in coastal Delaware.
But you don't want to pay for coastal Delaware.
My biggest piece of advice is to come visit the area
and don't just take my word for it.
Drive around.
See what I mean when I say everything is really, really close.
And what I want you to do is think about your ordinary day.
Maybe you go to the YMCA.
Maybe you want to go to the local coffee shop.
So pick the location and then take a drive.
See how long it takes you to get there.
Like I said, don't take my word for it.
It makes more sense to visit and actually see
and touch and feel everything before making
the decision on where you want to live.
So if you take one thing from this video,
it's not Georgetown versus Lewis.
It's really looking at the place that you want to live
and does that fit within your
budget?
I will tell you people fall in love with Lewis,
but a lot of times the price pushes them out
and that's okay too because
Georgetown, Millsboro, Harbison,
even Milton and Allendale are all amazing places to live.
But you still can go and visit the restaurants that you love in Lewis.
So before you fall in love with Lewis, why not widen the map
and actually take a look at what all of coastal Delaware has to offer?
Like I said, if you are looking for a guide comparing
all of these little small towns in coastal Delaware,
I've put a full guide together that is below down in the description.
So go ahead and grab that.
There's a worksheet where you can compare houses in different towns.
It is so, so, so helpful.
I really hope this video helped.
If it did, be sure to give me a thumbs up and be sure to
subscribe to the channel. Like I said,
if you are thinking about retiring to Delaware,
I would absolutely love the opportunity to help you.
My information is down below
in the description. So go ahead and grab that.
Hop on my calendar, give me a call, shoot me a text,
and let's get set up and get you here
and visiting Delaware so you can really see
what Delaware has to offer for retirement.
Once again, I really hope this video helped.
If it did, be sure to give me a thumbs up.
Be sure to subscribe to the channel
and I will see you on next week's video.
Thank you so much for making it this far into the video.
If you are interested in more Delaware retirement content,
check out this video right here.
And if you would love to tour
Delaware new construction homes with me,
check out this playlist right here.
And don't forget, subscribe to my channel.
