Retired Navy SEAL, Mark “Coch” Cochiolo, shares his thoughts on the new SIG SAUER XM5 rifle.
The SIG XM5 is the U.S. Army variant of the SIG MCX Spear, a 6.8×51mm (.277 in), gas-operated, magazine-fed, assault rifle designed by SIG Sauer for the Next Generation Squad Weapon Program in 2022 to replace the M4 carbine.
Coach from Tactical Hive analyzes the Army's new XM5 rifle, arguing that while it offers superior penetration and range against armored opponents, it is not a universal replacement for the M4. He views it as a \"battle rifle\" that should be part of a diverse \"toolkit\" of weapons rather than a single solution for every combat scenario.
Hey, it's Coach with Tactical Hive.
I'm not on the range today, but I have been reading comments
on a previous video, and there's a lot of concerns.
People asking my opinion of what the Army's new gun is going to be,
the XM5. I haven't shot it yet, but I did some research
and looked at the specs and kind of dug into it a little bit,
and I think I can give you my opinion.
Now my experience in procuring new small arms is the SCAR program,
and I know that the army
went out to industry and said we want something that does this,
and they have a list of stuff,
and they downloaded those three,
or down selected to the three that were advertised,
and SIG got the nod.
Now the army says they want to replace the M4 with this XM5,
It's kind of apples to oranges at this point
because the M4 is an assault rifle.
It's an intermediate cartridge, high capacity, you know,
rifle that everybody knows, you know, we grew up on it, right?
This one is a heavier caliber,
so it fits more into the battle rifle category in my eyes.
Now, it comes with some capabilities,
but it also comes with some weight.
And everything's a trade-off in the world.
There's no, like, perfect anything.
So when you trade off on weight, you need capability.
So if this thing has enough capability,
then it makes sense for some applications.
Maybe not all of them.
Now, one of the biggest concerns
is that we're moving backwards in time.
That we're going to a bigger,
bulkier thing that's supposed to take care of a lot of different stuff.
And this has its roots in the M14.
The M14 program, the M14 was supposed to replace the BAR, the M1
Garand, the M1 Carbine, and the submachine gun, the M3 Grease Gun.
So, there's just no way.
I mean, honestly, you had two different variants of the M14.
You had the regular Rifleman variant, and you had the heavy barrel
that was supposed to, I guess, be more machine gunny.
They didn't make very many of those.
I got to mess around with it a little bit, but, you know, not much.
I ended up adopting the pistol grip stock on my standard M14,
just because, you know, that pistol grip, it's more ergonomic.
It's easier to carry.
It's fun.
Anyway.
The M14 program, the Army, you know, you talk about the SPEW,
the Special Purpose Individual Weapon, and the OICW,
the Objective Individual Combat Weapon.
There you go.
Anyway, the Army has wanted to have, well, the military in general,
they want one gun that's going to do everything.
And it's a unicorn.
It doesn't exist.
Had they not been chasing that...
In Vietnam, we might have had,
if they'd gone to a better intermediate cartridge early on.
That's what the Brits were going after that
with their .280 British.
A lot of people took notice that the STG-44 was a good gun,
and that was the German assault rifle.
So the Soviets saw that and went, hey, cool,
and they rolled out with their 7.62-39 intermediate cartridge.
And they've been running with that ever since, right?
The Brits saw that and went, hey, we want this too, something similar.
So this .280 British was an intermediate cartridge.
If they'd gone to that with the FN FAL, you know,
maybe the M16 would have been rushed in as quickly as it was.
You know, there was some other issues in there as well.
But, you know, hey, that's politics.
And it's the past.
What I want to talk about is the future where this thing is going.
The family of weapons,
well the M16 really didn't start off as a family of weapons
but it kind of is now. You've got
everything from on that platform
from sniper rifles down to submachine guns. So you know
it fills a lot of niches.
So you can't come in with one gun and replace all of that.
So depending on how they feel this,
what box they want to put this in, if it's your frontline fighter
in open terrain with armored opponents, then yeah, I want that one.
For other...
Instances, you're going to need high volume of fire,
and you're not going to have that with this just because,
you know, that 20-round magazine is pretty shallow.
A 30-round magazine makes a lot more sense, and the lighter ammo
means you get to carry more so you can launch more bullets.
And depending on, you know, what the fight is...
You may need a combination of both of those,
maybe heavy-weighted more to one side than the other,
but that's going to be mission and terrain dependent.
So that's kind of where I'm at with this.
I don't think it's a bad thing.
It's going to depend how it's implemented.
Now, the MCX is a family of weapons.
The MCX itself is a 5.56 gun.
The MCX Rattler
300 blackout and currently our guys have
been overseas the last few years now
using the MCX Rattler
and .300 blackout to very good effect so this big brother
the MCX Spear is now going to give you another capability
so and now we've got
the tack hammer, the framing hammer
and the sledgehammer okay so now this thing
can reach out and touch you
The gun is built around this really hot
Okay, the cartridge
the pressures are upwards of 80,000 pounds per square inch
And that's, nothing's ever been able to do that
I mean, they did it with their cool bi-metal case.
And if you want to learn more about that
there's plenty of information out there
But they're doing it.
This thing is going to be a screamer
At 500 yards, it's zipping right through body armor that's worn
Because that's who we're planning on fighting
All right, we're planning.
If you're going to plan on fighting a First World nation
everybody's going to have body armor just like we do
All right, now, if I can punch through your body armor at 500 yards
and you can't punch through mine until you get up to 300 or 250,
then I've got an advantage if I've got the range
If you don't have the range, if you're running around in a city
it may come down to who's got the most bullets.
Because if we're all punching through
each other's body armor inside of 300
three hundred then
That kind of evens the playing field.
So, again, we're looking at this as a,
you so
I look at it as a family of weapons.
Now, the M4, because it's so ergonomically common,
much
you know, to the MCX
for
there's not a lot of retraining that has to happen between,
you know, using the two platforms.
being
So whether they go into, you know, everybody gets an MCX,
just, you know, different calibers or what, I don't know.
here.
But I'm not looking at this one gun that's going to,
you know, replace them all.
I'm looking at it from a family of weapons with similar ergonomics.
So you're not having to relearn something every time you do it.
You know, with my experience,
one of the reasons we moved away from the MP5, you know,
back in the late 80s, everybody who was anybody had an MP5,
but it had a completely different manual of arms than your AR-15.
So, the safety was in the wrong place, you know,
it didn't have a last round bolt hold open, a bunch of little things.
We probably would have been better off if we'd gone with the Colt 9mm,
because then at least we've been common through all our platforms.
So there's a chance that this could evolve into this.
And if it does, I'd say that's a good thing.
The round, I think, is the biggest plus for this gun.
They can make it a little bit lighter. Fine.
Things coming in at just over eight pounds
is what the advertised weight is.
I'm not sure whether that's with the suppressor on it or not.
But, you know, you're talking the SCAR naked comes in at,
what, 7.9 pounds.
So, eh, pretty close.
A fully loaded AR-15 with nothing else on it,
iron sights, weighs about 7.5 pounds.
So, you know, you can easily stack up,
and now you've got this huge heavyweight rifle.
We'll see.
The optic that comes with it.
So you dress it up with your 20-round magazine and your optic,
your can up front.
And, yeah, you're going to have a gun that weighs 10,
11 pounds probably.
Does everybody need to carry one in the platoon?
Going back to my experience in the SEAL teams in the platoon,
we had belt-fed machine gunners.
We had guys running with...
M16, CAR-15s, and M14s.
Back then, M14, what'd that give you?
Yes, 20-round magazine, but you could punch through foliage.
It maintained a better,
there was more bullet when it got to the target.
Okay, whereas the 5.56 round was...
A bit finicky, especially out of the barrels
that we're shooting with the 1 in 12 twist.
It's a little unstable, hits a little bit of foliage,
it's off some, you know, you never
know exactly where it was going to hit.
So there's more penetration capability,
and you could also reach out farther with it.
So the way I see it, it all depends on how this thing is implemented.
If you just want to give this to everybody who's,
you know, going outside the wire, that
may not be the right thing, you know.
But it's like choosing the right hammer
if you're a carpenter, right?
The right tool kit.
You know, think of a platoon as a toolkit, right?
You have to have a bunch of different stuff in it.
You can't just have a box of hammers, right?
So if you're going to include it and put it as the designated marksman,
or if you're going to engage targets at distance all the time,
you're on an open plain someplace and you expect to, you know,
encounter armored individuals, you know,
with body armor out at 500 yards,
yeah, you're going to want this thing.
Because I don't care how many times you shoot it with that 5.56,
you're not getting the effect.
This will give you that effect.
So my thoughts are, I think it's a good gun.
I think the capabilities are there.
It's just a matter of how they implement it.
I really don't think it's a complete replacement for the M4,
but it's more a replacement for the battle rifle
that, well, hell, the Army doesn't even have right now.
So that's kind of where I'm...
You know, I'm at right now.
I may, you know, if I have a chance to, you know, shoot it, test it,
you know, ballistically and actually feel that recoil because some
of the guys shooting, you look at a lot of the video out there,
some of the guys, they're not very good.
Their stance isn't very good and that recoil will rock you.
If you know how to shoot it and get used to it,
I think the recoil is not going to be that bad.
But again, I'll let you know when I try it.
Anyway, if you like this content, like, subscribe, leave me a comment.