It doesn't take a genius to work out that I am not impressed with this Eheim pro 4 filter but I'll list a few positives: 1 - The pro 4+ 600 holds approx. 3.6kg of media which makes it suitable for a normally stocked tank of around 350 litres or a heavily stocked tank of around 175 litres (when using biohome ultimate for a full cycle). That's between 92 US gal. (normal stock) down to 46 US gal. (heavy stock) for you guys in the US. 2 - It comes with media, some is good (substrat pro). 3 - It looks nice......errrr...ummmm...hmmmm.....I'm struggling after those first two points......nope, just thought of another one.... 4 - The sides of the filter are see through which allows you to see that the trays don't fit together properly....is that a positive?
OK, now the negative attributes of this (very expensive) filter: 1 - The outer fittings / clasps are made from the cheapest most brittle plastic I've seen on a canister filter 2 - The 'extender' function relies entirely on the fine pad being the last stage of filtration therefore rendering the feature useless as water polishing should be done BEFORE it hits the biological media. Having a fine pad at the end of the process guarantees that fine dirt is concentrated in media trays and will reduce the efficiency of the system by encouraging premature clogging of the media and guaranteeing cleaning is a more messy process than it should be. 3 - The 'mech pro' is similar to a small version of flocor which is often used in cheap pond filters to reduce weight and therefore reduce shipping costs. As a mechanical media, filling the first 2 trays with this is a total waste since medium and light weight dirt will easily go through it straight into the media trays, covering it in dirt and reducing efficiency. 4 - Trays are a design which is sure to lead to handles snapping off. They will still fit together without the handles but the plastic is so brittle that handle breakage is a real concern. Then there is the... 5 - Ridiculous design of the 'tube' which is formed by the trays fitting together. Having three thin pieces of plastic forming a 'tube' instead of one moulded piece of plastic (e.g. on pre-filter tray) ensures that the trays will not fit together properly when one part of the 'triangle' gets bent out of shape and that will cause bypass on a grand scale. The problem could be avoided if the triangular piece of plastic was formed the same way as it is for the pre-filter tray. Pythagoras would be turning in his grave....... 6 - The trays don't even fit together properly when all parts are present and straight - they easily push inside each other. This is by far the worst example of tray construction I've seen on a canister filter. 7 - The cost. In the UK this filter sells for well over £200 which puts it right at the top of the list of expensive filters but considering the many critical flaws of the pro 4+ 600 a £60 All Pond Solutions / $60 SunSun filter will hold more media (5kg / 11 lbs) and will actually function like a filter is supposed to do, unlike this travesty from Eheim.
The main competitor to Eheim is Fluval and Fluval have maintained or improved the build quality of their filters with successive generations. However, Eheim seemed to hit a high point with the pro 2 series then reduced the quality for the pro 3 and reduced it again for the pro 4, all while increasing the selling cost of the 'new generation' filters and claiming that the filter is 'more advanced' - the only thing which is advancing is Eheim's bank balance and that is down to mugging fish keepers who bought the pro 3 and pro 4 filters. Can they pull it back with their next filters? sure they could but so many other companies are making better filters at a fraction of the cost the market is wide open for someone to steal their crown - that is awful to see as I have great respect for German engineering / work ethic / construction quality / after sales care. Instead of being a 'next generation' filter the pro 4 is a massive step back.
If you've enjoyed this video please check out the playlists on my channel for hundreds more.. Feel free to share or link any of my videos on facebook, twitter, forums etc. for the benefit of anyone you think may also enjoy watching. See you next time. Pondguru RECOMMENDED PRODUCTS ON AMAZON: https://goo.gl/jMaBWy INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/pondguru_outdoors/
Hello there, welcome back to another edition of Pimp My Filter,
and in this episode we're going to be taking a look
at a filter that I've been asked about more than any other.
This one is the Eheim Professional 4 Plus 600,
and I think there's been some media left in it as well.
So we're going to get this out of the box, open it up, take a look,
I'll explain how it works, and then we'll see what we can do,
if anything, to make it more efficient.
All right, so we've got our in-pipe here,
which goes down here into our pre-filter tray,
which has got a coarse foam in it.
And I'll just take a second to explain this.
Basically, the water comes in into the bottom of here.
It then swirls around in here.
All the heavy muck settles out in here,
gets caught in the foam.
Water rises up, goes down through here,
all the way down to the bottom of the canister
before rising back up.
And out of the centre of here, which has got a little flappy valve,
this particular part fits on here,
and that's where our pump is.
So our pump draws the water out, spits it back to the tank.
There is an extra part here,
which is found in the plus versions of these filters,
and that allows the flow to be altered,
but I'll explain that once I've actually set it up.
So that's our pre-filter tray.
And then we've got one.
Four main trays and unfortunately unlike a lot
of the older Eheim filters we don't have space in
the bottom of here to put any rings as a primary settlement
but we do have that pre-filter which
should act as the primary settlement.
So we'll get that out the way and have a look at the trays.
So from bottom to top, water rises up.
Through this stuff which is a plastic mech media
that's meant to trap muck and also support a bit
of bacteria but unfortunately it's plastic plastic
static it's just it's hopeless basically i don't
know what to say about it it's bloody useless
that is the same in the second one up then we've got a
void that would normally be filled with biological media
and the last one is filled with biological media
Actually, as far as filter media goes, it's pretty good.
It packs in nice and tight
so you can get a hell of a lot of surface area in there.
It's basically just a sintered glass.
It's very similar to our bio gravel.
It's not quite as porous, but it's getting there.
So that's actually a pretty good media.
And then we've got the obligatory fine pad on the top.
As you know, that's not where it needs to be, but we can change that.
And before we go on to upgrade this particular filter,
I may as well point out what this hole is here for.
That is to let water through.
So if you notice that the return flow back
to your tank is slowing down,
you can actually turn this.
And what that does, it allows
a large proportion of water just to bypass.
this fine pad and comes straight up here
and out of this part of our pre-filter tray so just
pours the water all over here it ends up going through here
getting sucked out by the pump
so it's a bypass function it's not as well made
as the Pro 2 series as far as I'm concerned there's
a lot that could smash off
They do fit together but you have to be very careful.
If you're a bit rough you're easily going
to smash these little fittings off.
And I'm not, I'm actually not a fan
of the the fiddliness of it. You know,
all these little fittings,
I mean you slip when you're carrying one of these, you drop it,
smash, that's gone you know.
The Pro 3 has this similar problem
as well from as far as
I can remember. If every one of the series
of Eheim filters has got more fiddly,
And ultimately less useful, you know? I'll explain.
Everything is just more fragile than it was years ago.
There's so much scope for the things not fitting together properly,
for the fittings smashing off, and really the extender function
is good if you're not physically capable
of getting to your filter very regularly.
You can extend it that little bit longer.
But really if the filter was set up properly in the first place,
That function just would never ever be used.
You wouldn't need to use that function.
This is frustrating. They do size their filters well
as long as you look at their website and see
the figure that says for aquariums of about,
not the figure that says for aquariums up to.
They used to make filters really, really well.
Now they just make them
overly technical and I'm not a fan of them.
I would love to be excited about this because I know there's
so many fanboys out there who
are excited about this and they're going
to really defend this particular range of filters
to the hilt.
But I just can't do that, you know,
I've got no allegiances to any company or any particular
type of filter.
I just want something to be good that I know
is going to last for many, many years.
This is a step backwards.
I'm going to stop going on about it now though
because people are just going to think I'm
I don't like rant videos
because generally they have no sort of weight to them whatsoever.
My concerns with this however are 100% genuine.
Right that is how our filter is set up.
So we've got the pre-filter in the top, the water comes into,
goes down the side of here, rises up through the trays.
So in the bottom tray remember we've got our plastic mech media.
Next tray up we've got more mech and that's far too much mech.
Then we've got nothing, that would normally
be filled with biological media.
And then in the top one we've got some good biological media
and we've got a fine pad.
So that's how it is set up, that's how it's recommended to be set up.
That's not the most efficient way to set it up
though, I will now show you
what is the most efficient way to set it up in my opinion,
you can change it if you want.
Let's go.
So first job is to get rid of all of this plastic mech media.
Right, that is all of our mech pro gone from the filter.
We may as well chuck the pad away, it has been used.
And we're going to tip this Substrat Pro out as well.
It's okay, certainly better than ceramic rings, but we can do better.
Right, so we're going to leave the pre-filter tray exactly as it is.
Nothing really we can do to that so that one is going
to be left with the Eheim blue pad in there.
It's actually the only thing that we're going
to be keeping from this setup.
Bottom tray, coarse,
medium, fine pads.
Coarse and the medium pads
are just pond foams.
The bumpy side down so you've got maximum contact surface area
and fine pad is just a cheap
Fine pad that you buy for pond filters.
Don't waste money on ones that are marketed for aquariums,
because they will be twice the price.
All that goes in the bottom tray.
That will ensure that all the muck in the filter,
apart from what is in the pre-filter,
will be held in the bottom third of the filter.
It won't be in amongst all your filter media,
clogging it up and making it inefficient.
It'll be held below this in here,
exactly where you want it.
And on top of there, we've got three media trays left.
So, we're gonna fill them all with biological media
to combat the ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate in your tank,
because we're gonna be using the BioHome Ultimate.
I'll fill all the trays, and then I'll let you know
exactly how much we can get in each tray.
Okay, that fits on there well.
Another thing about these trays, though,
is they can just drop inside each other like that.
I must have had too much coffee today.
I do apologise, especially if anybody from Eheim's watching.
But this is riling me.
I like things to be right, you know.
This isn't right. It's not right.
It's close, but it's not right.
Here's another catchphrase. Not sitting on air properly,
that's a little bit better. I'm just going
to bring the camera in to show you
one of the problems,
just one of the problems with these trays.
Okay so in our pre-filter tray we've got a solid piece here
and that creates a tube which goes all
the way down and that's where our water goes after it's milled around
in here, all the way down there
to the bottom, rises up through the trays.
So we'll take this off and you'll notice that next
one instead of it being solid it's actually three thin pieces
of plastic and they can get bent out
of shape. One of them actually arrived bent out of shape,
I had to bend it back.
To get these to sit together properly,
they are going to get snapped off very, very easily.
I don't know whether you can see,
but there's already some plastic fatigue there.
When this arrived, that was actually like that on the outside.
So as these were pressed down, that is weakened.
Eventually, that was going to get snapped off.
And because these don't lock together all the way, you lose that.
The water's going to come down here, pee out the side.
And because the trays don't fit together
properly, you're going to get bypass.
That is a shocking, shocking design problem from a German manufacturer.
And I haven't even mentioned the clasps.
They are weaker than I have seen on any other Eheim filter.
I don't know what, I kind of think what they were thinking of.
I really don't know.
The German companies pride themselves on design
and quality of construction and efficiency.
This flies in the face of all of that.
Another German manufacturer,
which is Tetra, also make canister filters.
When they came out initially, I wasn't very pleased with them.
The quality of construction wasn't too good.
However, successive models have got better construction and a better...
They're just better all around.
They're certainly better all around than
this generation of Eheim filters.
So I didn't get this riled up
when I took a look at the Boyu EF25,
which was a god awful filter.
That's made in China.
The fittings were better than they were on here.
It was an awful filter but I didn't expect anything from it.
I expected, I didn't expect perfection, I just expected something
that at the very least bloody fit together properly.
Anyway, let's get back to it.
Each tray has got 1.2 kilos of Biohome Ultimate in.
So that's a total of 3.6 kilos
which is approximately seven pounds or thereabouts.
Maybe seven and a half pounds for you guys in the U.S.
That's not too bad,
but I'm just struggling to find anything positive.
And I don't want to be negative.
I don't want to just say negative things about this.
But this is the one I just cannot recommend at all.
I mean, I'm really grateful for Chat,
who sent me this, for sending me it,
because I get asked about it all the time.
It's not a good filter
It's not at all.
Before any fanboys say anything, I'm not being paid
by any filter manufacturer to big up or run down anybody's filters.
I'm looking at these objectively and I'm disappointed.
Right, I'm going to put all the trays back in,
hopefully not smash any when they go in.
And we'll talk a few facts and figures about this filter.
Right, I'm going
to have to keep
that one
for the top.
That's the one that's bent out. It doesn't fit together properly now.
That one looks okay.
That one's been bent out
but it's sitting a little bit better so I'll put that one in.
Now luckily you can see through the side of this so that is a positive.
You can check if the trays are sitting together properly.
That one is good.
Yeah that one's
gone together good.
And that one's in good as well.
It's just this one.
Come
on.
Right I've stuck
that side in first.
That's where our problem is.
I'm just going to try and drop both of these trays in together.
And hopefully hit the mark.
Oh man.
Nah, nah, nah, nah, nah.
Man,
how
wacky.
Right.
At the risk of snapping that little bit off,
I've managed to bend it in
and get everything fitting together perfectly.
But this is the edited version you're watching.
I've cut out so many swear words.
If this was my own filter, I would have smashed it.
I literally would have taken it outside
and had a great big mel and smashed it to pieces.
That might sound like blasphemy for something so expensive,
but that's just how I feel.
I need to quickly get it back before it falls to bits.
Okay, so that, in a nutshell, is the Eheim Professional 4-600.
A huge disappointment, and I wouldn't recommend this over any
of the filters that I've taken a look at so far.
Except for that Boyu EF-25, which was an absolute abomination.
If you're going to look for an Eheim,
see if you can get an Eheim Pro 2 series.
Or one of the many copies that are out there.
Probably the nearest one to the Pro 2 would be...
The Aquis range from Aqua One, they're excellent,
they hold a lot of media, they're well made.
I think I've done one of those in a previous video,
it was a 1250, an excellent filter.
Infinitely better than that,
and probably is less than half the price as well.
So that is the one I would recommend over this in a heartbeat.
I'll put the link to that in the video
description. That is a good filter.
This is not. I'm going to get this packaged up, send back to chat.
Thanks very much again,
chat, for sending me this.
I know I've been horrendously negative with this particular
filter, but I can only say what I see and that's
facts and figures, facts and figures, facts,
figures, right. Okay, so the flow rate on this,
1250 liters per hour, which is roughly 329 US gallons
It's recommended for tanks between 240 litres to 600
litres, which is roughly 63 US gallons to 158 US gallons.
On the Eheim website,
it does say for aquariums of about 240 litres, so that would...
That would be a realistic figure for this.
That 240 litres, or 48 US gallons,
is a normally stocked tropical community tank.
600 litres, yeah, it's going to keep a very,
very lightly stocked 600 litre fully planted tank perfect.
But that's not what most people have.
Most people have a canny few fish in, you know.
So roughly 240 litres.
But if it's upgraded like this with 3.6 kilograms
of BioHome Ultimate that'll make it suitable for
nearer 350 so it kind of bumps it up by about 100 liters.
Remember for a normally stock tank we
generally use one kilo per 100 liters to deliver that full cycle
which is zero ammonia zero nitrite
and low nitrate.
For a heavily stocked tank,
you could halve that from 350 litres all the way down to 175 litres,
which is about 33 US gallons.
So that would be for a heavily stocked tank to achieve a full cycle.
I don't really know what more to say about this.
I've been pretty much negative from start to finish.
As soon as I got that top off, I didn't like what I saw.
So, again, apologies to Eheim.
Apologies to anybody that's got one of these.
I know there'll be loads of fanboys writing in there.
comments section that it's the best thing ever
but it just isn't unfortunately and that
disappoints me so if you found this video useful for one reason
or another please hit the thumbs up
if you're a fan boy give it
a thumbs down share it wherever you want i'm sure some people would
like to be able to see all these problems
that are evident in this particular range of filters
so share it wherever you can please um i really i don't
It sounds awful but I don't want people to buy
this because they are going to experience
those stupid niggling little problems with it
and that is unforgivable, it really is.
Anyhow, hopefully the next episode will feature
a good filter because it
cannot get much worse unless it's another boy you
Thanks for watching