Honda Civic Hybrid vs Hyundai Elantra Hybrid Comparison

Sedan Autos
6 followers
#GJWauto #reviewcars #sedan #sedanauto #reviewauto #drivingcars #popcars #cars #autos #review #reviewautos #reviewcar
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video compares the Honda Civic Hybrid and the Hyundai Elantra Hybrid, analyzing performance, efficiency, and design. While the Civic is praised for its superior power, refinement, and interior quality, the Elantra is highlighted as a more affordable, feature-rich alternative that offers excellent value for budget-conscious buyers.
A few weeks ago, we did a massive compact car comparison,
and these were the top two finishers.
It wasn't really that surprising that the Civic won.
We always had an inkling that it would,
because it's just so darn good.
But we were really surprised at just how well
Hyundai's Elantra Hybrid finished.
So we're going to go a little more in depth
with both of them right here.
We've got the two big H's in a hybrid head-to-head.
We'll get you back to the hybrid sedan comparison
in a second, but let's take a
moment to talk about protecting your car.
Custom made for an exact fit, WeatherTech
offers complete protection for your vehicle's interior,
especially family cars like these.
There's the original WeatherTech Floor Liner
and the new Floor Liner HP,
made from a more flexible material.
Both work with your OE floor mat clips and protect up the
sides of your footwell,
plus the Floor Liner HP comes with these spikes for even better grip.
And let's not forget the cargo liner for trunks and hatchbacks
which is great to protect your vehicle
from everything you might need to carry
in your brand new car. All WeatherTech products come
with a lifetime guarantee.
You can order online at weathertech.ca.
Shipping is free anywhere in Canada or for those who are
local they can visit our retail showroom
at 1164 Walker's Line in Burlington and get their order
Honda's eCVT does a really good job of both blending
or switching between the power sources, too,
with very little of that elastic rubber band feeling that we used
to get in earlier versions of Honda's hybrid system.
It's also just properly quick.
It's responsive, and it has so much torque that...
This just feels way more than enough for an everyday car.
It actually basically just feels like a bigger engine.
It doesn't necessarily give off super hybrid vibes.
It's just you have a lot more displacement now.
Now don't let the numbers fool you.
The Elantra is not as far down on power as it might seem.
Sure, it only has 139 horsepower, but it has 195 pound-feet of torque.
Also advantage for the Hyundai,
it is lugging around about 200 pounds fewer than the Civic.
Also that six-speed auto is its secret weapon.
Sure it isn't quite as responsive as something
like a CVT or eCVT, but it does respond pretty darn quickly
and there's very little jerkiness
or even clear signs of any handoff between the power sources
or the blending of them.
Plus with regular shift points it just feels
a little more grown up than a droney CVT.
It helps make a compact affordable
car just feel a little bit more premium.
Fuel economy goes to the Hyundai, at least officially.
So according to the EPA this thing will score 49 miles
per gallon in the city and 52 miles
per gallon on the highway which are the equivalents of 4.8
and 4.5 liters per 100 kilometers.
On our drive loop in the Mega Comparison,
which included a little bit of everything,
the Hyundai matched that highway rating too.
But so did the Civic. Now officially, the Civic
is a little thirstier. It has a rating of 50 miles
per gallon in the city but only 47 miles per gallon
on the highway, which are the equivalents of 4.7
and 5.1 liters per 100 kilometer.
However, like I just said, it matched the Hyundai on our test loop.
We assume it's because the Honda just doesn't have to work as hard.
Also, based on previous time with this powertrain,
it's pretty easy to beat those figures.
I took the Civic home for a night and did just that.
However, the last time I drove a Hyundai Elantra Hybrid,
it was the same story.
Needless to say, you're going to be saving
a lot of money not buying gas.
The Civic rides better than some premium cars.
It is seriously impressive with how
well damped and just big car stable this thing is.
It sails over bumps and you don't get a lot
of noise of the suspension doing
its thing making its way into the cabin.
In fact you don't get a lot of noise coming
into the cabin period. That's not to say that
the Civic can't also let its hair down.
You get the feeling that when the engineers were
asked whether they wanted to make this generation sporty
or comfortable they said yes.
Good consistent steering means that the Civic
is actually genuinely fun to pitch down the
nearest back road and it keeps the driver in the conversation.
All that torque makes it a low-key
rocket too. Now you can pull on the paddles behind the wheel,
but they're not going to change gears
or pretend to simulate gear ratios either.
They'll just deal with the regenerative braking.
You can select a few different levels, all of them are pretty light,
but it kind of gives you
that added decelerative feel of a manual, right?
The Elantra does not have the breadth of abilities of the Civic,
but as much as I enjoy the driving dynamics of this Honda,
I recognize that most people shopping
in this segment are looking for something that is
predictable, reliable, and comfortable,
and the Elantra is all of those things.
It just feels light. That is the overriding term.
It's a lighter curb weight, it translates to
lighter steering, it feels more compact even though it isn't.
While the Elantra does have a sport drive
mode selector, I wouldn't recommend it.
It just feels against the character of the car. It also
does not have paddles to adjust the regenerative braking,
even though newer Hyundai models do.
Now Honda debuted this generation of Civic four years ago
and we all thought it was a very
very conservative design,
a far cry from the fractal-like Elantra. The flip side is that
all these years later the Civic has arguably aged better.
Honda gave it the lightest of
facelifts this year with a new grille
and a front lower air intake that juts out a little bit more.
It's a bit fussy to my eyes
and weirdly looks kind of like a BMW 3 Series.
The overall shape emphasizes the size of the Honda though.
It's big in all directions.
I like that. The big glass house gives a sense of space,
it improves sight lines,
and it makes this look a little bit more like
the classic civics of the 90s.
Fun fact, I was on the first drive launch of both of these vehicles
when these generations
launched. Now when it was new the Elantra was a shock.
It was such a different design language
that we didn't really know what to expect.
Now over the years I've grown to like it but
Mike is a little less enthused.
I think Hyundai is now even trying to walk it back because for
the facelift last year the Elantra gained
a stylistically safer front end design.
Now, to Hyundai's credit,
back when this overall model first launched in 2020, rear light bars
weren't quite as ubiquitous as they are now,
so the Elantra was ahead of the curve there.
I also like that this model rides on those 17-inch alloys.
It just gives the whole
car a sense of being a little more actually compact, especially
compared to the Civic.
The weird thing, though,
is that if you actually bust out the measuring tape, this is bigger
in every direction or...
It's the same height.
That's impressive.
The cabins tell a similar tale.
The Civic's is a little more restrained and conservative.
The Hyundai's is expressive and dramatic.
Now, I'm sitting here in the Civic,
and I think it was the right choice for Honda
when it debuted this generation a few years ago.
And I mean, obviously, Honda thinks that too,
because this basic design language
has spread across the entire lineup at this point.
You have this wonderfully wide dashboard that really shows off,
well yeah, the width of this
cabin. Honda carves out space in cars in a way
that I just can't comprehend, and on more than
a few occasions we've asked ourselves,
do you even really need a cord anymore? I like the mesh across
the vents, it's a nice classy touch,
and you have these super easy to understand and nicely clicky
Little adjusters.
Of course if I'm saying clicky I feel
contractually obligated to talk about
the dials for the climate controls.
They're knurled and it's just really nice to play with them.
There's a good use of materials and textures.
There is some piano black but luckily it is kept
in a place where you're not going to touch it very often
so you're not going to muck it up.
The texture down here on the center console is interesting
and it also hides dirt and scratches
pretty well so it's practical.
There's also a noticeable advantage in terms of material quality
in the Honda. This goes some way to explaining its higher price tag.
You have really smooth
nice leather on the steering wheel
and a lot of soft touch parts say down on the doors.
Now Mike really likes the styling of the Elantra's interior
and I get it. It has a distinct cockpit
like vibe. There are a lot more materials
and colors in that but I think that is an advantage
for the Hyundai because it just breathes a little bit
of life into the cabin. Sure the wool-ish
material only looks like wool on the door panels
and you probably don't want to touch it.
But again, it's visually interesting
and Hyundai is one of the leaders in the market as far as I'm
concerned in terms of playing with textures.
The most divisive aspect of the Elantra's cabin,
almost literally, is the bar that goes down the center console.
Now I know some people really
don't like it. I do.
I think it is a great little touch that makes the Elantra feel special.
Don't touch it.
Don't wrap your hand around it as a driver because you're going
to touch the seam on the far side and that just feels cheap.
Overall, the Elantra is the better equipped vehicle of the two
with features like ventilated seats, a 360-degree camera,
and a larger, more configurable infotainment system.
While the Civic does counter, it has a power passenger seat
and wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.
Yes, the Elantra in 2025 still does
not have wireless Apple CarPlay or Android Auto,
and if you want to plug it in,
you need an old-school USB-A, yes, the big rectangular one,
and not the more modern oval USB-C.
But back to the infotainment systems for a second.
The Civics uses Honda's latest and greatest infotainment software.
But the actual physical screen and buttons
and the software itself all look a little dated.
The Hyundai screen and software looks more modern and it has some great
features not found in the Civic like the split screen capability.
I also found it was easier to configure
and personalize the system in the Elantra more than
the Civics by setting things like my favorite presets.
Presets.
I will say though, there needs
to be a special shout out to both manufacturers
for having actual physical climate controls.
There are dials and buttons in both cars for all the
system and it's what every car should have.
It may look old to some people, but it's so much
more functional and safer
to have physical climate control buttons. Okay, I'm done ranting.
In terms of comfort, well, the Civic is the easy winner.
Although the Elantra has a very comfortable front seat
that's supportive and I enjoy being here,
it lacks a bit of headroom found in the Civic and,
well, those Civic seats are even more comfortable.
They're squishier, yet somehow more supportive
and just a great place to spend a lot of time in.
Stepping back to the rear seats, well,
it's a case of numbers can be deceiving.
On paper, it looks like the Civic should have
the less comfortable rear seat because it offers
less headroom and legroom.
Well, in real-world testing, it's quite the opposite. We prefer
being in the Civic's rear seat more.
We found headroom more lacking in the Elantra, and then
there's also the sloping down roof,
which blocks outward visibility for rear seat passengers.
Both cars do include...
Rear heated seats for outboard passengers,
so that's a nice plus on cold wintry days.
Continuing further back through the car,
the Civic's trunk once again wins as it's larger,
more square, and has a better rectangular trunk lid opening.
But coming back up front in terms of comfort,
the armrests here are nice and squishy.
My arms seem to be in the exact place I'd want them
to get on the steering wheel,
and the steering wheel itself is nice, smooth leather.
Having this long center bar is actually nice because sometimes
I can rest my arm on there when I'm waiting at a stoplight.
Like, I don't know.
At an as-tested price of $30,995,
including destination charges, the Elantra Hybrid Luxe,
It undercuts the Civic Hybrid Touring by nearly $3,000,
so that raises the age-old question
of is the Civic worth the extra money?
The powertrain's more robust,
the driving experience more refined, comfort has an edge
in the Civic, it has better fuel economy, and so on and so on.
But a nearly 10% price difference
is something that shoppers need to consider.
All right, obviously cost no object.
Yes, the Civic is still the best car in its class.
It rides like something from the class above,
and even though it is plenty powerful,
it's still so fuel efficient.
But the Elantra is a really solid choice as well.
Maybe it makes a little less power in the real world
and gets a little less fuel economy in the real world,
but it also has more features and costs less.
It's a great alternative to the Civic.
